Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Accused of benefit fraud

110 replies

cakeinspiration · 01/09/2021 11:30

I think my daughters dad and his girlfriend have reported me for benefit fraud. Is there any way I can find out if it was them or not?
I had my girl when I was 18 and split up with his dad when she was 6 months old. He got together with his girlfriend just before our daughter turned one. My girly is now 4.
I think his girlfriend is jealous of me because she loves kids but can't have any yet for whatever reason. She's told me she can't wait to be a mum and always tells me how lucky I am as my daughter is so polite and she loves her loads. I guess I'm happy that my daughter has someone who loves her a lot but sometimes feel like she's a bit much.
AnywY I met my partner a year ago and he stays at mine sometimes, maybe 2 or 3 nights a week. His 2 daughters (7 and 10) come and stay at mine too. I only have 2 bedrooms so the kids share my daughter's room or the living room.
I got a call the other week from the council asking if I share my home with anyone and I said no. My partner rents his own flat so pays council tax there and my council tax is just for me and my daughter, I have universal credit to go towards rent which is for my flat that I got when I moved out of my parent's house just before I had my daughter.
My partner and I don't want to move in yet as it would be hard for us to afford a place big enough for the kids, and we would lose out on universal credit and I don't think we can afford it.
The council lady said they might come and do a home check in the next couple of weeks and I'm really worried about it, what can they do? Will I get kicked out of my flat?

OP posts:
Greystray · 01/09/2021 14:53

For the purposes of the home check, get him to take all his stuff and his kids stuff back to his place until it's done. And if you're really worried, suspend visits until the check is done. I'd assume your DP is supportive and will be mature about that.

2-3 nights isn't a big deal, but for simplicity unless you've said otherwise just say 2 nights. Tenants are allowed to have visitors. And he's paying council tax on a place so it should be clear you're not trying to fiddle anything.

crowsfeet57 · 01/09/2021 14:52

I think it's more likely to be your neighbours who have reported you OP, as three children in a 2 bed flat is likely to be much noisier than one.

CiaoForNiao · 01/09/2021 14:51

I was told, by someone at the benefits office, that the "3 nights a week rule" is, and always has been a myth. There is no set number of nights someone is allowed to stay. As long as you can prove that he doesn't contribute financially towards the household. However they said there's an element of personal judgment and some people think you should never be allowed an overnight guest. I was told this could, potentially, mean your dp buying a takeaway could be seen as contributing. They also said it would be unlikely that they would class it as such on the basis that your mum, or a friend could also treat you to a takeaway.

And if they use number of toothbrushes as an official measure of how many people live there then I'm screwed. I think there are about 6 in my bathroom. There are 3 people who live here and we are all single
(Well I guess the teens might not be but they don't have guests over). And there are men sized shoes and clothes. Because I have man sized teens.

BungleandGeorge · 01/09/2021 14:43

It could have been anyone who reported you, it’s not really in your exes interests to try and reduce the income in your home but who knows. It also could have come about if your partner has used your address for something. If your partner has a rental agreement, pays council tax and has bills at another property you have nothing to worry about. Perhaps he would give you a copy of something not too personal (rental agreement or council tax?) to send them? He doesn’t have to but it would save you hassle!

Babyroobs · 01/09/2021 14:41

@2catsandhappy

Remove all their property from your place and no more sleepovers. Then you can honestly say you live singly.
Agree.
2catsandhappy · 01/09/2021 14:39

Remove all their property from your place and no more sleepovers.
Then you can honestly say you live singly.

IWasBornInAThunderstorm · 01/09/2021 14:35

If they are watching OP then it will look a bit odd her suddenly getting all his stuff out her flat?

Imatramp1 · 01/09/2021 14:33

@LakieLady a razor wtf woman don't shave their legs then Hmm sounds like he should not have been working there. Imagine the stress he caused people

LakieLady · 01/09/2021 14:18

@PyjamasAndWellies

I know someone who had this happen to them, her dp stayed over sometimes (as you would expect) and someone reported him as living there (he wasnt)

They were told that he wasnt allowed to stay over even occasionally. The idea that they can stay 3 nights a week is a myth apparently, they arent allowed to stay over at all. It's obviously ridiculous, people have a right to a relationship for gods sake. She was just given a warning, they said please dont do it again and that was the end of the matter. I really doubt you would get in any trouble

That's crazy. Of course people are allowed to have other people to stay overnight!

As long as there is evidence that he has his own place, eg tenancy agreement/mortgage, council tax bill, bank statements and other official correspondence etc sent to his home, the DWP are very unlikely to deem you to be cohabiting.

Making sure that he doesn't have clothes etc kept at yours is good advice though, OP. Also be clear that he doesn't eat at yours every night, that he does his laundry at his place and stuff like that.

There used to be a particularly unpleasant bloke in the housing benefit team here, who once insisted that the presence of a man's razor in a woman's flat was proof that her boyfriend was living there. It was her razor, ffs! And her BF had a beard. Grin

I won 3 appeals against him, and he hated my guts.

Cuck00soup · 01/09/2021 14:17

I believe the main thing is that you need to demonstrate that your finances are completely separate. I used to work with someone who was convicted of benefit fraud and amongst other things they used evidence that her DP had paid for her hair appointments as proof that their finances were linked.

In that particular case he was also a financially abusive cock who controlled her completely, and clearly didn't live anywhere else but sadly she believed that he was "treating" her.

user1471457751 · 01/09/2021 14:15

@Haffdonga stop being so dramatic. Sharing a takeaway once a week isn't benefit fraud.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 01/09/2021 14:13

You will be fine, OP. Move all his stuff out, obviously, but if he has his own home and can prove it, they will not be interested.

Just to say, it may not be the case that anyone reported you. Years ago I got quite an accusatory letter from my council stating that they had reason to believe I had another adult living with me and should not be claiming single person discount on my council tax. I was outraged. Outraged! I rang them up to protest and got a weary and apologetic person who said someone had got overzealous and sent the same letter to every person in Waltham Forest who was claiming 25% off their CT.

Until I heard that I was becoming paranoid wondering who had wrongly reported me. Nobody had - that were just shooting in the dark.

IWasBornInAThunderstorm · 01/09/2021 14:10

Oh and if your bank accounts and bills etc are all in your own names and addresses it should be fine

IWasBornInAThunderstorm · 01/09/2021 14:09

I doubt you can find out who it was and it doesn't really matter who it was. You've done nothing wrong so nothing to hide.

SunnySideDownBriefly · 01/09/2021 14:08

You won't have a problem at all because you're aren't committing fraud. Someone reported me years ago and the investigators were so nice. My boyfriend also rented another property and paid tax and everything he was supposed to. He wasn't the father of my children and we didn't have joint finances.

My boyfriend used to keep a toothbrush at mine and stay a couple of nights a week. I put this away and made sure there wasn't anything of his at mine. They did check the bathroom - one of them made an excuse to use the loo so it was pretty obvious. They didn't ask to look in the bedrooms.

What they will be interested in is whether you are operating as a couple/family. So whether you have joint finances or if he pays for anything of yours beyond some shopping and a takeaway now and then. Make sure he doesn't have any mail addressed to your property and that he isn't making any regular standing order-style payments to your bank account. Try and keep the sleepovers with the kids to the weekends only and put away the things they have at yours. Can you pack away their stuff into a box and store it under a bed or in a cupboard? You aren't doing anything wrong but it still makes sense to keep things as clear as possible.

God, you've got me thinking who could have reported me again now....all these years later. It was so strange because no-one really knew my circumstances and I guessed it was probably the drunken and chaotic neighbours who thought I was a snooty cow for not joining in with their behaviour.

Haffdonga · 01/09/2021 14:01

SOME OF THE ADVICE ON THIS THREAD IS WRONG.

People who are saying you have the right to have him stay over are wrong. People who say they'll only look at his council tax and see he has another home are wrong. People who say they wont inspect your toothbrushes and drawer contents are wrong. This is Universal Credit, not common sense or fairness.

If you are on Universal Credit there is NO permitted number of nights that your boyfriend can stay without it possibly be considered as living together

It's to do with sharing your household expenses, so even if he has contributed to a takeaway on a Saturday night that could be seen as sharing costs. The fact his dc are also staying over could very much be considered as combining your households.

DWP have warned you they're looking closely so I agree that you need to remove all his and his dcs' stuff and stop the overnights completely for now. If he claims UC too then I'd advise him to do the same.

user1471505494 · 01/09/2021 13:55

@Karlee30

You are not going to lose your house. Years ago people used to say a partner can stay 3 nights a week but I don't think that's even relevant anymore. It's simply if someone is deemed living with you ie they pay bills, bath and shower at yours and do laundry, keep clothing and other belongings there etc. So amount of days doesn't come into it. Because your partner has his own place I don't think you have anything major to worry about. Is there any evidence of your partner at your flat? Clothes, belongings etc? They may hold that against you if they spot it. Does he park outside? Does he leave the house in the nornings?

But if it was me I would deny it rather than admit he stays sometimes and keep it low key for a while? Maybe stay at his? Tell them he has his own place.

My partner told me someone reported his ex girlfriend (who has kids) for benefit fraud (many many years ago) when they were together and sometimes he stayed there. He had his own place and she denied. Nothing ever come of it. But he did stop staying there... he would go over and leave at 3am. He just as well have slept there but was concerned someone was watching him leave in the morning.

My own mother in law too. She did do the dirty with it though. She had her bloke fully moved in but still claimed benefits as a single parent as her partner was a 'lodger' at someone else's house. She was reported too but somehow she got away with it... god knows how!

I think you just need to be more careful about it tbh!

Very bad advice. If they suspect someone else is living with you they are quite likely to do some surveillance and will soon find out the truth. Honesty is best
Redkatagain · 01/09/2021 13:51

I had this exact situation.
I had this exact situation around council tax. My partner lived elsewhere within the same district and we both expected to be staying at each other's guest. Mummy enquired about the council tax situation it turned out regular thing we'll both required to pay full council tax and neither of us was entitled to the 25% single person discount even though we were not living together.

In effect we will both required to pay for council tax as though we were a couple at both addresses.

Plumtree391 · 01/09/2021 13:44

[quote cakeinspiration]@entropynow that does worry me because he does keep stuff here for himself and the girls because it's less hassle than them all bringing things over every week - the girls all love their sleepovers and they like having home stuff here, is that going to be a problem?[/quote]
Just keep anything obvious out of sight just in case but I don't honestly think you have anything to worry about.

Reallyreallyborednow · 01/09/2021 13:44

I think my daughters dad and his girlfriend have reported me for benefit fraud. Is there any way I can find out if it was them or not?

It doesn’t matter who reported you. You’re either committing benefit fraud or not.

If you are, then they’re right to report.

If you aren’t, then nothing to worry about.

Plumtree391 · 01/09/2021 13:42

You have done nothing wrong, you're entitled to have anyone to stay and your boyfriend has his own place.

I haven't read the entire thread but thinking your ex's girlfriend has reported you for benefit fraud is a huge allegation. I doubt anyone has reported anything, frankly, and daresay the authorities do check up on tenants occasionally (though I don't know this).

Whatever, you have nothing to hide.

fruitbrewhaha · 01/09/2021 13:38

How much stuff exactly can they have at your?

I'd probably have a sort out and get them to take their stuff home, as a precaution. It's a good reason for it and they may well have forgotten what's at yours anyway.

As mentioned upthread, there is no hard and fast rule about how many nights a partner stays to determine if you are "Living together as husband and wife" therefore it would make sense to reduce these and not have the kids to stay, then the DWP will have no reason to investigate further. If they see he is there a lot with the kids and there appears to be older kids clothes there etc they will want to check yours and his financial records, bank statements and it will be stressful and invasive.

Tinkerbellfluffyboots79 · 01/09/2021 13:37

My sons have size 11 & 8 trainers sat at my door men’s coats etc how to home checks know what is yours and what is a visitors. I wouldn’t have the kids visiting overnight tbh but you are allowed a boyfriend but I’d stay there. It doesn’t matter who accused you. If you’re not doing anything wrong you have nothing to hide.

On the rare occasion I don’t have any kids the dog and I go off to my boyfriends lovely kid free house, it’s a lovely break away from the norm. No one would find anything if they ‘checked’ here I pay all my own bills/food etc he obs has his own house but he stays here occasionally as works from home so easier for him to be there. And I pop over or we go out with the dog. My children aren’t his so he’s not responsible for them and I’m keen for it to be just us in the house the majority of the time whilst they are still young.

ChateauMargaux · 01/09/2021 13:37

www.advicenow.org.uk/guides/survival-guide-benefits-and-living-together

Two seperate households is evidence that he is not living with you. I am sorry you are being investigated. If someone implies that one or two nights a week is problematic, ask them to show you where the rules state that.

MrsScrubbithatescleaning · 01/09/2021 13:35

What are the actual rules for each benefit that you’re claiming, that you’re supposedly breaking?

Presumably something to do with what constitutes ‘a household’ or similar. That’s all you need to check.

Whether someone stores their spare toothbrush at yours is irrelevant.

Contact Citizens Advice as they should be able to give you useful guidance.

Thirty odd years ago my ex boyfriend at that time was charged with benefit fraud by the Council, but I looked up the regulations and put his case together to give to his defence lawyer. The Council dropped the case on the day of the court hearing for lack of evidence. Basically, they assumed he’d plead guilty and stop claiming but he was staying over at mine regularly but not living there as he had his own place that he was paying bills for.

Swipe left for the next trending thread