Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Accused of benefit fraud

110 replies

cakeinspiration · 01/09/2021 11:30

I think my daughters dad and his girlfriend have reported me for benefit fraud. Is there any way I can find out if it was them or not?
I had my girl when I was 18 and split up with his dad when she was 6 months old. He got together with his girlfriend just before our daughter turned one. My girly is now 4.
I think his girlfriend is jealous of me because she loves kids but can't have any yet for whatever reason. She's told me she can't wait to be a mum and always tells me how lucky I am as my daughter is so polite and she loves her loads. I guess I'm happy that my daughter has someone who loves her a lot but sometimes feel like she's a bit much.
AnywY I met my partner a year ago and he stays at mine sometimes, maybe 2 or 3 nights a week. His 2 daughters (7 and 10) come and stay at mine too. I only have 2 bedrooms so the kids share my daughter's room or the living room.
I got a call the other week from the council asking if I share my home with anyone and I said no. My partner rents his own flat so pays council tax there and my council tax is just for me and my daughter, I have universal credit to go towards rent which is for my flat that I got when I moved out of my parent's house just before I had my daughter.
My partner and I don't want to move in yet as it would be hard for us to afford a place big enough for the kids, and we would lose out on universal credit and I don't think we can afford it.
The council lady said they might come and do a home check in the next couple of weeks and I'm really worried about it, what can they do? Will I get kicked out of my flat?

OP posts:
phishy · 01/09/2021 16:53

@PheasantsNest

Were you honest with them? Staying regularly two or three nights a week sounds quite often.
So people on benefits can’t have guests stay over? 🙄
Tinkerbellfluffyboots79 · 01/09/2021 16:50

Benefits people could open every cupboard in my house
Not sure what they think they’d find to use as ‘proof’ of anything I have 4 kids who I clothe and feed 2 of those are adult sized 16/19 boyfriend has his own house where be lives, pays mortgage, council tax and bills food etc he sometimes pays for food here if he’s round, but his bank statement doesn’t say on his statement ‘bought food for tinkerbell house’ on it? I pay all my own bills too. Nothing crosses over as we pay our own way or 50:50 for meals together out.

We may be a couple but he’s not responsible for me or my house/kids/bills as he has his own. And can prove that I think that’s the point, it’s when things become blurry that you can’t prove he doesn’t contribute to your bills/household.

gogohm · 01/09/2021 16:41

I do benefits advice! As long as your partner is maintaining a home elsewhere then you do not have a problem, those who have been harder to prove are when the partner claims to live with a parent/friend and has no utilities, mortgage or rental contract to link them there (you can have bank statements and car documents go to any address so they do not count) - councils and dwp will red flag such situations as possible benefit fraud and potentially observe movements from a property hence the 3 nights max suggestion. We advise clients to be truthful and to tell the relevant authorities if a partner is now staying more than half the week

NigellasCookalong · 01/09/2021 16:26

@PheasantsNest you are giving incorrect advice. 2-3 nights a week is NOT living together. OP can speak to CAB and they will confirm this. I used to volunteer in the benefits appeal team over there and that’s not classed as living together. Being on benefits doesn’t mean you can’t have a partner who regularly overnight visits.

There is no set limit of how many nights a person can have someone over and it should be fine as long he has a permanent address that he can provide bills for and doesn’t provide OP with any financial support. If your friend lost her benefits then there’s far more to that situation than you know.

OP, speak to CAB. They will put your mind at rest.

Janaih · 01/09/2021 16:22

The turn2us website has some info on this. The 3 nights a week thing is a myth, you can have someone stay in your house as often as you like.
But the benefits people have targets for stopping claims so you'd be wise to play their game. Remove obvious items from your house and shut down your social media. Contact citizens advice for support.
If your OP is truthful and your partner is paying bills including council tax at another property then you don't have any need to worry. I know it's very upsetting and stressful but try to keep calm. Its just box ticking for them.

iamjustlurking · 01/09/2021 16:19

I had this when i am positive it was my DP ex reporting me a few years ago before we did live together.
I was interviewed under caution at the job centre. But I could prove he lived elsewhere and had all his bills, bank, car insurance at this other address.
He was the same stayed over odd nights a week and weekends
They were really nice and reassuring when I advised I thought it was malicious reporting and said they would make a note incase it happened again

PheasantsNest · 01/09/2021 16:11

@entropynow @NigellasCookalong @LookAtMoiPloise I know someone who did this. The DWP turned up and opened every cupboard in her house. She lost all her benefits as a result. You are giving the OP false information. 2/3 nights a week is a regular amount.

lollipopsandrainbows · 01/09/2021 15:52

@Grinch48 I could prove all that, he was on electoral role at his address, car tax, bills etc. But the wording was "do other people consider you to be a couple". And we clearly was. So could no longer claim anything. I wasn't claiming anything I didn't believe I was entitled to as he worked away and only stayed here on a weekend.

Grinch48 · 01/09/2021 15:49

As long as your other half pay councils tax rent bills elsewhere and has proof of this and has no bills or credit or not on the electoral roll at your house there shouldn’t be a problem
They might assume stuff but it’s what they can prove so in my experience before they have even visited you they will do checks for any credit taken out in his name at your address bills like sky and internet DVLA driving licence at your address
I would move stuff that’s his and his girls

lollipopsandrainbows · 01/09/2021 15:46

It's all a myth that someone can stay over 2/3 nights per week. In the eyes of the tax credit people, if people around you consider you to be in a partnership or a couple, you have to declare them. For council tax, it's if you have any of their belongings in your house that would mean they could stay for a period without the need to return to their usual place of residence. So my partner had his own place and stayed at mine on weekends. On social media, we were a couple and everyone saw us that way. So tax credits/council tax discount had to stop. My partner then moved in with me and contributed the equivalent of my lost tax credits and council tax deductions to cover my loss as a single household. This was almost 10 years ago.

gogohm · 01/09/2021 15:43

There's a set number of nights you can have a partner stay over before it affects benefits, I think it's 3 days maximum. If he's got another property he's paying council tax for you shouldn't have an issue.

Rosscameasdoody · 01/09/2021 15:40

@ChateauMargaux

www.advicenow.org.uk/guides/survival-guide-benefits-and-living-together

Two seperate households is evidence that he is not living with you. I am sorry you are being investigated. If someone implies that one or two nights a week is problematic, ask them to show you where the rules state that.

The two or three nights rule doesn’t apply any more. They now do it on merit according to what constitutes full time occupation. The council may or may not carry out a home check but in cases where they do, and suspect fraud, surveillance will monitor who goes in and out and at what times of the day. Evidence from that will be used to determine what’s going on. If the OP’s DP has his own place and there’s evidence of him paying bills/council tax there, then there shouldn’t be a problem if he and his kids stay over for the odd night. What does matter is UC - if the DP is making any kind of contribution to the household, the OP would be expected to declare it.
fruitbrewhaha · 01/09/2021 15:31

Why should OP not be allowed to have her partner stay round?

That he is referred to as PARTNER is problematic. If he is your partner OP and and your are financially enmeshed then you could be in trouble. even if he does not live with you full time.

ThreeFlowers · 01/09/2021 15:26

Surely the only way they can actually prove anything is by having photographic evidence that they’d been living there. My DP has had to move out but hopes to come back soon (very complicated situation), lots of his stuff is still here - stuff in a house means nothing, it’s not an actual person, just stuff 🤷🏻‍♀️

Beautiful3 · 01/09/2021 15:25

I wouldn't have their things there. Bag them up and get him to take them home with him. As its a sign someone else is living there.

sandragreen · 01/09/2021 15:22

So either he is living there sometimes, with his DC, and contributing to your bills etc which = benefit fraud.

Or - he isn't contributing, which = Cheeky Fucker Wannabe Cocklodger.

Has this just crept up on you OP? Might be time to re-evaluate how much of his/their time is spent at yours, to the financial detriment of yourself and your DD.

LookAtMoiPloise · 01/09/2021 15:20

@2catsandhappy

Remove all their property from your place and no more sleepovers. Then you can honestly say you live singly.
Why should OP not be allowed to have her partner stay round?

That's ridiculous.

PandemicAtTheDisco · 01/09/2021 15:18

It could be anyone that has reported you. Have you considered your partner's ex partner or his or her families and friends?

They may resent his children being around at yours so much - it may be that it appears as if you do all his child care. Are they shared 50/50? Do they have bedrooms at his place? How much of their stuff is at your house?

There may be concerns about where all the children are sleeping. Do they have proper beds?

EverybodyIsInteresting · 01/09/2021 15:11

A minor point to what others have said, but try to refer to him as your 'boyfriend' rather than your 'partner'. I know it might sound silly, it's all about how they perceive the relationship.

LakieLady · 01/09/2021 15:10

[quote Imatramp1]@LakieLady a razor wtf woman don't shave their legs then Hmm sounds like he should not have been working there. Imagine the stress he caused people[/quote]
He was utterly foul. He behaved as though every penny paid in housing benefit came directly out of his own pocket.

He was also intimidating. While we were waiting for the appeal on one of these cases, he saw the claimant early one morning, near the home of the bloke she was alleged to be living with. He demanded to know what she was doing there, and told her that he would add this to the evidence, as it was proof that she was living with the man. She was really upset.

Her friend had broken his leg, and early every morning, she used to go to his house and take his dog for a walk.

Her neighbours had "informed" on her. They really resented the fact that she had a flat of her own but spent very little time there, preferring to visit friends and family. This was because she hated being at home alone. She had MH issues and an LD, and she found being alone all day and night made her MH a lot worse.

The tribunal that heard the appeal were brilliant, and I've never got so much satisfaction from winning an appeal than I did from that one. The look on the odious bloke's face was a picture.

He took early retirement not long afterwards, thankfully.

autummvibes · 01/09/2021 15:10

Just out of curiosity, do you spend most of the other days at his home?

BlackShadowCat · 01/09/2021 15:02

So much conflicting advice on this thread. Confused

I think if I were you, I'd box up their stuff and hide it at the back of a cupboard somewhere and have no overnight visits for a few weeks. It's better to be safe than sorry, I think.

Greystray · 01/09/2021 14:58

Actually, do you enjoy keeping the stuff of three extra people in your flat? If it gets under your feet this is a good time and good excuse to get rid. The kids can just bring a bag when they visit. I wouldn't leave their stuff lying around. Maybe you can all split visit nights between both of your places from now on?

I hope it all goes okay.

bluebeck · 01/09/2021 14:57

I don't understand - why are his DC sleeping at your place if he doesn't live there? You obviously don't mean for the odd sleepover or they wouldn't have their own stuff at yours.

I don't think you are intentionally doing anything wrong but this man appears to be moving himself and his children in by stealth. Is this really what is best for you and your DD?

Greystray · 01/09/2021 14:56

If they are watching OP then it will look a bit odd her suddenly getting all his stuff out her flat

It's unlikely they've got people doing surveillance on a flat with ambiguous evidence. It's more likely that a neighbour has grassed and will have their phone at the ready.