Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU for asking . . .

36 replies

Bettyboop3 · 01/09/2021 10:40

How many of you would have had children if schools didn't exist?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SleepingStandingUp · 02/09/2021 17:40

@Mistleine

I decided not to put my three daughters into the school system from the beginning (they're teenagers now), so school hasn't ever and never will play any part in our lives. Frankly, after seeing the state of system at the moment, I have never felt happier about that!
I think home ed is great if you have the time and the skills and of course can afford for someone to be home all day with them. I have friends who home ed and have wonderful networks to share learning but i do wonder how kids who are home ed will cope at Uni or College, just from an experience perspective
MedusasBadHairDay · 02/09/2021 16:44

@Bettyboop3

Parttimemostofthetime sadly i feel you are in the minority. I am thinking more of the parents that don't really want to spend their time with their children and count the days until the school holidays are over. There are also plenty that seem to forget school is about education and not childcare.
Oh I see what you're avidly getting at.

Fwiw schools aren't just about education, as all the time in lockdown has shown they are also a valuable opportunity for socialising.

Personally I cannot wait for the school holidays to finish because my kids are so restless and fed up with being off school, they are desperate to go back, which has turned them into grouchy, whiny creatures. So having them back at school will be so good for them, and that will make parenting easier and more pleasant all round.

I think you might have the mistaken belief that quantity of time spent with children is more important than quality.

Peace43 · 02/09/2021 16:43

How’d you get new brain surgeons and engineers and other highly specialised individuals without education and higher education?

If you are asking if I’d like to spend my days doing home learning with my DD… no. I love spending holiday time with her, I adore her and we have fun together. However I’m a shit teacher, lockdown showed me that. I also love my job and cannot work and home educate at the same time (also lockdown!)

Mistleine · 02/09/2021 16:37

I decided not to put my three daughters into the school system from the beginning (they're teenagers now), so school hasn't ever and never will play any part in our lives. Frankly, after seeing the state of system at the moment, I have never felt happier about that!

MagnoliaBeige · 01/09/2021 12:33

I don’t know where I fit into your question - I do love spending time with my kids and I’m also counting the hours til they’re back at school. I can’t think of anyone I’d want to spend 24/7 with 365 days a year and that includes my partner. I’m definitely of the “absence makes the heart grow fonder ilk”

Toomanyradishes · 01/09/2021 12:32

Communities around the world who dont have schools tend towards more communal childcare arrangements anyway (generalising here) so your whole wanting to send kids back at the end of the summer holidays thing is irrelevant anyway because there is a difference between, for example, a single mum trying to hold down a job and care for a couple of children over 6 weeks with limited funds, and a culture of all adults, or all women, pitching in and children being looked after in groups, sharing the load. No doubt if we didnt have schools this more communal style of childcare would have persisted.
This is also a time when far more structured hands on childcare is needed. Children used to be turfed out of their house to roam all day and come home when it was dark. Now due to a greater awareness of dangers, and a greater level of dangers (faster cars etc) that just doesnt happen. Again with less education there would be less dangers, no cars etc, children might roam more, in groups, requiring less childcare.
You are kind of bitchy in equating struggling with looking after children in the 6 weeks with not liking children, the two are so not the same.
And no before you assume you are hitting a nerve, I dont even have children and I can still see how disingenuous and mean your second post is

SquirryTheSquirrel · 01/09/2021 12:15

I didn't want, and didn't have children even though we do have schools.

BroccoliFloret · 01/09/2021 12:09

@Bettyboop3

Parttimemostofthetime sadly i feel you are in the minority. I am thinking more of the parents that don't really want to spend their time with their children and count the days until the school holidays are over. There are also plenty that seem to forget school is about education and not childcare.
Oh you're one of THOSE posters.

The #makingmemories with my precious famalam, shedding tears when the babies go back to school because precious family time, #lovinglockdown with all my little chicks around me. Hmm

Yeah, you can fuck off with that and your sneery superiority.

Most of us are delighted our kids are back at school. That doesn't mean we don't like spending time with our kids.

PlanDeRaccordement · 01/09/2021 11:57

Lol.
I would have had a dozen children. Because with no schools I’d be illiterate, uneducated and need the extra hands to help run my family farm.

GreekMIL · 01/09/2021 11:54

If there wasn't an education system then we would probably revert back to a hunter gatherer existence but with better clothing and hairstyles. Kids were shoved out of the hut as soon as they could walk to go hunt so yeah, I could probably handle that.

WTFisNext · 01/09/2021 11:48

@Bettyboop3

Parttimemostofthetime sadly i feel you are in the minority. I am thinking more of the parents that don't really want to spend their time with their children and count the days until the school holidays are over. There are also plenty that seem to forget school is about education and not childcare.
Your original post was disingenuous. You weren't really asking if people would still have children if school didn't exist, you were asking if there are any other smug parents out there that revel in every single second spent with their children. Completely different.

For what it's worth, one of the wonderful things about lockdown was that I've spent more time with my children than was ever possible before because life isn't free and I'm the main breadwinner but they need school just as much as they need me.

School isn't childcare, but it is a space that allows them to learn and flourish in a way that wouldn't be possible if left just to my husband and I. We can't provide the innate socialisation that being in a school environment creates naturally, nor can we effectively teach our children all the things that they need to be well rounded individuals.

With the benefit of hindsight, no I wouldn't have children without the support to their development that schools offer. Lockdown revealed I am not cut out to educate and work simultaneously. My husband is not cut out to educate full stop. Nothing to do with childcare, everything to do with their personal development and growth.

Xiaoxiong · 01/09/2021 11:45

Yeah my 2 have begged me for the last 18 months to board, I have caved to the extent of allowing them one night a week flexi-boarding. They can't wait and I am secretly super excited to see them spreading their wings and having some more independence, while still having fun together (they will be in the same bunk bed).

Lockdown was tough on all of us and we realised how much they needed to run around at school with other kids. School isn't just about education, it's also socialisation.

Come at me, OP!

MrsRobbieHart · 01/09/2021 11:42

@Cocomarine

Right, so it’s not a genuine question - where we can start interesting “what if” scenarios, as per *@HarrietsChariot* really interesting post.

It’s just you wanting a vague pop at people who’ve dared to let off steam that parenting the summer holidays can be hard?

Goady fucker 🙄

This is supposed to be a site for parents.

Yep.
NerrSnerr · 01/09/2021 11:36

I am thinking more of the parents that don't really want to spend their time with their children and count the days until the school holidays are over.

I'm one of these- but it's because it's a bloody nightmare. We don't have enough annual leave to cover the holidays. We don't have any family to help. The children hate holiday clubs. My husband and I are exhausted as we're working all hours so we can also care for our children and it'll be lovely when back at school and we can just get on with work and the weekends are just ours to spend with the family.

SleepingStandingUp · 01/09/2021 11:28

@Bettyboop3

Parttimemostofthetime sadly i feel you are in the minority. I am thinking more of the parents that don't really want to spend their time with their children and count the days until the school holidays are over. There are also plenty that seem to forget school is about education and not childcare.
Oh you mean the parents paying out more in childcare than they bring in, or who's kids have additional needs and struggle with the lack of routine, who can't afford to go away or do much and so the kids are spending nearly every day in the house, who have health issues themselves?

I mean if you're having a cheap pop at people looking forward to schools going back, what about all the parents who send their kids to boarding school? Where's the bitchy post about them?

Cocomarine · 01/09/2021 11:27

@Bettyboop3

Good point Beetlewing, i also feel very strongly that children should be treated more as individuals and nit everyone is academic or gets a great deal out of a school setting.

Ouch Cocomarine did i hit a nerve? 🤔

Not one related to my own child, no 🤷🏻‍♀️ I only have one, and have plenty of money to entertain her, and as I’m divorced don’t have her every day in the summer. She’s easy both in temperament and lack of additional needs, I wish I had more time with her. I also loved home school during Covid.

But restore finding summer easy - and too short - myself, I can empathise with other parents who don’t have it so easy. Try it.

steppemum · 01/09/2021 11:27

@Bettyboop3

Parttimemostofthetime sadly i feel you are in the minority. I am thinking more of the parents that don't really want to spend their time with their children and count the days until the school holidays are over. There are also plenty that seem to forget school is about education and not childcare.
but that is also in a context where schools do exist.

As pp said, if there were no schools, then society would be structured differently.

Look at the Amish, the boys follow the dads round all day learning how to run the farm.

But the whole of modern society, from work to housing, is formed around the idea that

  1. we work outside of the home
  2. work and children are mutually exclusive
  3. our kids are in school for their formative years.

if there were no schools, everything would be different.
But I would be willing to bet that the main care givers, the ones who would be at home and not working outside the home, would be women

And I am also sure that since humans existed childcare has been shared. Grannies in the village, while parents in the fields etc

Upamountain43 · 01/09/2021 11:22

Whilst schools have existed since ancient Greece they have only been accessible to the majority of people for a couple of hundred years maximum. And post 11/12 education for less than 100 years. But all children have been educated since there have been children!

Children would learn from their parents the skills they needed to be functioning adults within the society they live in. Our society is structured that we need qualifications but the knowledge we need to gain those qualifications is not needed to be functioning adults. An alternative would be children would learn on the job from a young age - either from their parents or apprenticeship type situations or most likely a combination.

Society would be completely different and work would be different, a lot more home based and flexible hours and child care shared between the wider family and community. People would almost certainly live much closer to their employer and their colleagues. It may well allow for a far more equal society than currently.

We would also probably be a lot more relaxed about leaving children at home on their own.

A society without formal schools is completely possible - its how the vast majority of humans lived until the industrial revolution demanded a large workforce in a large building totally seperate from the home.

SleepingStandingUp · 01/09/2021 11:22

@BroccoliFloret. No, i assume that's against the rules. I mean access to proper home learning materials and better information about how to access it and what to teach my son. I'd know how it works from my own childhood and all my peers, as opposed to schools closing one day and the teacher setting 45 minutes of work per day on the computer.

Also societally, it would be more likely that every family would have a non working parent or families would live closer together to look after rach others kids more - so like a voluntary small home learning co-op.

Bettyboop3 · 01/09/2021 11:20

Good point Beetlewing, i also feel very strongly that children should be treated more as individuals and nit everyone is academic or gets a great deal out of a school setting.

Ouch Cocomarine did i hit a nerve? 🤔

OP posts:
Deadringer · 01/09/2021 11:19

I love the school holidays and hate when they go back, but would i want to spend 24 hours a day with my kids, or anyone else for that matter? No, probably not. I am pretty sure if school wasn't a thing the human race would keep going though, so yabu, and silly.

Beetlewing · 01/09/2021 11:16

Kids still learn if they aren't at school! They would just learn more practical things. We might not be as reliant on materialistic trappings if we as kids weren't schooled in a formal setting, we'd be more mindful and conscientious, and care more about the environment

Hemingwaycat · 01/09/2021 11:15

If they didn’t exist we’d know no different and we’d all be uneducated idiots anyway so we’d all have lots of children because we wouldn’t know any different 🤷🏻‍♀️.

Miniroofbox · 01/09/2021 11:13

Well how would we get all the various sorts of engineers, doctors, nurses, healthcare professionals in other fields, vets, linguists, airline pilots… I could go on.

Or are you expecting we go back to the Stone Age?

Cocomarine · 01/09/2021 11:12

Right, so it’s not a genuine question - where we can start interesting “what if” scenarios, as per @HarrietsChariot really interesting post.

It’s just you wanting a vague pop at people who’ve dared to let off steam that parenting the summer holidays can be hard?

Goady fucker 🙄

This is supposed to be a site for parents.