Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask my almost 17YO to pay board?

282 replies

Icanflyhigh · 01/09/2021 07:57

DD is 17 end of October. She started an apprenticeship earlier in the summer and earns £14.5k per year.

Apart from buying herself lunch each day (which she doesn't HAVE to do as there is food available to take from home) she has no other outgoings.

I have asked her to contribute £50 per week to the household, for that, she will have all food provided, washing done, all the hot water she can use, lifts to wherever she wants, pretty much whenever she wants them, a lift to and from work each day (we don't live on a bus route) and other usual stuff.

Well she's made me feel like the worst mother in the world for asking.
I've explained that we've lost her child benefit now, and I'm expecting her dad to stop paying maintenance too (not that his £17 a week makes a huge difference to be fair) but our outgoings have remained the same or increased.

On top of that I've asked her to pay her own phone bill. She had a brand new iPhone X in July on the premise that she would pay the bill. We haven't had a penny yet, but its attached to our BT account so if we don't pay it, we screw up our own credit rating.

The board I have asked her for will be put straight towards her driving lessons. I've already bought her provisional driving licence and she has a car waiting for when she has passed her test.

So AIBU for asking?
What would you do if she decides not to pay it? TIA x

OP posts:
Cleverpolly3 · 01/09/2021 13:45

@LindaEllen

You actually think that university loans cover everything and parents don’t have to pay?

Most parents would want to minimise the amount of debt their children accrued at university if they could do so I think. I certainly will be.

Cleverpolly3 · 01/09/2021 13:43

This isn’t about needing the money from her as to You clearly don’t based on what she gets already from you.

The introduction of apprenticeship and a wage has raised the issue of contribution and I think that’s the mistake here. You should be using this opportunity to encourage her to start saving and to learn the value of money. A peppercorn rent as such doesn’t do that at all.

I think there is a stronger argument for insisting she contribute towards learning to drive and her car plus perhaps paying for her phone every month. That’s encouraging awareness of budgeting.

If it were me I’d keep some of the money for those things back each month and out to one side for her when she moves out.

Given that you seem to have enough money to spend freely on her now the argument you need £50 a week which doesn’t cover a phone a certain and driving lessons never mind anything else she has cost for years as a kid doesn’t hold water for me.

Perhaps tell her she needs to show you proof she is saving a good chunk of her wages not frittering them away too.

LindaEllen · 01/09/2021 13:39

@GreenLakes

Tbh I certainly wouldn’t be charging a 16 your old to live in their own home. I don’t know of any parents who do.

Presumably if she hadn’t taken up an apprenticeship, she’d be going to sixth form and then university. In which case, you’d be paying out thousands of pounds.

£14k a year is hardly rolling in it and tbh I don’t see why she should effectively be penalised for choosing to follow an apprenticeship route.

Why would she be paying out thousands of pounds? Uni students take out loans.
LindaEllen · 01/09/2021 13:38

@Rozziie

I think it's mean. She's still a child! The idea of charging your own child, the child YOU decided to bring into the world, to live in her own house doesn't sit right with me at all.

However, I would also not be funding driving lessons or anything else, really. I think free 'rent' and board is fair, and any extras like driving lessons, holidays or whatever else should be paid for out of her own pocket.

Well it's not her house is it, it's her mum's house. Nobody should be pocketing £15k a year and living for free. Nobody.
LindaEllen · 01/09/2021 13:36

YANBU. She wants to live in your house for free, have everything done for her, have you pay for her phone, get lifts to work, AND keep £15,000 a year to herself?! Sorry but what world is she living in? What the actual fuck?

We've had a similar situation with 18yo. Got a job right after finishing college, earning more than my minimum wage DP, does fuck all in the house, and won't give us a penny. We're struggling, plus DP's child benefit has stopped plus £400 a month maintenance from 18yo's mum.

He is going to uni in a few weeks so that will be a financial relief, but honestly, he eats us out of house and home, has 2 half hour showers every day, does his washing a couple of items at a time (because he resents that I said I wasn't doing his washing anymore as he has more time off than me - he washes items as he needs them, then he tumble dries them rather than hang them out).. and he's stopped visiting his mum now he legally doesn't have to, so he's here 100% of the time yet we're much worse off and really struggling.

And he won't even pick up the odd thing from the shop on his way home from work without asking us for the money when he gets home (after moaning about being asked in the first place).

Rozziie · 01/09/2021 13:29

I think it's mean. She's still a child! The idea of charging your own child, the child YOU decided to bring into the world, to live in her own house doesn't sit right with me at all.

However, I would also not be funding driving lessons or anything else, really. I think free 'rent' and board is fair, and any extras like driving lessons, holidays or whatever else should be paid for out of her own pocket.

GreenLakes · 01/09/2021 13:23

I would say though that there’s a difference between charging her rent and asking her to fund her own driving lessons.

I don’t have an issue with expecting DC to pay the costs of running a car (as it is optional). But I don’t think it’s acceptable at all to make a 16 year old pay ‘rent’ to live in their own home.

I think it’s perhaps your framing of the whole thing that caused the issue.

GreenLakes · 01/09/2021 13:19

Tbh I certainly wouldn’t be charging a 16 your old to live in their own home. I don’t know of any parents who do.

Presumably if she hadn’t taken up an apprenticeship, she’d be going to sixth form and then university. In which case, you’d be paying out thousands of pounds.

£14k a year is hardly rolling in it and tbh I don’t see why she should effectively be penalised for choosing to follow an apprenticeship route.

RandomMess · 01/09/2021 13:12

When my DD was getting cross about paying board she looked into moving out.

She quickly realised what a bargain she was getting 🤣

All your DD is actually covering is the lost child benefit, maintenance and covering her phone bill!

Oodles54 · 01/09/2021 12:21

This has made it to The Sun already, well actually did 2 hrs ago just saw it while scrolling through fb

SueSaid · 01/09/2021 12:09

I wouldn't take £50 a week off a 17yr old for board and lodge. The bills would need paying regardless.

What I would do is make them pay for all their own treats etc. So before a salary parents would be giving them money every time they go out, that obviously would stop. Board and lodge seems a bit ott though imo.

Keke94LND · 01/09/2021 11:59

YANBU, I moved back home for a bit when I was 21 and was earning £21k whilst spending £400 on my commute a month and I paid my mum and dad £200 a month, because I'm a grown up with money 🤷🏼‍♀️ my mum and dad saved the money I gave them and gave it back to me when I moved out again but I didn't expect them to do that, if she doesn't pay her way a bit how will she learn, she could always move out and be charged much more than £50 a week!

Raindancer411 · 01/09/2021 11:49

@icedcoffees

I think you've spoilt her too much - why are you paying for a brand new iPhone, a car and driving lessons when she's earning 15k a year?

If she wants those things, she can sort them and pay for them herself. She can contact instructors and book/pay for lessons. She can get herself a cheap phone if she can't get a contract and pay for it out of her salary.

She doesn't need a car at seventeen years old - she can have lessons and pay for a cheap runaround if she wants it.

And she should be paying rent ON TOP of those things. £200 a month for food, bills and rent is nothing. Don't make it cover driving lessons too. Mine cost almost £50 a week for a two hour lesson - it's not cheap.

This...

I had to pay for my own lessons and car and I only had a Saturday job!!

HeronLanyon · 01/09/2021 11:46

So sorrynop I hadn’t read an update te need for car.
I think I’d try to rejuges what you lay for so at 16 she isn’t being asked to lay for her basic needs such as food. That may well feel, to a young mind, as hard. Same good message about financial responsibility would be maybe less linked with basic needs if it were connected to eg driving lessons or her phone which she could pay for for herself ? Plus some into a savings account.

stepupandbecounted · 01/09/2021 11:45

200gbp a month is much too much as well. Max should be 20.00 a week she isn't earning that much!! Especially not if she is running a car. I think you are being quite unfair and sound quite harsh. She is a kid for christ sake. Still a child until she is 18 years old.

stepupandbecounted · 01/09/2021 11:42

My dd is the same age, and they are very young at sixteen to be paying board, in my view. I would ask her for a small contribution and then save it for her into a savings account to be given to her at 25 years old with a view to putting it towards a deposit for a house etc.

I would let her enjoy the feeling of having her own money, small contribution to the house and she needs to be doing her own washing anyway and running her life preparing for independence.

Icanflyhigh · 01/09/2021 11:39

Thanks all, I should clarify re the car. My mum has given her a car - she's unable drive any more through ill health and it seems daft to have it sat there doing nothing when DD could use it. That said, she has mentioned it isn't the car she would choose for herself and has been looking at other options to buy herself a car.

She will be paying her own insurance, I've explained how expensive it is and the car from my mum will be about as cheap as it gets for a 17YO new driver- though still extortionate!!

Me and her stepdad agreed to the new phone as her contract was up for renewal, it was a good deal and the caveat was that she paid for it.

Now, IF she was still at 6th form or college and doing a part time job, I wouldn't have even considered this, but as it is, she has landed a very good apprenticeship with a brilliant salary attached for her age and I want to do the right thing with teaching her about budgeting and finance.

She is working 40 hours a week, with the training element all in house.

Yes I'll admit she has been a bit spoilt but we've done the best we can for all three DC, and always will.

With regard to paying for her driving lessons, it was always planned that she would have driving lessons for her 17th birthday and that hasn't changed, but if we use her board money towards that too, then we can potentially afford an intensive course for her with a test at the end of it - and providing she passes that test, she could be on the road by Xmas. That means I don't have to make the twice daily journey to take her and pick her up from work, as well as making sure her younger siblings are both in school on time.

As I said before, we don't live on a bus route, it's a minimum of a 1.5 mile walk to the main road to get a bus, there are no pavements or street lights for much of this so it isn't safe to make her walk for a bus.

This is not about making money out of my child, this is about teaching her how to budget and manage her finances.

Once the driving lessons are paid, future months board will go into a savings account and will be used either as we need them for the household, or to make the load a little lighter at Xmas/birthdays etc.

We are a family of 5, we both work full time (me and DH), but neither of us are massively high earners.

I should also point out that exH has continued to pay maintenance as directed by CMS, at a total of £51 to be split between 3DC. I don't have any conversation with him re this, and I won't challenge him if/when he stops paying it.

I refuse to pay for DD to buy lunch at the office every day, there is always food at home she can make herself a packed lunch with. I/DH continue to cook an evening meal for all of us every day and we are quite happy to accommodate her boyfriend too when he stays here.

Her washing gets done with ours, and I can't imagine not doing it or withholding detergent etc. I also make sure she has the toiletries she likes too, decent shampoo etc.

I wish I could get all of this for 50 quid a week!

OP posts:
oohthatrisottowasnice · 01/09/2021 11:27

My 18 yo starts an apprenticeship next week and I'm not asking him for any contribution. He will take over paying for his phone contact and the fuel, insurance and maintenance for his car.

thistimelastweek · 01/09/2021 11:25
  • lessons not reasons
thistimelastweek · 01/09/2021 11:25

I don't think it's unreasonable to ask for a contribution towards good and board. But that's not what you're doing. What you are doing is deciding how part of her earnings should be used; ie saved for driving lessons. That's her decision to make.

By all means charge rent if you want to but leave funding of driving reasons - and phones - for her to figure.

Her money, her choice. If she squanders it, so be it.

PheasantsNest · 01/09/2021 11:23

That's far too much. I would say £50 a month.

ssd · 01/09/2021 11:20

I know shes getting pelters here but i dont think she deserves them. Youve not taught her the value of money, or the value of you op. Why does she have a car sitting waiting for her??? Shes spoiled, spoiled by you and now youre getting huffy about it. Acknowledge your own faults here before printing off a thread to show her Hmm

SpilltheTea · 01/09/2021 11:14

If this is the attitude she has now, she's really going to struggle in a few years. Why does she thinks it's acceptable not to contribute, especially for her own phone? She sounds spoilt honestly and like she needs some lessons in independence and responsibility. It's not being mean, it's a reality check.

MidnightMeltdown · 01/09/2021 11:14

@icedcoffees

I think you've spoilt her too much - why are you paying for a brand new iPhone, a car and driving lessons when she's earning 15k a year?

If she wants those things, she can sort them and pay for them herself. She can contact instructors and book/pay for lessons. She can get herself a cheap phone if she can't get a contract and pay for it out of her salary.

She doesn't need a car at seventeen years old - she can have lessons and pay for a cheap runaround if she wants it.

And she should be paying rent ON TOP of those things. £200 a month for food, bills and rent is nothing. Don't make it cover driving lessons too. Mine cost almost £50 a week for a two hour lesson - it's not cheap.

This exactly. I didn't want to sound rude, but she does sound quite spoilt. You shouldn't be paying for phones, cars, driving lessons etc when she's earning her own money.

Cuddlyrottweiler · 01/09/2021 11:09

Usually I'd say you're bu but if you're paying for everything then I think it's fair.