Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask my almost 17YO to pay board?

282 replies

Icanflyhigh · 01/09/2021 07:57

DD is 17 end of October. She started an apprenticeship earlier in the summer and earns £14.5k per year.

Apart from buying herself lunch each day (which she doesn't HAVE to do as there is food available to take from home) she has no other outgoings.

I have asked her to contribute £50 per week to the household, for that, she will have all food provided, washing done, all the hot water she can use, lifts to wherever she wants, pretty much whenever she wants them, a lift to and from work each day (we don't live on a bus route) and other usual stuff.

Well she's made me feel like the worst mother in the world for asking.
I've explained that we've lost her child benefit now, and I'm expecting her dad to stop paying maintenance too (not that his £17 a week makes a huge difference to be fair) but our outgoings have remained the same or increased.

On top of that I've asked her to pay her own phone bill. She had a brand new iPhone X in July on the premise that she would pay the bill. We haven't had a penny yet, but its attached to our BT account so if we don't pay it, we screw up our own credit rating.

The board I have asked her for will be put straight towards her driving lessons. I've already bought her provisional driving licence and she has a car waiting for when she has passed her test.

So AIBU for asking?
What would you do if she decides not to pay it? TIA x

OP posts:
CatsArePeople · 01/09/2021 21:52

We want her to realise what a great set up she has at home, & learn about what life costs.

Plenty of young people happily ditch "great setup" for "independence" in a shitty relationship or chaotic living (with illegal substances and petty crime). Teenagers aren't known for reasonable judgement.

ChargingBuck · 01/09/2021 21:23

As for all those saying she can move out. Seriously? You want a teenage girl to shack up with a first possible boyfriend, or go squatting with some dodgy friends?

No, @CatsArePeople. We want her to realise what a great set up she has at home, & learn about what life costs. Asking her to consider what it would cost a young adult to live independently illustrates the bargain she is getting at home, & what a lucky girl she is to be bought a car etc.

cittigirl · 01/09/2021 20:05

Yanbu.
I was charged about 60% of my take home pay when I was that age and it certainly wasnt put aside for me.

My parents were rubbish with money.....I've always been pretty good with money, because of them I think. I think it's a good lesson to learn. I intend on doing similar with my dd if she hangs around long enough, but I will save it for her....mostly 😉

Rozziie · 01/09/2021 20:01

@CatsArePeople

YABU. Fair enough that she should pay her own phone bill, transportation and things that she needs to buy for herself, like clothes or toiletries. But pay board to live at home? That's grabby.

As for all those saying she can move out. Seriously? You want a teenage girl to shack up with a first possible boyfriend, or go squatting with some dodgy friends?

This is exactly the sort of scenario that leads to that. If OP wants her daughter to end up in an abusive relationship or getting involved with the wrong sorts of people, making her feel unwelcome in her own home is a great way to go about it. My aunt threw my cousin out at 16 because of some petty rubbish like her not doing enough chores or paying her way, and she ended up pregnant and living with a (much older) narcissist within a few months.

I think a lot of people who think 'tough love' is good parenting later end up wondering why their kids don't talk to them anymore or visit. A lot of them seem to end up in the worst and cheapest care homes too. Funny that. It goes both ways.

IwantToDatePicard · 01/09/2021 19:53

@GreenLakes

I would say though that there’s a difference between charging her rent and asking her to fund her own driving lessons.

I don’t have an issue with expecting DC to pay the costs of running a car (as it is optional). But I don’t think it’s acceptable at all to make a 16 year old pay ‘rent’ to live in their own home.

I think it’s perhaps your framing of the whole thing that caused the issue.

This, I don't charge my dd rent but she paid for her own driving lessons and bought her own car at 18.
IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 01/09/2021 19:39

I’d let her pay for the driving lessons but no I wouldn’t charge a 16 year old rent just because her child benefit has stopped.

CatsArePeople · 01/09/2021 19:22

YABU.
Fair enough that she should pay her own phone bill, transportation and things that she needs to buy for herself, like clothes or toiletries. But pay board to live at home? That's grabby.

As for all those saying she can move out. Seriously? You want a teenage girl to shack up with a first possible boyfriend, or go squatting with some dodgy friends?

chocolateorangeinhaler · 01/09/2021 19:21

God no you are not unreasonable at all. I was paying board at 16 when I started work and child allowance stopped.
She has a choice here. She can pay £50 a week to you or go and find somewhere else to live for £50 a week that includes everything she's getting at home. Let her wear herself out trying to prove to you that she can.
Paying bills as you become an adult is something everyone on this planet has to do, she is not exempt.

Feelingoktoday · 01/09/2021 19:20

It’s really not about the money. It’s about teaching your child to budget, save and understand the value of money. I can afford to take 20% of my son and save it. However if I couldn’t afford to save it on his behalf 20% really doesn’t go far in an all inclusive luxury house plus he gets his washing done.

Rozziie · 01/09/2021 19:18

@theemmadilemma

FFS, the child is basically earning a full time wage. She's adulting. She needs to learn to pay her way in life. She's now of an age and income to contribute and understand how life works as an adult. Jesus, some of you will raise incapable kids.
She's not an adult though, is she? It's not appropriate to expect your child to pay rent just because they chose to do an apprenticeship rather than keep studying.

Most 16-year-olds are full-time students, so it's hardly making someone 'incapable' if they don't need to pay rent at that age! The girl can still do her own laundry, cooking, pay for her own driving lessons, do housework, etc.

Nobody at my uni had ever paid rent before they moved into halls at 18, and absolutely everyone managed just fine with adulting and getting things done. Weird, that.

theemmadilemma · 01/09/2021 19:14

FFS, the child is basically earning a full time wage. She's adulting. She needs to learn to pay her way in life. She's now of an age and income to contribute and understand how life works as an adult. Jesus, some of you will raise incapable kids.

theemmadilemma · 01/09/2021 19:11

From the time I worked full time, (this would meet that) I had to give 1/3 of my earnings to my Mum for board.

Rozziie · 01/09/2021 19:06

@ChargingBuck

And it's very hard to move out as a 16-year-old.

Of course it is @Rozziie, Because even renting a room in a houseshare is going to take a couple of hundred a week, & that's before food, travel costs, utilities ...

OP is hardly being mean - she's still subsidising her daughter, who is also being given a car & having driving lessons paid for - as well as having household chores performed for her, her own choice of toiletries provided etc. Just also teaching a lesson about the cost of living.

Nothing immoral about that - but you do you.

Well, the point is, she can't even get a room in a houseshare, can she? She's a child. The council will house her if she's homeless, that's about it.

I grew up with a mother with your mentality and we now have a very fractured relationship. Talking about 'subsidising' a CHILD is gross. In most other countries, parents happily have adult children living at home until well into their twenties and even thirties. I've lived in loads of other places and only in Britain do people seem to think it's OK to treat their children like this.

Do you think people in other countries don't grow up and learn to adult? Of course they do. The tough love mindset and making things even harder than they need to be is unnecessary.

If OP doesn't want to clean up and do chores, that's fine. She doesn't have to do her washing and clean her bedroom. She does, however, have a legal obligation to provide for the child she brought into the world.

DaisyArtichoke7 · 01/09/2021 19:04

If you are going to use the money to pay for her driving lessons why don't you tell her to pay for the driving lessons herself? Job done surely? She is learning to pay for the things she needs and you don't have to argue over rent.

SleepingStandingUp · 01/09/2021 19:01

This child is old enough to move out if someone will take a tenancy on for her
get married with parental permission
& have her own child always been a weird outlier given the above points
She also has a job which out-earns many adults adult minimum wage full time is over 18k. You can't compare her to someone working part time and decry their lower income

ChargingBuck · 01/09/2021 18:59

And it's very hard to move out as a 16-year-old.

Of course it is @Rozziie, Because even renting a room in a houseshare is going to take a couple of hundred a week, & that's before food, travel costs, utilities ...

OP is hardly being mean - she's still subsidising her daughter, who is also being given a car & having driving lessons paid for - as well as having household chores performed for her, her own choice of toiletries provided etc. Just also teaching a lesson about the cost of living.

Nothing immoral about that - but you do you.

SleepingStandingUp · 01/09/2021 18:54

Well one the one hand if she's unhappy, she can live with her Dad...

On the other hand some of the things you've listed like lifts. Well its not her fault you live in the middle of nowhere. And you were getting her droving lessons for her 17th but now you intend to use her board money for them, that feels a bit 🤨 but I'm not sure why.

I would look at pulling back on what you pay for - clothes, extra bits, toiletries beyond the basics etc. but ultimately if you can't afford to keep her without her CB /tax credits/ CMS I'd look at asking for that - £13 pw for CB and £17 for CMS, what's the drop in tax credits? she is old enough to understand you're skint

If you can afford to keep her, I'd say she pays from the August after she turns 18 / roughly when she'd have left school but talk to her seriously about savings

Rozziie · 01/09/2021 18:53

@ChargingBuck so what? She isn't choosing to do those things, is she? Her parents are still legally responsible for her. And it's very hard to move out as a 16-year-old. In most cases, she would have to be housed by the local authority. And can only get married with parental permission because she's, you know, a child.

No, I'm not from a wealthy family at all. I just think it's disgusting to take rent/food money from a child under 18. I would never dream of it and indeed, it's probably a big part of why I haven't had children myself. I will never think it's OK to charge the child I decided to have for basic survival.

The issue here isn't the amount of money, it's how it's being framed. Telling a 16-year-old they have to pay for their own driving lessons, phone and clothes (assuming she wants fashionable ones) is reasonable. Telling a 16-year-old to pay for room and board, IMO, is not. It would be better to just tell the girl she has to pay for all her 'wants' herself out of her wages rather than charging her for the roof over her head as if it's some kind of privilege.

MidnightMeltdown · 01/09/2021 18:48

@stepupandbecounted

As parents we should be covering the basics until adulthood as a minimum.

If she was in college you would have to fund much more than the house bills and food etc, and if she was doing a degree/masters for many years she would be living with you with no bills, but because she has secured a great apprenticeship she is now going to be punished with some big bills from you (and I would argue working 40+ hours a week and the responsibilities at her age is A LOT to take on)

Back off and give her some support.

Not necessarily. I did A levels and a degree and my parents didn't pay a penny. I got a student loan and a part time job and I certainly wasn't living at home having my parents buying my food and paying my bills!

It's not a lot to take in at all. Plenty of young people who stay in full time education have a job on the side to make ends meet, so work far harder.

ChargingBuck · 01/09/2021 18:37

@stepupandbecounted

As parents we should be covering the basics until adulthood as a minimum.

If she was in college you would have to fund much more than the house bills and food etc, and if she was doing a degree/masters for many years she would be living with you with no bills, but because she has secured a great apprenticeship she is now going to be punished with some big bills from you (and I would argue working 40+ hours a week and the responsibilities at her age is A LOT to take on)

Back off and give her some support.

& maybe, like millions of other young adults, this DD won't be doing a degree or a masters because that would be unaffordable for her family.

Not everyone is middle class, with middle class finances.
£50 a week for everything, on a comfortable apprentice salary, is not a punishment ffs.

ChargingBuck · 01/09/2021 18:34

[quote Rozziie]@ChargingBuck it's not her concern what it costs her mother to keep her!! She.Is.A.Child.

Just because she's chosen to do an apprenticeship rather than school/college doesn't mean it's OK for her parents to decide they're not going to cover her basic needs anymore. They should tell her to buy her own driving lessons and sort her own phone, but asking for rent money is not OK.[/quote]
This child is old enough to move out, get married, & have her own child.
She also has a job which out-earns many adults.

Not teaching children basic budgeting skills & finance facts is irresponsible & setting them up for failure.

And her parents ARE still covering her basic needs. All they are asking for is a small contribution to them, so that their daughter can become a fully fledged adult who understands the cost of living.

Maybe you come from a wealthy background, but I can assure you that there are millions of families in the UK that simply cannot afford to subsidise their working children. Pearl-clutching about She.Is.A.Child!! doesn't make it any more affordable for those families, so I think a little more thought on the financial realities & a little less moralising might be helpful to OP.

MatildaTheCat · 01/09/2021 17:52

YANBU.

Re driving I’d be cautious about fast tracking her lessons too much. She’s young, you sound rural and the nights are drawing in. IME people drive fast on country roads. She’s already learning a new skill in her apprenticeship presumably so trying to drive independently as quickly as possible does sound appealing on one hand but I personally would prefer to see my DC learn a a slower pace and consolidate with a LOT of practice before going it alone.

Good luck to her and to you with the conversation this evening.

stepupandbecounted · 01/09/2021 17:44

As parents we should be covering the basics until adulthood as a minimum.

If she was in college you would have to fund much more than the house bills and food etc, and if she was doing a degree/masters for many years she would be living with you with no bills, but because she has secured a great apprenticeship she is now going to be punished with some big bills from you (and I would argue working 40+ hours a week and the responsibilities at her age is A LOT to take on)

Back off and give her some support.

Rozziie · 01/09/2021 17:44

@ChargingBuck it's not her concern what it costs her mother to keep her!! She.Is.A.Child.

Just because she's chosen to do an apprenticeship rather than school/college doesn't mean it's OK for her parents to decide they're not going to cover her basic needs anymore. They should tell her to buy her own driving lessons and sort her own phone, but asking for rent money is not OK.

stepupandbecounted · 01/09/2021 17:41

I don't agree, she is a child.

I would give her some time to save up for her car insurance and let her get used to working first. It looks really grabby jumping in with your demands when she has only just started. Really grabby. If I were her I would be looking to move out and stay with a friend.

There is one thing making a small contribution and quite another shouldering hundreds of pounds at 16 years of age.