Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask my almost 17YO to pay board?

282 replies

Icanflyhigh · 01/09/2021 07:57

DD is 17 end of October. She started an apprenticeship earlier in the summer and earns £14.5k per year.

Apart from buying herself lunch each day (which she doesn't HAVE to do as there is food available to take from home) she has no other outgoings.

I have asked her to contribute £50 per week to the household, for that, she will have all food provided, washing done, all the hot water she can use, lifts to wherever she wants, pretty much whenever she wants them, a lift to and from work each day (we don't live on a bus route) and other usual stuff.

Well she's made me feel like the worst mother in the world for asking.
I've explained that we've lost her child benefit now, and I'm expecting her dad to stop paying maintenance too (not that his £17 a week makes a huge difference to be fair) but our outgoings have remained the same or increased.

On top of that I've asked her to pay her own phone bill. She had a brand new iPhone X in July on the premise that she would pay the bill. We haven't had a penny yet, but its attached to our BT account so if we don't pay it, we screw up our own credit rating.

The board I have asked her for will be put straight towards her driving lessons. I've already bought her provisional driving licence and she has a car waiting for when she has passed her test.

So AIBU for asking?
What would you do if she decides not to pay it? TIA x

OP posts:
PlanDeRaccordement · 02/09/2021 09:52

@aSofaNearYou
I know what you're saying but this is a very middle class attitude. Some do it purely for the tough love life lesson, but most parents who charge board from their young adult children do it because that is a genuine reflection of the family's finances.

But that isn’t the case with this OP. She has said from the start that she doesn’t need the money for household finances as she plans to put all of it towards driving lessons. So yes, in this case it is “tough love” although everything the OP has said about her 16 yo DD just drips with scorn and contempt.

bettertimesarecomingnow · 02/09/2021 09:47

No that's fine! Our 16yo has started up self employed and he's earning a good few hundred quid a week. He pays digs - £50 a week - on his own suggestion.

ChargingBuck · 02/09/2021 09:46

I know what you're saying but this is a very middle class attitude. Some do it purely for the tough love life lesson, but most parents who charge board from their young adult children do it because that is a genuine reflection of the family's finances. Everyone needs to chip in. It might not be ideal but it is a normal part of family life for lots of people. Bear in mind in some cultures she would have been working from a younger age on OPs instruction. She really doesn't have it that bad. It's only for the middle class upwards that this is a shocking concept.

Hear hear @aSofaNearYou.
Some people are so eager to kick the OP that she's now a monster for living rurally ffs ....

A lot of posts on this thread moralising about "punishing" a child by needing some of her hard-earned cash are utterly oblivious to the fact that millions of families simply couldn't afford to do otherwise.
The remark upthread about "just because your child benefit has stopped you shouldn't expect her to pay" is a classic example. For many parents, that child benefit was food on the table, not discretionary spends.

And ... cue a flurry of posts claiming not to be MC or privileged - again, oblivious to the fact that privilege is invisible to the privileged.

Chilver · 02/09/2021 09:43

I agree she should be paying board but more importantly I think you and she should be sitting down for a financial planning session now she is earning a fairly decent wage. For example, she should be looking at investing/ pensions now - the earlier she starts, the less she will miss it and boy oh boy will she benefit from it later in life. I tell all my graduates starting to put the maximum they can away now because you can NEVER plan on what happens in your life further down the line (early cancer for me and a decade of no pensions contributions as a result) - the scenarios of starting to invest/ pension early vs later in life are startling. She will likely never have this much disposable income ever again in her life.

PlanDeRaccordement · 02/09/2021 09:41

@Icanflyhigh

Varied responses..... Nice to get balance.

We had a chat last night. She'd told her dad I was charging £150! A WEEK, which explains why he was being so shitty.

Upshot is, she's decided she'll pay what I used to pay which was £25 a week and nothing more - despite me then being on less than half of what she earns now.

She will only give it to me in cash, she won't set up a direct debit and make a transfer either weekly or monthly.

And despite being paid on Tuesday this week (2 days ago) she can't afford to pay it this month.
So unfortunately for her I have prioritised my youngest two DC and they are having a much needed lie in this morning. Meanwhile she will be late for work having spent 25 quid getting there by taxi.

She will cut her nose off to spite her face, and it will be her loss - though I'm aware we might be in for a rough few days of tantrums and moods.

For all of those going on about driving lessons, the plan was always to pay for some driving lessons for her 17th birthday. Her paying board would have enabled us to pay for more for her, but it seems the general consensus is that I shouldn't be doing that, so I'll leave it with her.

I can guarantee she will squander her wages on takeaway, cinema trips and taxis to see her boyfriend (who treats her like shit).

And there was me trying to be a responsible parent and teach her some life skills. Ah well, can't win 'em all!

That was a petty thing to do to let her be late for work in retaliation. I am not surprised she’s with a boyfriend that treats her like shit, that’s how you treat her and so she thinks that love= being treated like shit.
aSofaNearYou · 02/09/2021 09:31

@stepupandbecounted

Some people have had crap childhoods with very little support and wish to keep continuing the hardship cycle because 'why should they have it any easier' therefore guaranteeing the shit parenting/deprivation/poverty continues in their families.

What a wonderful legacy to pass on to your children yet more 'tough love' will be meted out. And apparently no emotional intelligence or awareness by these posters of what they are actually doing.

I know what you're saying but this is a very middle class attitude. Some do it purely for the tough love life lesson, but most parents who charge board from their young adult children do it because that is a genuine reflection of the family's finances. Everyone needs to chip in. It might not be ideal but it is a normal part of family life for lots of people. Bear in mind in some cultures she would have been working from a younger age on OPs instruction. She really doesn't have it that bad. It's only for the middle class upwards that this is a shocking concept.
SyIviescup · 02/09/2021 09:30

@Rozziie

God, I feel so, so sorry for your daughter, OP.

Stuck in a rural area because YOU decided to move there and late to work because you're refusing to drive her in to teach her a lesson. What if she loses her job now? Great lesson! That'll learn her, eh?

You're short of money mostly because her dad won't pay maintenance. Instead of blaming him for that, or yourself for picking such a crap father for your child, that's her problem as well now.

I'm not surprised her boyfriend treats her like crap - look at the sort of people she has in her life! A dad who you think is exploiting her for money (and you're blaming your child for this, not your ex) and a hard mother who talks about her with contempt even though most people would be very proud to have a daughter who has landed a decent apprenticeship in a pandemic.

The lack of self awareness brings tears to my eyes, honestly. Everything is someone else's fault or problem, never yours. Can't wait for when you're posting here in six months about how your daughter is pregnant, unemployed, and living with her abusive boyfriend and how stupid and selfish she is, without even a hint of acknowledgement of what you did wrong.

Thats out of order and you need to get a grip. Tears to your eyes? FFS! Hmm
PlanDeRaccordement · 02/09/2021 09:30

YABU,
You don’t need the money for household bill, because you’ve said it will all be used to pay for her driving lessons.

She is not an adult, but still a child so your responsibility to feed, clothe, house and educate.

I would simply tell her she needs to pay for her phone and driving lessons and leave it at that. Taking money off her doesn’t teach her to budget at all because you’re doing it for her.

Rozziie · 02/09/2021 09:26

@stepupandbecounted

Some people have had crap childhoods with very little support and wish to keep continuing the hardship cycle because 'why should they have it any easier' therefore guaranteeing the shit parenting/deprivation/poverty continues in their families.

What a wonderful legacy to pass on to your children yet more 'tough love' will be meted out. And apparently no emotional intelligence or awareness by these posters of what they are actually doing.

Yep. Bang on. It's actually sickening to read.
Rozziie · 02/09/2021 09:25

God, I feel so, so sorry for your daughter, OP.

Stuck in a rural area because YOU decided to move there and late to work because you're refusing to drive her in to teach her a lesson. What if she loses her job now? Great lesson! That'll learn her, eh?

You're short of money mostly because her dad won't pay maintenance. Instead of blaming him for that, or yourself for picking such a crap father for your child, that's her problem as well now.

I'm not surprised her boyfriend treats her like crap - look at the sort of people she has in her life! A dad who you think is exploiting her for money (and you're blaming your child for this, not your ex) and a hard mother who talks about her with contempt even though most people would be very proud to have a daughter who has landed a decent apprenticeship in a pandemic.

The lack of self awareness brings tears to my eyes, honestly. Everything is someone else's fault or problem, never yours. Can't wait for when you're posting here in six months about how your daughter is pregnant, unemployed, and living with her abusive boyfriend and how stupid and selfish she is, without even a hint of acknowledgement of what you did wrong.

crossstitchingnana · 02/09/2021 09:25

My dd is earning just under £10000 and I ask for £100 a month. She pays her own phone and her driving lessons. It's a lot cheaper than a place of her own. I do feel mean but then without asking she'd have hundreds a month to do with what she wants. Life is not like that, I don't get to do it.

LaikO · 02/09/2021 09:21

Yanbu, and after reading your latest updates, definitely let her go ahead and spend all her money on taxis and eventually fund her own driving lessons. You're not obliged to give her lifts, she has somewhere safe and warm to live, clothing and food and drink. If she can't afford anything else, tough.
Fwiw, I'd have been happy to contribute if I was in her position, she'll regret it when she's skint after paying full whack for driving lessons!

TodayIsYesterday · 02/09/2021 09:12

I actually have a sneaking suspicion she's lent money to her dad to pay for his holiday abroad which is why she doesn't want me to see her accounts. More fool her if she has as she will never see it again.

He would take money from his teenage daughter to pay for his holiday, I’d be very angry about that. I know she’s being challenging at the moment, but I’d want to protect her from that.

IdblowJonSnow · 02/09/2021 09:10

Yanbu- that is a lot of money for someone that age to earn. Why does she think it's ok for you to be out of pocket?!

Don't let her make you feel guilty - she needs to grow up a bit!!

Icanflyhigh · 02/09/2021 09:05

@Fr0thandBubble

I have to say I wouldn’t ask mine to give me a bean, ever. I’d make sure they were saving some of their pay though.
She would rather pay for taxis here there and everywhere than be honest with me about savings and what she has spent.

I actually have a sneaking suspicion she's lent money to her dad to pay for his holiday abroad which is why she doesn't want me to see her accounts. More fool her if she has as she will never see it again.

OP posts:
Fr0thandBubble · 02/09/2021 09:03

I have to say I wouldn’t ask mine to give me a bean, ever. I’d make sure they were saving some of their pay though.

Icanflyhigh · 02/09/2021 09:02

Varied responses..... Nice to get balance.

We had a chat last night. She'd told her dad I was charging £150! A WEEK, which explains why he was being so shitty.

Upshot is, she's decided she'll pay what I used to pay which was £25 a week and nothing more - despite me then being on less than half of what she earns now.

She will only give it to me in cash, she won't set up a direct debit and make a transfer either weekly or monthly.

And despite being paid on Tuesday this week (2 days ago) she can't afford to pay it this month.
So unfortunately for her I have prioritised my youngest two DC and they are having a much needed lie in this morning. Meanwhile she will be late for work having spent 25 quid getting there by taxi.

She will cut her nose off to spite her face, and it will be her loss - though I'm aware we might be in for a rough few days of tantrums and moods.

For all of those going on about driving lessons, the plan was always to pay for some driving lessons for her 17th birthday. Her paying board would have enabled us to pay for more for her, but it seems the general consensus is that I shouldn't be doing that, so I'll leave it with her.

I can guarantee she will squander her wages on takeaway, cinema trips and taxis to see her boyfriend (who treats her like shit).

And there was me trying to be a responsible parent and teach her some life skills. Ah well, can't win 'em all!

OP posts:
OfNick · 02/09/2021 08:57

Your daughter earns more than me (albeit I work part time and am a single parent, but even so). I've told my children that if they leave school and decide not to carry onto further education they will be expected to get a job and contribute to the household costs. I won't be able to afford to do this after losing child tax and benefit.

Icanflyhigh · 02/09/2021 08:50

@Jangle33

Why on earth would having a car be a good idea? They are extremely expensive to run, strongly recommend you get rid of that as an unnecessary expense. And yes she should pay for her own phone, anything else at 17 seems tough unless you really can’t manage financially.
We live rurally 1.5 miles from a main road with a bus route. She NEEDS to be able to drive ASAP. We've lived here for over 12 years, it isn't like we moved here recently.
OP posts:
billy1966 · 02/09/2021 08:43

Encouraging her to get her driving licence asap is a great life skill in her pocket and money very well spent.

Cactusmum · 02/09/2021 08:22

Yep if they are earning money, they need to contribute. Its not necessarily for our benefit, its so they start getting used to having responsibilites and bills. My 18 yr old pays 10% of her pay per week board (about $50) plus $50 a week to pay off half of the car we bought her (that'll only take about another 7 months) Plus pays her car insurance and phone bill monthly. Shes more than happy with this.

Jangle33 · 02/09/2021 07:47

Why on earth would having a car be a good idea? They are extremely expensive to run, strongly recommend you get rid of that as an unnecessary expense. And yes she should pay for her own phone, anything else at 17 seems tough unless you really can’t manage financially.

stepupandbecounted · 02/09/2021 07:43

Some people have had crap childhoods with very little support and wish to keep continuing the hardship cycle because 'why should they have it any easier' therefore guaranteeing the shit parenting/deprivation/poverty continues in their families.

What a wonderful legacy to pass on to your children yet more 'tough love' will be meted out. And apparently no emotional intelligence or awareness by these posters of what they are actually doing.

winniemum · 01/09/2021 22:34

No I absolutely would not charge her rent on £14.5k a year!
Yes to paying her own phone bill etc but she needs all the help she can get for when she’s in her 20s.
17 is still young, I can’t imagine anyone who is saying let her stay somewhere else has older children!
What’s the point in taking money from your DC only to save it for them?
Surely they need to learn how to save for themselves.
If they spend it all in rubbish, they soon learn.

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 01/09/2021 22:09

I think a lot of people who think 'tough love' is good parenting later end up wondering why their kids don't talk to them anymore or visit

I know.

From the daughters point of view, imagine being told now there’s no government money you need to make up the shortfall and double it to continue to live at home as a child. That’s how I would view it if I were her.
Picking up her phone and lesson costs is one thing, paying rent to live at home with parents quite another.