Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask my almost 17YO to pay board?

282 replies

Icanflyhigh · 01/09/2021 07:57

DD is 17 end of October. She started an apprenticeship earlier in the summer and earns £14.5k per year.

Apart from buying herself lunch each day (which she doesn't HAVE to do as there is food available to take from home) she has no other outgoings.

I have asked her to contribute £50 per week to the household, for that, she will have all food provided, washing done, all the hot water she can use, lifts to wherever she wants, pretty much whenever she wants them, a lift to and from work each day (we don't live on a bus route) and other usual stuff.

Well she's made me feel like the worst mother in the world for asking.
I've explained that we've lost her child benefit now, and I'm expecting her dad to stop paying maintenance too (not that his £17 a week makes a huge difference to be fair) but our outgoings have remained the same or increased.

On top of that I've asked her to pay her own phone bill. She had a brand new iPhone X in July on the premise that she would pay the bill. We haven't had a penny yet, but its attached to our BT account so if we don't pay it, we screw up our own credit rating.

The board I have asked her for will be put straight towards her driving lessons. I've already bought her provisional driving licence and she has a car waiting for when she has passed her test.

So AIBU for asking?
What would you do if she decides not to pay it? TIA x

OP posts:
FlowerPower3110 · 02/09/2021 20:00

If she doesn't pay don't cook for her, don't allow her access to laundry detergent etc, no doubt anything for her, lifts, laundry etc, if she doesn't want to pay for her luxuries and recognise you are being very generous, she can pay for everything she needs.

She is 16, still a child. You can't possibly be serious?!

wedwewerpink · 02/09/2021 19:55

@KingdomScrolls
If she doesn't pay don't cook for her, don't allow her access to laundry detergent etc, no doubt anything for her, lifts, laundry etc, if she doesn't want to pay for her luxuries and recognise you are being very generous, she can pay for everything she needs.

You see this gets me! My dc will be in school until age 18/19 (there's no option here to really quit at age 16!) so imo age 16/17 is still young! If her dc was in school then she would be supporting her but just because she is working then she is being told to basically go hard on her or she can move out? I think it's a bit of a double standard in a sense and I find it quite sickening. I'm all for teaching children to budget and fend for themselves but not in a way that cuts ties or takes 20% of their money each week Hmm

My parents didn't charge me a penny! I was still a great saver and helped out at home, and then when my parents we're moving home and needed to live with me whilst they renovated their new house I didn't charge them either. My mum would make dinner the odd day and do the ironing for me and it was lovely. Again no money involved but still a lot of respect and appreciation.

Holskey · 02/09/2021 19:37

@KingdomScrolls

If she doesn't pay don't cook for her, don't allow her access to laundry detergent etc, no doubt anything for her, lifts, laundry etc, if she doesn't want to pay for her luxuries and recognise you are being very generous, she can pay for everything she needs.
I agree with this. It's so difficult to get your children to appreciate money and all you pay for as parents. I think allowing her a choice of living there rent-free but paying for detergent, fuel, any nice food you buy at her request etc, or just paying one sum for all is a great idea. She gets to choose for herself and she can understand what the luxuries cost and how lucky she is.

You sound like a generous parent, OP. I hope your children will appreciate it one day!

Rozziie · 02/09/2021 19:33

@IceCreamAndCandyfloss

And do you really think she can do it any cheaper on her own or with a friend

The point is she shouldn’t have to go on her own or with a friend as she’s just 16 and a child. Of course she should have food, clothes, hot water etc provided by her parents.

This is the point! The idea that a literal child should be grateful for being provided with shelter, food and hot water is horrifying!

OP could be reported to social services for neglect if she failed to provide these things - they are NOT privileges!

Vodka1 · 02/09/2021 19:29

Awww bless her, shes 16, that's still a child. She's not yet an adult and is a while away from being one.

Don't fixate on money being the only way to teach her - why aren't you teaching her the basic life stuff instead?

You're 16 now you can do your own washing.
You're 16 now could you cook tea tonight?
Can you go and grab some essentionals from the shop, clean the car, visit your nan...

Whys it soley based on finances and teaching her shit needs to be paid for?

Let her do her own shopping & buy her own clothes.

Forget the maintenance and child benefit, it's not really her job to replace this missing money when the time comes, it's shit I understand but can't she just have a little freedom, for a little while?

If you want to pay for her lessons do it of course, if you don't then don't. But coming straight from a covid situation finishing school and straight into an full time job is a great thing and letting her see her money for a while would be the greatest lesson for finances to be honest.

Work hard get paid do well.

I'd not be thinking of board/rent until they was 18.

If she said she was moving out tomorrow would you really truely wave your 16 year old daughter off? Or would you be telling her no chance your still a child?

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 02/09/2021 19:18

And do you really think she can do it any cheaper on her own or with a friend

The point is she shouldn’t have to go on her own or with a friend as she’s just 16 and a child. Of course she should have food, clothes, hot water etc provided by her parents.

CreamFirstThenJamOnTop · 02/09/2021 18:49

Yanbu. I’d actually ask for more than that - especially if it’s going to be spent on her!! It’s only 1/5 of her weekly wage.

stepupandbecounted · 02/09/2021 18:29

Our dds are the same age, and have had a really rough ride in lockdown. I am doing my level best to ease the pressure not put more on her. My dd is going to be doing a levels, and we will be funding her throughout, she is working part time to pay for driving lessons. I agree with you there, driving is a life skill.

Personally I think you are charging too much and she is too young. I have read all of your posts, and I still think it is. You can't make her save but you could together set up a savings account, and she could have the choice she either pays you or she puts money in her savings account that is tied up until she is 21 for instance. You could put measures in place to help her do the right thing couldn't you?

At 23 of course dc should be paying their way, my issue is her age and the fact she is still a minor and a child. And when she gets to adulthood, and she has felt supported and cared for and ready, then charge away.

I left home at seventeen and could not get away fast enough - because given the choice between grumpy parents charging me money to live there, or the bright lights of freedom for not much more I choose the later. I was nowhere near ready. I was young, vulnerable and at risk in the situations I was in at times, but I couldn't see it at the time. I was earning money yes, I was managing just about of course, but I was still a child - I did not have the maturity, the foresight or the capacity to understand true responsibility.

I am picking up from you op a real lack of warmth, love and compassion for your dd. You sound very hard nosed where she is concerned. 'Its my way or the highway' thinking. The house of hard knocks. I think it will eventually drive a real and potentially long term wedge between you and your child. If you are happy to do that, keep going, but your dd has a point if she feels you are being harsh, I would agree.

Rozziie · 02/09/2021 18:19

Why are you doing all her laundry and everything? That should be prioritised far beyond money if you want her to learn life skills and be an independent adult. Why can't she do her own laundry, clean her own space, help out with household chores, etc.? That's a normal situation for a 16-year-old, not some weird set-up where she's paying you to be her maid.

luckylady22 · 02/09/2021 18:06

Feel your pain !
My 23 year old has just finished Uni and got first full time job and when I mentioned paying board they looked at me as if I had just asked them to give me all their wages ! Was not happy ! Now had 2 salaries and not offered a penny
I've not said anything again but I am going to as I think that's such a bad attitude and they should contribute something whether I need the money or not
They have had part time jobs throughout uni and have pretty much managed to fund their own social life and expenses without too much help but have helped with things like car ins and bits of clothing here and there and kept a roof over their head and food in their belly so feel a bit mean asking for money but wish they had a different attitude and just offered it as thats what I did with my parents back in the day

Icanflyhigh · 02/09/2021 18:02

@stepupandbecounted

Also I am wondering what happens if she loses her job? And has to accept one with a lower salary? Will you continue to charge her?

On balance it is just all too much pressure for such a young person. Why not get her to save instead the same amount and start charging her at 18 when she is an actual adult?

Paying bills, being charged rent, holding down a 40 hour plus job and the pressure to pass her test quickly because you don't want to drive her. It all sounds extremely intense.

If she loses her job and has to take another we go back and reassess. If she goes back to full time college/6th form that changes things entirely. I cannot make her save anything. It's her money. There is no pressure on her to pass her test at all, she will do it at her own pace, but as with anything, of we can afford to get extra tuition for her, that's a good thing right?

I feel you are reading far too much into my posts and assuming an awful lot, even when the information has been made clear.

I've written it all down for her today. £50 per week equates to £7.14 per day and considering for that she will get a lift to and from work as long as she needs it, a lift to her friends/boyfriends as and when she wants (as far as we can possibly manage) all of her food/cooking done, her laundry washed dried folded and returned to her bedroom, clean bedding as she wants it, her room hoovered and dusted and bin emptied at least weekly, hot water as and when she wants it for bath/shower, all of her toiletries, Netflix and now TV in her room, superfast broadband, her own room in a nice house, and all of the other things she has had from childhood. Do you really think that's a bad deal for a little.over £7 quid a day?? And do you really think she can do it any cheaper on her own or with a friend?
Be honest?

Now, her taxi this morning cost her £30 to get to work. I've told her how much that equates to if she decides to not pay board and get a taxi to and from work every day. That's £150 PER WEEK just in taxi fare to work or £600 PER MONTH.

Long story short, she's walked in tonight (after I picked her up from work) and threw £250 quid at me and DH. She had a hard lesson today but she has hopefully realised we are not BU and she will calm down.
I have very kindly agreed to let her off the other £30 as she stumped it up for a taxi this morning - so she is now up to date with her phone contract and board.

I will prepare for round 2 at the beginning of next month as she adamantly refuses to arrange a direct debit and has stated that she will be sorting everything else out first and her phone and board are not a priority.

I am prepared to do the same again as I have today, I've explained that bills get priority and there have been times I've paid electricity bill over buying food to make sure the kids were warm etc but that also falls on deaf ears.

OP posts:
stepupandbecounted · 02/09/2021 17:30

Also I am wondering what happens if she loses her job? And has to accept one with a lower salary? Will you continue to charge her?

On balance it is just all too much pressure for such a young person. Why not get her to save instead the same amount and start charging her at 18 when she is an actual adult?

Paying bills, being charged rent, holding down a 40 hour plus job and the pressure to pass her test quickly because you don't want to drive her. It all sounds extremely intense.

FlowerPower3110 · 02/09/2021 17:25

@stepupandbecounted

Some people have had crap childhoods with very little support and wish to keep continuing the hardship cycle because 'why should they have it any easier' therefore guaranteeing the shit parenting/deprivation/poverty continues in their families.

What a wonderful legacy to pass on to your children yet more 'tough love' will be meted out. And apparently no emotional intelligence or awareness by these posters of what they are actually doing.

I agree with this.

I'm a bit surprised that so many people are okay with charging a 16 year old CHILD £50 per week to continue living in her childhood home. No wonder she's a bit shocked.

stepupandbecounted · 02/09/2021 17:21

She is sixteen though, she could probably hook up with a friend. Obviously not a penthouse, but I did a room share at a young age with a friend and it cost very little, and we came and went as we pleased.

I am simply pointing out that a transactional financial arrangement where is paying to live at home is ultimately going to give her much more power and control over her life - whether she chooses to stay at home or not, and whether she thinks real independence would be a better option for her.
She isn't like other girls of her age being cared for and looked after by their parents at home whilst they go to college/sixth form and onto university, she is clearly going to be growing up far faster than the others. It won't take her long to work out she has many options now if she is being charged to live at home. It opens up a different world, as it did for many of us that left home early. I hope op is prepared for all outcomes, and ones possibly she didn't envisage.

Independence too soon can have some very negative outcomes.

GreyhoundG1rl · 02/09/2021 17:12

She won't be going far on 50 quid a week...

ChargingBuck · 02/09/2021 17:09

@stepupandbecounted

How are you going to feel if she moves out soon? As she might find for a little more money she can have a lot more freedom and her own rules for instance. Once you have introduced money, it stops being a parenting relationship after all she is PAYING to live there and no longer being cared for. I hope you are prepared for the change in dynamics that will bring.
It wouldn't be "a little more money" - it would cost nearly all of her salary to live independently & pay her own way.

And she isn't being asked to PAY to live in her home - she's being asked for a small contribution to her living expenses, out of her quite considerable, currently entirely disposable, income.

Of course the dynamic is going to change.
Children grow up, get jobs, & eventually move out - having kids is all ALL about changing dynamics, so not sure why you are trying to convince OP that's something to fret about.

stepupandbecounted · 02/09/2021 17:02

How are you going to feel if she moves out soon? As she might find for a little more money she can have a lot more freedom and her own rules for instance. Once you have introduced money, it stops being a parenting relationship after all she is PAYING to live there and no longer being cared for. I hope you are prepared for the change in dynamics that will bring.

GreyhoundG1rl · 02/09/2021 15:32

Oh, I see. She's in a very good position, really, yanbu at all.

Icanflyhigh · 02/09/2021 15:26

@GreyhoundG1rl

Who bought her the car?!
The car is a gift from my DM, she is in very ill health, won't ever drive again and it seems daft for DD to scrimp and save for one when there is one sitting there doing nothing. DD will have to tax and insure it herself though.
OP posts:
GreyhoundG1rl · 02/09/2021 15:22

Who bought her the car?!

Icanflyhigh · 02/09/2021 15:19

@stepupandbecounted

Have you considered actually training or getting yourself a better job op? You seem obsessed by the fact she is earning more than you. That is the part that needs to change, not charging a child money.

Why have you settled for a such badly paid work? Why not better yourself, and then you won't begrudge your dd her salary and opportunities.

I am yet to hear how proud you are/her obviously excellent work ethic/the challenge of FT work at such a young age or any kind of serious support that she isn't being reminded of on a daily basis. Give her a break, let her find her feet. Show some kindness.
All we hear is endless banging on about money money money from you. It is depressing to read.

@stepupandbecounted nowhere in ANY of my posts have I said DD earns more than me. She doesn't! What I have said is that she is being paid twice the amount I was at the same age. Very different thing, but then if you'd read any of the thread properly you'd know this.
OP posts:
Icanflyhigh · 02/09/2021 14:09

@AllTheSingleLadiess

She needs to pay for her phone or you need to take it back. Does she know what a direct debit is? She could set it up so the money goes to you on pay day ?

Instead of board, make her responsible for her own washing and ironing. Don't pay for her driving lessons. Make sure she knows that her car expenses will be hers to save and fund.

Presumably she needs lifts for work. She either pays for public transport or taxis or she can come up with a offer for you to do lifts (in cash)

I've explained what a Direct Debit is, but she has flat out refused to set one up.
OP posts:
stepupandbecounted · 02/09/2021 13:56

Have you considered actually training or getting yourself a better job op? You seem obsessed by the fact she is earning more than you.
That is the part that needs to change, not charging a child money.

Why have you settled for a such badly paid work? Why not better yourself, and then you won't begrudge your dd her salary and opportunities.

I am yet to hear how proud you are/her obviously excellent work ethic/the challenge of FT work at such a young age or any kind of serious support that she isn't being reminded of on a daily basis. Give her a break, let her find her feet. Show some kindness.
All we hear is endless banging on about money money money from you. It is depressing to read.

WingingItSince1973 · 02/09/2021 13:46

YANBU I think I need to review my dds rent. Shes 23 lives here with her 6 year old ds and pays that amount each week 😬 I'm too soft!

worriedatthemoment · 02/09/2021 12:55

Yanu to charge when she is earning £14500 k a year