Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask my almost 17YO to pay board?

282 replies

Icanflyhigh · 01/09/2021 07:57

DD is 17 end of October. She started an apprenticeship earlier in the summer and earns £14.5k per year.

Apart from buying herself lunch each day (which she doesn't HAVE to do as there is food available to take from home) she has no other outgoings.

I have asked her to contribute £50 per week to the household, for that, she will have all food provided, washing done, all the hot water she can use, lifts to wherever she wants, pretty much whenever she wants them, a lift to and from work each day (we don't live on a bus route) and other usual stuff.

Well she's made me feel like the worst mother in the world for asking.
I've explained that we've lost her child benefit now, and I'm expecting her dad to stop paying maintenance too (not that his £17 a week makes a huge difference to be fair) but our outgoings have remained the same or increased.

On top of that I've asked her to pay her own phone bill. She had a brand new iPhone X in July on the premise that she would pay the bill. We haven't had a penny yet, but its attached to our BT account so if we don't pay it, we screw up our own credit rating.

The board I have asked her for will be put straight towards her driving lessons. I've already bought her provisional driving licence and she has a car waiting for when she has passed her test.

So AIBU for asking?
What would you do if she decides not to pay it? TIA x

OP posts:
stepupandbecounted · 03/09/2021 11:20

Having only a GCSE level education is likely to be limiting fact. We have no idea in the long term if the apprenticeship will work out, hopefully it will be, but dd will be limited/capped by the salary ceiling.

Getting over excited about 14,000 PA at sixteen years of age and charging a child to live at home, rather than saving is limiting her chances further still. You can call it a fairytale, I call it the school of hard knocks with parents absolutely intent on their child never having a better future than them. The attitude if it is okay for me, and I survived it is okay for you. Rather than wanting something infinitely better for your own children. That kind of parenting is why some kids never make it out of the poverty trap, lack ambition and confidence because their parents make damn sure that they don't get above their station in life.

I say that as a child who left education far too early and I am from a working class background. You are doing her no favours taking away he her only advantage (the ability to save whilst her peers study and have free board) Her one and only benefit to working so early in life, is being taken away by her mother.

ChargingBuck · 03/09/2021 10:45

@stepupandbecounted

You do know people from all walks of life are allowed to save up & buy houses, don't you?

Yes but generally you need the money to do so. Which is why being grabby is not helpful

What grabby? Where?

Asking for £50 a week, which is all to be put aside for DD's driving lessons? The driving lessons that go with the car OP's mum has given DD, to increase her independence & career choices?

ChargingBuck · 03/09/2021 10:42

@stepupandbecounted

Additionally her siblings will have a carefree youth and fun to the age of 21 without having to pay you a penny. DD, on the other hand gets to do 40 hours every week, at least, and has to pay you for the privilege and she does not get the option just to enjoy being young for a while, and her future job options will be very limited in the future with such a basic education that basically stops at sixteen, and leaving school.

Do you not see what you are doing?

At least now she is committed to the apprenticeship you could level the playing field a little by putting the money away for her. So she has some chance of buying a house at some point....

Oh NOW I see!

OP is Cinderella's stepmother, & is just passing DD off as her own daughter here, to gain sympathy.

Oh, will no one think of Cinderella's blighted life, unable to have a carefree existence on £800 disposable a month, with her mum still doing the basics for her, like shopping, cooking, cleaning & even providing the specific toiletries she prefers?

stepupandbecounted · 03/09/2021 10:42

Especially because such a huge deposit is needed to buy a house these days.

stepupandbecounted · 03/09/2021 10:41

You do know people from all walks of life are allowed to save up & buy houses, don't you?

Yes but generally you need the money to do so. Which is why being grabby is not helpful

ChargingBuck · 03/09/2021 10:38

This is extremely short sighted of you op. You are setting her up for a life of poverty and hard graft, rather than one with a good education that sets her up into a profession that will pay well, and will offer the chance to buy her own home etc.

Grin Grin Grin

This is hilariously hysterical projection @stepupandbecounted
.
Apart from your appalling snobbery, where you insult DD's choice of profession, because you are assuming it's one that doesn't lead to a nice MC white collar office job.

You do know people from all walks of life are allowed to save up & buy houses, don't you?

stepupandbecounted · 03/09/2021 10:24

Additionally her siblings will have a carefree youth and fun to the age of 21 without having to pay you a penny. DD, on the other hand gets to do 40 hours every week, at least, and has to pay you for the privilege and she does not get the option just to enjoy being young for a while, and her future job options will be very limited in the future with such a basic education that basically stops at sixteen, and leaving school.

Do you not see what you are doing?

At least now she is committed to the apprenticeship you could level the playing field a little by putting the money away for her. So she has some chance of buying a house at some point....

stepupandbecounted · 03/09/2021 10:19

**How would it be fair

stepupandbecounted · 03/09/2021 10:19

How would it be far to fund your other two children through university (I assume you will still feed, clothe them) knowing FULL well that with a university education they are much more likely to earn a great deal more than your dd in the longer term, so they have the benefit of years and years of free 'board' but she does not?

That is grossly unfair.

Especially as you plan to keep the money, so rather than levelling up their chances a little by putting it away for her, you are going to keep it! In the end have paid thousands to you, whilst her siblings have not, she is then stuck in a job that doesn't pay very well in the long term, with VERY LIMITED education. She has no a levels and no degree.

This is extremely short sighted of you op. You are setting her up for a life of poverty and hard graft, rather than one with a good education that sets her up into a profession that will pay well, and will offer the chance to buy her own home etc.

A quick buck now she will pay for many times over later on by limiting her job opportunities without a full education to 18 years of age.

Icanflyhigh · 03/09/2021 00:51

Well it's nice to see the nest of vipers is still as strong as it was 10 years ago!!!

For the record, I've never suggested she move out, I've never said I would withhold laundry detergent and toiletries etc and I've never said she wouldn't have a roof over her head.

For those who asked, I do her washing because we are a family of 5 and in all honesty it would take longer to sort hers out for her to do than it does to just bung it in. I work full time but from home, so I have a lot of flexibility over my hours. Sometimes I spend the whole day doing housework and cleaning, some days I don't even manage to clear the sink of breakfast pots.....
Same with cooking. She is perfectly able to cook a meal and sometimes she does, but most days, I cook an evening meal for all of us and because I'm at home, I have more time to do it around my work.
Whether you think I'm doing the right thing or not, I'm doing it how I was taught and I have a brilliant relationship with my parents.
If the other 2 decide to go to Uni or not, that's up to them and we'll cross that bridge when we get to it.

OP posts:
cherish123 · 02/09/2021 22:51

I would not ask her. Alternatively, you could ask her for the £50 and save the money for her for a house deposit.

Rozziie · 02/09/2021 22:48

@ChargingBuck

Reading this thread, I honestly don't understand why some people bother having children.

Aren't you the PP who had tears in her eyes thinking of the poor abused DD with only £800 left for her own personal spending every month @Rozziie?
Do you think it would be best to step away from the thread before it all goes a bit Sistine Chapel for you?

Oh dear - the concept of a 'turn of phrase' a bit alien to you? You do realise when people say they're 'dying laughing' they're not really dying?

I'm sorry you think it's acceptable to charge a child for their basic needs, including a roof over their head. I've never met anyone who was a fan of 'tough love' parenting who wasn't themselves extremely broken and recipients of the same sort of tough love from their own parents. Funny how these types always shout about how they 'turned out fine' when they really haven't.

ChargingBuck · 02/09/2021 22:30

Reading this thread, I honestly don't understand why some people bother having children.

Aren't you the PP who had tears in her eyes thinking of the poor abused DD with only £800 left for her own personal spending every month @Rozziie?
Do you think it would be best to step away from the thread before it all goes a bit Sistine Chapel for you?

Rozziie · 02/09/2021 22:25

@ChargingBuck

In your position OP I would feel that I have been let off lightly- had she chosen another route and 5 years at university that may have cost you ££££.

Again, this assumption that just by dint of being a parent, there will be enough spare cash to fund 5 years of university ...

If the family income is too high for the daughter to get any grants or bursaries then yes, they are expected to contribute.

Reading this thread, I honestly don't understand why some people bother having children.

FlowerPower3110 · 02/09/2021 21:10

[quote KingdomScrolls]@FlowerPower3110 no I'm not of you'd read any of my other posts you'd see in against charging young adults to live at home. I do think it's fair for her to cover her own mobile bill and driving lessons[/quote]
Alright, I'm happy to apologise then. Covering her own mobile bill sounds reasonable.

DecorChange · 02/09/2021 20:44

Don't know if you now but this has been picked up by the sun

speakout · 02/09/2021 20:37

Expectations don't put cash in the bank.
Nobody can contribute what they do not have.

Indeed. And that is why kids from lower income backgrounds tend not to go to university. Very sad but true.
Many parents struggle to help their children through univeristy
The OP does not have that burden.

ChargingBuck · 02/09/2021 20:32

@speakout

Again, this assumption that just by dint of being a parent, there will be enough spare cash to fund 5 years of university ...

Spare cash or not if a child wants to go to go to university parents are expected to contribue.

Expectations don't put cash in the bank. Nobody can contribute what they do not have.
KingdomScrolls · 02/09/2021 20:27

@FlowerPower3110 no I'm not of you'd read any of my other posts you'd see in against charging young adults to live at home. I do think it's fair for her to cover her own mobile bill and driving lessons

Teebear431 · 02/09/2021 20:25

I don't have children so my opinion holds very little weight, however when I was a kid (I'm 36 now) I had a job at 15 and I was expected to pay for some things around the house...I bought my first cell phone (those Nokia ones that were indestructible)I paid the bills for it and I paid my own gas and if I didn't have the money to pay for those things I didn't drive, or my phone didn't have minutes (it was pre-paid). When I got older I paid my own insurance and I contributed $75 a month to the house. It helped me learn about budgets and paying things on time. I don't understand how someone could feel so entitled that the don't need to contribute at all. Also this is a lesson for mom...maybe you have been a little too easy on her when it comes to giving her what she wants. I think it may do her some good to understand money and how it's not just unlimited. Plus I know I felt great when I bought things for myself and didn't have to rely on my parents.

speakout · 02/09/2021 20:23

Again, this assumption that just by dint of being a parent, there will be enough spare cash to fund 5 years of university ...

Spare cash or not if a child wants to go to go to university parents are expected to contribue.

LibbyL92 · 02/09/2021 20:21

She needs to start getting used to paying bills. So it’s an absolute must you do this!

Will teach her how to budget ect.

ChargingBuck · 02/09/2021 20:17

In your position OP I would feel that I have been let off lightly- had she chosen another route and 5 years at university that may have cost you ££££.

Again, this assumption that just by dint of being a parent, there will be enough spare cash to fund 5 years of university ...

Chunkymenrock · 02/09/2021 20:14

Of course she should chip in with household expenses. Why has she got a free car and free driving lessons? That's all wrong! She should pay towards both of those too.

speakout · 02/09/2021 20:06

Depends on your circumstances.
Makes total sense o charge her if you need the money.
In your position and didnlt need the money then no, I wouldn't charge.
She is 16 and earning. Many older teenagers at univerity and college live away and require a great deal of parental funding for rent, fees, living expenses.
In your position OP I would feel that I have been let off lightly- had she chosen another route and 5 years at university that may have cost you ££££.
So in your position OP, no I wouldn't expect her to pay.