Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

“Helpful” Mother in law

86 replies

ElsieDoo · 01/09/2021 07:46

We been living together for just over a year. Prior to that my husband lived on his own with his mum regularly visiting him (she lives abroad) for weeks on end. She would come over to do his cleaning, laundry etc and pretty much treated his house like her own.

Since the pandemic she has not been able to come over at all and we have managed to set up our own home and enjoy life just as our family.

Now however that the lockdown is over his mum is a regular visitor in our house! My husband just tells me that his mum will be coming over for a week or so on particular dates. I’m expected to just accept it as he wouldn’t dare to tell his mum that we want to spend time just as our own family.

The most irritating thing is that when she is over she completely takes over. She will not only try and do the cleaning her way but will go into our bedroom and move my things. My husband turns into a child when she is over refusing to help with any housework or childcare because “his mum will do it for him”

I feel like she is invading my personal space. I hate the fact that things are not done my way in my own home. I feel completely pushed out.

When I mention it to my husband he gets annoyed and says that he doesn’t see a problem with it, she is just trying to be helpful.

Am I being unreasonable or is it wrong for a guest in your own home to go up to your bedroom and start re arranging your clothes and doing your bed, and using your dish cloth to clean dirty trainers?

I feel that I should bite my tongue to keep the peace but every day of her being here makes me miserable to the point that I’m considering moving out with the kids!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
tempchecked · 01/09/2021 19:12

I don't think the situation will change as long as DH is ok with it as it is.

The MIL and DH will probably gang up on you and gaslight you anyway.

Unless the DH supports his DW, there will be no change at all, so OP might need to make some plans of her own.

I'm also guessing MIL is the archetypal matriarch in her own country, serving penis portions to her boy(s) along with looking after their every need. They are both used to this arrangement and enjoy it. When MIL is not there DH has OP to step in.

I could only lay my cards on the table ONCE, then I'd be gone. But son would probably like his mother to replace his wife anyway. It is no way to live IMO.

opinionminion · 01/09/2021 19:11

Arrrgh sent too soon ! I had MiL like this ! I think in her eyes she does think she is being just that; helpful !!! However, she isn't a guest - she is a family member and I think I would suck it up - try to embrace her 'helpfulness' ... at least you have a date when she will be leaving !
My exDH saw nothing wrong in telling me - usually the night before that she would be staying the weekend - it is that what annoyed me ! Lack of communication !!! Go out with your children a bit more so that mum and son have time together but don't make it cause a rift.
Just my view/ experience that's all .

opinionminion · 01/09/2021 19:00

Um ... im sure

CattyMcNips · 01/09/2021 18:23

Every time she comes over leave a massive dildo and a gimp mask out in your bedroom.

KILNAMATRA · 01/09/2021 15:34

Is it an intercultural marriage? Relationship? My friend married an Indian gentleman and her MIL is more respectful but along the same vein.. she was well aware beforehand and has enough space to deal with it.. can you play to her strengths a bit? Like if you say to her “I’ll tidy my own room snd I prefer to do our own laundry but your such an excellent cook… “

sandragreen · 01/09/2021 15:33

YANBU but as is often identified, you have a DH problem. He has to be more scared of upsetting you than of upsetting his mum.

Outfoxedbyrabbits · 01/09/2021 15:22

When I mention it to my husband he gets annoyed and says that he doesn’t see a problem with it, she is just trying to be helpful.

I would tell your husband: "Actually, YOU do not get to decide whether I have a problem with something. There may not be a problem for YOU, but there IS a problem for ME. Similarly, your mother does not get to decide whether doing something is helpful FOR ME, I get to decide that. I have a problem with you announcing that a guest is coming to my home without even asking me first. I have a problem with you regressing to a childlike state whenever your mother is here, you are an adult and you should be acting like one. I have a problem with your mother entering my bedroom and interfering with my belongings. We are a married couple. This is our home. You cannot live here in our marital home with me, your wife, AND live with your mummy. It is an either/or choice, you cannot have both. You seem more concerned about upsetting your mother than about me, your wife, being upset. I have had enough. I feel like she is invading my personal space. I hate the fact that things are not done my way in my own home. I feel completely pushed out. I feel that I should bite my tongue to keep the peace but every day of her being here makes me miserable to the point that I’m considering moving out with the kids!"

Then see what he says.

FooFighter99 · 01/09/2021 14:51

Well what did you expect? You married a man-child

2bazookas · 01/09/2021 14:45

Of course she knows she's overstepping the mark.

So it won't be any kind of a shock when you tell her so in words of one syllable.

portocristo · 01/09/2021 14:21

Fair point

RamblingJenny · 01/09/2021 14:17

@portocristo Personally there is a marked difference that it was your mum doing it and therefore you were more relaxed about it. I can bet that out of anyone you know the person you would be be most comfortable with finding in your bedroom would be your own mother.

portocristo · 01/09/2021 13:35

Pile of ironing in front of the telly, cleaning the oven , wiping down skirting boards ,giving the bathrooms the once over , god I would love this my mum used to be like this till she got alzeimers, it was a massive help

SeoultoSeoul · 01/09/2021 13:15

Babyiskickingmyribs Well, we will have to disagree, I think its far better to talk to her firmly and directly, telling her what is pissing you off, rather than resorting to making digs and passive aggressive remarks about medical devices or her age.
Nastiness met with nastiness solves nothing. Be the bigger person OP, stand up to her and your DH.

Tabitha005 · 01/09/2021 12:55

My sister's ex-MIL used to do this, to the extent where sis would come home from work and not be able to find certain ingredients, spices etc in the kitchen when she went to cook dinner because her MIL had rearranged her cupboards, fridge etc. There was the now-famous 'egg-gate' when MIL insisted (to the point of shouting over my sister in her own kitchen) that, under NO circumstances, should eggs be unrefrigerated and simply left in a bowl on the counter. That whole situation resulted in divorce which, all things considered, was a double bonus for my sister in getting rid of an absolute dick of a MIL as well as an even bigger dick of a husband.

Personally, I'd cut your husband out of it entirely, as he doesn't sound like he'd be much help anyway, and politely explain to your MIL that it's your house, too, and you'd rather she didn't do any housework whilst she's there. If that doesn't work, next time you go 'round her house, take it upon yourself to start doing HER housework and see if she likes it.

Failing that, get some really huge and obvious sex toys and spread them all around your house in clear view. Maybe she'll think twice about cleaning any of those with a dishcloth! Say; 'Oh, sorry, would you mind giving those an extra-hard buff? They take a lot of pummelling'?

saraclara · 01/09/2021 12:47

Does he still see it as 'his' home that you live in? I think it's very likely that she does. And the only person who can put her right is your DH.

He clearly thinks that it would be rude to do so, but he really does need to make it clear to her that it is now your home and you have your own way of doing things and your own right to personal space and privacy.

Failing that, you need to move so that it's clear that you and your DH are equals in its ownership.

How often does she/will she visit? And for how long each time?

starfishmummy · 01/09/2021 12:26

@fruitbrewhaha

Give her a list of what she can and cant do.

She can clean the windows, hoover, do the garden, cook etc

She CANNOT tidy your room, do your laundry etc

Then save up jobs for her, weeding, scrubbing the patio, tidying the shed and garage ,repotting plants, get her to batch cook for the freezer and clean out the kitchen cupboards. Give her the cloth she can use etc and then sit down for a cup of tea while she's busy.

Use it to your advantage.

Or "Mil, my to do list is on the table. You can do something off that list if you want to help"
fruitbrewhaha · 01/09/2021 12:16

Give her a list of what she can and cant do.

She can clean the windows, hoover, do the garden, cook etc

She CANNOT tidy your room, do your laundry etc

Then save up jobs for her, weeding, scrubbing the patio, tidying the shed and garage ,repotting plants, get her to batch cook for the freezer and clean out the kitchen cupboards. Give her the cloth she can use etc and then sit down for a cup of tea while she's busy.

Use it to your advantage.

Cam77 · 01/09/2021 11:54

Golden rule still applies here: Never mix relatives with work/business unless there’s really no other option. Looking after grandchildren is ok if they really want to do it but that’s it.

Let your husband know that you are happy for MIL to visit X number of times a year for total X amount of total time. But that’s the limit and it needs to be agreed months in advance. Your home your life your family. Be assertive.

saraclara · 01/09/2021 11:48

If it was his house that you moved into, it's going to be hard to change her habits. So you need to be firm, but empathetic.

"Our bedroom is our personal space. Can you please not go in there? If you like to be busy, we can find you some things to do, but privacy is important to me."

Or as a pp said
You need to say directly and clearly:

MIL, please don’t go into our bedroom.
MIL, that’s the dishcloth. Don’t use it on shoes, use this instead.
MIL, leave the laundry, please.

TheWeatherWitch · 01/09/2021 11:44

I’m going to repeat that classic mn line. ‘You don’t have a ‘mil’ problem, you have a DH problem’

Tell him next time he announces ‘’mil’ is visiting that you will be away. Then make plans and disappear for the week. Remind him that she (his mum) better be able to give blow jobs just as good as you as he seems far more attached to his mum than his partner.
Repeat until he gets the massage or until you decide to move out.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 01/09/2021 11:40

PS. Apologies for awful grammar. Small phone kept deleting words for some reason.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 01/09/2021 11:40

@KidneyBeans

You moved in, got married and had a baby during a pandemic to a man who you knew had an overly dependent relationship on his mother and are now surprised at that relationship continuing?

It sounds like you don't know your husband very well. His mum is his priority. That won't change

This sounds quite harsh and extreme. Or would do, had I not seen this dynamic unfold far too many times not to recognise its truth. It's a harsh and extreme situation.

Your relationship is salvageable, but it will be very hard and will require a lot of work and pain on your behalf. Because you already know they won't change: mother and son are perfectly happy with their enmeshed dynamic and the one who will suffer at the brunt of it is you.

You can't change other people but you can change your own. It has to start with getting DH onside, otherwise it's a waste of effort. Rather than venting, give him a clear-cut set of objectives, ie. this behaviour makes me feel sidelined in my own home, frustrated, and hurt. Then give him expectations as to exactly what you will and will not tolerate. (I'm willing to let her make everyone a cup of tea or cook a meal; I'm not willing to have her gut my home and rearrange my bedroom).

You definitely need to read Susan Forward's brilliant book Toxic In-Laws. You'll recognise your MiL as the engulfer.

This book has been a game-changer for many people, including me. It provides brilliant non-defensive strategies for laying down healthy boundaries, without which unfortunately the ultimate result is likely to be NC with her, or the breakdown of your marriage.

Best of luck.

Bellringer · 01/09/2021 11:34

Invite your mum when she is there

Elkey · 01/09/2021 11:32

You need to kick off. I'm afraid you'll need to be quite unpleasant and suffer some uncomfortable awkwardness. Being clever, compromising, explaining, asking how they'd feel if they were you etc. etc. will not work. You need to make it so that they'll comply rather than face the consequences of your wrath.

Currently, you're making it too easy for them to disregard you. You're trying to convince them that you're being treated unfairly and that this behaviour isn't normal, and I can see why, but it's not effective, so forget that and let them think you're unreasonable for a time while you force some proper boundaries by being very difficult.

DifferentHair · 01/09/2021 11:25

Time to stop being polite and asking nicely.

Decide what your boundaries are and assert them firmly. Expect that this will not be popular, but ride it out anyway.

If she feels uncomfortable- tough. No one in this situation has given any thought to your comfort, so stop protecting theirs.

I'd be taking DH to marriage counselling. He is still enmeshed with his DM and he needs to grow up and build an adult to adult relationship with her.

Swipe left for the next trending thread