Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a tax on nappies is unfair?

291 replies

colacolaco · 31/08/2021 22:52

It just seems like yet again, it’s the poorest families who will be penalized and suffer most from this.

And what next - a tax on sanitary pads and tampons? Because guess what, they’re not very environmentally friendly either.

OP posts:
HungryHippo11 · 01/09/2021 07:11

While I do think that costs are a good reason for those on very low incomes, there are a lot of excuses on this thread. If we want to do something about saving the planet, there will have to be some inconvenience. Convenience products is partly what's got us in to this massive mess in the first place, and somethings got to give.
Or it is only acceptable if it inconveniences other people?

Nurseries - they would find a way to change 30 cloth nappies. Just like they find a way to change 30 disposable nappies, to feed 30 kids and get them down for a nap at once. Thats what they're paid to do.

Homes - people would find a way to fit in the extra 2 washes a week, or to buy nappies which don't take forever to dry.

Or they have the choice to continue using disposables and pay the extra tax, its not compulsory.

Brokenrecord3006 · 01/09/2021 07:10

I tried cloth nappies for DS but trying to juggle my already shattered mental health, full time job and running the house, meant those sodding nappies nearly made me a breakdown. We were also quite skint when DS was a baby so I'd have been gutted to pay a premium on disposables.

I also agree with comments about childcare and them having to organise cloth nappies for all the babies. That sounds like a nightmare. I know a few other mums who use cloth nappies, they are all SAHM.

Mummyme87 · 01/09/2021 07:09

I used disposable nappies and reusable wipes with my first, then went all reusable with second. No dryer as should tumble dry them anyhow, no significant extra time involved. Got money from the council to help buy them initially, bought a fair few second hand aswell.

SquirryTheSquirrel · 01/09/2021 07:06

Back in the 1970s, my mum (in common with most people) used terry nappies and she didn't even have an automatic washing machine, let alone a tumble dryer.

The same ones served me and my sister, and saw out their days as cleaning rags until they eventually wore out, so very eco-friendly.

DobbyTheHouseElk · 01/09/2021 07:05

DM used terries on me. I potty trained at 2.4 yrs
I used disposables on my DC who was trained at 2.5 yrs.

I use reusable san pro now, and don’t find it any bother. But I don’t think I could have managed to use the cloth nappies. I had a non sleeping Velcro baby who vomited every hour. My washing machine was on constantly as it was.

It didn’t have any difference in the potty training because it took 2 days and it was done. I used Gina Fords method, I know her name is sewage on MN, but her potty training book worked for me.

OlympicProcrastinator · 01/09/2021 07:04

What about the mums who have to work full time? How would a nursery for example deal with 30 kids in cloth nappies? Would they be doing all this extra washing or drying or have a cloakroom full of stinking shit filled cloths to give back to the parents?
It’s no good talking about the olden days either. Women largely stayed at home. This just smacks of ‘poor women shouldn’t have children’ again to me.,

HungryHippo11 · 01/09/2021 07:02

Please could someone link me to the potty training thread discussed as I find it really unbelievable that so many kids are 3+ when training starts!

User56439876 · 01/09/2021 07:01

Are those that use cloth nappies working full time and do you provide the nursery/childminder with cloth nappies?

Billandben444 · 01/09/2021 07:00

Disposables are so easy that there's no incentive to potty train. In the 70s, we sat them on potties when we knew a poo was expected and by the time they were 2 most were out of nappies - it took a week of concentrated effort (and having a potty in the car) - and I've got photos to prove mine were clean and dry by 2. The wet nappies went in a bucket of napisan and were then machine washed and line dried (no tumble dryers). Disposables came on the market during that time but were very expensive and my MIL used to treat me to a box (Snugglers?) and I'd take one if we were out and baby needed changing but it was a real luxury. Perhaps we'll go back to those days?

reluctantbrit · 01/09/2021 06:59

Read this:
www.theguardian.com/society/2021/aug/31/campaigners-urge-ministers-to-introduce-vouchers-for-reusable-nappies

The campaigners make it clear that a tax is unfair and there should be other solutions.

I used cloth nappies for 18 months 14 years ago and I think today I would have had them longer but then DD outgrew them and no toddler ones were available. Even our nursery didn't blink but I know others insist on disposables.

We used Eco by Naty if we needed convenience and they are slightly better than Pampers/Huggies but again, they do come with a price.

The problem needs to be addressed and more should be done to encourage parents without coming over as the typical middle class earth mother approach.

The same is for period products, I moved to pants and eco pads but again, they are a lot more expensive.

RedMarauder · 01/09/2021 06:59

@PieMaster

They should just give manufacturers 3 years to create biodegradable ones and not be allowed to sell non biodegradable ones after that time. Laundry poverty is really tough. Washing machines are the highest cause of debt through HP. They break, they cost a lot to run etc. That said my Mum used cloth nappies on us Nd handwashed them and then used a wringer. Can't imagine that today, but maybe that's why we are in this mess.
Did your mum work outside the house?

Where you in any form of childcare at all?

It would mean for working parents they would need 2-3 times as many nappies as childcare providers, grandparents and other people who look after your children won't be expected to wash the soiled nappies. They would bundle them up for you to wash at the end of the day.

Samcro · 01/09/2021 06:58

yanbu
this would also affect people with disabled children badly.

PieMaster · 01/09/2021 06:55

If you have a washing machine once the initial outlay has gone it is much much cheaper to use cloth nappies.

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 01/09/2021 06:55

And agree which earlier potty training. People can’t be bothered now because disposables are convenient, and it would save huge amounts of resources.

PieMaster · 01/09/2021 06:54

It doubt it would encourage people to potty train earlier though that would be no bad thing. The average age has shot up.

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 01/09/2021 06:53

We used cloth nappies and we were on a very tight budget then. Also no tumble dryer m, but the dry very quickly.

Sorry, but there is an alternative to disposable nappies, and if you choose the use them they you ought to pay for them.

PieMaster · 01/09/2021 06:52

They should just give manufacturers 3 years to create biodegradable ones and not be allowed to sell non biodegradable ones after that time.
Laundry poverty is really tough. Washing machines are the highest cause of debt through HP. They break, they cost a lot to run etc.
That said my Mum used cloth nappies on us Nd handwashed them and then used a wringer. Can't imagine that today, but maybe that's why we are in this mess.

User56439876 · 01/09/2021 06:49

I was one of those 50s babies who were supposedly potty trained by 9 months old, apparently DB was over 1😯, in reality I think that my DM just plonked me on the pot many times a day to save washing the nappies but nowadays many work. I can't imagine nurseries and childminders doing that or fiddling around with cloth nappies. Nursery costs will go up because of the extra bother.

Goatinthegarden · 01/09/2021 06:45

I haven’t had children and one of the reasons is because the planet is literally going to shit.

I’m hardly the world’s biggest eco warrior, but I try to be considerate as possible in the things that I do, and change wasteful habits wherever I can. Using reusable nappies for your children instead of sending hundreds of plastic nappies to landfill seems like a pretty reasonable thing to do.

The poster who complained about a £50 outlay - think how much each packet of nappies will cost in the long term!

Seymour5 · 01/09/2021 06:43

My DC were potty trained by 2/2.5 years in the 1970s. Cloth nappies were the only choice for most of us as disposables were too expensive. I handwashed, or went to the laundrette if I could afford it. Line dried, or on an airer in front of our one coal fire. However, I didn’t go out to work when they were tiny, unlike most parents now. Having said that, I belive all the DGC were out of nappies by 3. I can’t believe so many children are starting school still in nappies!

My sanitary products from those years won’t be in landfill, wrapped in newspaper, they went on our open fire along with any other rubbish that would burn.

TheReluctantPhoenix · 01/09/2021 06:40

It is ridiculous to start with nappies and, again, is yet another regressive tax on the less well off.

What about large taxes on holiday flights, larger luxury cars, and boilers above a certain size?

In addition, ultimately, if we have to ration polluting activities, is tax the best way, as opposed to legislation? Is it fair that someone can have 2 houses, 4 large cars and 3 holidays abroad, whereas someone else will have to cut their weekly treat to afford nappy tax?

The way to deal with the environmental challenge is science and incentivisation, not a tax on the least well off, of minimal benefit.

RedMarauder · 01/09/2021 06:39

Potty training doesn't start until about 3 now so that's an extra year a child is in nappies and they are huge nappies at that age.

Wrong.

Some of us start at 2.

In fact due to my DD interest in the toilet the other 2 children around 2 years at my CM started potty training as well. Same happened with one of my friends DD's at nursery.

HungryHippo11 · 01/09/2021 06:38

There are eco friendly biodegradable disposables available it would be better if they became mainstream in the same way biodegradable wipes did
Biodegradable products don't break down in landfill, so this wouldn't make any difference. Plus if they're inside a nappy bag or bin bag, they wouldn't degrade even if the right conditions. They basically have to be composted and even then part of the nappy would remain as they're only 60-80% biodegradable.
www.which.co.uk/news/2021/02/why-biodegradable-nappies-might-not-be-as-eco-friendly-as-you-think/

Equalpayquery · 01/09/2021 06:35

I really really wanted to do reusable nappies but I had a very traumatic birth, a baby who would never be put down, and who did 10+ vile poos a day until 6 months (undiagnosed cmpa). And we lived in a building site. I was barely functioning and had severe PND. I would not have coped with the nappies.

Caspianberg · 01/09/2021 06:31

I do think more should be done to promote reusable. We use them and I remember reading lots and there were so many options it can get confusing.

We ended up with an all in one type for daytime that goes on just as easily as disposable and isn’t bulky. We use a two part for nighttime and never had a leak.

There is a lot of ‘old’ nappy mistruths also. They aren’t huge and bulky now, nor do they take forever to dry as a blend of fabrics.
I have never used tumble dryer, outside when dry, inside on rack when raining. You don’t soak them either. Just in machine.

I think the brand tots bots actually now include one free nappy in the baby boxes you get given for free in Scotland. Maybe something similar in England or easier access to go and try them would be beneficial. I think supermarkets now sell some , but otherwise most still online only, so easier access for people.