Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a tax on nappies is unfair?

291 replies

colacolaco · 31/08/2021 22:52

It just seems like yet again, it’s the poorest families who will be penalized and suffer most from this.

And what next - a tax on sanitary pads and tampons? Because guess what, they’re not very environmentally friendly either.

OP posts:
LetgoOrnot · 01/09/2021 07:40

I'd have use reusables but DDs nursery wouldn't use them so she'd have still been in quite a lot of disposables - she was in 4 days a week from 12m (3 days a week from 11m and 2 days from 6 m as I slowly increased my working days) so I think childcare needs to catch up if they do bring this in as none of the local nurseries would use reusable nappies.

gogohm · 01/09/2021 07:39

Low income families should be given a pack of 24 reusables as part of a new baby box for first children - the kind I used are suitable from around 6-8 weeks until potty training and can be secured with with pins and plastic pants or wraps (different sizes needed as they grow). Yes they need washing but they can be dried on a line or rack, my grandmother hand washed her nappies, my mother used a twin tub - it's really not an effort in a washing machine. If you have two kids in nappies at the same time you don't need more, you just wash more often.

99victoria · 01/09/2021 07:39

Yes, my mum brought me 24 cloth nappies when my son was born 35 years ago. We lived in a one bedroom flat but I bought a small tumble dryer second hand that we kept in our bedroom. Soaked the used nappies in a lidded bucket and put on a wash every couple of days.
They lasted for all 3 of my children and I still have some which I use for all kinds of things around the house.
We were very hard up when we first had kids and they saved me a huge amount of money

skodadoda · 01/09/2021 07:38

@Niconacotaco

I agree. I don't have a tumble drier. I don't know how I would have coped with reusable nappies and paying extra tax wouldn't help me afford a lovely big kitchen to fit a drier in.
None of us had tumble driers in the 70s, we dried nappies on the washing line or clothes airer.
Debetswell · 01/09/2021 07:36

@User56439876

A tax on poor women working full time while well off SAHM with their cleaners, large utility rooms with Miele appliances are on Mumsnet telling everyone how virtuous and eco friendly they are, that is the future.
@User56439876 you do know poor women worked before disposable nappies were invented. Especially in WW2. Who do you think staffed the munitions factories.
waitingpatientlyforspring · 01/09/2021 07:36

We used cloth nappies and didn't have a tumble drier and managed just fine. We do need to do something as expendable products which are horrendous for the environment are seen as the only option. If we keep going this way we will be an island of dirty nappies.

Miniroofbox · 01/09/2021 07:34

Just in the last month I threw out the last of DS terry squares. Harrington’s gold for anyone who remembers. He’s 31. They did him and no2. They’ve been floor cloths for years.

With my last (who is 19) I used them but also upgraded to prefolds and they’re still in use as floor cloths and currently my oven glove because I need a new oven glove and keep forgetting.

I worked, sent them to the childminder and she sent them home (albeit in a plastic bag) and they were washed every night and set in front of the coal fire on an airer or dried outside if I could.

I thought I was lucky I didn’t have to use a twin tub to wash them.

Megan2018 · 01/09/2021 07:33

Cloth nappies are inexpensive, easily bought secondhand, far cheaper than disposables and can be used on multiple children.
Education is what is needed so that more people use them. We have clothed since home from hospital. It’s really easy (and we’ve never used a tumble-drier for them. Line dry in summer or indoors in winter).
I’m all for a tax and eventually a ban.

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 01/09/2021 07:31

@laurenlodge

Women don't choose to have periods, so equating nappies and tampons isn't really a relevant analogy is it.
Exactly.

Having children is a choice. If you don’t want to pay tax on children items then don’t have children. It’s a known fact that children come with costs, financially and environmentally.

RoseAndRose · 01/09/2021 07:31

www.standard.co.uk/news/uk/government-justine-roberts-whitehall-downing-street-david-lynch-b953075.html

It's been quite strongly denied.

But there are eco versions, and we really should see some nudging towards using them. Less plastic is still a step forward

Caspianberg · 01/09/2021 07:31

You don’t wash nappy after every use. So childcare is the same as at home, you use liner to ‘tip’ any poop off and liner and nappy into wet bag like you would roll up a disposable. They would just give wet bag with dirty nappies in to parent. After newborn, most babies use around 6 nappies per day. Not all would be at nursery.
Same as if I am out all day.
Wash every 2 days here.

reluctantbrit · 01/09/2021 07:26

I worked 3 days, DD went to nursery for 4. All the time in cloth nappies until she was 18 months.

I supplied 4 cloth nappies each day plus a handful of disposables for emergencies (never really used). Used cloth was put in a wet bag. Poo was catched in liners and flushed.

Every two evenings I would wash the nappies when I came home and put them in a dryer overnight. DD slept in the same room as the nappy bin, no smell at all. The bin was washed and I used tea tree and lavender oil to disinfect.

EmeraldShamrock · 01/09/2021 07:25

yes, and it takes sanitary pads and tampons a similar amount of time to decompose. Should we hike the prices of those up too?
They should phase out over time due to the damage caused to the environment.
Free mooncups and towel nappies or look for a material that will break down over a shorter period.
There is tons of nappies going to the dump weekly, if we continue using disposable products we'll be over run.
I don't agree with additional costs for a hard up parent but they do cause lots of damage to the environment and didn't exist 50 years ago.

HungryHippo11 · 01/09/2021 07:25

@User56439876

A tax on poor women working full time while well off SAHM with their cleaners, large utility rooms with Miele appliances are on Mumsnet telling everyone how virtuous and eco friendly they are, that is the future.
Interesting. Most families i know are the opposite. SAHM live in small houses with a lower income and working parents have huge houses and a cleaner. I can only think of one exception.
Underhisi · 01/09/2021 07:25

"Should adults who require such products for incontinence also have to use cloth nappies/inco pads?"

Anyone who thinks adults and teenagers should be walking around with a big fat nappy arse should be forced to wear one themselves.

Knittingupastorm · 01/09/2021 07:25

I tried to use cloth nappies, but without a tumble drier they were not feasible for me. Plus they leaked and the only answer to that seemed to be to try different brands until you found one that worked for your child, which was a huge cost. Disposable nappies would have to be considerably more expensive before they come close to the upfront cost of reusables, which must be a significant factor putting people off. Even if they’re cheaper in the long run, you still need the starting costs.

I do use reusable sanitary towels though and think they’re great. Smaller than nappies and obviously only used for a few days a month so I don’t have any issues washing/drying them.

RealBecca · 01/09/2021 07:23

Didnt people used to be able to afford them? And im not being funny because i do understand the upfront cost is a barrier but if there was a grant or families adjusted to gifting a set rather than brand new prams it would be within reach of more people.

Kids dont need brand new clothes and toys but a surprising number of people wont consider second hand.

HungryHippo11 · 01/09/2021 07:22

I also agree with comments about childcare and them having to organise cloth nappies for all the babies. That sounds like a nightmare. I know a few other mums who use cloth nappies, they are all SAHM.
Its about 3 extra washes a week. I put them in with towels, flannels etc, so saves doing separate wash for those

Nursery could easily fit a toilet with hose attachment in their changing area. For a wet nappy: take off wet nappy and put in childs wet bag, put on fresh nappy. For a dirty nappy: take off dirty nappy, rinse in toilet, put in childs wet bag, put on fresh nappy. Most nursery age kids aren't doing dirty nappies at every change.

NantesElephant · 01/09/2021 07:21

The majority of people have a washing machine and some kind of drying facilities for their own clothes and bedding. If a new parent is struggling to buy a washing machine, maybe there should be a grant to help them buy one rather than just saying, well they can use disposable nappies. Imagine the hassle of having a baby without having a washing machine or a laundrette very close by. When mine were small it felt as though the washing machine was constantly on despite using disposable nappies for much of the time!

ElfDragon · 01/09/2021 07:19

Oh, and yes, nurseries did use my cloth nappies, 15 years ago. I sent in enough to last the day, they saved them and sent them home for washing. No different from when a child is toilet training and they save the clothes from when they have an accident.

burritofan · 01/09/2021 07:18

But I don’t think I could have managed to use the cloth nappies. I had a non sleeping Velcro baby who vomited every hour. My washing machine was on constantly as it was.
Same. I had a full kit of second-hand cloth nappies of all types and sizes, I was all set up to do it… then DD woke hourly til 18 months, napped only in the sling, fed constantly, and pooed at every feed. My MH was broken as it was without the added burden of a dozen pooey nappies to wash. Daily.

I’m not sure a nappy tax is the solution. Pity we don’t have the technology to make nappies recyclable.

ElfDragon · 01/09/2021 07:18

I used cloth with all 3 of mine. 2 were very late toilet trained (SN), so I had 3 in nappies at one point (albeit part time nappies for one as only overnight).

Cloth really isn’t that much harder than disposable (I used disposables on holiday), and I say that as someone who had dc with multiple allergies and intolerances (so really rank nappies!).

They can be expensive, but there is a thriving second hand market, and the plainer ones (rather than the fashionable ones) are a lot cheaper.

I had some nappies that went through my 3, plus 2 cousins, and still had some wear left in them - think of the amount of disposables not used by those 5 children.

I never tumble dried any nappies - outside on the line, or (more likely) on an airer next to a slightly open window.

My dds now use reusable sanpro. I thought dd2 would be hesitant about this (she is so very squeamish that I thought that she would want the highly sanitised use and bin approach) but she was adamant from the start (actually helped by the fact that she remembers being in nappies, and how much more comfortable cloth ones were than disposable!).

There should be all kinds of incentives to get people using cloth, rather than taxes to punish people who can’t afford the initial outlay.

Mummyme87 · 01/09/2021 07:18

There’s a lot of misinformation around reusable nappies as I can see from reading comments.
I worked, washed nappies 2-3 times per week, kept in a wet bag which contained any smells. Used reusable liners which caught the poo and tipped the poo down the toilet, I personally did rinse any heavily stained liners but many don’t.
No dryer as they should air dry.
Does not need to be expensive at all, with council schemes, nappy library’s, second hand nappies. Also the idea being you reuse them for your subsequent children.

I used a nanny for my work days, and she used the reusable nappies. I’m on many cloth bum Facebook groups and lots send their babies in cloth nappies to nursery, they provide them with wet bags which used nappies are but in to you be collected.

User56439876 · 01/09/2021 07:15

A tax on poor women working full time while well off SAHM with their cleaners, large utility rooms with Miele appliances are on Mumsnet telling everyone how virtuous and eco friendly they are, that is the future.

Debetswell · 01/09/2021 07:14

@SquirryTheSquirrel

Back in the 1970s, my mum (in common with most people) used terry nappies and she didn't even have an automatic washing machine, let alone a tumble dryer.

The same ones served me and my sister, and saw out their days as cleaning rags until they eventually wore out, so very eco-friendly.

This ^^ When I was pregnant with ds in the 80's I bought 2 dozen Terry nappies. They were very expensive but they lasted. Also the liner went down the toilet with the worst of the mess. We didn't have a tumble dryer. It was never a problem. The nappy bucket was grim though.

However , unless they've improved, Terry nappies are not absorbent like disposables.

Manufacturers need to produce a biodegradable nappy.