Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a tax on nappies is unfair?

291 replies

colacolaco · 31/08/2021 22:52

It just seems like yet again, it’s the poorest families who will be penalized and suffer most from this.

And what next - a tax on sanitary pads and tampons? Because guess what, they’re not very environmentally friendly either.

OP posts:
StarfishDish · 01/09/2021 08:15

Going slightly off topic but if parents are struggling to pay for nappies, I've found Lidl's own to be very good quality and very reasonably priced! Smile

FedNlanders · 01/09/2021 08:12

Having children is a choice but being disabled isn't? So what about prolonged use of nappies in older children and adults?

MarleneDietrichsSmile · 01/09/2021 08:11

Deal with the washing of shitty nappies will be mostly women’s work, as it’s the women that take more maternity leave, and that’s how society rolls anyway (yes I know there are exceptions and all the exceptions are vociferous Mmers Grin)

Back to washing nappies. By hand as washing machines are not environmentally friendly either.

No dryers because…. Energy

And whilst we go back in time, pretending or trying to be green, the rest of the world will continue it’s expansion and consumption

HungryHippo11 · 01/09/2021 08:09

@poshme

How much more heating and electricity will people use to dry washable nappies? In some places they will dry inside overnight (very bad for your house & condensation) but if you live near the coast the air is damper and clothes don't dry overnight in winter without heating or dehumidifiers.

What's the knock on effect in terms on health for kids growing up in damp houses?

What do people do with their clothes, bedding and towels? Do the same....
DingleyDel · 01/09/2021 08:08

Also anyone who tells me that washables are fine to go in on a 40 degree wash is lying. They need to be washed at 60 to be hygienic.

GreenTortoise · 01/09/2021 08:07

@thecognoscenti

Having children is a choice. Using disposable plastic which will take centuries to decompose is a choice. Choices have consequences.
I hope you don't buy anything from the supermarket that has plastic on.
FedNlanders · 01/09/2021 08:06

So would this include adult nappies too? I use disposable with my care clients, where do they draw the line? Sounds like penalising the poorest again. Unless reusable are more affordable.

GreenTortoise · 01/09/2021 08:05

Isn't it funny how it really only affects woman. Of course some man but the majority of the time it's the woman buying the nappies.

This world really does hate woman doesn't it.

DingleyDel · 01/09/2021 08:05

What’s the goal here? I remember reading a gov. report on washable vs disposable and the washables created more carbon emissions. Is landfill worse or better than high carbon emissions? I genuinely don’t know but it seems everyone latches on to certain ideas such as plastic being awful (obviously single use is bad) but actually glass is much worse for the environment because they are rarely reused and it takes a lot more energy to recycle glass. It also seems the people who are buried with all this extra washing are female.

poshme · 01/09/2021 08:04

How much more heating and electricity will people use to dry washable nappies? In some places they will dry inside overnight (very bad for your house & condensation) but if you live near the coast the air is damper and clothes don't dry overnight in winter without heating or dehumidifiers.

What's the knock on effect in terms on health for kids growing up in damp houses?

DdraigGoch · 01/09/2021 08:03

@Anothernamechange3

Why can’t they tax the manufacturers more based on amount of plastic packaging they use instead of it all being up to us? The idea that we take our reusable bags to the supermarket to fill them with food covered in unnecessary plastic just doesn’t make sense to me. If it was solely about the environment and not money, surely that would be a more effective way to start?
The customer always pays, one way or the other.
Kakser · 01/09/2021 08:03

@User56439876

Are those that use cloth nappies working full time and do you provide the nursery/childminder with cloth nappies?
I normally work as a teacher, averaging 40 hours a week on a 0.8 contract and use a mix of nursery and family help. None of the nurseries I looked round batted an eyelid when I said she was in resables.
User875906 · 01/09/2021 08:03

I doubt many men will need to worry about this, they will be too busy with their hobbies and work.

AutumnLeafDance · 01/09/2021 08:00

A tax on nappies? Sounds interesting. Great if it could be paired up with a policy to subsidize the initial outlay for a set of cloth nappies. I've been using fabulous bamboo fibre nappies for the past two years and am very proud at having prevented thousands of nappies from ending up in landfill where yes, they take 500 years to breakdown. 500 years in n exchange for a couple of hours of convenience! And I don't believe using cloth nappies is a privilege thing, it's a get into a good habit and stick to it thing.

thecognoscenti · 01/09/2021 07:56

Having children is a choice. Using disposable plastic which will take centuries to decompose is a choice. Choices have consequences.

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 01/09/2021 07:56

I agree the method the government is implementing is taxing the less wealthy yet again.

As there are far more people who are less wealthy then it's inevitable that they will be taxed, alongside with the wealthier, who BTW are taxed too.

We cannot deal with pollution by taxing only the wealthy 5% or so. But we have to deal with air fuel, and the aviation industry, which, is not taxed.

User875906 · 01/09/2021 07:53

It will likely be women that have this extra washing to sort out so government won't care anyway.

EdithWeston · 01/09/2021 07:53

I think we sometimes forget how recent an invention plastic throw-away nappies are.

My elder siblings pre-dated them. They were newish when I was born. DMum used cloth we me in the main, because of the expense, but she treated herself to disposables for holidays (doing nappies at home was something you just got into the habit of, dealing with a strange machine or launderettes on holiday was a PITA)

It's difficult to make a biodegradable throw-away nappy - because they have to contain warm wee/poo for a while without leaking/coming apart. But there are versions which use different materials, which are still up to the job and degrade more quickly that can replace some, if not all of the tougher ones.

And yes, we should be looking at eco sanpro and inco products too

beautifullymad · 01/09/2021 07:50

It's going to take a lot of unrest, a lot of hard evidence, and many tax breaks to get people to change their behaviours and get where we need to be.

As it's all some generations can remember they are reluctant to change the convenient way of living into something more sustainable.

The reality is, in no shape or form should plastics be made from crude oil. The plastic used in society going forward should be solely from recycled plastic and this will in itself push up prices of products. Alternatives to plastics will be made if the need to find them is great. We need to find alternatives urgently.

The whole mindset of most of the developed world is towards comfort and convenience with very little thought to the bigger picture.
Plastic in cars needs to be rethought, plastic windows, insulation, all packaging, every single throw away item, it's in so many everyday items.

The only items that might be worth the environmental price are single use medical items as infection is an issue with older methods, these can then be recycled.

A cohesive coordinated approach with tax breaks for environmentally friendly products might be a better way ahead. And stricter rules on what crude oil can be used for.

Sadly we are so far from this, people give lip service to change until it affects them. Then they want the instant cheap disposable option.

We only get one shot at this and the goal moves further away each moment.

I agree the method the government is implementing is taxing the less wealthy yet again. Maybe a substantial subsidy towards reusables issues for new mums might have been a better idea then taxation coming in later.

At least give people time to change before taxing them.

StillMedusa · 01/09/2021 07:48

DD1 has reuseables for her baby ..we got them second hand and they are brilliant, and no more hassle than any other washing. Use a liner and booster (washable) at night. It has saved her hundreds of pounds already, and as long s you have a decent supply drying time isn't an issue. We picked them up from FB marketplace.

Years ago everyone used cloth nappies and it wasn't an impossible task! I think they should be taxed..and made something only used in emergencies because they are horrific for landfill!

TheGoogleMum · 01/09/2021 07:45

Cloth nappies are a much more expensive up front cost which won't be possible for many families who live paycheck to paycheck to afford. We tried cloth nappies but couldn't get the hang of tjem they kept leaking and creating more washing as clothes would be wet. So yes I'd prefer not to have a nappy tax but I can see why they want to implement it.

JingleCatJingle · 01/09/2021 07:43

My nursery also took cloth nappies.

JingleCatJingle · 01/09/2021 07:43

Several councils provide cloth nappies free of charge for babies if you apply.
You can often pick them up second hand or from freegle.
They are actually really easy to manage and save a fortune. I worked full time with two kids in cloth nappies and managed. Yes it was extra work being organized but I was haunted by the nappies sitting in waste for hundreds of years.

gogohm · 01/09/2021 07:42

Ps I sold my nappies once youngest was potty trained for almost as much as my outlay!

Miniroofbox · 01/09/2021 07:41

Mine for DS 1 were a present from my aunt and granny I think. I didn’t buy them