Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a tax on nappies is unfair?

291 replies

colacolaco · 31/08/2021 22:52

It just seems like yet again, it’s the poorest families who will be penalized and suffer most from this.

And what next - a tax on sanitary pads and tampons? Because guess what, they’re not very environmentally friendly either.

OP posts:
twinningatlife · 01/09/2021 09:07

@LittleBiscuit09

You have a choice though.

Use disposable and pay the tax or buy reusable and don't be.

It isn't like there is no option.

I looked into reusable nappies for my twins but based on how many I would need per child (as recommended by the company that sells reusable ones) the upfront cost was over £400 - not many people can afford that type of outlay in one go compared to a few pounds here and there weekly for a pack of disposable nappies
ginghamstarfish · 01/09/2021 09:06

We DID pay tax on sanitary products until very recently, and that's something that women don't have the choice of using or not, so arguably more important. Not a bad idea to promote the use of cloth nappies though surely? Maybe subsidised to begin with.

katnyps · 01/09/2021 09:06

You don't necessarily need a tumble drier for reusable nappies - but it might depend if you have space for an extra clothes area at home. I think a lot of people might say no when the answer is actually yes... they just don't want the inconvenience. There are those that won't though, for sure. There are more eco friendly disposables - I think we should be looking to see how those can be made more affordable but often a tax on the worse option is the only way to do that!

Lonelylooloo · 01/09/2021 09:03

So women have to do the extra washing AND resolve ingrained societal inequalities in a patriarchal system? I suppose it’s something to pass the time on maternity leave

^ THIS
It drives me crazy when people point out negative connotations of government decisions on women’s lives, just to put it right back at women’s feet. ‘Well if women don’t want to be disadvantaged they should take on and overhaul the entire system singlehandedly’ FFS

Also can’t stand the amount of ‘well you should just force your DP/DH to do it’ kinda comments, how exactly can anyone force a grown adult to do anything? If women just went on strike and ‘left men to it’ it’s the children who would suffer, not get changed, not get washed, not get fed. You cannot turn your infant children into pawns in your relationship power play and that it why women will always lose.

Would social services accept ‘well I was teaching my DH a lesson’ as a reasonable excuse for a child getting hurt? Hmm NO

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 01/09/2021 09:03

So women have to do the extra washing AND resolve ingrained societal inequalities in a patriarchal system? I suppose it’s something to pass the time on maternity leave.

what a strange comment. If you are in a relationship where you feel like needing to “resolve ingrained societal inequalities in a patriarchal system” then what are doing in that relationship anyway? Who do you want to solve that for you?

As with extra washing, it comes with the territory when you have a baby.

Newmumatlast · 01/09/2021 08:56

I tried reusables for quite a long time but my daughter wasnt getting on with them and ended up switching. Feel awful about it and am genuinely going to donate a sum to environmental charity or to plant trees to counter it. So I understand reuseables can be too much for some people to cope with. However if there just weren't disposables anymore and the gov put money into giving, via midwife, a small set of reuseables to families to use then that would help tremendously. Cost of washing would then be like buying disposables anyway

burritofan · 01/09/2021 08:54

If women are being stuck with all this extra washing, then surely that is up to us to do something about it? The government or council or whoever cannot intervene in your relationship to make it one where household chores are split equally. Are we really suggesting we should set environmental policy because some women get left with housework?
So women have to do the extra washing AND resolve ingrained societal inequalities in a patriarchal system? I suppose it’s something to pass the time on maternity leave.

LittleBiscuit09 · 01/09/2021 08:53

You have a choice though.

Use disposable and pay the tax or buy reusable and don't be.

It isn't like there is no option.

Kithic · 01/09/2021 08:52

@KilljoysDutch

People who think £50 or £130 is cheap are living a different reality to that of many women in the UK. £50 was more money than I got per week to survive on in 2002 as a teen mum on benefits. Even now on Disability payments if I fell pregnant I absolutely would not be able to pay that out, it would mean not eating for a good couple of weeks.
That's nearly 20 years ago!

Also, if £50/£130 means you wouldn't be able to eat, then you really can't afford a baby full stop!

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 01/09/2021 08:50

I think this is a ridiculous proposal - and obviously is thought up by men to have a go at women (and yes I know men change nappies too).

But how many nurseries deal with non-disposable nappies? When my son was small they didn't. Oh well you shouldn't be working then should you? Why did you have kids if you are going to outsource their upbringing etc.

But more particularly, the vast, overwhelming, majority of waste is caused by industry. Something like 93%. So maybe we could get industry to clean up its act first? And getting rid of general plastic tat would be a better start than nappies.

Nappies really aren't the issue here (and neither is sanitary protection). Anyone who thinks it is, please form an orderly queue to wash my sanitary towels (tried a mooncup about 15 years ago, leaked, didn't use again before anyone suggests it).

I'd rather see a ban on SUVs and I think it would have a much bigger and more immediate impact on the environment, and especially air quality.

Livpool · 01/09/2021 08:48

I couldn't have afforded cloth nappies- and when I had DS I was unaware of any grants.

How are you supposed to wash and dry them in the winter, when you and your partner work full time?

It may suit SAHM (again it may not) but for parents who work who has the time. Or else enough money to buy more so you don't have to wash as often

User875906 · 01/09/2021 08:47

Are they not hard and scratchy if you don't use a dryer, I line dry my towels in summer and tumble dry in winter and the difference is quite noticeable. Maybe they are made of different material to towels.

a8mint · 01/09/2021 08:44

Why can’t they tax the manufacturers more based on amount of plastic packaging they use instead of it all being up to us?
It would amount to the same thing

TheLette · 01/09/2021 08:40

@HungryHippo11

For those interested in trying affordable reusable nappies, aldi sell their own mama brand ones for about £5 and they often have a leading all-in-one nappy (Bambino Mio) for under £10. They are both microfiber so quick drying.
Unfortunately both of those are notoriously bad for leaks. They may be ok for light wetters / younger babies. Microfiber isn't very absorbent. I would advise against those 2 brands.

Second the previous tumble dryer comments - no tumble dryer required.

Eskarina1 · 01/09/2021 08:39

I think in general we need positive measures for the environment not punitive ones. We did reusable nappies, it was a huge set up cost and would have saved us a fortune except we got Velcro ones which turned out to be very easily undone by a one year old (so they were not birth to potty). Nursery also couldn't handle them so they were in disposables all day.

So instead of penalising disposable nappies, put support in place for reusable (libraries etc). Except that costs money, whereas taxing nappies brings money in.

jacks11 · 01/09/2021 08:38

If women are being stuck with all this extra washing, then surely that is up to us to do something about it? The government or council or whoever cannot intervene in your relationship to make it one where household chores are split equally. Are we really suggesting we should set environmental policy because some women get left with housework?

Other than harvest or lambing time, things are fairly evenly split in my house- because we chose that. Well, actually I made it clear when we started living together that that was the deal, as DH was used to a slightly different set up- mum was a very traditional farmers wife, which I think she was quite content with- but he adapted quickly.

offyougotwantychops · 01/09/2021 08:33

I would have thought the answer was biodegradable nappies. I use compost liners made from potato starch. They are waterproof (for several hours) and take the same amount of time to rot down as the rest of my compost (have two garden compost bins). I can't see why nappies can't be made using this method.
For my own dc I used a 50/50 nappy. Had a reusable waterproof outer, and completely natural fibre throw away main part. The waterproof outer washed well at 40 (unless we had poo explosion!) and dried quickly either on the line or clotheshorse.

twinningatlife · 01/09/2021 08:32

If anything nappy manufacturers should be pushed to make the material more biodegradable rather than taxing the end user

Thecathouse · 01/09/2021 08:26

@LegoCaltrops

How long does it take for happy meal toys to decompose? Or the toys from comics? Or cereal boxes? Or the 3 layers of mixed plastic packaging from numerous overpackaged food items sold by supermarkets?

I'm not arguing against promoting cloth nappies. It's a good thing to do. But I think there are better places to start. And there needs to be more carrot before the stick is used.

Considering mc Donalds happy meal toys are now cardboard things, a couple months on my compost heap

Comic toys - well take responsibility for that, either don't buy, buy and give the toys to a charity shop when they get bored with them, or realise that chucking them in the bin is an awful thing to do, they still get more than the hour or two use of a disposable nappy mind

Cereal boxes... uk cereal no longer gives away toys in the box - for starters they don't want people having more reason to but sugary cereal

And just don't buy the overpackaged food - if you aren't buying crap then it can come without plastic, lobby supermarkets and companies to reduce it

We cannot afford to choose right now what waste reduction get a priority, our earth is on a knife edge, unless every individual does all they can and forces companies to make a move to reduce waste, we won't be around to use the products anyway

HungryHippo11 · 01/09/2021 08:24

For those interested in trying affordable reusable nappies, aldi sell their own mama brand ones for about £5 and they often have a leading all-in-one nappy (Bambino Mio) for under £10. They are both microfiber so quick drying.

jacks11 · 01/09/2021 08:23

@beetuljoos

I used cloth nappies as a young, skint parent with no tumble drier or outside space for a clothes line. It's not very expensive upfront, nor overly difficult. Many councils also give grants for cloth nappies.
I agree with this- although I was fortunate to be financially comfortable-I found the cloth nappies to be easy to use, I had fewer issues with nappy rash when we moved onto them and they didn’t cost nearly as much as I thought to buy outright (and our council does provide financial assistance to low income families for use of cloth nappies, so it isn’t just beetuljoos’ council). It made little, if any, difference to electricity bill, I did not have a tumble drier at the time and managed just fine. You don’t need one to use cloth nappies. Generations of people managed to use them, there is no reason why we can’t now. It is less convenient, but it isn’t necessarily more expensive.

Everyone is going to need to make changes to try to protect the environment. Even if the “rich” did everything possible (I know they aren’t) it would not be enough, the middle and low income groups are going to have to make changes too. And we know that making things more expensive is one of the more effective ways to change behaviour (education helps, but if something is more convenient and there is no real price difference, even in the knowledge of plastic waste, many will still choose convenience).

I agree more pressure should be put on manufacturers to reduce plastic packaging, and other measures such as higher taxes on non-environmentally friendly luxuries, flights etc. And more money put into research for green fuels and technology. Whataboutery is not helpful though. All of these measures need to take place, so we might as well start somewhere.

User875906 · 01/09/2021 08:22

@CourgetteGlutTony

The nursery my children went to used Terry square nappies for all the children. Supplied by the nursery and washed by the nursery. They put the reusable nappy my child arrived in into a waterproof bag to be taken home, and changed them into one of my own nappies late afternoon to go home.
That sounds good as they will be washing full loads of nappies also, rather than individual DPs washing a few at a time and having the washer on, maybe that should be the way forward.
LadyJJ · 01/09/2021 08:21

I also used cloth nappies with no tumble drier and a small kitchen....
I bought them second hand mostly and re sold them when we had finished potty training.
Its really not a big inconvenience, it was just a washing machine load every other day for me.
I loved our colourful nappies.
I'm not sure where the idea that you have to tumble dry them comes from.
Mine either went on the line or radiator.

HungryHippo11 · 01/09/2021 08:20

@FedNlanders

Having children is a choice but being disabled isn't? So what about prolonged use of nappies in older children and adults?
These would presumably be qualified as "medical" products and not subject to the same taxation.
CourgetteGlutTony · 01/09/2021 08:17

The nursery my children went to used Terry square nappies for all the children. Supplied by the nursery and washed by the nursery.

They put the reusable nappy my child arrived in into a waterproof bag to be taken home, and changed them into one of my own nappies late afternoon to go home.

Swipe left for the next trending thread