Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a tax on nappies is unfair?

291 replies

colacolaco · 31/08/2021 22:52

It just seems like yet again, it’s the poorest families who will be penalized and suffer most from this.

And what next - a tax on sanitary pads and tampons? Because guess what, they’re not very environmentally friendly either.

OP posts:
JustAnotherOpinion21 · 01/09/2021 09:53

@Niconacotaco

I agree. I don't have a tumble drier. I don't know how I would have coped with reusable nappies and paying extra tax wouldn't help me afford a lovely big kitchen to fit a drier in.
Cloth nappies shouldn't be tumble dried, it ruins the cover
Lockheart · 01/09/2021 09:49

@lockdownmadnessdotcom

Also - they fit better. The few times I've used disposables overnight, we've had leaks

We had the opposite. We used Nature's Child nappies which did not leak. I also tried washable ones for using at home and they leaked every time so I gave up on them. Maybe they are better now though. But I still wonder how many nurseries or childminders would deal with them (although I suppose if disposables were made expensive enough they would have to).

Funny how nobody ever says we should be using washable loo roll. I wonder why that is? I can't think that it has anything at all to do with the fact that men use it too.

Loo roll is biodegradable and almost dissolves in water, which is why it is the only thing you should flush down the toilet apart from waste.

You could use washable cloths or a bidet as an alternative if you wanted, no-one is stopping you, but loo roll isn't an environmental disaster.

CatOfTheLand · 01/09/2021 09:44

@Lockheart

How long does it take for happy meal toys to decompose? Or the toys from comics? Or cereal boxes? Or the 3 layers of mixed plastic packaging from numerous overpackaged food items sold by supermarkets?

All of the above are unnecessary plastic litter and should be banned in my opinion.

Cheap plastic giveaway toys from the 50s and 60s can often be found on beaches.

Agree! I can't believe Happy Meal, magazine and Kinder Egg toys are still allowed to be honest
CatOfTheLand · 01/09/2021 09:42

@00100001

Maybe more people will consider cloth nappies this way?
Trouble is, making disposable nappies more expensive won't erase all of the reasons why I can't use cloth nappies eg. No space to dry them, a baby with food intolerances who poos big wet ones x5 a day, and very little spare time because of working.
frazzledasarock · 01/09/2021 09:40

@lockdownmadnessdotcom

Also - they fit better. The few times I've used disposables overnight, we've had leaks

We had the opposite. We used Nature's Child nappies which did not leak. I also tried washable ones for using at home and they leaked every time so I gave up on them. Maybe they are better now though. But I still wonder how many nurseries or childminders would deal with them (although I suppose if disposables were made expensive enough they would have to).

Funny how nobody ever says we should be using washable loo roll. I wonder why that is? I can't think that it has anything at all to do with the fact that men use it too.

Were you not around during the pandemic loo roll shortage and a lot of people getting utterly hysterical at the prospect as possibly just having to jump in the shower in the morning if they ran out of loo roll?

A lot of eastern countries use bidet's hand showers, water jugs, and do perfectly well. Lets tax loo rolls

ImprobablePuffin · 01/09/2021 09:39

@Malin52

Tax them to the high heavens. As the rest of us are worrying about single use coffee cups or infinitely recyclable aluminium coffee pods a single baby is using tens of non biodegradable nappies a week that will take 6 generations to degrade. It needs addressing.

Reusable is an option. Nappy services are an option. Laundromats are an option. Drying reusables on a clothes horse is an option. Line drying is an option.

Tampons and pads I agree. Most of my friends have now moved to moon cups or period pants.

Pretty much every baby pre the 60's managed to live life with the supposed trauma of cloth nappies.

And what about disabled children who for many reasons may not be able to wear reusables? What an ignorant comment. Tax them to high heaven? Ffs
thecognoscenti · 01/09/2021 09:37

@lockdownmadnessdotcom

Also - they fit better. The few times I've used disposables overnight, we've had leaks

We had the opposite. We used Nature's Child nappies which did not leak. I also tried washable ones for using at home and they leaked every time so I gave up on them. Maybe they are better now though. But I still wonder how many nurseries or childminders would deal with them (although I suppose if disposables were made expensive enough they would have to).

Funny how nobody ever says we should be using washable loo roll. I wonder why that is? I can't think that it has anything at all to do with the fact that men use it too.

Loo roll biodegrades.
frazzledasarock · 01/09/2021 09:37

Nappies are zero rated currently.

I did use re-useable when my two older ones were babies, they were massively expensive and I needed a massive number of nappies to ensure I didn't run out especially in winter.

I've not had a disposable leak providing it's the right size and child not been wearing it for ages.

HavelockVetinari · 01/09/2021 09:37

@00100001

Maybe more people will consider cloth nappies this way?
Except the people who tend to use cloth nappies are middle class folk with plenty of money - they can afford the up front cost. There's also the fact that you do what others around you do (e.g. working class mothers are far less likely to breastfeed despite it being much cheaper than formula).

It's really not as straightforward as "it's cheaper, therefore most folk will do it".

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 01/09/2021 09:36

Also - they fit better. The few times I've used disposables overnight, we've had leaks

We had the opposite. We used Nature's Child nappies which did not leak. I also tried washable ones for using at home and they leaked every time so I gave up on them. Maybe they are better now though. But I still wonder how many nurseries or childminders would deal with them (although I suppose if disposables were made expensive enough they would have to).

Funny how nobody ever says we should be using washable loo roll. I wonder why that is? I can't think that it has anything at all to do with the fact that men use it too.

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 01/09/2021 09:34

@ginghamstarfish

We DID pay tax on sanitary products until very recently, and that's something that women don't have the choice of using or not, so arguably more important. Not a bad idea to promote the use of cloth nappies though surely? Maybe subsidised to begin with.
I suspect nappies are already subject to VAT? To be honest I don't know the ins and outs of the current rules but had assumed this would be an extra tax.
justanoldhack · 01/09/2021 09:33

I work full time and use cloth nappies. It's fine! I really don't understand why so many think it would be impossible for them. You just get into a routine and it becomes part of your week. I never tumble dry the nappies - it's not recommended as it makes them less absorbent. Just get one or two and see what you think? You can get good quality secondhand very easily.

I've saved so much money! And I really hate seeing how much plastic waste disposables generate. It's so unnecessary.

Also - they fit better. The few times I've used disposables overnight, we've had leaks. Never once with a reusable. I have a friend whose child has a leak pretty much every time, day and night. Honestly, a reusable is SO much easier than having to change clothes and bedding 4 x a day.

Give it a go! You may be pleasantly surprised... And if not, you can always go back.

CarryOnNurse20 · 01/09/2021 09:33

@00100001

Maybe more people will consider cloth nappies this way?
I think thats the idea of it.

I try really hard to be eco-friendly. I use mooncup/washable pads, we use washable wipes etc but I did NOT get on with reusable nappies. We got them second hand, tried different brands and they all leaked. I know some people love them and the principle is great but they're expensive! And you need space to hang them/a tumble drier which in itself if bad for the environment. It is hideous how long they take to break down. I think more should be done to create single use ones that are less bad for the planet but are still affordable. Certainly taxing them seems cruel to those who are already struggling.

Abouttimemum · 01/09/2021 09:32

The government refuted this really quickly so it’s not going to happen. Essentially another made up story by the media.

frazzledasarock · 01/09/2021 09:31

@ImprobablePuffin OMG that's a very good point. My grandmother in her later years was put in adult nappies as she was bed bound a few years before she died.

How will this affect people with additional needs and hospitals?

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 01/09/2021 09:30

This is going to disproportionately negatively affect women, mostly working women on lower income

I agree.

And the constant "well women did it in the 1960s" is ignoring the point I made that over 90% of all waste comes from industry - we are having a go at the wrong people.

frazzledasarock · 01/09/2021 09:28

@Malin52

Tax them to the high heavens. As the rest of us are worrying about single use coffee cups or infinitely recyclable aluminium coffee pods a single baby is using tens of non biodegradable nappies a week that will take 6 generations to degrade. It needs addressing.

Reusable is an option. Nappy services are an option. Laundromats are an option. Drying reusables on a clothes horse is an option. Line drying is an option.

Tampons and pads I agree. Most of my friends have now moved to moon cups or period pants.

Pretty much every baby pre the 60's managed to live life with the supposed trauma of cloth nappies.

Out of curiosity how many women with kids had full time jobs in the sixties, how many spent a disproportionate amount of time washing and cleaning?

Governments should incentivise biodegradable nappies. Whacking a tax on nappies is not going to make everyone suddenly stop using them, they are convenient and easy and cheaper and less labour intensive than washables.

How are people on a budget going to afford the initial outlay for washable nappies for their babies? Are we then all going to have to fork out for dryers, won't loads of people suddenly buying up and using dryers have an effect on the environment?

This is going to disproportionately negatively affect women, mostly working women on lower income.

ImprobablePuffin · 01/09/2021 09:24

HRTFT yet but slightly different perspective from what I've read so far.
It's all well and good to say just use reusable stuff but spare a thought for all the SEN parents out there (including myself) who can't use reusables if the child won't tolerate them.
We have had to use disposables with my kids (both SEN) and the youngest is 6 and still in them. I've been buying nappies for a decade now and the price of that is already extortionate. Why should people who can't use reusables for whatever reason be punished? Why should I have to pay more when I have no other option?

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 01/09/2021 09:20

.And my comment was quite clearly not about resolving patriarchal inequalities within the context of a single relationship, but the idea that women are supposed to bear the burden of nappy washing AND the burden of fixing that washing as a group

What is a group made of? Individual relationships.

Malin52 · 01/09/2021 09:20

Tax them to the high heavens. As the rest of us are worrying about single use coffee cups or infinitely recyclable aluminium coffee pods a single baby is using tens of non biodegradable nappies a week that will take 6 generations to degrade. It needs addressing.

Reusable is an option. Nappy services are an option. Laundromats are an option. Drying reusables on a clothes horse is an option. Line drying is an option.

Tampons and pads I agree. Most of my friends have now moved to moon cups or period pants.

Pretty much every baby pre the 60's managed to live life with the supposed trauma of cloth nappies.

elbea · 01/09/2021 09:19

@User875906 no, modern nappies generally have something like fleece inner or liner. You stuff the bamboo or cotton inserts into the pocket so they don’t touch the babies skin.

burritofan · 01/09/2021 09:17

If you are in a relationship where you feel like needing to “resolve ingrained societal inequalities in a patriarchal system” then what are doing in that relationship anyway? Who do you want to solve that for you?
I’m not. Plenty of women are in unequal relationships, though, and no one can be so obtuse as to think the answer is simply “Don’t be, then” or “Make your DH change”. And my comment was quite clearly not about resolving patriarchal inequalities within the context of a single relationship, but the idea that women are supposed to bear the burden of nappy washing AND the burden of fixing that washing as a group.

noideawhatusernametochoose · 01/09/2021 09:17

@katnyps

You don't necessarily need a tumble drier for reusable nappies - but it might depend if you have space for an extra clothes area at home. I think a lot of people might say no when the answer is actually yes... they just don't want the inconvenience. There are those that won't though, for sure. There are more eco friendly disposables - I think we should be looking to see how those can be made more affordable but often a tax on the worse option is the only way to do that!
I used reusables for both of mine. I did get a tumble dryer, thinking I'd need that, but hardly ever used it. I bought a fair amount of the nappies second hand so the outlay wasn't that much, and spread over 2 kids was really minimal. Yes they weren't necessarily convenient. I did however have 6 months maternity leave first time round, and worked part time after mat leave for 2nd one so that was helpful. But it wasn't convenient, it was a commitment but I still thought it was worth it.

For trips away etc I did sometimes buy disposables but bought "eco friendly" ones. They were quite pricey so I can see why they aren't (yet) a viable alternative for full time use for anyone on a budget.

Equally I absolutely get why people will want to use disposables.

elbea · 01/09/2021 09:15

@User56439876 why would nursery costs go up? There are lots at our nursery in cloth and we don’t pay any extra. Modern cloth nappies look just like disposables, you just have Velcro tabs or poppers.

BellaRoseP · 01/09/2021 09:08

I don’t think this tax is necessarily a bad thing, although agree that it should come alongside subsidies for reusable options. Me and my husband were both students for our first and used reusables. We didn’t have reliable access to a tumble drier and dried them inside, and I returned to work/placements full time at 7 months. It probably was more hassle, but it was definitely manageable and definitely worth it to save money for us. Most areas have good networks for second hand nappies, or loan out ‘kits’, so the upfront cost was very small - you don’t need the brand new expensive ‘fashion’ nappies if struggling for money. I think this tax would probably affect people who can afford to pay for convenience more than the poorest families. And it might encourage families, especially poorer ones, to look into other (cheaper) options and end up being a win-win situation.

Swipe left for the next trending thread