Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a tax on nappies is unfair?

291 replies

colacolaco · 31/08/2021 22:52

It just seems like yet again, it’s the poorest families who will be penalized and suffer most from this.

And what next - a tax on sanitary pads and tampons? Because guess what, they’re not very environmentally friendly either.

OP posts:
NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 01/09/2021 20:03

The problem with biodegradable nappies and wipes (or anything marked in that way tbh) is that the conditions needed for something to biodegrade are not created in landfill so they just sit there the same as the things that aren't "eco-friendly" it's just greenwashing by companies so they can sell a more expensive product.

This!

But while I do think people are potty training later too late, lots of people I know have done girls at 2y- 2y 3m and boys at 2y 6m.

I've done my kids just before age 2 with no problem.

Warsawa31 · 01/09/2021 19:51

I think it's time to start connecting direct taxes to direct sources of funding to be honest.

If the government procurement departments were in any way capable of making good use of public funds you could use the extra money to directly invest in cloth nappy schemes - or distribute the money to local councils to run schemes.

As it is the money is swallowed into the treasury and as pp have said the poorest people are effected.

Same with toothbrushes - they are way to cheap right now, the market forces are so slow to switch to bamboo.

IMO sooner or later we will have to accept that the "choices" we make in the market are going to have to be very heavily limited - that's not a conversation anyone wants to have at the moment.

Nsky · 01/09/2021 19:49

You need cheap good nappy services

N1no · 01/09/2021 19:31

@FuckinGoddess

How wonderful!

Higher initial investment, more washing and drying, more labour, more time- and we all know it will be the women doing all that extra work washing shit out of reusable nappies.

Wonderful.

While we’re at it, perhaps we should go back to using washboards for our laundry as well? 🙄

You might have chosen the wrong partner/husband. Mine does more then 50% of cooking, nearly all the shopping, I put things in the wash and he hangs it up. I organised the household and he does it. It works well for us, prevents my eczema from flaring up and it is the most organised way of getting things done.

Hand washing is definitely his job!

I would have a discussion with him.

FuckinGoddess · 01/09/2021 19:24

How wonderful!

Higher initial investment, more washing and drying, more labour, more time- and we all know it will be the women doing all that extra work washing shit out of reusable nappies.

Wonderful.

While we’re at it, perhaps we should go back to using washboards for our laundry as well? 🙄

SlipSlop · 01/09/2021 19:24

@Lockheart

I think if you want the convenience of a disposable polluting item over a more environmentally friendly option then yes you should have to pay for the privilege of having your consequent rubbish sit in landfill for several hundred years, for example.

The same principle applies for cars, energy, travel, clothing etc.

All of our choices have consequences. Up until quite recently we've been able to do what we like and consume what we like and throw away what we like without really having to ever think about it. Unfortunately that's not sustainable.

Agreed

I admit I used disposable nappies for convenience when my son was a baby. Now that we are all expected to think of the climate, then we should pay extra for that convenience or use resuable ones instead.

Babies are expensive. If you want one you have to suck up the associated expenses.

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 01/09/2021 19:09

I don’t think the government should subsidise them, just make disposables more expensive and more will opt into cloth.
Costs of a child should be borne by the parents not other tax payers.

Bunnycat101 · 01/09/2021 19:03

I think heavy government subsidies could work. If I’d have had a free trial pack of reusables I’d have given it a go but it seemed like too much effort to be honest to do the research and extra washing. The problem with raising tax is that people who are comfortable like me would just pay it for the convenience while the people who don’t have that choice will be the ones who are punished.

N1no · 01/09/2021 18:13

My order of cloth nappies (second hand) has arrived today, my postpartum pads and breast pads are due tomorrow and I have had a menstrual cup for years. It’s cheaper than disposable products so wouldn’t hurt the poor families. A free credit for low income families could help with the initial cost and a 0% tax rate on reusable products should also be introduced at the same time as disposable products (including menstrual products) should be taxed.

HungryHippo11 · 01/09/2021 18:02

[quote MyDcAreMarvel]**@laurenlodge*
Women don't choose to have periods, so equating nappies and tampons isn't really a relevant analogy is it.* and babies don’t choose not to bother going to the toilet![/quote]
Perhaps not, but parents choose to have kids and many choose to wait until age 3 to potty train

ActonSquirrel · 01/09/2021 17:28

*reasonable age

ActonSquirrel · 01/09/2021 17:27

@Sockwomble

"So would this include adult nappies too? I use disposable with my care clients, where do they draw the line?"

It absolutely shouldn't include older childrens or adults products.

There are fewer adults and disabled children needing them though..

Every baby wears them for at least 2.5 to 3 years or even longer and people don't bother to train them at a reached anymore.

I would imagine disposable pads and sanitary products for hospitals would be exempt from the tax as it is unsanitary to have reusable in a hospital setting.

Sockwomble · 01/09/2021 17:17

"So would this include adult nappies too? I use disposable with my care clients, where do they draw the line?"

It absolutely shouldn't include older childrens or adults products.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 01/09/2021 17:16

Oh and

  1. you dont need a tumble drier to use washable nappies. There are lots of modern fabrics options that dry relatively fast and remember how women used to use washable nappies before the tumble drier was invented?

  2. they dont have to be that expensive either. The trendiest yummy brands with limited edition prints are a rip off yep, but there are loads of much cheaper approaches and there's a roaring second hand trade because washable actually work better when they've been used and washed a few times already. There are also people happy to hand on preloved sets for free (I gave mine away).

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 01/09/2021 17:11

Its difficult. At the end of the day, disposable nappies and cheap and easy, so there's little to incentivise people to change to washable, which are clearly far better for the environment.

I think this is only reasonable if it is matched with:

  • government grants or subsidies to provide cloth nappy sets for low income families
  • advice services to help get people started on cloth

At the end of the day potty training has got later and later since the introduction of disposables - it's easier for parents to just leave them in disposables, especially between 18m and 3, when most children need some help to go the loo (eg wiping and managing clothes), and often need more reminders too. It requires the parent to put in some effort but the reality is we need to do that for the environmental benefits.

BobMortimersPetOwl · 01/09/2021 16:56

I think wherever there's a reusable option of something, any disposable versions should be taxed to the hilt.

ATrifleofFun · 01/09/2021 16:38

We use reusables for DD. Have to say I'm generally impressed but not so impressed by the Bambino mios. They are losing velcro stickyness after a year, and guess what they only have one year warranty. Which of course is over because we bought them before having the child Envy not envy as someone who doesn't have the skills to unpick and resew velcro this makes them useless for a second child Sad. Buyers beware and all that.

Caspianberg · 01/09/2021 16:03

I estimate with do an extra 3 loads per week, it probably takes me ( or dh) 1 mins to put in machine, and 5mins to hang up and 5 mins to put away. So 10-15 mins 3 times per week. We both do it, so it’s maybe 15 mins per person per week ‘work’

We use the same small flannels for cleaning baby butt and wiping face and hands after meals ( obviously not the exact same one!). What do people use if they don’t use washable cloths? Do you use a disposable wet wipe at every meal?

HungryHippo11 · 01/09/2021 15:48

Extra work required for all the cleaning of reusable nappies would probably finish me off
Two or three extra loads of laundry a week would finish you off? Honestly, people are acting like you have to sew your own nappies and scrub them in a river 🙄

OhGiveUp · 01/09/2021 15:46

I managed to work full time and wash nappies with a twin tub, as did my mother.
By the time my second child arrived, I had an automatic washing machine so I used to put the nappies in on a boil wash before I went to bed, then either peg them out or put them on the airer, weather dependent.
How you manage your time is down to you.
My daughter has the time management skills of a garden snail, fortunately she doesn't have, nor want kids otherwise she would be buried under a mountain of housework wondering why the kids dinners are six hours late and why the cat hasn't been seen for a week. ( I actually read that last paragraph out to her and she's nodding in agreement ) 😂

HungryHippo11 · 01/09/2021 15:33

@User875906

Are they not hard and scratchy if you don't use a dryer, I line dry my towels in summer and tumble dry in winter and the difference is quite noticeable. Maybe they are made of different material to towels.
Ours are made of bamboo. We live in a very hard water area and they're still soft and not scratchy, although not as soft as when they were brand new. You could always put them on a quick tumble dry for 5 mins to soften them up a bit. I use a fleece liner so the nappy isn't against the babys skin so much anyway, just the soft liner.
CustomerRelations · 01/09/2021 14:46

All poo goes in the toilet. It always amazes me on these threads how many people think disposable nappies go in the washing machine stacked with turds.

Poo from disposables should also go in the toilet. Because that's where poo goes.

poshme · 01/09/2021 14:39

@UndertheCedartree yes you should ventilate obvs. But an awful lot of landlords don't like tenants drying washing inside- for good reason. It's really bad for buildings. (Just ask @pigletjohn )

And being near the coast can make a difference- depending how close to the sea. I remember trying for 3 days to dry clothes & sheets in a house on the Cornish coast (on cliff top right next to sea). Drying nappies as well would've added to the damp air in the house and made it even worse.

Malin52 · 01/09/2021 14:36

@jacks11

Absolutely this. Fewer women prior to the 60’s may have been “at work” in the sense we now think, but many, many women (especially in poorer households) did work- often in much more physically demanding jobs than nowadays- as well as bringing up their families and doing household chores. My paternal grandmother and great-grandmother (fishermen’s wives) both worked (gutting/dressing fish/repairing nets and an oilskin factory, respectively) and this was very common among their peers. There was no maternity leave, no sick pay etc. In addition, many women had informal “jobs” or aided their husband by working alongside/doing work behind the scenes (common in farming and fishing communities, for instance, but also shop-keepers). I have absolutely no wish to return to those days- but let’s not pretend that everything is harder for women now. The challenges are different, not necessarily harder.

On top of this, the housework was very different before household appliances were common. More time consuming and sometimes more physically demanding. So even for those who weren’t in formal employment housework would have taken up more time. My mother remembers when her parents bought their first washing machine. Prior to that it had been hand washing/mangle etc. My grandmother had “wash days” at the local community laundry (not laundrette- this was hand washing) and clothes were dried on the green or the laundry had an inside area. Some families had pulleys. My father was born in 1951 and he can remember this, so within living memory.

Meals had to be made from scratch. Freezers didn’t exist, or were only for those who could afford them in the early days, so could batch cook and freeze. No ready meals/much less in way of prepared and processed foods. No hoovers, no microwaves to hear things in seconds. Everything took longer as had to be done by hand.

Our lives are different now, with different pressures, but let’s not pretend that women didn’t work in the past. They did and housework was far more time consuming than it has to be now. It’s really not as simple as “no working mother has time for washing cloth nappies, but the mothers in the past did as they did not work”. I work full time, in a professional job with long hours. I found it easy to integrate into my routine, it is possible if it’s something you want to do. It also isn’t as expensive as you think, can get second hand and there are grants too. No need for a tumble drier. It is less convenient, but it’s not uncommon to have to pay now for convenience.

Either way- it’s not about each woman “challenging the patriarchy” whilst she’s on maternity leave. My point is that it is up to each of us to manage our own relationships. The government, local authorities or whoever cannot make policy based on whether some/many women do more than their fair share of housework! That is up to each of us to sort within our relationships.

Most women are not in arranged or forced marriages/co-habiting partnerships. The majority of women chose to get married/live with their partner, they are partly responsible for domestic arrangements and if they aren’t happy they are the only ones who can ask/demand change if they aren’t happy. They are the only ones who can chose whether to stay and put up with the situation if their partner won’t change, or whether to leave. They are the ones who choose to have children with these men who won’t share the burden of household chores. Of course, men who don’t share household chores (and childcare) are equally, if not more, responsible for their failings as women who tolerate it. BUT if you chose to be in a relationship, live with and have a child (or children) with a man who will not act like an equal partner, who do you expect to be able to change that?

Wonderful post @jacks11 we forget that our parents/grandparents, whereas having the supposed luxury of time because they were able to not work, in actual fact didn't have as much of the labour saving elements of life we so take for granted now. Days were taken up with activities which now take moments.

I remember as a kid even with an auto twin tub in the late 70's, washing day was exactly that a day or two days of work. The machine was ceremoniously trundled out to the middle of the kitchen floor. Several loads hand transferred from one tub to the other requiring constant attention with tongs In the washer, floods, untangling stuff in the spinner and then 'pegged out'. No shoving things in a machine and walking away. According to my mother this was just a generation away from scrubbing the clothes by hand and then running them through a mangle.

Miniroofbox · 01/09/2021 14:20

Puts a whole new spin on a compost toilet 😂😂😂

Swipe left for the next trending thread