Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a tax on nappies is unfair?

291 replies

colacolaco · 31/08/2021 22:52

It just seems like yet again, it’s the poorest families who will be penalized and suffer most from this.

And what next - a tax on sanitary pads and tampons? Because guess what, they’re not very environmentally friendly either.

OP posts:
Megan2018 · 02/09/2021 10:47

There's no claim that reusables are carbon neutral - they aren't, very little really is.

But the manufacture of disposables in addition to the landfill they occupy far outweighs the effects of additional electricity and water used for washing reusables - especially as they serve multiple children.
A lot of people don't think about the resources used in manufacture, but is huge. Water, power, chemicals, fuel for transportation of raw materials and finished product, plus the resources used by the retailers and the consumer in buying them. With cloth these are fewer and a one off. With disposables they are ongoing.

Akire · 02/09/2021 10:12

I was going say same on smart meter a 45m wash is about 45p. That’s without price increase that are coming

User875906 · 02/09/2021 10:11

18p is less or about 1kwh of average price electricity, a washing machine uses about 2.5 units for average 40c wash so more like 50p an hour

elbea · 02/09/2021 08:47

@AveryGoodlay your point about the cost isn’t really valid. Many councils provide kits for free and if not there are nappy libraries that give out free kits. I do an extra quick wash everyday and two main washes every week (although her clothes are washed in on the main washes too). A quick wash costs about 9p and a main wash 18p. So about an extra £1 in electric per week. Modern nappies shouldn’t be tumble dried. Significantly less than a packet of nappies.

00100001 · 02/09/2021 08:28

@Icytundra

I was quite keen to use cloth nappies but the choices felt too many and as a new mum it was just overwhelming to me to make that decision and then work out how/ when they'd get washed.

It needs to be a practice that's shared more widely and where councils who offer grants publicise it more. As with many things I think for many mums it's possibly a confidence thing?

Our council has FB page with stories from real parents and what they do.

It's one of those things that's so easy... When you know!

reluctantbrit · 02/09/2021 07:55

@ReggaetonLente - I agree. I often find articles in magazines or government ideas too far aloof and away from reality. And as this thread shows, half-baked headlines from certain newspapers just confuse everyone.

We had a very active NCT group, not all middle-class earth mothers, we also covered areas where parents where counting pennies to the next pay day and relied on second hand to buy clothes for the children and themselves.

I did an article for our newsletter about my experience with cloth nappies, the good, the bad, the ugly and the funny. I even wrote that I found a friend was out of her mind when I saw her using cloth nappies a year before DD was born and why I changed my mind.

It is this what makes parents look up and take notice. We had a lot of mums telling us that they showed the article to their partner and we managed to get the council to be more open about the grant (I think it was £15 then) by asking the Health Vistors and GP receptionist for help.

It's like period pants, first where only the expensive ones and now you can get them at Primark. If Bodyform moves to period pants in addition to pads and tampons we need Pampers or Huggies to do cloth in addition to disposables.

ReggaetonLente · 02/09/2021 07:41

As with many things I think for many mums it's possibly a confidence thing?

Absolutely. I only started part timing DD is cloth when she was about 9 months, before then it just seemed way too scary, I didn't know anyone doing it til I made a mum friend at a baby group who showed me how she did it.

DD2 has been in them since birth, because I know what I'm doing this time!

We used to get all kinds of 'guest speakers' at our local church bumps and babies group, we had a lactation consultant, someone to talk about weaning, a lady from the sling library and a pelvic floor health specialist! It was great. Someone coming in to talk about cloth nappies would have been really useful.

Icytundra · 02/09/2021 06:28

I was quite keen to use cloth nappies but the choices felt too many and as a new mum it was just overwhelming to me to make that decision and then work out how/ when they'd get washed.

It needs to be a practice that's shared more widely and where councils who offer grants publicise it more. As with many things I think for many mums it's possibly a confidence thing?

AnguaResurgam · 02/09/2021 05:59

But noooo! Slap a tax on disposable nappies! Bloody lazy women that'll show them! (JRM idea? About 32 children has never changed a nappy and moreover is inclined to inform the press of this)

It's no-one's proposal. Invented by the newspapers (like charging fir LFTs) to keep up the 'nasty party' trope. Sometimes it does seem that an idea was considered only to be discarded. Others seem complete invention.

And as this one seems to have no originator, I'd put it in the latter category. But it's led to an interesting read, and far more support for re-useables than I would have expected. I think it really does come down to what you get in the habit of using.

MissTrip82 · 02/09/2021 03:07

We used cloth. Unlike all the other posters who use them however, I also drive a car and fly in planes. I’ve only been vegetarian for 24 years, so before that ate meat, and am not vegan. So clearly I’d be a roaring hypocrite to criticise anyone else’s environmental choices.

I an interested to hear of all the other working women who used them - reading the thread it seems they were working part time, or ‘working’ meant sat in an office sending emails. You must understand that doesn’t correlate to many others experience of work - not doing 50% nights? Not on your feet without eating/drinking/weeing for 12+ hrs? Then no, your workplace experience is not comparable to many others. I’d not find it easy to criticise others in the same working boat as me who decided to use disposable either.

NiceGerbil · 02/09/2021 01:18

'Unless we are lucky enough to afford non-mechanised servants of course.'

Just remembered a thing about working as a cleaner and families insisting on eco products that were way less effective and a general pita for a woman on an hourly rate to get X done.

Meanwhile there's all sorts of stuff going on that is much more impactful.

But noooo! Slap a tax on disposable nappies! Bloody lazy women that'll show them! (JRM idea? About 32 children has never changed a nappy and moreover is inclined to inform the press of this).

Same old same old.

NiceGerbil · 02/09/2021 01:13

Just thought. Good point.

Washing machines do consume water electricity. Chemical detergents. And if course the energy materials in manufacture. And disposal. There's plastics in them for sure.

Yes good point.

Ditching washing machines along with using cloth nappies sounds like the most environmentally sound option.

(And when that was the deal babies spent a lot of time sitting on potties!).

HelgaDownUnder · 02/09/2021 00:59

@NiceGerbil

All of the things listed there are about children.

I read an article a while ago about how often environmental initiatives mean more work for women.

Of course they do!

Historically, half the adult population (women) did not engage in paid work because the effort of existing required that much labour.

The equality gains if the last century have coincided with technological innovation that replaced this labour.

Do you think it would be possible to have dual income families if it wasn't for washing machines, dryers, dishwashers, long life food, refrigeration, (food packaging, storage and refrigeration allows supermarkets to exist), cheap cars, disposable stuff.

I mean, I'm sure some one will come along shortly to insist they and their DH have high flying careers, and rise at 3 every morning to pick home grown lentils for their DC, but most of us skate through relying on an army of mechanised servants and single use plastic to condense what was once a full time job into a few hours per week.

Unless we are lucky enough to afford non-mechanised servants of course.

Take away the conveniences, and we are back to the mangle.

NiceGerbil · 01/09/2021 23:49

The fact that most of our carefully separated recycling ends up dumped or burnt....

NiceGerbil · 01/09/2021 23:48

I've read that a lot of household level initiatives around this just mean more work for women. And more guilt/ responsibility. And as seen on this thread encouraging women to have a go at others.

I mean it won't make a dent. In the scheme of things. And falls to women.

In my work male dominated by far. The women have a stash of bags to take to the shop and put their lunch etc in. Mostly.

The men don't and it wouldn't cross their minds. Mostly.

It's the same with charity stuff, D&I, you name it.

Women's work. Women's stuff. Most of them just don't even register it.

Meanwhile we have the govt renewing trident (massive amount of materials energy etc). A handful of billionaires blasting all sorts into space in an advanced version of my bikes better than yours. Oil and all sorts of shit periodically being dumped into oceans. The taleban and other areas of unrest explosions all over the place.

But yeah. Nappies!

Plus pubs heating the outdoors (??!!) shops offices with lights on all night...

Etc etc etc

AveryGoodlay · 01/09/2021 23:25

You might have chosen the wrong partner/husband. Mine does more then 50% of cooking, nearly all the shopping, I put things in the wash and he hangs it up. I organised the household and he does it. It works well for us, prevents my eczema from flaring up and it is the most organised way of getting things done Do do I now after years of abuse. However I'm not so blind (unlike you) to see that it is still the norm for women to be forced to do the majority of these tasks. You are victim blaming.

AveryGoodlay · 01/09/2021 23:19

Maybe more people will consider cloth nappies this way? Haven't you considered poor people wouldn't be able to afford the energy supply bills to wash and dry these let alone the initial up front cost?!

Women don't choose to have periods, so equating nappies and tampons isn't really a relevant analogy is it. Many mothers have children who are conceived via rape. Making them a single parent with no one to help or pay child support for. Why should we be forced to pay more tax because of this?

DingleyDel · 01/09/2021 23:11

If my older child has a wee accident, I don't wash her pants and leggings at 60, I just throw them in the wash with other clothes

I do. Because if I don’t they come out of the wash stinking of wee! A friend had 2nd hand cloth nappies that stank to high heaven of piss and no matter how many hot washes it wouldn’t come out. You need to wash at 60 to kill most bacteria/bugs, and even then not all are killed at that temp.

BritWifeInUSA · 01/09/2021 21:06

To me it’s not worse than tax on clothing. You have to wear clothes. It’s illegal in public places to walk around naked. So we all have to have clothes.

Megan2018 · 01/09/2021 20:57

@lllllllllll

Plus point is we don't have a full bin full of shit - now that stinks.

@Megan2018 why would you have a bin full of shit because you use disposable nappies? Am I missing something here? Confused

Next door have an overflowing bin every fortnight full of revolting nappy bags. I’m 99.99% sure they aren’t flushing the shit before bagging. I don’t have an overflowing bin. Ours is barely half full.
Kakser · 01/09/2021 20:48

@DingleyDel

Also anyone who tells me that washables are fine to go in on a 40 degree wash is lying. They need to be washed at 60 to be hygienic.
Hygienic how? It's just had wee on it and is going to go against the same child's bum when it'll soon be covered in wee again. It's not like you eat it... If my older child has a wee accident, I don't wash her pants and leggings at 60, I just throw them in the wash with other clothes. The nappies are probably more hygienic than a towel that's not washed between uses.

I don't agree with a tax at all but there's so much rubbish still being repeated on this thread.

  • Yes you can work full time and use cloth nappies
  • Yes nurseries will deal with them
  • No you don't need a tumble dryer
  • No, you don't need to spend a hundreds to start (think I spent £50)
lllllllllll · 01/09/2021 20:47

Plus point is we don't have a full bin full of shit - now that stinks.

@Megan2018 why would you have a bin full of shit because you use disposable nappies? Am I missing something here? Confused

Spaceprincess · 01/09/2021 20:33

@User56439876 yeh I worked full time, used cloth nappies.
You send them in with the child jn the morning, staff shake the poo into the loo same as at home give you them back at night in a waterproof bag.
I did a nappy wash every other day, they dry very quickly.
I loved ours.

BungleandGeorge · 01/09/2021 20:19

The other thing is that reusable products are so much better then they used to be. Not so long ago there were no menstrual cups/ period pants etc and cloth nappies were terry squares.

BungleandGeorge · 01/09/2021 20:08

You pay tax on adult incontinence products unless you have a disability and then you are exempt. The product itself isn’t exempt though.
Tampons are just made of cotton, why would they take ages to break down? It’s the plastics and gels that don’t decompose.
Not my experience that the majority of kids are in nappies until 3+ because parents ‘can’t be bothered’ to potty train. Cleaning pooey bottoms is rank when they’re on 3 square meals a day!

Swipe left for the next trending thread