Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a tax on nappies is unfair?

291 replies

colacolaco · 31/08/2021 22:52

It just seems like yet again, it’s the poorest families who will be penalized and suffer most from this.

And what next - a tax on sanitary pads and tampons? Because guess what, they’re not very environmentally friendly either.

OP posts:
mayblossominapril · 01/09/2021 02:07

It’s just anothertax in women and the ones who will suffer are babies, there will be a lot more babies sitting in their piss for a long time and a lot more serious nappy rash.
There are eco friendly biodegradable disposables available it would be better if they became mainstream in the same way biodegradable wipes did after Hugh’s campaign.
I have tried washable nappies but faced with constant leaks and there fore more laundry with limited space to dry it in bad weather I went back to disposables. I can’t afford to buy the current expensive biodegradable nappies but could afford a bit more on nappies
In our area all waste is incinerated as well.

Smartphonetoomuchoo · 01/09/2021 00:55

@ReggaetonLente or get health visitors to ask if mums have considered them and the overall cost effectiveness of them.
my health visitor knew nothing about them when I had my second.
I bought 3 'pants' and 9 liners with my first and used to hand wash them in the sink so they could dry in time. it cost me about a tenner (which I saved for then Shock) and when I had more money with my second I bought more.
you can buy one at a time or look second hand. people give them for free, especially or eco friendly groups online if the velcro or button is broken or needs mending.

There needs to be more adverts for cloth than there are for huggies and pampers.

also cloth babies potty train sooner because they feel more wetness, nappies such as dry nights and the like stop a child feeling wet which hinders potty training and prolongs the time they are in nappies.

Moelwynbach · 01/09/2021 00:51

I tried cloth nappies but they leaked after only an hours wear. I had to cart dirty nappies everywhere. We never stayed home it was impractical and after one to many posts car seat situations I have up.

ReggaetonLente · 01/09/2021 00:48

@UndertheCedartree

I used cloth nappies. I am on a low income and it saved me a tonne of money. I don't have a tumble drier (nor a big kitchen with room for one). It was fine. I don't agree with a tax on disposable nappies but it would be good if more people tried cloth nappies. At the time my council was running a scheme where you got a few free to try out.
Yep exactly the same here. We've saved hundreds after the initial outlay. I dry them in my bathroom and I do 2-3 extra loads a week - for a family of 4 I think that's nothing but appreciate we're all different.

Rather than taxing nappies couldn't they give people a voucher for cloth nappies or a little pack of free ones?

Smartphonetoomuchoo · 01/09/2021 00:42

@Niconacotaco

I agree. I don't have a tumble drier. I don't know how I would have coped with reusable nappies and paying extra tax wouldn't help me afford a lovely big kitchen to fit a drier in.
we half and halved reusables and disposables for years in a tiny flat. No dryer. No garden and the kitchen was tiny. 3 bums at one time. you don't need to use them all the time, even once a day is worth it. its something
araiwa · 01/09/2021 00:37

There's a better, cheaper overall, more ecological solution available, so I'm all for it

GTAlogic · 01/09/2021 00:28

I used cloth nappies fory first. We had a lot more money then though so we could afford the upfront cost of the inners, shells, liners and buckets.

Our local authority had a scheme where they gave you £50 if you could show a receipt for the nappies and a health visitor's letter saying that you actually used them.

We didn't (and still don't) have a tumble dryer but still managed to get them washed and dried ready for use the following day.

We only used them for just over a year though because they started leaking but the extra pads made them too bulky and when dc 2 was a baby, dc 1 was still only toddling and it felt like too much to cope with.

KilljoysDutch · 31/08/2021 23:54

People who think £50 or £130 is cheap are living a different reality to that of many women in the UK. £50 was more money than I got per week to survive on in 2002 as a teen mum on benefits. Even now on Disability payments if I fell pregnant I absolutely would not be able to pay that out, it would mean not eating for a good couple of weeks.

DaphneDeloresMoorhead · 31/08/2021 23:37

Oh and I forgot - once Dd was dry I sold them on and pretty much got what I paid for them. Meaning 2 years or so of nappies cost me pretty much nothing

DaphneDeloresMoorhead · 31/08/2021 23:36

We bought second hand cloth nappies from a lady on a forum I belonged to before MN. I think it cost me less than £50 to kit DD out. And we had plenty. We also didn't have room for a tumble dryer so they were either line dried or dried on the airer. I didn't find them a great hassle.
So no, IME it is not expensive to do cloth nappies.

Tigger85 · 31/08/2021 23:32

@ActonSquirrel

You can say the same about adult nappies, incontinence pads that go in underware and incontinence pads that go on beds used by cafe homes, hospitals and people in their own homes. Adults who require them tend to need them for a longer length of time than babies/toddlers, they are much larger than baby/toddler nappies and I have never seen a carer or HCP empty the poo into a toilet either. Do you think they should be taxed more too or just baby/toddler nappies? Should adults who require such products for incontinence also have to use cloth nappies/inco pads?

Catawaul · 31/08/2021 23:32

I bought cloth nappies second hand, used them on two DC then sold them. No tumble dryer, you need a socktopus!

Akire · 31/08/2021 23:30

I think it’s awful, by all means encourage people try greenest things going. But For everyone who has nice warm well aired home that can dry a load washing overnight in the kitchen without a tumble dryer. There will be someone in tiny flat that’s damp and freezing cold. That even t shirts take days to dry never mind the thickness of nappies.

Lockheart · 31/08/2021 23:27

How long does it take for happy meal toys to decompose? Or the toys from comics? Or cereal boxes? Or the 3 layers of mixed plastic packaging from numerous overpackaged food items sold by supermarkets?

All of the above are unnecessary plastic litter and should be banned in my opinion.

Cheap plastic giveaway toys from the 50s and 60s can often be found on beaches.

Justanotherlurker · 31/08/2021 23:26

These are the realities of becoming more green, but as with most things people will ignore that in a few years time that people will question why washing machines are taxed because they have to use them more, water and electric bills will follow, unironically posting on a nice new smart phone.

It's the nimby style argument, it's reducing the wider argument down to the lowest problem with the added emotional angle.

Ariela · 31/08/2021 23:26

Single-use nappies have become a lot cheaper in recent years, even so the cheapest and easiest to dry are flat nappies (terry squares and prefolds). What few people realise is that because cloth nappies are designed for multiple use they have superior elastic at the legs and waist, which in turn gives better containment overall, and less leaks. I know plenty of people have been surprised by this and that actually there isn't masses of difference in the amount they wash.
As for drying washing (any washing) , we plonk ours on an airer pointed a desk fan at it and it dries very quickly, leaving a top window slightly ajar to prevent condensation.

It's worth remembering that up till about 30-40 years ago terry squares were the most popular choice. They're cheap (a full set including covers and everything else you need for around £130 or less). Even if you only substituted half your throwaway nappies with washable, you can save lots of money and save throwing away lots of nappies. Doesn't have to be all or nothing, every little helps.

Ylvamoon · 31/08/2021 23:26

RainbowMum11- there are now happy laundry services available...

RubyGoat · 31/08/2021 23:25

How long does it take for happy meal toys to decompose? Or the toys from comics? Or cereal boxes? Or the 3 layers of mixed plastic packaging from numerous overpackaged food items sold by supermarkets?

I'm not arguing against promoting cloth nappies. It's a good thing to do. But I think there are better places to start. And there needs to be more carrot before the stick is used.

ActonSquirrel · 31/08/2021 23:18

You can't really compare tampons as they are so much smaller.

Potty training doesn't start until about 3 now so that's an extra year a child is in nappies and they are huge nappies at that age.

Most people don't bother to empty the poo down the toilet to be dealt with by sewage as you're supposed to do. You're not supposed to thrown human feces in a bin but there you have it...poo inside a plastic nappy rotting in landfill.

Lockheart · 31/08/2021 23:17

I think if you want the convenience of a disposable polluting item over a more environmentally friendly option then yes you should have to pay for the privilege of having your consequent rubbish sit in landfill for several hundred years, for example.

The same principle applies for cars, energy, travel, clothing etc.

All of our choices have consequences. Up until quite recently we've been able to do what we like and consume what we like and throw away what we like without really having to ever think about it. Unfortunately that's not sustainable.

beetuljoos · 31/08/2021 23:15

I used cloth nappies as a young, skint parent with no tumble drier or outside space for a clothes line. It's not very expensive upfront, nor overly difficult. Many councils also give grants for cloth nappies.

UndertheCedartree · 31/08/2021 23:14

I used cloth nappies. I am on a low income and it saved me a tonne of money. I don't have a tumble drier (nor a big kitchen with room for one). It was fine. I don't agree with a tax on disposable nappies but it would be good if more people tried cloth nappies. At the time my council was running a scheme where you got a few free to try out.

JackieChiles · 31/08/2021 23:14

If they tax the manafacturers they will just pass the cost on anyway. It would hit poorer people harder but doesn’t VAT do the same? Is it fair to pay a flat percentage of VAT on necessary items like petrol, electricity, prams, car seats, and adult clothing and shoes? Everything hits poorer people harder.

The trouble is we all need to change our consumption habits, not just the people who can’t afford the tax increase. I would almost say the tax on things like nappies should be very very high? If it were set high enough even financially comfortable people to look for options that don’t contribute to the impending climate disaster.

laurenlodge · 31/08/2021 23:12

Women don't choose to have periods, so equating nappies and tampons isn't really a relevant analogy is it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread