Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a tax on nappies is unfair?

291 replies

colacolaco · 31/08/2021 22:52

It just seems like yet again, it’s the poorest families who will be penalized and suffer most from this.

And what next - a tax on sanitary pads and tampons? Because guess what, they’re not very environmentally friendly either.

OP posts:
ActonSquirrel · 01/09/2021 06:29

Mid 90s jeez early 2000s that should have said.

HungryHippo11 · 01/09/2021 06:29

Definitely, not defibrillator 🙄

Oh I also agree with PPs suggestion of taxing supermarkets on the amount of plastic packing. I recently noticed asda has reduced the plastic on their chicken products by 50% so it can't be that hard to do.

ActonSquirrel · 01/09/2021 06:29

There's another thread running at the moment about potty training where a lot of people are saying any children supposedly potty trained under 3 are no doubt having multiple accidents and being dragged to the toilet hourly by their parents - complete disbelief that a child just turned 2 could possibly be trained despite many posters saying their children are.

I baby sat as a teen in the mid 90s. The little boy was potty trained at less than 2.5 and no he wasn't like that.

HungryHippo11 · 01/09/2021 06:27

Reusable nappies (and period products, since someone mentioned those) are defibrillator the way forward and should be encouraged far more than they are. Disposable nappies are the default, most patents don't even consider reusable and there are a lot of myths about them, like that it takes 3 days for them to dry.

However there are different steps the government could take to encourage the switch:

  • ban advertising of disposables
  • subsidise advertising of reusable
  • hand out free samples of reusable in the hospital, rather than free disposables and a little plastic pot of sudocrem (that's what we got anyway)
  • have midwives and health visitors exourage cloth nappy use
  • have courses about how to use them
  • subsidy schemes to make them more affordable.

The big difference is that all these things cost money and require effort, whereas sticking on an extra tax makes money and requires little effort. So what do you think the gov would choose, given the chance?

ActonSquirrel · 01/09/2021 06:27

Also what are the calls for finance for this. People honestly want government support to pay for nappies for a child one presumably decided to have?

ActonSquirrel · 01/09/2021 06:26

[quote veryblearyeyed]@ActonSquirrel I read a lovely book around ten years ago called Can Any Mother Help Me, basically a sort of pre-internet MN.

If I recall correctly, the debate then was whether to potty train before or after a year![/quote]
I have pics of myself at barely over 12 months sitting in the potty with a toothbrush.

Obviously I couldn't be potty trained and dry at that age but the point was I think people used to do it to get kids used to using it. Put them on it before bed, before bath or whatever. Then it was no big deal to start using it.

Now it's disposables until 3 before it is attempted in many cases.

Kakser · 01/09/2021 06:24

There's another thread running at the moment about potty training where a lot of people are saying any children supposedly potty trained under 3 are no doubt having multiple accidents and being dragged to the toilet hourly by their parents - complete disbelief that a child just turned 2 could possibly be trained despite many posters saying their children are. That's a lot of extra nappies if lots of people wait until 3. And even if a child did have an accident a day, what's an extra pair of leggings in your wash basket compared to a dozen disposable nappies being used every 24 hors day in say out?

onelittlefrog · 01/09/2021 06:09

If you think about the fact that your own nappies from when you weere a baby are still hanging around in landfill, it's kind of eye-opening!

Also your parents', possibly even your grandparents' if they had them.

It's a lot of landfill that is completely avoidable.

onelittlefrog · 01/09/2021 06:06

YANBU but I do think we are going to have to move towards reusables, for both nappies and sanitary products. It's just not sustainable to carry on like this.

Farevalah · 01/09/2021 05:53

DM used cloth nappies for my younger brother, I remember her buying them from Mothercare along with the rubber pants that went over them. He was out of nappies completely when he was 2, and DM used the old terry squares as floor cloths.
I used disposables for our DC though, but they were potty trained at 2. I'm sure I've read some children are still in nappies when starting at reception?

Maybe govt could look at making the initial outlay of cloth nappies cheaper to encourage more people to use them?

BaringasMare · 01/09/2021 05:52

I agree, it’s unhelpful.

I’m a massive advocate of cloth nappies - we’ve used them almost from birth, I think they’re great, and I fully appreciate that disposable nappies are an environmental disaster (every single disposable nappy ever used is still in landfill today!)

But I still think a disposable nappy tax is a terrible idea. I hate almost all forms of taxation which are non-progressive. It’s a stick instead of a carrot, which isn’t usually helpful. It penalises people without giving consideration to the reasons why cloth nappies might be inaccessible. It solves none of the barriers to using cloth nappies (lack of information / high upfront cost / time involved in laundering).

I also don’t think it’s even that effective - most people aren’t going to switch to cloth nappies just because their disposables cost a bit more each time. It’s not a strong disincentive, it’s just a crappy penalty to make people’s lives a bit harder.

I’d like to see proactive measures to promote cloth nappies. Grants for the start up cost would go a long way - many people don’t have hundreds of pounds to spend upfront on a cloth nappy bundle, even though the savings in the long term are much higher than that.

Investment in nappy libraries would help too. There are so many options and the cost of getting it wrong can be prohibitive. Giving people more opportunities to try different types before buying would help with this.

veryblearyeyed · 01/09/2021 05:47

@ActonSquirrel I read a lovely book around ten years ago called Can Any Mother Help Me, basically a sort of pre-internet MN.

If I recall correctly, the debate then was whether to potty train before or after a year!

Balonzette · 01/09/2021 05:39

I'm neither pro or anti this, despite having nappy-wearing-aged babies. The way I see it, we can't have it all. We need yo choose for ourselves whether it's more important to us to have convenient and affordable products at the expense of the planet, or whether we want to push people towards the inconvenient and eco-friendly option with moves like this. I honestly can't decide which is more important to me. I suppose in the grand scheme of things, everyone is going to need to be inconvenienced in some way if we stand a chance of saving the planet.

ActonSquirrel · 01/09/2021 05:33

@IHateCoronavirus

Maybe the increase in price might encourage potty training. The number of NT untrained children entering school seems to raise every year. I think someone mentioned up thread that the average age is 3.

When my eldest DC were training 10-14 years ago the advice was 2. So I waited for the nearest free week to their second birthday (half-term) and trained them without any bother.

I remember our head calling us in to write a personal care policy for non-SEND children for the first time and we were all HmmShock.
Now it is becoming the norm.

Well quite.

I read an article in the a while ago that said the age to start potty training rose to 18 months in 1960-1980 due to the labour-saving introduction of disposable nappies.

It rose to 18 months!! Meaning it used to be started earlier than that. Now potty training starts at around 3, which is double what it was 40 years ago.

Either every child is now incapable or doing git any earlier or people can't be bothered to try. But there is no need to delay it until 3 and maybe increase in prices will compel people to do it earlier.

Also reusable nappies used to let the child feel they were wet and now they have no idea due to modern nappies which never feel wet.

Kylee300 · 01/09/2021 04:49

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for privacy reasons.

EdithGrantham · 01/09/2021 04:24

@mayblossominapril

It’s just anothertax in women and the ones who will suffer are babies, there will be a lot more babies sitting in their piss for a long time and a lot more serious nappy rash. There are eco friendly biodegradable disposables available it would be better if they became mainstream in the same way biodegradable wipes did after Hugh’s campaign. I have tried washable nappies but faced with constant leaks and there fore more laundry with limited space to dry it in bad weather I went back to disposables. I can’t afford to buy the current expensive biodegradable nappies but could afford a bit more on nappies In our area all waste is incinerated as well.
The problem with biodegradable nappies and wipes (or anything marked in that way tbh) is that the conditions needed for something to biodegrade are not created in landfill so they just sit there the same as the things that aren't "eco-friendly" it's just greenwashing by companies so they can sell a more expensive product.
Kakser · 01/09/2021 04:21

Whilst I agree in principle, there are so many mistruths about cloth nappies. Don't know a single person who uses them who tumble dries them for example. Mine are almost dry when I take them out the machine. If they leak, something is wrong. Agree with pp you can use a mix and build up a supply at once. Yes the outlay of around £50 to start with would be a lot to some people, but so is a pram or cot surely? There should be schemes to help with this though. We got £25 back from the council but I appreciate not everyone can pay up front and wait for the cheque back.

IHateCoronavirus · 01/09/2021 04:10

Maybe the increase in price might encourage potty training. The number of NT untrained children entering school seems to raise every year. I think someone mentioned up thread that the average age is 3.

When my eldest DC were training 10-14 years ago the advice was 2. So I waited for the nearest free week to their second birthday (half-term) and trained them without any bother.

I remember our head calling us in to write a personal care policy for non-SEND children for the first time and we were all HmmShock.
Now it is becoming the norm.

NiceGerbil · 01/09/2021 02:52

All of the things listed there are about children.

I read an article a while ago about how often environmental initiatives mean more work for women.

UndertheCedartree · 01/09/2021 02:33

@LegoCaltrops

How long does it take for happy meal toys to decompose? Or the toys from comics? Or cereal boxes? Or the 3 layers of mixed plastic packaging from numerous overpackaged food items sold by supermarkets?

I'm not arguing against promoting cloth nappies. It's a good thing to do. But I think there are better places to start. And there needs to be more carrot before the stick is used.

Happy Meal toys are all cardboard now.
NiceGerbil · 01/09/2021 02:29

Looks like it's been shelved anyway.

UndertheCedartree · 01/09/2021 02:29

@KilljoysDutch - you don't need to buy them all at once. I bought mine gradually. The amount of money you save is incredible. It would have made life much easier on £50 pw if you didn't have to spend £5 odd pw on nappies.

NiceGerbil · 01/09/2021 02:28

Tax on nappies wtf?

Nope.

ReggaetonLente · 01/09/2021 02:22

Smartphonetoomuchoo yes they are still seen as something of a rogue choice aren't they?

ReggaetonLente · 01/09/2021 02:14

@Moelwynbach

I tried cloth nappies but they leaked after only an hours wear. I had to cart dirty nappies everywhere. We never stayed home it was impractical and after one to many posts car seat situations I have up.
This was my worry too, but honestly we have used cloth since birth and the only time she has leaked was when she was in a disposable that I had to borrow in an emergency off SIL!

I do think different babies suit different brands and styles and it was be so nice to be given a little starter pack of a few different cloth nappies to see which suited before making an investment.