Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a tax on nappies is unfair?

291 replies

colacolaco · 31/08/2021 22:52

It just seems like yet again, it’s the poorest families who will be penalized and suffer most from this.

And what next - a tax on sanitary pads and tampons? Because guess what, they’re not very environmentally friendly either.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HungryHippo11 · 03/09/2021 16:09

Many mothers have children who are conceived via rape. Making them a single parent with no one to help or pay child support for. Why should we be forced to pay more tax because of this?
Eh? Women who were raped can also use reusable nappies, so they wouldn't be forced to pay more tax than anyone else. Presumably they pay tax on food for their kids too, or should they be exempt from that too?

HungryHippo11 · 03/09/2021 16:04

@TempsPerdu

I'm also curious as to why certain practices are targeted but not others.

Agree. Along similar lines, we chose to only have one child, partly for environmental reasons. But we did use disposable nappies and we do travel overseas, albeit mainly short haul and not as frequently as some. We made a conscious decision when we had DD to base our lifestyle around experiences and travel rather than ‘stuff’, as I love other cultures and languages and don’t want her having the insular, xenophobic upbringing I had.

Why is that decision somehow morally ‘worse’ than having 2 or 3 DC but using cloth nappies and not travelling?

I don't think anyone is saying what is better or worse across the entirety of someone's life. Just that reusable nappies are better than disposable. You could have done everything you have done, exactly the same, except using reusable nappies, and that would be better for the environment. It doesn't really matter how you "compare" to some made up person.
Legomania · 03/09/2021 13:51

No but their parents can't be arsed to potty train them until 3 in some cases and that is a choice.

Hmm
ActonSquirrel · 03/09/2021 12:47

@User179335678

Babies don’t choose to shit themselves either… 🤷🏼‍♀️
No but their parents can't be arsed to potty train them until 3 in some cases and that is a choice.
User179335678 · 03/09/2021 10:49

Babies don’t choose to shit themselves either… 🤷🏼‍♀️

Megan2018 · 02/09/2021 15:13

@nonono1

I'm also curious as to why certain practices are targeted but not others. I use disposable nappies but don't take long haul flights and don't drive. I also eat very little meat.

Am I worse for the planet than someone who uses cloth nappies but regularly holidays in the Maldives, drives every day and eats meat most nights?

We're not playing environmental one upmanship here are we? But if you want I'll raise you:

2 fully electric cars
Not flown anywhere for 10 years
Renewable electricity supply and a home battery
Air source heat pump

But this thread is about nappies, so I won't as it's not relevant. Cloth nappies are an easy, affordable, effortless thing to switch to. The other things we do as a family are not in reach of the majority.

ActonSquirrel · 02/09/2021 14:49

I use disposable nappies but don't take long haul flights and don't drive. I also eat very little meat.

That's hardly earth shattering is it.

Your child's shitty nappies are being buried in landfill and will take hundreds of years to break down and there is an alternative that you won't take.

TempsPerdu · 02/09/2021 14:09

I'm also curious as to why certain practices are targeted but not others.

Agree. Along similar lines, we chose to only have one child, partly for environmental reasons. But we did use disposable nappies and we do travel overseas, albeit mainly short haul and not as frequently as some. We made a conscious decision when we had DD to base our lifestyle around experiences and travel rather than ‘stuff’, as I love other cultures and languages and don’t want her having the insular, xenophobic upbringing I had.

Why is that decision somehow morally ‘worse’ than having 2 or 3 DC but using cloth nappies and not travelling?

nonono1 · 02/09/2021 14:02

I'm also curious as to why certain practices are targeted but not others. I use disposable nappies but don't take long haul flights and don't drive. I also eat very little meat.

Am I worse for the planet than someone who uses cloth nappies but regularly holidays in the Maldives, drives every day and eats meat most nights?

nonono1 · 02/09/2021 14:00

Next door have an overflowing bin every fortnight full of revolting nappy bags. I’m 99.99% sure they aren’t flushing the shit before bagging.
I don’t have an overflowing bin. Ours is barely half full.

That's just one example though.

I use disposable nappies and flush any poos down the toilet before disposing of the nappy. Our bin is also barely half full as we do a lot of recycling.

EmeraldShamrock · 02/09/2021 13:47

I'd imagine companies will have to make changes or businesses will fail, more people will use cloth nappies.
It can't continue they're destroying the planet.
Pressure needs to be put on the big brand companies to change to biodegradable materials at a reasonable price.

Miniroofbox · 02/09/2021 13:23

I think you just binned the inner though.

Miniroofbox · 02/09/2021 13:23

@Cassandraprobs

I'm amazed that the nappy companies haven't figured out a 3rd option yet to disposables or cloth - why not some sort of ultra compressed paper-based liner like extreme toilet paper which fits inside a plastic outer nappy, basically deconstructing current disposables? So then you take the paper-ish liner out and flush it down the loo because it would just be toilet paper (maybe you'd have to let it sit in the loo for 5 mins to soak and start to break apart, same as if someone uses too much loo paper at once) and you just rinse the plastic liner and reuse? No, just tax us instead!
I remember my mum having disposables like that for my brother. He’s in his 40s.
Cassandraprobs · 02/09/2021 13:07

I'm amazed that the nappy companies haven't figured out a 3rd option yet to disposables or cloth - why not some sort of ultra compressed paper-based liner like extreme toilet paper which fits inside a plastic outer nappy, basically deconstructing current disposables? So then you take the paper-ish liner out and flush it down the loo because it would just be toilet paper (maybe you'd have to let it sit in the loo for 5 mins to soak and start to break apart, same as if someone uses too much loo paper at once) and you just rinse the plastic liner and reuse? No, just tax us instead!

firstimemamma · 02/09/2021 13:00

Disposables already work out more expensive than cloth - so I'm a way people are already taxed for using them - yet attitudes haven't shifted so it's a bit pointless really as it won't achieve anything.

Much more needs to be done. TV, shops, everything in society pushes disposable nappies like they are the only option and as a cloth nappy user I felt like an outsider. Things will only change with drastic measures and I really think this is needed.

Lockheart · 02/09/2021 12:59

[quote TempsPerdu]@Lockheart Ah well, as long as people are telling their sons that it’s back to the mangle from now on, as well as their daughters. And no foreign travel either, I suppose?[/quote]
Actually yes, we all need to reduce our foreign travel.

And yes, people should be raising their sons to take on an equal amount of the mental load / child rearing / housework. The fact that there is a feminist slant to the issues surrounding environmental problems (and there is, a huge one) does not negate the fact that we can't keep treating the planet the way we have been.

Miniroofbox · 02/09/2021 12:57

I have reared my son to take his equal share of household tasks. He actually did more than dd1 when he lived with me and more than pulled his weight in the house. I don’t expect that has changed now he has a partner.

TempsPerdu · 02/09/2021 12:56

@Lockheart Ah well, as long as people are telling their sons that it’s back to the mangle from now on, as well as their daughters. And no foreign travel either, I suppose?

EmbarrassingMama · 02/09/2021 12:52

Cloth can be expensive if you want fancy stuff and extras, but it can also be super cheap. My first was in cloth, my second will be, and I’ve never tumbled dried a single nappy.

Particularly if you’re using cloth for more than one baby they are super cheap, easy to use, reliable and don’t cost the earth.

I am fully in support of a disposable nappy tax, but I think the revenue should be put towards offering more cloth incentives (like freebie packs for new parents, which most councils offer).

Lockheart · 02/09/2021 12:21

And I wonder how many of the posters insisting that we should all now be using these amazing reusable nappies benefited from the convenience of disposables themselves but want to pull up the drawbridge now they no longer have young kids.

With respect, this a very silly argument. Just because one generation got to do something that was convenient but extremely damaging doesn't mean the following generation can carry on.

Subsequent generations need to learn from the mistakes of previous ones, not just keep repeating them because it's easy and it's not fair that our parents got to cover the earth with dirty nappies and we don't.

YouMeandtheSpew · 02/09/2021 11:51

I used reusables while on maternity leave. Quickly switched to disposables when back at work. We found we couldn’t manage it in addition to everything else. We still use reusable wipes though.

I’m sure there are people who manage to use reusables while both parents are working but it was too difficult for us.

TempsPerdu · 02/09/2021 11:40

I've read that a lot of household level initiatives around this just mean more work for women. And more guilt/ responsibility. And as seen on this thread encouraging women to have a go at others.

This. It’s always women who bear the brunt of this stuff - the actual practical ‘wife work ’ side and the guilt of all the societal expectations. I’m all for helping the environment where possible, but not at the cost of more domestic drudgery for women. I’m also in ‘trendy’ north London, and don’t know a single person who has used cloth nappies. One friend, who actually works for an environmental charity, attempted it for a few months and then sheepishly joined the rest of us with our trusty Mamia multipacks.

And I wonder how many of the posters insisting that we should all now be using these amazing reusable nappies benefited from the convenience of disposables themselves but want to pull up the drawbridge now they no longer have young kids.

FWIW we left DD’s potty training relatively late (she was 2.9), by which time she was fully ready for it and it took all of a week, with next to no accidents. Numerous friends were very vocal about doing it much earlier, went quiet for a while - and then confessed it had been a disaster and they had to do it all again a year later.

elbea · 02/09/2021 11:24

@User875906 this was my source - www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-44340082.amp although a couple of years out of date. Even if your machine does cost 45p for a full wash, still cheaper than a packet of nappies.

Legomania · 02/09/2021 11:12

@IHateCoronavirus

Maybe the increase in price might encourage potty training. The number of NT untrained children entering school seems to raise every year. I think someone mentioned up thread that the average age is 3.

When my eldest DC were training 10-14 years ago the advice was 2. So I waited for the nearest free week to their second birthday (half-term) and trained them without any bother.

I remember our head calling us in to write a personal care policy for non-SEND children for the first time and we were all HmmShock.
Now it is becoming the norm.

Plenty of kids, particularly boys, aren't ready at 2. Mine weren't. For every poster who says their child got it in a week at two, you have another saying it took weeks/months. Working parents don't have that. I would gladly have trained DS2 a year ago but he was nowhere near ready.
Ohshitiveturnedintomymother · 02/09/2021 10:58

@Megan2018

I am genuinely astounded at some of the comments on here. So much nonsense spouted.

For the record - in our house we both work (I am slightly part time at 30 hours, DH does 45), we don't tumble dry. DD is at nursery for 4 days a week - all in cloth. There are many children at nursery in cloth, it's roughly a third at mine although minor variations in each room. My nursery didn't bat an eyelid at using them and it's not an affluent area.

We both wash and dry them, it's not my job! The machine goes on early and we either hang out to dry or hang indoors to dry. We wash every other day. Solids are flushed, then nappies are rinsed in the machine before a full cycle is run. They dry indoors in 24hrs, less when the heating is on. We use cloth wipes as well as nappies, much kinder on skin and will be used afterwards for mopping up spills etc.

We're only having one child but could easily use the same nappies on 3-4 babies and we will sell on ours once potty trained so they will do multiple children. The initial outlay is less than the cost of disposables for one child, let alone two or more.

Modern cloth nappies don't need soaking, they don't need folding or pinning (although some people do use terries still)- the simplest designs go on and off just like a disposable. It takes longer to buy a pack of disposables from the shop than it takes to load and unload a washing machine. There's really no work at all.

Plus point is we don't have a full bin full of shit - now that stinks.

I could have written this exact post! The only difference is I now have two so they are being rescued for my second now my eldest is potty trained.

So much crap (pun intended) spouted on here and it’s no surprise that people are hesitant to try if this is the rubbish they hear.