Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are US States like separate countries in way?

37 replies

everythingishandy · 31/08/2021 16:06

Are individual states in the US like separate counties in a way? How much autonomy do they each get?

OP posts:
EKGEMS · 31/08/2021 17:09

You can travel into every state without showing ID but there are certain laws and regulations in each state but some counties or cities and towns within the states where they may or may not have different laws. Speed limits, liquor and alcohol sale laws, dog breeds,etc.Some places don't sell alcohol on Sundays or don't sell till afternoon. Some require alcohol sold in stand alone stores and others only sell beer or wine in grocery stores.I have lived in five states and three have mandatory yearly auto inspections for cars at certain age.

DerAlteMann · 31/08/2021 16:47

It's over simplifying a bit, but basically, yes they are.

SuperLoudPoppingAction · 31/08/2021 16:42

blogs.lse.ac.uk/usappblog/2019/02/18/why-the-us-complex-federal-system-will-blunt-the-worst-aspects-of-trumps-transgressive-presidency/

This is interesting

A bunch of interesting research papers popped up on Google when I searched. Depending on how interested you are, there is plenty of food for thought.

gwenneh · 31/08/2021 16:41

@MrsRobbieHart

In my head (which is probably totally wrong! Grin ) the states are like the different countries of the UK. They are the United States made up of 50 states and we are the United Kingdom made up of NI/wales/Scotland/England.
That's pretty close, though.

Federal law governs all 50 states; each state has the power to enact their own laws as long as those laws are considered "constitutional" and don't infringe on the rights set out in that document. The federal courts can hear challenges to, and overturn, state laws if they aren't considered constitutional.

Each state has a fair amount of autonomy, which is what you're seeing with covid rules. In theory this is a good plan, it means the governing of a state (with its own population, density, geography, and demographic) is highly individualised. In practice it means two states adjacent can have two entirely different sets of laws and cause confusion.

MrsRobbieHart · 31/08/2021 16:41

@SuperLoudPoppingAction

It's tricky to use that analogy as for eg Scottish people often feel Scotland is definitely a country rather than a state (I'm Scottish fwiw) but in a practical sense it is similar - some issues are devolved and some are national. Each state has a senate and they also send representatives to the national houses/whatever they are called. I used to know a lot more about this.

The us government has lots of Web pages on this kind of thing. I'm sure they will have one on this.

Yes I called them the countries of the UK. I consider them all countries.
CeeJay81 · 31/08/2021 16:38

I would say yes they are. Laws vary a lot between states and costs vary from taxes, to welfare, to wages etc. I'd say States have more autonomy than the UK countries.

SuperLoudPoppingAction · 31/08/2021 16:37

It's tricky to use that analogy as for eg Scottish people often feel Scotland is definitely a country rather than a state (I'm Scottish fwiw) but in a practical sense it is similar - some issues are devolved and some are national.
Each state has a senate and they also send representatives to the national houses/whatever they are called. I used to know a lot more about this.

The us government has lots of Web pages on this kind of thing. I'm sure they will have one on this.

MrsRobbieHart · 31/08/2021 16:33

In my head (which is probably totally wrong! Grin ) the states are like the different countries of the UK. They are the United States made up of 50 states and we are the United Kingdom made up of NI/wales/Scotland/England.

everythingishandy · 31/08/2021 16:30

I was just wondering, it's not homework don't worry. I was looking up at the covid restrictions in the US where I found out that each state has different laws and regulations in place.

OP posts:
SuperLoudPoppingAction · 31/08/2021 16:26

Federal - lots of countries have a federal system. State law vs national law etc. Why do you ask?

ditalini · 31/08/2021 16:24

Google States Rights.

DynamoKev · 31/08/2021 16:22

Homework already?

Swipe left for the next trending thread