Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are US States like separate countries in way?

37 replies

everythingishandy · 31/08/2021 16:06

Are individual states in the US like separate counties in a way? How much autonomy do they each get?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CounsellorTroi · 01/09/2021 09:07

Each state has its own justice system and its own Supreme Court.

Jaysmith71 · 01/09/2021 08:39

I think that if George III hadn't been such a nutter, we could have become a commonwealth country. There were a sizable number of tories who sold up and moved back to England after the revolution.

Most loyal American tories moved to Canada and became the majority of the population of Ontario. The young Republic then invaded Canada and burned down Toronto (then York) in an effort to incorporate it, a move that led to the British destruction of Washington DC and the burning of the White House.

It is at least likely that there were more, perhaps many more, loyal subjects in the colonies at the time of the Revolution than there were ardent revolutionaries. Most folk kept their heads down and waited to see who won.

But a good point noted above is that it was the 13 colonies that declared independence and only later established a federal republic.

MadameMinimes · 31/08/2021 23:11

It makes sense that the big cities would be more interested in international news. Thanks for the insight.

longerevenings · 31/08/2021 23:06

I live in the 3rd largest US city, I'm just guessing but I suspect there is even less enthusiasm for international news in most of America.

We have a choice of local and national channels, we usually watch CNN.
Living in a large city there is plenty of local news to follow as well.

MadameMinimes · 31/08/2021 22:32

@longerevenings That’s interesting. Do you think that’s the same across the country or do you think in some places there’s more demand for international news? Is TV news mostly national channels or do they tend to be state/regional/local?

longerevenings · 31/08/2021 22:00

The news channel on TV that I watch has almost no international news.
My radio station has an hour of international news from the BBC every morning.
Print press is a bit more international but I don't actually access any.

MissConductUS · 31/08/2021 21:18

I think the mixed model of government has served the US well. States can try different approaches to problem-solving and learn from each other in the process. Some states, due to their size, can set de facto national standards for things like allowable levels of emissions from cars.

I think that if George III hadn't been such a nutter, we could have become a commonwealth country. There were a sizable number of tories who sold up and moved back to England after the revolution.

As to international news, I listen to BBC World News on my national public radio station, and it gets plenty of coverage in the press, a bit less on TV news.

BeaucoupFish · 31/08/2021 20:53

SOME not sine

BeaucoupFish · 31/08/2021 20:52

Good thread it's very interesting how laws taxes vary from state to state I like reading about different countries. Its fascinating that the US Canadian border covers 13 states and is the longest border in the world at 5.5 thousand miles it's mind blowing really what a huge country it is and sine borders are water borders over the great lakes...geeky and off topic sorry 😞

MadameMinimes · 31/08/2021 20:44

Just to correct myself. I’m exaggerating when I say that no sovereignty was ceded before the constitution, but the powers given to central government by the articles of confederation were much weaker.

dreamingbohemian · 31/08/2021 20:41

Ah yes, the Articles of Confederation. Something you learn about endlessly in American schools and then promptly forget about forever : )

MadameMinimes · 31/08/2021 20:37

@PlanDeRaccordement

The USA was created by 13 separate, sovereign states deciding to cede a certain amount of sovereignty to a central government.

Not really, they were 13 British colonies. They weren’t individually sovereign states because they all had only one sovereign, the King of England and only one government, British Parliament.

There’s over a decade between the Declaration of Independence and the ratification of the constitution. No sovereignty was formally ceded by the states until this point. The Declaration of Independence was not the creation of the United States as we think of it now as a nation state. Rather, it was thirteen states declaring their own independence and their intention to stand together to resist British rule. The constitutional convention was thrashing out ideas about what the United States would be, but it was not at that stage inevitable that a true federal republic would emerge. In fact, a much looser confederation was attempted first.
dapsnotplimsolls · 31/08/2021 20:18

You might find this useful

www.bbc.co.uk/bitesize/guides/z2cy7p3/revision/1

dreamingbohemian · 31/08/2021 20:17

I'm trying to think of more examples

Each state has its own drivers' licences (although they all recognise each others)

Most states have their own public university system (University of Maryland, University of Virginia etc.)

Each state has its own state police force (separate from local police and from federal agencies)

Each state has its own covid laws and policies, though some things are becoming more federalised

Griefmonster · 31/08/2021 20:10

@MadameMinimes post is an excellent point. Helps to make sense of why there are so many aspects of state law that you would expect to be federal. I find it interesting that education, marriage, abortion and even voting laws are different from state to state.

Jaysmith71 · 31/08/2021 20:09

@PlanDeRaccordement

The USA was created by 13 separate, sovereign states deciding to cede a certain amount of sovereignty to a central government.

Not really, they were 13 British colonies. They weren’t individually sovereign states because they all had only one sovereign, the King of England and only one government, British Parliament.

Almost. The Govt. was not parliament but the King's ministers, at the time dysfunctionally alternating between Tories favoured by the King and without a majority in Parliament, then Whigs with a majority but disliked by the King who would dismiss them, and round and round we went.

The colonies rebelled and declared themselves independent in 1776. This was a de jure claim to Sovereignty on the basis of being a nations. This was not recognised in international law until the Treaty of Paris in 1783, which was the de facto recognition of the USA as a state.

dreamingbohemian · 31/08/2021 20:09

In a lot of ways they are like separate countries, each state has its own taxes, election rules, school curriculum, all sorts of things. The governor of each state has a lot of power.

And culturally it sometimes feels like several countries within one country, for example the East Coast and the Bible Belt are radically different places. As an East Coaster, I feel more at home in the UK than in the Bible Belt.

PlanDeRaccordement · 31/08/2021 20:02

The USA was created by 13 separate, sovereign states deciding to cede a certain amount of sovereignty to a central government.

Not really, they were 13 British colonies. They weren’t individually sovereign states because they all had only one sovereign, the King of England and only one government, British Parliament.

PlanDeRaccordement · 31/08/2021 19:59

No, not in my experience. Admittedly only lived there a few years and travelled around to several states. There seem to be regional cultural differences (East Coast vs Southwest vs Deep South, etc), but overall there is a distinct “American” culture and everywhere you go it’s all the same chain shops, and attitudes.

Different countries usually have different languages and cultures. So the US to me is diverse certainly, but not 50 seperate countries, it is all one common country.

Jaysmith71 · 31/08/2021 19:54

The USA is a federal republic, but so is Germany, and Germans wouldn't call another lander another country (except maybe Bavaria?)

There are states, territories with a government, and nations, people with a common sense of identity. The USA is notoriously 50 states in One Nation. The UK is four nations in one state, and one of those nations, Ireland, is one nation in two states.

EKGEMS · 31/08/2021 19:21

@everythingishandy They cover international stories on the national news but I'd say it's 75% US news 25% international stories unless something huge is going on like war or natural disaster-newspapers have sections devoted to international news.

MadameMinimes · 31/08/2021 19:04

@SuperLoudPoppingAction

It's tricky to use that analogy as for eg Scottish people often feel Scotland is definitely a country rather than a state (I'm Scottish fwiw) but in a practical sense it is similar - some issues are devolved and some are national. Each state has a senate and they also send representatives to the national houses/whatever they are called. I used to know a lot more about this.

The us government has lots of Web pages on this kind of thing. I'm sure they will have one on this.

This is a pretty good summary but in the USA powers are not devolved. The UK is a unitary state, where sovereignty lays with central government. Our government have devolved certain aspects of government to the Scottish parliament, Welsh Assembly etc.

The USA was created by 13 separate, sovereign states deciding to cede a certain amount of sovereignty to a central government. Powers aren’t devolved to the states, they were surrendered voluntarily to the federal government with the constitution acting as a sort of “contract”.

That might sound like a matter of semantics, but it really helps to make sense of why the systems and attitudes to central government are so different.

everythingishandy · 31/08/2021 18:52

In other word if the news event doesn't involve the US in some way people aren't bothered

OP posts:
everythingishandy · 31/08/2021 18:50

Is it true as well that in the US that there is less international news shown by the media and is more US focused?

OP posts:
Jaysmith71 · 31/08/2021 17:32

Unlike other Western democracies, people in the USA have no concept of their country as a state. They have the states, which make up 'The 'states,' and there is 'One Nation,' and 'The Government' (Boo, hiss etc,) but there's very little in the way of nationwide public institutions beyond the Post Office and the military.