Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to move to NYC?

107 replies

geraniem · 31/08/2021 15:58

We have been offered a move to NYC from london with DH job. he works in tech in a fairly niche/desirable skillset and the rest of his team are based there, so it hasn't come as a surprise, but they are pretty keen for us to go over, and we have been given an "emergency" appt to get visas sorted out. on paper it looks great, we have scrutinised the health insurance which looks excellent (biggest thing for me!), there's a decent relocation grant, first couple months accommodation paid, and DH would have a small salary increase which i suspect is to reflect the cost of living in NYC. also, according to the relocation package i would have a visa enabling me to work over there - i work in corporate admin and have some decent transferable skills. we've both been in london since before we met and we feel we have "done" it, we'd be otherwise looking to move out of our area if not out of london completely. also, people keep telling us how lucky we are and how amazing NYC is!

however. covid is worsening over there, and a lot of things about the US bother me (politics, healthcare, racism, gun laws etc). NYC looks mega expensive even compared to london prices, particularly rent. also -- we finally have a decent house deposit saved to buy our first home, a lot of family live within 2 hours drive/train of us, and dd is happy at school with friends she's known since babyhood. i've been at my company for a few years and am comfortable with the work and pay plus i can now work from home as much as i want, and i'm also just slightly anxious about starting over in a new country as an adult. i studied in the US for a couple of months when i was younger and we have some friends and family in different places over there, but otherwise our only experience is holidays, and it just feels huge and daunting. DH is super excited but i'm the pragmatic one. also, i lived abroad on another continent as a kid and look back on it with fond memories, though we returned to the uk permanently when i was about 9 and i do remember it feeling a bit strange not knowing all the cultural references etc (this was pre netflix/internet!). i settled in, but i never really felt like i "fit in" until probably university, though that could have been entirely my fault!

would you do it? we would be looking at early spring next year, so not during the tough (covid) winter.

any thoughts from anyone who has lived in NYC/the US, any americans, british expats, anyone really!? i don't want to rain on DH parade at all but its getting "real" now and i honestly dont want to be over influenced by people i know, who just love NYC from having had a great holiday there!

OP posts:
BritInUS1 · 31/08/2021 17:28

We just moved back to the UK from West Coast - I know the prices are similar and they are massively expensive over there - everything costs a fortune

To give you an idea, when we moved back to the UK, my H retained his job but was put on the UK equivalent, which was about a 40% decrease

sarahb083 · 31/08/2021 17:17

I'm an American who's lived in London for 7 years. Not from NY but east coast. I'd say it depends what you enjoy doing in your spare time and what your husband's salary will be. Where do you live in London and what do you enjoy about it? Have you looked at what you could afford to rent - that may make you feel strongly one way or the other.

You mention racism - I believe it's much worse in the US. My husband is mixed race and felt very uncomfortable in the US. There is much more inequality as well.

TheyWentToSeaInASieve · 31/08/2021 17:16

NJ has some of the best state schools -- something to consider.

Delatron · 31/08/2021 17:13

It’s eye wateringly expensive. I got used to paying the equivalent of about £6 for a packet of butter for example.
I think we went at the wrong time too. I love hot weather but the humidity and heat in August was something else. There is air con everywhere but I still found it stiffling.

The school system also put me off.

All I’m saying is do your research. To many it seems like an absolute dream living in NYC. The reality can be different.

fairlygoodmother · 31/08/2021 17:09

I moved from London to NYC ten years ago.

Culturally, I initially thought I didn't fit in but NYC is so full of people from all over US and the world, I realised very few people do.

If your husband has an L1 visa you will have L2 which does entitle you to work, but you still have to apply for a work permit so it won't be instant. Bear in mind that the L1 visa ties you to that one company. Check what would happen if he ever lost his job.

There are all kinds of tax implications to everything you do - lots (millions) of people live in New Jersey or Connecticut and work in New York, it doesn't mean you will pay more tax necessarily you will just have to file more tax returns. My husband travels for work quite a bit and ends up paying tiny amounts of tax in several states.

It's been great fun but living in Manhattan is MASSIVELY expensive.
If I were choosing again, I would live in the Westchester suburbs and commute. The public school system is straightforward and well funded and the commute is manageable. We have a lot of friends living in Jersey City and the commute always seems a lot more complicated than it's supposed to be. Public schools in NYC are very variable, there are excellent ones but it's a lot to navigate. Private costs $50,000/year at least.

Covid in the US is worsening but it's very regional. NY state has fewer cases than the UK by quite a bit and it doesn't feel scary here. New York Times website has excellent resources for more info.

Overall, it's an adventure but there are definitely risks. My children love it but they also still identify strongly as British and are thinking about returning to the UK for university.

feel free to PM me if you want any specific questions answered.

AllAroundTheWorldYeah · 31/08/2021 16:58

Are you planning to have another DC? There's no way I'd have a baby in the US! It costs a fortune and then no maternity leave!

ToykotoLosAngeles · 31/08/2021 16:54

I'm probably a lone voice saying no! Mainly because of how close you are to buying a place, the DC being settled with friends, the "small" salary increase and the horrible culture shock I experienced when I lived abroad for a year. Never thought I'd cry over Cadbury's chocolate...

Brighterblighter · 31/08/2021 16:52

Op I'd go but if dh suddenly had this offer I'm not sure what I'd do as I love my job and dd is in a great secondary.

If your dd is so young still... It's probably your last opportunity to move without massively changing her life.. (and move back)

geraniem · 31/08/2021 16:52

thats interesting delatron-- we already live in a fairly small, definitely overpriced apartment in london so we wouldn't be downsizing really or missing out on countryside. i guess thats one of the things in NY's favour, we havent put down "roots" anywhere nice in the UK yet, and if anything quality of life will be about the same. though i did have a hunch that NY is more expensive to live.

thanks so much to everyone for all the info so far, it's definitely reminded me to push for what i want/need!

OP posts:
gwenneh · 31/08/2021 16:50

@geraniem

no, the package doesn't include school fees.
That would be a deal breaker for me. US schooling is not equivalent at any point (it starts at a later age so there's a year or two difference), and the older the DC get the more obvious this becomes.
Stillfunny · 31/08/2021 16:49

Sorry MrsSmith2020. Just cant help myself !

Delatron · 31/08/2021 16:49

If you do it push for a very decent package with return flights.

gwenneh · 31/08/2021 16:48

i had the impression that living in NJ and working in NY (as DH would be at least) creates tax implications?

It does. You get double taxed and then wind up claiming a portion of it back. There is also a city tax for NYC.

do you think COL is high then in every respect- food, petrol, things to do, clothing etc?

COL is far, far higher than London. Food is the real sticker-shock item. Petrol is cheaper, clothing more or less the same.

I'm a dual national so prior to covid we went back and forth, depending on where the jobs were, fairly frequently. The salaries in the US were higher for the most part; once you get above a certain level in management or to executive level they even out.

Delatron · 31/08/2021 16:48

We were offered the same opportunity. I did lots of research and we turned it down.
We did a trial 5 weeks one summer and I hated it. I was so unhappy (previously loved NY).
I found our apartment claustrophobic and dark (was still an expensive apartment in a nice area). I missed the countryside and space we have here. I found it so expensive and the people unfriendly and rude. We were right in Manhattan though so maybe it would be different if you were further out.

I will say DH loved it and so did the kids. But of course he loved walking to his air con Soho office instead of commuting hours to Slough! Just make sure the move is right for you and not just DH.

Stillfunny · 31/08/2021 16:48

Long Island City is quite up and coming now. Also Jersey City is cheap to live. But if you want to take advantage of living in NYC , factor in time and travel costs. No point in living in a nice house in the burbs if you are bored shitless ! Can you tell that I am really pushing you to live in the city or nearby ? Can your DH reach out to his work colleagues for info too ? Most Americans are very obliging like this.

geraniem · 31/08/2021 16:46

no, the package doesn't include school fees.

OP posts:
MrsSmith2020 · 31/08/2021 16:45

@Stillfunny

Dont go to NJ. That is like going to live in London but ending up in Nothampton.! There is lower sales tax in NJ , so it is OK for a shopping trip. If you live near his work or in the city , dont even bother with a car .If you want one, hire it. There are also lots of free stuff to do in NYC .
Completely disagree. Google maps Weehawken, Hoboken, etc. It's literally on the banks of the Hudson, NYC views and Statue of Liberty (if you're high enough) and it's minutes on the water bus.
Lunificent · 31/08/2021 16:43

Does the package include school fees?

Dressingdown1 · 31/08/2021 16:42

I think you need to consider how the move would work for you, not just for DH. Can you find a job which is equivalent in terms of money and working hours to your existing job? What if you get out there and are not happy, but DH isn't prepared to move back to UK? You might be stranded out there anyway if he won't agree to you returning here with DD.. lots of different angles to consider!

amusedbush · 31/08/2021 16:35

Oh, I also recently saw someone recommend looking at Long Island City for cheaper rent with easy access to NYC. I visited LIC for a specific restaurant during my last trip and it was easy peasy to get there and back.

amusedbush · 31/08/2021 16:33

I would go in a heartbeat. I love New York with every fibre of my being and if someone gave me a decent package to live and work over there, I'd bite their hand off!

I know someone who lives in Weehawken, NJ and commutes but I don't know anything about the tax implication you mention above. As others have said, the rent is extortionate in Manhattan and parts of Brooklyn but the subway links are great so it would be easy to commute if you lived further out.

I hope it works out for you, I'm seething with jealousy in here a cold, grey Glasgow Grin

VickyEadieofThigh · 31/08/2021 16:31

The "small" salary increase worries me, I have to say - the cost of living in NYC is, as you say, greater even than London. What you don't want to have to do is dip into your savings for a deposit and you need to be able to keep saving for when you return, as it's unlikely the cost of a house will have dropped while you're away.

Reading about how flexible your current job is for you, remember that conditions of service in American firms are significantly worse than they are here - holiday entitlement, for example, is very poor.

Stillfunny · 31/08/2021 16:30

If it is a tech company, they may even have a realtor connected for HR purposes .

DynamoKev · 31/08/2021 16:29

YANBU.

Stillfunny · 31/08/2021 16:28

Dont go to NJ. That is like going to live in London but ending up in Nothampton.! There is lower sales tax in NJ , so it is OK for a shopping trip. If you live near his work or in the city , dont even bother with a car .If you want one, hire it.

There are also lots of free stuff to do in NYC .

Swipe left for the next trending thread