Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to move to NYC?

107 replies

geraniem · 31/08/2021 15:58

We have been offered a move to NYC from london with DH job. he works in tech in a fairly niche/desirable skillset and the rest of his team are based there, so it hasn't come as a surprise, but they are pretty keen for us to go over, and we have been given an "emergency" appt to get visas sorted out. on paper it looks great, we have scrutinised the health insurance which looks excellent (biggest thing for me!), there's a decent relocation grant, first couple months accommodation paid, and DH would have a small salary increase which i suspect is to reflect the cost of living in NYC. also, according to the relocation package i would have a visa enabling me to work over there - i work in corporate admin and have some decent transferable skills. we've both been in london since before we met and we feel we have "done" it, we'd be otherwise looking to move out of our area if not out of london completely. also, people keep telling us how lucky we are and how amazing NYC is!

however. covid is worsening over there, and a lot of things about the US bother me (politics, healthcare, racism, gun laws etc). NYC looks mega expensive even compared to london prices, particularly rent. also -- we finally have a decent house deposit saved to buy our first home, a lot of family live within 2 hours drive/train of us, and dd is happy at school with friends she's known since babyhood. i've been at my company for a few years and am comfortable with the work and pay plus i can now work from home as much as i want, and i'm also just slightly anxious about starting over in a new country as an adult. i studied in the US for a couple of months when i was younger and we have some friends and family in different places over there, but otherwise our only experience is holidays, and it just feels huge and daunting. DH is super excited but i'm the pragmatic one. also, i lived abroad on another continent as a kid and look back on it with fond memories, though we returned to the uk permanently when i was about 9 and i do remember it feeling a bit strange not knowing all the cultural references etc (this was pre netflix/internet!). i settled in, but i never really felt like i "fit in" until probably university, though that could have been entirely my fault!

would you do it? we would be looking at early spring next year, so not during the tough (covid) winter.

any thoughts from anyone who has lived in NYC/the US, any americans, british expats, anyone really!? i don't want to rain on DH parade at all but its getting "real" now and i honestly dont want to be over influenced by people i know, who just love NYC from having had a great holiday there!

OP posts:
Bedsheets4knickers · 01/09/2021 06:35

I would go for it , I would buy a property in the uk and rent it out . Gives you options and pays your mortgage .

Stillfunny · 01/09/2021 06:34

@@pleasekeeptotheright. We shall have to agree to disagree . Still think to go to NY and live in NJ suburbs would be a shame. But then I ❤ NY. Grin

Maskless · 01/09/2021 05:59

Just to add, it will delay your getting your own house by however many years you are out there.

When you come back you will be in exactly the position you are in now. Just 5 years older.

The reason the company is making the package attractive is because they know they have to entice people to go and that it will take more than just a job offer.

The crime rates are so high there you could never let DD out of your sight. Her freedom would have to be much more restricted than living here.

Just my 2p,

Veronika13 · 01/09/2021 05:59

You'll get used to pieces. I'll never forget my shock at $19.50 John Frieda blonde shampoo - I paid £3.5 in England.

$20 for a kilo of parsnips 😳
But of course I got used to it and don't bat an eyelid now. So don't compare prices (only if it's to make sure you've enough to live comfortably)

Balonzette · 01/09/2021 05:58

I'd do it! I'm an expat and I love this life as home will always be there, but you won't always have amazing opportunities! When you're an expat, everything feels like an experience - even a shitty day is an interesting experience, a funny story, etc. I plan on living in as many places as possible and NYC would DEFINITELY be on my list! What an exciting opportunity!

Veronika13 · 01/09/2021 05:56

I've emigrated twice in my life.

I'd go. You can always come back.

If you don't go, you'll always wonder and maybe even regret. Plus, your DH would regret it too.

Maskless · 01/09/2021 05:55

sorry I meant "could live in NYC?"
"

Maskless · 01/09/2021 05:54

I honestly can't see what you would gain from such a massive upheaval.

Had DH not received this offer, would there ever have been a time when you'd be wistfully wishing you could love in NYC?

It's a great place for a holiday, sure, but that's competely different from the day to day atmosphere once the initial excitement and 'glamour' has worn off.

I absolutely would not do it, ESPECIALLY as you have a DD. And especially as she has far more to lose than she would gain being there during her late-primary years.

If it was for 3 to 6 months I would say grab it with both hands. But not 5 years.

I can see that it's tempting, but please, don't do it. Because you'll hate it.

gofg · 01/09/2021 05:34

I would be off like a shot - it's a wonderful opportunity.

Pleasekeeptotheright · 01/09/2021 05:27

@Stillfunny all of that is irrelevant to the OP though isn't it? Advising her that NJ is the equivalent of Northampton is one of the most inaccurate and misleading comments on this whole thread. That might make it somewhat tricky for her.

Everyone agrees that he should be pushing for a better package. Nobody said otherwise.

ThePriceOfSugar · 01/09/2021 05:08

Do it!! I moved to NYC from New Zealand and love it. Manhattan is the most partisan county in the US (91% for Biden). Living here is much better than visiting. Take advantage of the H4 or whatever spousal visa offer! Working visas are so hard to get and yours won't tie you to an employer. Exciting!

knitnerd90 · 01/09/2021 03:30

It isn't double taxes. You file in NYS, and they take your state taxes out at source. You will not pay city income tax.

Then you file in NJ, and New Jersey credits your NYS tax paid. The wrinkle is that it isn't a perfect dollar for dollar credit so you might still owe New Jersey, but it will not be anywhere near double. If it were double there wouldn't be nearly so many people commuting from NJ to NY.

It is worth mentioning that NYC work culture is particularly driven, especially if your DH is at all connected to the finance industry. (Lawyers also. Everything is about billable hours, but this is true everywhere in big US law firms.) Not everywhere in the US is that bad, but many jobs in NYC are definitely into long hours culture, so I would try to find out more about the job, as well as the salary.

I think NYC is a great experience but it is simply setting yourself up for misery to go there from abroad on a poor package. Quite aside from it being an expensive city, when you're an expat you need that money to smooth things out.

Gemma2019 · 01/09/2021 02:16

I lived and worked there for a couple of years in midtown Manhattan before I had kids. It was a great experience but I was pleased to come home again. I had thought that my UK law firm were slave drivers but the NYC office was another level. I found it difficult surviving on so little annual leave too. I'm glad I did it but wouldn't rush to return.

movinghelprequired · 01/09/2021 02:08

Sounds like a fab opportunity and I'd say go but I'd also push for a greater salary increase.
In my experience there are lots of extra costs living in the us. My impression is that friends of mine with a comparable lifestyle in USA earn much more than I do in the uk.
As pp said you MUST check insurance fine print on things like deductibles. Cost of prescriptions etc. these things can be very hella expensive.

MrsJemimaDuck · 01/09/2021 01:59

I’m an American, and I’ve lived in both NYC and London. If I were you, I wouldn’t do it, unless the salary is frankly double. NYC is so much more expensive, and living in NJ or CT, would mean double taxes. There is a lot to love about New York—but it’s difficult to do with children. Private schools are breathtakingly expensive, and the public school system is difficult to navigate and involves living in the “right” place. Some of the suburbs other posters have suggested are great for young professionals—not for families with children in school. If you do want to have another child...I have what is considered to be amazing insurance in the US...I had a baby a few months ago. It’s cost me about $4,000 so far, and I am still getting bills.

If you’re getting paid enough, it could be worth the experience. But don’t underestimate how much money you need to live there.

SherryPalmer · 01/09/2021 01:43

We’ve done a stint in the US with DH’s job. I also think the package doesn’t sound great. Sounds like he’s getting a U.K. level salary still but none of the “expat” perks (free housing, free schooling, flights home etc).

Also, if you are on a L2 visa, whilst you are technically allowed to work there are a lot of hoops to jump through.

Stillfunny · 01/09/2021 01:34

@pleasekeeptotheright . Yes , I have been .To both .Moved from NYC to UK . Told Northampton was 1 hour by train to London. No idea of the outrageous train service prices in UK until then.
I have lived in Manhattan and Brooklyn for years. Like London , different neighbourhoods have different vibes. And prices.
I thought OP DD was a preschooler ? And it was a contract move rather than long term plan.

If the DH has a niche tech skill , if the company want him enough , he should try to negotiate a package to cover all the extra costs involved .
Like everything else , there are always reasons for doing or not doing something. All these different opinions makes one realise how individual everyone's expectations and comfort zones are.
Personally , I felt this negatively about London. I found it so expensive and no value for that money. The service industry , pricing in restaurants , cost of rentals , transport just didn't deliver for me .

Hope all these different opinions haven't made it even more conflicting for you OP .Flowers

MrsEricBana · 01/09/2021 01:20

I can't give a detailed answer as my experience is some years ago but we had the opportunity to do this when kids were younger. I didn't want to go even though I knew it was a great opportunity etc etc BUT we did go and it was 100% amazing and none of us will ever forget it. I say find a way to make it work!

Foldinthecheese · 01/09/2021 01:12

As I mentioned previously, we moved to upstate NY in April. Obviously, our experience is very different to what yours would be in NYC, but there are some similar elements.
As mentioned, the cost of living is high. Food is expensive, and property taxes in NY are high and make a big difference to your overall housing costs. There are also little things you might not initially consider. The climate is much more extreme, so we’re having to shell out more for proper winter gear for us all, which isn’t cheap! You also need to provide all school supplies.
Childcare is very expensive and, particularly at the moment, hard to come by. If you do decide to go and you require childcare, I would get registered as soon as possible.
We have two 5yos and a 2.5yo and the move has definitely been harder on the twins than I expected. Particularly with covid, it has been difficult to establish the same sort of community we had in England. I’m hoping that the return to school will help them to feel more settled as they get to know more people, but you shouldn’t underestimate the enormity of such a move.

fiveminutebreak · 01/09/2021 01:09

Not read all the posts but you mention your DH getting a small salary increase... unless he's on mega bucks now you really need to push for more. Living expenses in much of the US can be very high, much more than London. Quality of schooling can vary widely and you need to research best school districts and then find somewhere to live in that area. Depending on age of your DD, you also need to think about transition. Once they finish elementary school at 11, they go on to middle school which is a much more generalised education than in the UK. So not much cross over.

Having said all that, it could be an amazing experience and NYC is an exciting place to be. But obviously Covid is still a problem in much of the US though most people are living relatively normal lives with only a few restrictions like mask wearing.

Notdoingthis · 01/09/2021 00:19

No I wouldn't. I visited and it is very noisy all the time. My best friend lives there and loves it but I couldn't.

hangryeyes · 31/08/2021 23:57

For an NYC tech salary, I would expect it to be at least 40-60% more than a London salary to achieve a similar standard of living. As others have said the cost of living is higher- particularly to eat like you likely do in the UK, I always found fresh food less accessible/more expensive than here. Also I know from my colleagues’ experience that childcare is more expensive in comparison to the UK.

user1471439310 · 31/08/2021 23:03

I live in the US and would never live there.

HazelBite · 31/08/2021 22:57

OP I am deeply jealous, it is such a fantastic city, what an opportunity.
(New York and London are my favourite cities
Just go with your heart, you will only regret opportunities missed.

BeenThruMoreThanALilBit · 31/08/2021 22:35

I moved to NYC from London 10 years ago. There’s a lot of exaggeration on this thread, I think.

If you’re ready to leave central London and move to the country, closer to family, a smaller community, more time at home etc, this move is not for you.

To make NYC work, you have to want it to work. Otherwise you will find fault with everything because there is a lot to fault. If you do want it to work, it will be no more expensive than London (for overall cost of life as a family), perhaps even cheaper, and could be a truly life-enhancing experience.

If you’re middling about it, at least come with an open mind.

Swipe left for the next trending thread