Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Housing Eviction

187 replies

WaferThinIce · 31/08/2021 14:51

I realise this isn't the right place but am hoping to get some information or guidance as soon as possible. Friends (genuinely friends and not me) have been given an eviction notice as their landlord is selling their home. They, so far, haven't been able to find other suitable accommodation. They either can't afford it or they miss out because they come second. It's a family of three adults, parent and 2 children, and one older teenager, plus dog. As the end of their notice period comes ever closer and they still haven't secured a place they are getting very worried and stressed. Does anyone know what they can do if they haven't found another home. Will they be turned out onto the street or what might happen? Will there be an obligation on the local council to offer them temporary accommodation. They have looked not just where they currently live but also nearby towns and there's just nothing available.
Thank you

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
stuarttipo · 14/09/2021 12:44

Thats the problem renting a home to someone should come with obligations and the law allows a pathetic two months to up sticks, find a place to move too and all the costs to move, its not good enough just saying its their house, yes it is but its also someone elses home

stuarttipo · 14/09/2021 12:41

Tell them to lie, tell them they have two kids and no pets, then just move them all in if they look after it ish most letting agents dont care just make sure the dog and all other humans arnt their on inspection day

stuarttipo · 14/09/2021 12:38

Tell them not to mention the dog, yes just lie, as it happens in law the landlord shouldnt refuse them in any case to have a pet , worse case after the contract ends he could issue a section 21, tell them to puish for a one year rental and ideally a 2 year rental contract, but unlikey, if id have told all my x landlords id had a dog id have been homeless, also tell them not to mention the older child, landlords are tight and prefer small familes less wear and tare, often paying more rent up front helps but be careful of the letting agent if they go bust

stuarttipo · 14/09/2021 12:34

It should be illegal to descriminate against dog owners for a start, best they just lie and dont mention the dog

stuarttipo · 14/09/2021 12:31

Wow you must be a landlord, I can sniff them out, its rediclous that someone has just two months to find a place & no im sorry if they cant find a place the law should allow them to stay much much longer and no I dont care why they want it back

HarrietsChariot · 02/09/2021 15:39

If the landlord didn't pay the mortgage and the property was repossessed, the new owner (presumably the bank) would have the same responsibilities to the tenants as the old landlord did. This would also be the case if the bank then sold it on to another person, they would have the responsibilities.

However - if the property is repossessed or sold, the new owner can apply for a court order to dispense with the need to serve notice on the tenants. Effectively they would be at the stage of reaching the final day of their tenancy, but without having had a notice period. They would then have to follow the standard procedure, go to court because they haven't left, go to court again because they ignored the order, get the bailiffs in.

It would take the same amount of time as with a normal termination of tenancy, the only exception is the tenant wouldn't be told in advance their tenancy was due to end on a certain date.

Journeyofthedragons · 02/09/2021 13:51

In my experience a lot of landlords aren't professional landlords at all and don't understand their obligations

This is the crazy bit because in a sense all landlords are professional landlords and as with starting any business due dilligence should be undertaken thoroughly - failiure to prepare is preparing to fail.

Luobogao · 02/09/2021 13:46

@LoislovesStewie, I suspect we actually broadly agree with each other, just different angles.

I am by no means a professional landlord - I'm a landlord by circumstances (and that's a choice, I could have sold) - but honestly I find not being a shit is a pretty good way to stay on the right side of the law. It's honestly not that complicated to get right.

Idontknowwhat2 · 02/09/2021 12:31

It sounds like the dog is the problem, as three adults should be able to earn enough to pay the rent on another house. Pets being a problem in rentals is the government's fault as they stopped landlords being able to cover their risks with more deposit. I dont have a dog and haven't had this problem (full time working single parent).

Could they rehome the dog? It seems stressful and unfair to them and the LL to drag it all out through the courts.

LoislovesStewie · 02/09/2021 12:14

As I said, I would be in favour of bringing back protected tenancies so that tenants had more rights. When tenants had protected tenancies homeless officers saw far fewer people presenting as homeless because the landlord wanted the property back. The grounds for possession were, mostly, if the tenant had broken a condition of the tenancy. From memory there were a couple of odd conditions; if the landlord was a missionary or priest he could be awarded possession if it was his only home.
In my experience a lot of landlords aren't professional landlords at all and don't understand their obligations.
BTW, when I started as a homeless officer protected tenancies were all that was offered.

Luobogao · 02/09/2021 12:06

Well private tenants actually are treated worse in a lot of ways, mainly because they have less secure tenancies.

But you seem to be missing my point, at no point have I said that private tenants should be treated worse. I'm saying (pretty clearly I thought) that they shouldn't have to wait for eviction to qualify for council support. We shouldn't be putting families through that trauma and the courts shouldn't have to be dealing with it.

For what it's worth, I've had to 'evict' tenants twice. On both occasions they went voluntarily on/before the notice date. The second time they really shouldn't have done as although they had rent arrears, they had an argument to make that the rent arrears weren't their 'fault' (delays in benefit payments) and so they may have given up their entitlement to council support as a result and it would have been because they didn't know (they wouldn't communicate or I would have told them).

sirfredfredgeorge · 02/09/2021 11:55

If the LL stopped paying the mortgage, I bet the tenants would be evicted far sooner than if they LL continued to lay the mortgage….

Unlikely the bank would just repossess the property and then auction the property off with tenants, they have no reason to go through the expense, delay and hassle of evicting the tenants, they won't get as good a price of course which means they'll still be seeking more from the landlord, but it's rare for these hobby incompetent landlords to not have other money they can recover the deficit from.

LoislovesStewie · 02/09/2021 11:48

And the tenancy only ends when a PO is issued; why should private tenants be treated worse than other tenants?

Luobogao · 02/09/2021 11:46

@LoislovesStewie

Because, usually, an applicant has to be threatened with homelessness with 28 days, legally they are only threatened when the court issues the PO as per my previous comments.
And that is what I'm saying is wrong. Plus the fact that leaving before that date (but after the notice date) is considered making yourself 'intentionally homeless' which means you're completely screwed if you didn't know that and just follow what the notice says.

We need to fund councils better so that they are able to provide support earlier. The current system is to no one's advantage (except I suppose lawyers!). Tax landlords. I'm an overseas landlord and I currently pay no tax at all (annual rent is too low to trigger any tax). That is wrong.

TableFlowerss · 02/09/2021 11:34

pay

TableFlowerss · 02/09/2021 11:34

@clarkkentsglasses

Just out of interest, what happens if LL doesn't pay the mortgage? Who then evicts the tenant?
If the LL stopped paying the mortgage, I bet the tenants would be evicted far sooner than if they LL continued to lay the mortgage….
LoislovesStewie · 02/09/2021 11:32

Because, usually, an applicant has to be threatened with homelessness with 28 days, legally they are only threatened when the court issues the PO as per my previous comments.

Luobogao · 02/09/2021 11:30

Where have I suggested tenants aren't entitled to due process? I am talking about eligibility for council support. That should not require a tenant to have had to go through the full eviction process. That's not fair on the tenant or the court system.

More generally, there will always have to be checks and balances to protect tenants. One major underlying issue is that private tenants should have more security. My tenants have been in my property for five years. It is rediculous that (until Covid) I only had to give them two months' notice. 4 months also isn't long enough - it should be 6. The solution to that not being long enough shouldn't be that they desperately hang on to the absolute last not knowing from court hearing to court hearing how long they have. It should be that the landlord has to give a long enough notice period that the tenant can realistically find another option in that time.

Practically, there will always have to be a court process involved if tenants refuse to leave (again - landlords should not be able to send someone in to drag people out) but the number of tenancies going through that process should be reduced as much as possible by making the actual law more tenant friendly.

LoislovesStewie · 02/09/2021 10:59

Because any tenant is entitled to due process of law. I have dealt with many tenants where the landlord hasn't issued a correct notice, doesn't think he needs to and thinks he can just tell the tenant to leave I've met landlords who issue notice 'just in case' they might want to repossess the property; issue the notice on the day the tenancy starts or issue a notice that ends before the end of the tenancy. As I said earlier tenants are entitled to due process, would you think that a tenant of a registered social landlord should be evicted without. The law either covers ALL tenants or none. The fact that a particular government decided to do away with protected tenancies and start assured shortholds doesn't do away with the due process in respect of evictions.
The 1977 Act states that;
'it shall not be lawful for the owner to enforce against the occupier, otherwise than by proceedings in the court, his right to recover possession of the premises.'
Which is why landlords have to get a PO and then a bailiff.

Luobogao · 02/09/2021 10:47

Could you clarify, are you saying that because it's illegal for landlords to harass tenants to move out, it's completely fine to set up a process that drags tenants who would like to move on through the courts and a baliff process because otherwise they will be considered intentionally homeless?

I'm not following the relevance of the law reference. I'm not saying the current process doesn't mean that a tenant can stay until eviction, I'm saying that it is rediculous that the courts' time is being wasted because councils want to delay the point their responsibility starts. Courts are also paid for from our taxes! Plus the stress on the tenant. Does an eviction order also impact references for future (private) tenancies?

How is it not better in that situation for the landlord to have to pay for the tenant to get independent legal advice on whether the notice is valid and then the council relies on that to have its obligation start from the date of the notice. Even without changing anything in the current laws, that would mean tenants are formally told (1) if the notice isn't valid and they have grounds to insist on longer, and (2) that they can't be forced to leave before formal eviction so they know they have that option.

LoislovesStewie · 02/09/2021 09:13

I suggest that you read the Protection from Eviction act 1977.

Luobogao · 02/09/2021 09:12

Should not be allowed to waste court time 🤣

Luobogao · 02/09/2021 09:11

I think the process councils put in place to determine who is eligible for housing should be allowed to waste court time and make tenants go through the court and baliff process who would happily just leave but have to wait until eviction because otherwise they will be considered voluntarily homeless.

I also think there should be a far more tenant friendly system that means that cases don't get pushed to court. Absolutely there should be checks and balances in place but rather than say it's two months notice and the tenant can they stay until the baliff is at their door (meaning they don't actually know the day), say landlords have to give six months notice and have a process where tenants are properly supported with how to challenge unlawful notices.

There will still need to be a process for tenants who refuse to leave of course (I'm not suggesting the landlord should be able to send in the heavies) but that process shouldn't be used for tenants who want to comply but can't because the council won't let them.

VanCleefArpels · 02/09/2021 09:07

I can see both sides too - I’m a landlord but also give housing advice to people in the OP’s friend’s situation. I certainly went in to the letting business with eyes wide open! In my opinion the biggest hurdle is the NIMBYs that oppose development of even scrubby bits of unused land relying on outdated notions of green belt and loss of “amenities”. This happens all the time in my area and the only reason is to protect property values.

LoislovesStewie · 02/09/2021 09:04

@Luobogao

As a start with the money being spent on court at the moment? Tax landlords more as well.
Do you think that Housing Associations or Local authority Housing Departments should not have to get possession orders and bailiff's warrants to evict tenants? if not, why?