Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Covid Test for guests?

87 replies

SturminsterNewton · 31/08/2021 09:42

I have a couple of guests for the weekend at the end of September. They are staying with other people before they reach me and also have a wider social/family life than I. I live alone and WFH, so have been quite sheltered since Covid.

AIBU to ask them to do a test before they set off to me, or is that just being over-anxious (and rather inhospitable)?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
cardibach · 02/09/2021 23:08

@Clymene your link actually says this: Because of this relatively low sensitivity, a negative test result cannot guarantee that you aren’t infected – false negatives are reasonably common
While if it says you are positive you almost certainly are, if it says you are negative you could very well be positive. They aren’t worth doing in my view, and anyone doing them every time they meet anyone…I just don’t get it. And I’ve been very covid aware and pro-lockdown.

SoupDragon · 02/09/2021 22:55

Have you ever added anyone to test fir flu/norovirus/ multiple other respiratory viruses? Even during winter 2017/18?

Are there readily available, self-administered tests for those?

Dee1975 · 02/09/2021 22:38

@Aprilx
You do realise that the government/ NHS recommends everyone does a LFT twice a week?

Regular testing is about reducing transmission in the community, in order to help protect public health.

Your comment regarding ‘tax payers paying for someone to do a test to visit a friend’ is (and to quote your words) ‘pretty dumb’.

Whilst we are still in the middle of a public Heath outbreak, it’s sensible to do regular testing.

The tax payer isn’t paying for someone to do a test ‘to visit a friend’. The tax payer is paying for everyone to do regular testing to try and reduce transmission of a major disease that has caused a worldwide pandemic! The cost of a LFT is far cheaper than the cost of someone to stay in hospital ….

Of course a time will come when the world has reached an amount of heard immunity and it can be treated like flu.

ratspeaker · 02/09/2021 17:38

Personally I think its polite to test before visiting.

My DD is a keyworker and tests before coming to stay.
I tested before giving my DC and pals a lift to a holiday , they all did the same

Maybe its more normal in Scotland to do a lateral flow.

millymollymoomoo · 02/09/2021 16:44

I agree with what someone unthread said
Fir how long do you expect this?
It’s not going away
Have you ever added anyone to test fir flu/norovirus/ multiple other respiratory viruses? Even during winter 2017/18?
The tests are not free - they are costing the country millions and millions

If you’re this anxious I don’t think you’re ready for guests. I mean, so they test before, turn up at your house then aren’t allowed out fir the duration? What if they test the morning they are due- it’s negative but then they stop off for petrol/supermarket/etc on the way and could pick it up there…,

Clymene · 02/09/2021 16:19

@MyAnacondaMight

Everyone at my office does them twice weekly. We still get plenty of Covid outbreaks. Plenty of anecdotes about people having negative LFTs throughout their Covid infection.

I’d take one if it made you feel better, but I don’t think it would do anything to protect you.

Why do people always say this? All the research shows they are 95-99% accurate at detecting positive infections. So the anecdotal 'evidence' that is so popular on MN doesn't stack up.

www.gavi.org/vaccineswork/how-likely-positive-lateral-flow-test-covid-19-be-wrong

ThinWomansBrain · 02/09/2021 14:18

sounds a bit OTT - would it give you a degree of assurance if you knew they'd been vacinated?

worriedatthemoment · 02/09/2021 11:38

@Stuffin i have to test twice weekly for work , not nhs , not that anyone checks
When i meet my friend who is undergoing chemotherapy I always do a lvt and so do kids and dh
Yes i know there not fully accurate but better than nothing at all and its a just incase it picks up a positive , then we have done all we can
She is on life long treatment so can't wait for treatment to be over and does know there is still a risk its just one measure we do to help minimise it , even if only a little bit

MyAnacondaMight · 02/09/2021 11:01

Everyone at my office does them twice weekly. We still get plenty of Covid outbreaks. Plenty of anecdotes about people having negative LFTs throughout their Covid infection.

I’d take one if it made you feel better, but I don’t think it would do anything to protect you.

MakeMeCleanTheHouse · 02/09/2021 10:50

I'd happily do it and have done so before seeing family, friends, going to a wedding etc. I've also asked family to do one before staying with me. My DD is a nurse working with Covid patients and always has one or a PCR before staying because my Dad is CEV. It's really not an issue. I wouldn't let people stay who were not vaccinated or unhappy to consider others regarding covid.

SoupDragon · 02/09/2021 10:42

@clarkkentsglasses

I would ditch you as a friend
Lovely.
clarkkentsglasses · 02/09/2021 10:36

I would ditch you as a friend

Aprilx · 02/09/2021 10:36

@Dee1975

Perfectly reasonable and sensible to ask. Posters saying ‘well I wouldn’t visit’ … you really need to get over yourself! It’s a LFT. It’s free. It’s easy to do.

If it makes your host feel more comfortable then why wouldn’t you do it?

Op - As long as you realise they are not 100% effective. But of course are one thing, out of many, you can do to reduce risk.

You are pretty dumb if you think tests are free.

For how long do you think people should be demanding tax payer funded tests before they go to see friends? For the next six weeks, six months, ten years, forever more? And all paid by taxes, really, what increase in your income tax / cut in services would you accept in order to fund this testing before socialising?

OP can ask if she wants, personally if a friend asked me to take a test, I would say no and if that is what they want, I won’t be seeing them again until presumably they are past their health anxiety.

PurpleOkapi · 02/09/2021 07:12

You can try, but honestly? If you're that anxious about possible exposure you should probably just skip the visit. False negatives are very common with rapid tests, and even if they're negative at the time they test, they could still become positive and contagious while visiting.

hibbledibble · 02/09/2021 07:04

A lateral flow or a PCR?

LF is not particularly reliable, with a lot of false negatives.

For PCR tests, unless they are symptomatic or a contact, then this test should be done privately.

Stuffin · 02/09/2021 07:01

Perfectly reasonable and sensible to ask. Posters saying ‘well I wouldn’t visit’ … you really need to get over yourself! It’s a LFT. It’s free. It’s easy to do.

It's not free in the long term as these things are paid for by us all.

And I don't think it is necessary and I am not going to normalise covid testing of healthy people to make someone less anxious. So I think those that want everyone to test whenever they meet should get over themselves Grin

DinosApple · 02/09/2021 06:58

I do them before my parents come over, and before I visit other people, and still do them regularly for work so I wouldn't be offended to be asked. I'd be miffed if you weren't doing one though.

Clymene · 02/09/2021 06:54

I would be perfectly happy to. I totally accept that some people are more anxious. We test regularly anyway so it really is no big deal. My kids tested themselves before going to one another's houses over the summer. It seems to be the polite thing to do in their groups of friends.

waitingpatientlyforspring · 02/09/2021 06:48

I test for work, my DH works from home so doesn't need to test but he still does. On the few times I have gone to stay at someone's house, especially if I've been out and about before then I've done a test. Its polite and makes me feel better.

I don't think its rude to ask a guest to take an LTF, although they are not very accurate they do pick up positive cases.

liveforsummer · 02/09/2021 06:20

Do you have CEV loved ones in your home?

Op doesn't though, and isn't CEV herself.

Personally in these circumstances I'd do it if asked but it would probably change the tone of the holiday and i'd be less relaxed. It all just seems a bit over the top when everyone is healthy (along with washing shopping. Still can't believe that was/is a thing).

Probably best to broach it as 'I was thinking maybe we should all test before meeting' rather than a direct request for the visitors, to make it less like an accusation of them bringing the plague.

Wallywobbles · 02/09/2021 06:05

We've just done a tour of family and friends in the UK. We tested before leaving each place.

icedcoffees · 02/09/2021 06:04

If it makes your host feel more comfortable then why wouldn’t you do it?

Because their comfort is not more important than mine.

They can ask but they can't expect people to agree. I wouldn't even think about asking anyone to test before we met up - it's a very alien concept to me.

If I didn't feel safe I just wouldn't meet. A negative test isn't proof of anything much.

Dee1975 · 02/09/2021 06:01

Perfectly reasonable and sensible to ask. Posters saying ‘well I wouldn’t visit’ … you really need to get over yourself! It’s a LFT. It’s free. It’s easy to do.

If it makes your host feel more comfortable then why wouldn’t you do it?

Op - As long as you realise they are not 100% effective. But of course are one thing, out of many, you can do to reduce risk.

Stuffin · 02/09/2021 05:43

I wouldn't visit. If you were that anxious about covid to need me to test which aren't accurate then I don't think you are ready for visitors.

I am happy to get back to normal and don't want to be around covid anxious people so would give it a miss.

Others on this thread feel happy about testing themselves all the time so you might find a request welcomed instead.

icedcoffees · 02/09/2021 05:31

I don't think YABU to ask but personally I would decline and not visit you.

I've never taken a test and don't intend to start now unless I show symptoms.

Swipe left for the next trending thread