Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who gets the boots?

162 replies

Bootdilemma · 31/08/2021 07:30

About 5 years ago I bought dd2 a pair of long riding boots. She wore them for a couple of years then gave up riding. Dd3 started wearing the boots. She's worn them almost every day for three years. Along with me, she does all the looking after of our two horses. The boots are falling apart, cracked, one has a hole in. But they are "the most comfortable boots in the world" apparently.

Dd2 has a gap year job in a school that has horses. At interview they mentioned she might be able to ride out with the little ones. Dd2 wants to take The Boots, saying they were bought for her originally so they are her boots
Dd3 is livid as she wears The Boots everyday and feels that as she does all the horse stuff at home, she should get The Boots

Neither want a new pair of boots

Help me solve this ridiculous dilemma as both of my normally kind sensible dds have become fixated on the Boots.

YANBU - DD2 TAKES THE BOOTS TO HER GAP YEAR JOB
YABU - DD3 KEEPS THE BOOTS TO WEAR AT HOME EVERYDAY

OP posts:
AttaGirrrrl · 31/08/2021 07:59

I mean, if the neoprene lined pair are causing you a problem, I will happily offer them a loving new home.

Bootdilemma · 31/08/2021 07:58

@AttaGirrrrl

I knew they were going to be Ariats Grin

Is that the problem? Does DD2 want the branded boots and the alternative are not?

Yes probably

I am most definitely not buying dd2 a new pair of ariats

And to make matters worse there's a neoprene lined pair of ariats in the cupboard thst Dd1 won in a competition that NONE of them like!!

OP posts:
leavesthataregreen · 31/08/2021 07:57

@MyOtherProfile

Give them one each Grin
brilliant. Telll DD2 they are not fit for purpose if they have holes in them and she must have new boots for work.
FreeBritnee · 31/08/2021 07:56

If DD3 has been wearing them daily for years then they’ll be moulded for her foot/leg shape now. They are hers. If they are leather they can be mended by the way.

Dontfuckingsaycheese · 31/08/2021 07:56

Also before all this blew up Dd3 did used to sigh happily as she put on The Boots saying how she would still wear them even if they got holes all over.

Ayyy. This is priceless OP. Let her keep the boots Smile. DD3 will be out of the way anyway so you won't have to witness her whingeing!

AttaGirrrrl · 31/08/2021 07:55

I knew they were going to be Ariats Grin

Is that the problem? Does DD2 want the branded boots and the alternative are not?

Whinge · 31/08/2021 07:54

@Sciurus83

They're DD3s boots now, but you have to buy DD2 new ones if she needs them for the job.
OP really doesn't need to buy new ones. There are other boots DD2 could take. Buying new boots would be a waste of money, as she might not even get a chance to ride.
Bootdilemma · 31/08/2021 07:54

@Sciurus83

They're DD3s boots now, but you have to buy DD2 new ones if she needs them for the job.
I have offered her short riding boots and chaps (gaiter type things you wear over your jodhpurs) but she's having none of it
OP posts:
Bootdilemma · 31/08/2021 07:53

Also before all this blew up Dd3 did used to sigh happily as she put on The Boots saying how she would still wear them even if they got holes all over.

Ariat - you certainly make desirable riding boots!

OP posts:
Sciurus83 · 31/08/2021 07:52

They're DD3s boots now, but you have to buy DD2 new ones if she needs them for the job.

Bootdilemma · 31/08/2021 07:51

@Pashazade

I think the original boots definitely belong to DD3. I would point out to DD2 that she is aiming to make things difficult for you and her sister by demanding the boots on the off chance that she might get to ride and she hasn't even been in the job a week. Just say no and if it looks like she's going to ride occasionally then help out with a pair of boots that won't break the bank. If she'd done anything with the horses in the last few years I'd possibly consider otherwise but they obviously aren't a priority for her just a nice perk so she doesn't get to dictate! Good luck!
Thank you! She is lovely and helps a lot around the house but hasn't been near the horses in years so I'm definitely starting to agree with you
OP posts:
Bootdilemma · 31/08/2021 07:50

@Crabbitcrab

Did she give the boots to her sister or did dd3 just take them? If she gave them away then dd3 keeps them but if dd3 just took them she has to give them back
I would imagine they sat for a while in the boot cupboard going spidery then I fished them out and gave them to Dd3
OP posts:
Pashazade · 31/08/2021 07:49

I think the original boots definitely belong to DD3. I would point out to DD2 that she is aiming to make things difficult for you and her sister by demanding the boots on the off chance that she might get to ride and she hasn't even been in the job a week. Just say no and if it looks like she's going to ride occasionally then help out with a pair of boots that won't break the bank. If she'd done anything with the horses in the last few years I'd possibly consider otherwise but they obviously aren't a priority for her just a nice perk so she doesn't get to dictate! Good luck!

Whinge · 31/08/2021 07:49

If she might not even get the chance to ride then DD2 should take the shorter boots you've offered and stop being so stubborn. I wouldn't be buying new boots, you offered and she refused.

OhSmellyCatSmellyCat · 31/08/2021 07:49

Dd3 getsto keep them. Dd2 needs to realise she can't dip in and out then expect her own way. She will only want them for a little while compared to Dd3

Crabbitcrab · 31/08/2021 07:48

Did she give the boots to her sister or did dd3 just take them? If she gave them away then dd3 keeps them but if dd3 just took them she has to give them back

Bootdilemma · 31/08/2021 07:47

@Dontfuckingsaycheese

Why did dd3 start using the boots as hers in the first place? Did she just take the boots? She saw they weren't in use so she decided they were rightfully hers as the cheeky little sister (me) did in our house ? Or were they offered to her by dd2 seeing as they were bought for her? Or are their clothes usually seen as communal?
All horse riding stuff in our house is pretty much communal. If someone grows out of something someone else gets it as it's all too expensive to have four sets (I have four dcs 🙄)
OP posts:
chesterelly · 31/08/2021 07:47

New boots for new job. Especially if the old ones are now stretched and will be too big. I think you should pay for them though to minimise any sibling resentment.

Bootdilemma · 31/08/2021 07:45

@LeonardLikesThisPost

It seems obvious to me they belong to dd3 now. On the app so can't vote.

I'd buy dd2 a new pair to show support and she will just have to break them in.

This is what I have finally decided. They are £££ though and the annoying thing is she might not even get to ride!
OP posts:
Bootdilemma · 31/08/2021 07:44

@AttaGirrrrl

They’re DD3’s boots.

Look on eBay for another pair of already broken in ones for DD2?

I've tried this but she's going tomorrow!

I can't believe after all the problems we've had this summer (dh breaking his ankle, Covid, my job looking dodgy) that this is the hill two of my teens are willing to die on

OP posts:
Dontfuckingsaycheese · 31/08/2021 07:44

Why did dd3 start using the boots as hers in the first place? Did she just take the boots? She saw they weren't in use so she decided they were rightfully hers as the cheeky little sister (me) did in our house ? Or were they offered to her by dd2 seeing as they were bought for her? Or are their clothes usually seen as communal?

LeonardLikesThisPost · 31/08/2021 07:44

It seems obvious to me they belong to dd3 now. On the app so can't vote.

I'd buy dd2 a new pair to show support and she will just have to break them in.

BareVanilla · 31/08/2021 07:43

I had a similar issue with cream jacket that I bought, I loved it but didn’t wear it as really it wasn’t the fashion or a good style for me. My young Aunt went into my wardrobe and borrowed it saying I never wear it. In the end I let her have it but when I track the reason for not having an adult relationship with her now it started with the jacket. I need therapy 🤣

LivingLaVidaBabyShower · 31/08/2021 07:43

DD3 should keep them.

But for fun i would "do a king solomon" and give them one boor each to discover who truly loves them. Wink

Fredoftheforest · 31/08/2021 07:42

If DD3 has stretched out the boots over time then they will be uncomfortable for DD2 now.

In any event she (presumably) agreed to them going to her younger sister 3 years ago so she doesn’t get them back now!