Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have a back up school bag?!

93 replies

amiasheep · 31/08/2021 00:11

11 year old son chose a Smiggle bag for school. I suggested it was too young and he looked a bit hurt as he really liked it. So we bought it and I said it was lovely (it is).
I have just now ordered a bog standard black Nike one to tuck away as back up and I'm feeling guilty for not getting on board with individuality etc.

I'm not particularly conventional so not sure why I try to make him "fit it".

(It won't go to waste, I am in need of a new bag for walks etc)

OP posts:
nicky2512 · 31/08/2021 13:49

I would have done exactly the same.
School can be hard enough!

Hankunamatata · 31/08/2021 13:42

We are lucky high school insist on a relatively plain black bag. And junior have their own branded school bags

autummvibes · 31/08/2021 13:19

I wouldn't be allowing a year 7 to go into school with a Smiggle bag. The first year is all about finding your feet. Most children walking in with a bag like that will be ridiculed and wouldn't stand a chance from day one. I couldn't do that to my child.
School politics are shit but it is what it is. Whether we agree with it or not I wouldn't want to make an example of my child, it's not us who has to deal with the next 5 years. You've done the right thing buying a different bag.

DogFoodPie · 31/08/2021 13:10

No need to tell him you bought the other bag just in case his smiggle one didn't fit in. Just say you've heard it's good to keep a spare bag for secondary school.

Kotatsu · 31/08/2021 13:07

(oh, and it's been in use for over a year - skipping the covid break - and is still totally fine this year, so it's not all tat from there)

Kotatsu · 31/08/2021 13:05

really? My 11 year old has a smiggle bag (he always forgets to zip his bags, and they have an opening/structure that means stuff doesn't immediately fall out when he walks with an open bag)

It's got pacman or something on it. No-one's said anything at all.

I would hope that in a school they'd at least make an effort to keep the kids polite and friendly and discourage bullying for something as simple as a schoolbag, but perhaps I'm naive and have just been lucky with my kids' schools.

Glittertwins · 31/08/2021 12:39

@THisbackwithavengeance

My DD is taking an actual large black handbag in as that is apparently what they will all have.

She had earmarked my Ted Baker large satchel but funnily enough, I said no and we have now settled on a particularly cheap and nasty looking Matalan bag that will no doubt last 5 minutes.

If she has a fair distance to walk, it's going to hurt her back to carry it and if it rains, stuff will get wet. I won this particular discussion and it turned out the majority had a backpack style bag anyway.
Willdoitlater · 31/08/2021 12:34

I think he will appreciate that you 'had his back' on this one. Personally, I still remember and resent the times an older, wiser person didn’t step in to stop me or my friends making fools of ourselves. (Or in one case inflicting a bully-magnet briefcase on my best friend!)

BoomChicka · 31/08/2021 12:26

I've had all this with my year 7, it's a fine line between letting them have what they like and not wanting them to stand out too much immediately.. I remember how brutal high school was for some kids, and dd has other issues to contend with so I've steered her towards the mainstream shoes and bag. Don't feel guilty! My mum was oblivious to trends and I had to beg and plead for the "right" stuff, this way is better I think Smile

UserStillatLarge · 31/08/2021 11:34

I wouldn't have bought a back up. If he decides he doesn't want the smiggle bag and you produce another one that you bought just in case, you're basically saying that you'd expected him to "fail". Why not wait for him to decide he doesn't want the bag (if he does) and then get another one?

tiredanddangerous · 31/08/2021 11:33

YANBU. Smiggle bags seem to be very much Year 4 and below in dds primary. I think he'll probably last a day with it unfortunately.

0palescent · 31/08/2021 11:29

I also think you did the right thing. Plain black backpacks seem to be what most boys use at high school here, and a Smiggle one would probably stand out. Your DS might very well be more than happy with his, I hope that's the case, but you've not done any harm having an alternative there too.

knobblykneesandturnedouttoes · 31/08/2021 10:58

It's worth having a spare anyway so if a strap breaks or it gets soaked in the rain, there's a back up available.

But personally I dread the day my daughter takes an interest in smiggle. The same kind of dread as I feel about LOL dolls, poppits, soft play birthday parties etc

THisbackwithavengeance · 31/08/2021 10:58

My DD is taking an actual large black handbag in as that is apparently what they will all have.

She had earmarked my Ted Baker large satchel but funnily enough, I said no and we have now settled on a particularly cheap and nasty looking Matalan bag that will no doubt last 5 minutes.

DogFoodPie · 31/08/2021 10:48

I think it's fine. Hopefully the bag will be fine but a spare bag may come in handy anyway. My dd had a second bag she used for trips and sleepovers.

Boredhimtodeath · 31/08/2021 10:21

This is so sad!

By any chance is the Nike bag bigger? Can you claim he should use that on the first day because he might be given lots to carry and then he might notice other not having smiggle bags?

Also, to reassure you! Lots of kids have smiggle pencil cases/stationary at my school and the others seem jealous of it, including me! I’ve not noticed smiggle bags though.

BikeRunSki · 31/08/2021 10:13

DS’s birthday was 3 days after he moved up (her we go to middle school at Y6). He started school with his old bag, and requested a new one for his birthday! He chose a Hype one, but a more teenage design. He’s still using it, 13 next week.

pecanmix · 31/08/2021 10:03

@MaryTalbot

It’s hard as you want they to do what they want and not go down gender stereotypes etc but not want them bullied either.

I remember my parents handing down uniform from my sister to me and it was horrendous they bought her new uniform and I was called ‘holy Mary’. One awful year I went to get shoes and my parents insisted on the brown shoes as they were cheaper (I was about 12) and I went into school (big posh grammar school) and there was a huge peg area in the girls changing room and you went in and hung your coat etc up and as I went around the corner huge laughs from about 20 years and they all said ‘We all had a bet who was going to turn up in turd shoes and we all thought no one would dare and yet we have a contender for the shit student of the year’ I was known as turd all year. School bullies are awful.
My eldest just doesn’t care and never has and chooses what shoes she wants - etc so recently we looked at girls shoes and she wasn’t interested she sniffed and went to the boys section and chose a pair of them as she has a walk to school and wants sensible shoes. All of her 5 friends have got similar types of shoes - all fine. She can hold her own.

My youngest went from infant to junior for the taster days and took his book bag and he was sad as everyone else had a rucksack - being new we didn’t realise this was the ‘deal’ infants = book bag junior = rucksack and we went immediately that evening to buy one.

I really do think you have done the right thing and it’s great that you have it - useful for pe kit etc anyway!

I always keep a spare rucksack for mine as they always break.

Aw that's awful, that must have been so horrible for you :(
hartwood · 31/08/2021 10:01

I would have done the same. As someone who had unconventional parents your son may well thank you one day. I still cringe at my mum presenting me with a hiking backpack she had dragged out of the loft for my first day in year 7.

Marmelace · 31/08/2021 09:55

You are a great mum, don't second guess your decision. I'm thinking back to my carrier bag now, it was the 80s though 😆

zingally · 31/08/2021 09:50

I think that's very sensible.

I'm a primary school teacher, and would very much see Smiggle as something the younger junior school ages like... ages 7-9.

Whatwouldscullydo · 31/08/2021 09:43

I wouldn't worry about it on a " piss taking " basis. The "right bag" does not deter anyone from being a dick.

But they do have lot of walking around to do and lockers seem to be on a first come.first served here's 20 quid basis.

The bags take a battering Hmm

amiasheep · 31/08/2021 09:38

I'm a bit surprised at the quality comments as my children have had Smiggle bags last a couple of years, although they don't get much use I guess.

Secondary school does sound brutal!! DS has a number of physical health issues that mean he has developed pretty good resilience, and is used to being a bit different. Primary school is such a nice homely environment though.

OP posts:
exLtEveDallas · 31/08/2021 09:29

My DD rang me from the toilets at about 11am on her first day of Year 7 (when only Year 7 and Year 10 were in school) because she’d been given grief about her school PE bag. I met her at lunchtime and swapped her black with a pink strap messenger bag for a plain black drawstring bag. Year 7 can be brutal.

JudgeRindersMinder · 31/08/2021 09:29

@amiasheep

I am glad this seems sensible, I thought I was being over the top or shallow. It's difficult letting them work stuff out for themselves at times.
It’s not OTT or shallow, it’s the best of both worlds, if it turns out he feels he’s made the “wrong” choice, you’ve got his back-it’s a nice thing to do if you’re in a position to do it
Swipe left for the next trending thread