Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lyse Doucet still in Kabul

211 replies

everythingthelighttouches · 30/08/2021 22:25

I know she regularly reports from dangerous places but am I the only person to be surprised that Lyse Doucet is still in Kabul? How on Earth will she get out? She must be a target for ISIS?

OP posts:
SpindleWhorl · 31/08/2021 07:09

[quote HemanOrSheRa]She was in Kabul 1988/89 to cover the Soviet withdrawal. There's a NewStatesman article that hints at her staying in Kabul this time.

www.newstatesman.com/world/2021/08/lyse-doucet-s-kabul-notebook-dystopian-airfield-and-afghans-leaving-everything-behind[/quote]
I read this section of Lyse Doucet's piece with eyes widening:

The next day, in the summer heat, we’re taken to the civilian side of the airfield where a hoarding of President Ghani hangs in pieces. The iconic “I Love Kabul” sign with its bright red heart is decorated with razor wire, blocked by American soldiers. Our escort arrives. A bus provided by the Qatar embassy – the country that has hosted the Taliban political office for years, as well as the negotiations that led to the US-Taliban deal in 2020.

I hope more people will finally wake up to the international scandal that is the Qatar World Cup 2022. The allegations that Qatar is a base for the Taliban and terrorism might finally be properly addressed, where corruption, slavery, discrimination and other human rights abuses have not been.

DobbyTheHouseElk · 31/08/2021 07:03

I’m so glad there is a thread on this. I’ve been worrying about her every night when she comes on he news. We watched her last night thinking how is she still there.

For the 10 0’clock news she’d donned a helmet and changes her red scarf for a blue one and I hope she had a bullet proof vest on. She is so brave. Love her reporting.

MyOtherProfile · 31/08/2021 06:57

@VestaTilley

She’s fantastic. Both her and Orla Guerin need a huge pay rise.
Yes, both are amazing. Modern day Kate Adies!
VestaTilley · 31/08/2021 06:53

She’s fantastic. Both her and Orla Guerin need a huge pay rise.

habibibibi · 31/08/2021 04:06

@UrbanRambler
I agree! It was just that she's not plopped in there by an established news agency like the BBC with no arrangements.

However, no doubt she (and her crew) are taking enormous personal risk even if they have agreements. I wouldn't want my safety dependent on the Taliban's goodwill!! She's a brave and dedicated journalist and kudos to her and the others helping her.

YukoandHiro · 31/08/2021 03:58

I'm a journalist who has on the odd occasion managed staff inside hostile zones. She will have fixers inside the Taliban and those in the resistance too. Im not saying she will be fine - her work is dangerous - be she will never have relied solely on the British gov for her access. Journalists who did were just doing glorified PR work.

bluewanda · 31/08/2021 03:38

But I thought maybe the Taliban see some journalists as useful and part of their PR

@QueenPeary like this one, you mean? Terrifying Sad

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-9941179/Terrified-Afghan-TV-news-presenter-reads-headlines-surrounded-gun-toting-Taliban-thugs.html

Lyse Doucet still in Kabul
UrbanRambler · 31/08/2021 03:37

@habibibibi

She's certainly brave and putting herself at risk. But they will probably have helpers and fixers who will have made an arrangement with the Taliban to allow her to operate, otherwise it would be impossible.
Well, imagine having to rely on the Taliban to ensure your safety - talk about dancing with the devil! I feel very concerned for her, I thought she'd be on the last flight out. She seems very dedicated and always comes across as truthful and well informed.
Godwits · 31/08/2021 03:25

I cannot imagine what it must feel like to hear the last planes fly out and the airport fall silent. Extraordinary courage, both of them

They're also adrenaline junkies. And I'm not being derogatory. It's what makes them want to risk their lives in war zones whilst we scroll through Mumsnet.

habibibibi · 31/08/2021 02:41

She's certainly brave and putting herself at risk. But they will probably have helpers and fixers who will have made an arrangement with the Taliban to allow her to operate, otherwise it would be impossible.

IHateCoronavirus · 31/08/2021 02:41

I hope and pray that they all remain safe, the reporters and those helping them. Sad. Sad and frightening times.

NiceGerbil · 31/08/2021 01:40

They are in enormous danger.

There's no other way about it.

SnowAndIcicles · 31/08/2021 01:35

French reporter Margaux Benn is also still in Kabul. She said her Afghan translator colleague was beaten by Taliban guard at a checkpoint despite having a Taliban document permitting him to do his job. It's going to be a tough job for these reporters to stay there and work but they will be doing such an important job telling the world what is happening there.

NiceGerbil · 31/08/2021 01:33

[quote PerkingFaintly]NiceGerbil, you might be interested in this article about how the Taliban have been using online media to shape the information environment for years.

It's one of the reasons they were able to advance so very quickly – faster than even they seem to have expected.

The Taliban’s vast propaganda machine has a new target
www.wired.co.uk/article/taliban-propaganda-news-afghanistan#intcid[/quote]
It's interesting how much they have learnt. The spokesperson chap. So reassuring. So reasonable.

I'm amazed they're on Twitter though. That's so out of line with their principles. The spokesperson bloke? Anyone got a link?

I'm more amazed that anyone is buying the charm offensive. We know who they are and what they do. We know what they believe. Because they were in charge before.

A nice chappie comes on telly and says look we're fine. And everyone forgets about what happened before? Not for me.

They've already started.

But this time they have learnt.

Women have to stop going to work and stay inside **for their own protection. Because some of their people haven't been trained in how to treat women yet.
What a crap excuse. Sounds better than the reason before though.

People already been summarily executed in some regions
Ah well we are looking into that. Can't say what happened yet.

Music banned.
But they want people to choose not to listen to any thing they don't approve of.

Yes they have learnt.

viques · 31/08/2021 01:25

And thankyou to @ PerkingFaintly for reminding me of Wahida Faizi, I heard that interview, it was heart rending, really brought home the horror and terror that ordinary people in Afghanistan have been living under.

NiceGerbil · 31/08/2021 01:23

In a way survival or not is not the point.

The point is she feels the need to be there. People who take these risks have a skewed view about their own mortality. They don't have the same fear of death as most people.

Explorers of really difficult areas, those who get people out at huge risk in wars/slavery/other awful situations. Spies behind the lines. And then the ordinary people who jump into the sea, rush into the burning building, walk up to the man with the knife and try to talk him down.

A particular type of person. It can't be learned I think it's a part of who you are. People who so often make a huge difference. And I suppose sometimes it's things that are not good.

viques · 31/08/2021 01:23

She is an amazing person. Kudos to her, and to her camera and sound people who I assume are also still with her.

PerkingFaintly · 31/08/2021 01:21

NiceGerbil, you might be interested in this article about how the Taliban have been using online media to shape the information environment for years.

It's one of the reasons they were able to advance so very quickly – faster than even they seem to have expected.

The Taliban’s vast propaganda machine has a new target
www.wired.co.uk/article/taliban-propaganda-news-afghanistan#intcid

PerkingFaintly · 31/08/2021 01:16

She's the Kate Adie of her time.

As long as she doesn't become the Marie Colvin of her time.

I absolutely take my hat off to Doucet. Like another poster, I was so relieved to see her reporting from Dubai a week or so ago – then she popped up in Kabul a few days later.

All power to her, and may the patron saint of journalists watch over her and keep her safe. And over Wahida Faizi, the female Afghan journalist whom Doucet interviewed on the tarmac a few days ago. Please god Faizi has got somewhere safe.

NiceGerbil · 31/08/2021 01:04

I've had a look through a load of her recent stuff can't see anything.

The taleban have learnt to try and look better to world which is I suppose understandable they don't want the spotlight on them etc.

The idea they have is bizarre. The things they did the way they ruled was because it was their core aim. That Afghanistan should be a proper Islamic country according to their beliefs.

Now they're all like yeah that was then we've done a 180?

I'll believe it when I see it. And if it's seen its because they put a few hand picked female docs etc on interviews and execute people indoors rather than in the football stadium.

The people there are fucked. The taleban are fucking awful. Isis are worse. And they're going to be fighting each other on top of everything else. Jesus.

This is just so upsetting.

NiceGerbil · 31/08/2021 00:49

The taleban are tweeting? God things change? Got a link? That's just.. I had no idea the taleban bosses had Twitter accounts!

You learn something every day.

pollyglot · 31/08/2021 00:48

Kiwi Charlotte Bellis, who reports for Al Jazeera, is still there too.

MistySkiesAfterRain · 31/08/2021 00:45

I think she is brave and courageous, like so many others there still.

jimmyhill · 31/08/2021 00:21

She's trusted by the Taliban and Pakistan. One of the Taliban leadership tweeted her earlier today. She'll be OK.

Don't confuse the Taliban with ISIS: the Taliban are media savvy. Just because they don't want Muslim Afghan women working doesn't mean they're going to kill a woman BBC journalist.

NiceGerbil · 31/08/2021 00:18

[quote Empressofthemundane]@PicsInRed

Is she worth more as a bribe? Who would pay it?

The UK government has a no payment for hostages policy. I am not sure the BBC would be allowed to pay either as a state organisation.[/quote]
Knows people who have routes out or contacts to get her out quietly when time to go that meant. As a Western journalist it will be extra £££ to help her due to consequences if found out. IE death.

That's what was meant I'm sure not hostages.

Taleban aren't into hostages for cash anyway and nor are Isis. The taleban said would play nice but already have executed told women to stay at home banned music.

Now the planes have left all bets are off. And they aren't going to be dicking around with hostages when they have Isis to fight.