Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lyse Doucet still in Kabul

211 replies

everythingthelighttouches · 30/08/2021 22:25

I know she regularly reports from dangerous places but am I the only person to be surprised that Lyse Doucet is still in Kabul? How on Earth will she get out? She must be a target for ISIS?

OP posts:
phishy · 31/08/2021 13:38

Did I say it was was easy? Pakistan has been and will continue to be a route into and out of Afghanistan, albeit with its own dangers.

lllllllllll · 31/08/2021 13:34

er, via Pakistan?

@phishy Do you really think it’s that easy just to get out via Pakistan? It sounds like it’s you who needs to read up on the current situation at the border there.

phishy · 31/08/2021 13:28

@everythingthelighttouches

But how is she going to get out? Kabul airport is now unmanned, there is no air traffic control. Sorry, it’s just something I don’t know anything about at all so I can’t imagine how it is going to be done.
er, via Pakistan?

People really need to read up on basic geography and journalism in the area.

RedToothBrush · 31/08/2021 13:18

@1jan2020

Being a journalist is a dangerous occupation that can get you killed or imprisoned.

@RedToothBrush depends what type of journalist. I shouldn’t think the journalists working on lifestyle magazines live in fear of their lives. War correspondents are a whole different matter though!

You'd be surprised.

Its not just war correspondents who are at risk. In an authoritian country with certain cultural expectations, even lifestyle reporters can be at risk.

Drugs and crime reporting is also extremely dangerous. That can include stuff like bribes, money laundering which isn't inherently thought of as violent too. Merely being critical of government can get you killed or imprisoned.

rsf.org/en/news/rsfs-2020-round-50-journalists-killed-two-thirds-countries-peace
RSF’s 2020 Round-up: 50 journalists killed, two-thirds in countries “at peace”

www.statista.com/statistics/266229/number-of-journalists-killed-since-1995/
The most dangerous country in the world for journalists is Mexico, where eight journalists were killed in 2020. Journalists in Mexico are frequently placed under surveillance, threatened, and fatally punished for attempting to expose or publicize political corruption, and despite the country being war-free, an average of eight to ten journalists are murdered in the country each year.

Journalists arrested and imprisoned
Journalists are at risk of being captured and detained as punishment for criticizing a political regime or a religious ideology, persecuted for insulting those in positions of power, hunted down for images they published, and shot dead simply because they were in the wrong place at the wrong time. The yearly number of imprisoned journalists regularly surpasses 250 worldwide, and arrests and kidnappings are also common. Between 2014 and 2019, almost 1,500 journalists were arrested and close to 400 were kidnapped, highlighting the harsh reality for many media workers around the world.

1jan2020 · 31/08/2021 13:01

Being a journalist is a dangerous occupation that can get you killed or imprisoned.

@RedToothBrush depends what type of journalist. I shouldn’t think the journalists working on lifestyle magazines live in fear of their lives. War correspondents are a whole different matter though!

HemanOrSheRa · 31/08/2021 12:45

Lyse is a co founder and mentor of the Marie Colvin Journalists' Network supporting female Arab journalists.

mariecolvinnetwork.org/en/home-page/about-us/project-team/

BabyLeaf · 31/08/2021 12:45

@PicsInRed

I think about John Cantlie pretty much every week, I really, really hope that some day we are able to find out what happened to him.

sleepygnome · 31/08/2021 12:44

I don't think she is brave, just selfish and arrogant. I hope no soldiers are going to be expected to risk their lives getting her out.

umberellaonesie · 31/08/2021 12:29

@Watapalava

Hmmm not sure on this

Surely she will at some point put other lives at risk who try to get her out etc

Yes her life and those helping her will be at risk. But the lives at risk if we turn away from what is happening in Afghanistan is huge. Lyse obviously feels reporting, shining a light on the lives of Afghan nationals and their plight is worthy of the risk. I for one have the upmost respect for journalism like this and the journalists who risk life and limb to tell the story.
RedToothBrush · 31/08/2021 12:17

At least 1,059 journalists have been murdered in the past ten years, and 387 were arbitrarily detained at the end of 2020, according to RSF. The rate of impunity for crimes of violence against journalists is still around 90%.

Being a journalist is a dangerous occupation that can get you killed or imprisoned.

RedToothBrush · 31/08/2021 12:10

More details on the restrictions that journalists are having to report under are here (article dated 24th August)

rsf.org/en/news/new-unofficial-oppressive-rules-imposed-journalists-afghanistan
New (unofficial) oppressive rules imposed on journalists in Afghanistan

It talks mainly about what is happening to Afghan journalists but it says this about foreign correspondents:

Foreign correspondents still in Kabul have not yet been subjected to these dictates and are managing to work in an almost normal manner. But for how much longer? The Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan’s Youth and Information Department issued this message to foreign journalists on 21 August: “Before going into the field and recording interviews with IEA fighters and the local population, they should coordinate with the IEA or otherwise face arrest.”

“There are no clear rules at the moment and we have no idea what will happen in the future,” said a Swiss freelancer who has stayed in Kabul. Another foreign reporter said: “The honeymoon is not yet over. We are benefitting from the fact that the Taliban are still seeking some legitimacy, and the arrival of the big international TV stations in the past few days is protecting us. The real problems will start when we are on our own again.”

So they have to have permission / authorisation (and probably an escort) to do interviews.

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 31/08/2021 11:43

Yes I was going to mention Malta too. And there was that young woman in Northern Ireland - Lyra McKee? Very close to home!

Blossomtoes · 31/08/2021 11:21

@Bluebellsinparadise

Closer to home, Veronica Guerin was murdered in Ireland (by organised crime). It felt closer, because she was the cousin of someone I know.

That was when I realised just how risky journalism can be. It’s a dangerous profession.

And Daphne Caruana Galizia, murdered by the Maltese state because she was getting too close to uncovering the corruption it was involved in. Journalists don’t have to be in a war zone to be in danger.
Bluebellsinparadise · 31/08/2021 11:15

Closer to home, Veronica Guerin was murdered in Ireland (by organised crime). It felt closer, because she was the cousin of someone I know.

That was when I realised just how risky journalism can be. It’s a dangerous profession.

Bluebellsinparadise · 31/08/2021 11:12

I admire her - putting herself in harm’s way to enable those without a voice to tell their stories to the world. I hope she can get out safely when the time comes.

Somewhat off topic, but I struggle to decipher where Lyse’s accent is from. I read she’s Canadian, but she sounds a little bit Irish and a little Northern European too. Is she a native English speaker?

PerkingFaintly · 31/08/2021 11:08

Gardner isn't the only high-profile journalist to have been specifically attacked.

Marie Colvin, and the media building where she and other journalists were working, were deliberately targeted by the Syrian government in 2012.

I'm pretty sure I remember reports of the shelling even before the strike that killed Colvin.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marie_Colvin

IIRC, the Syrians Colvin was working with were planning to risk their own lives to get her out, for the same reason the Syrian government was desperate to stop her, viz: the story she could tell if she got out.

Thus far, the Taliban have a use for Doucet being there – as PR for how all is going nicely.Hmm But that could change.

RedToothBrush · 31/08/2021 10:57

@RobinPenguins

Right now she is probably far safer than most Afghan journalists are.

And she has decades of contacts and experience of the region.

Amazing journalist, I’m such a big fan.

Its probably her contacts and fixers both within the liberal circles and taliban who are currently more at risk than she and her camera man - because of her. They deserve some credit too - regardless of their agenda. It is important to have journalists there even if they don't have full freedom to report.
SwedishEdith · 31/08/2021 10:49

@NiceGerbil

I'm amazed they're on Twitter though. That's so out of line with their principles. The spokesperson bloke? Anyone got a link?

Twitter account of spokesperson here (not verified though).

twitter.com/suhailshaheen1?s=20

What's noticeable is how many astroturf/bot accounts there are as well. Any news report on an atrocity or extreme ruling, whatever is followed up by an account with a young looking male saying something like "Sounds fair to me" etc. How quickly they've learnt to use social media.

RobinPenguins · 31/08/2021 10:25

Right now she is probably far safer than most Afghan journalists are.

And she has decades of contacts and experience of the region.

Amazing journalist, I’m such a big fan.

RedToothBrush · 31/08/2021 10:22

@GU24Mum

Unless she's had cast iron behind the scenes assurances, it does seem risky (putting it mildly) that she's still there. What about Secunder Kermani - is he there too?
I believe he is.

I admire the two greatly. Always had such respect for war journalists.

Yes they are both targets for terrorism, however they both speak the local language and both have lots of experience in the area and in dangerous situations.

Also i would imagine its very much in the Taliban's interests to protect them too if they want to be taken seriously as a country. So i suspect they will get support from the authorities there. The Taliban want to show the world that they aren't just from the middle ages and can be a islamic state for the 21st Century.

There have always been reporters in war zones. Its rare there is no journalists or citizen reporters at all. Syria being one of the most notable exceptions (which says something about how bad the situation was there). But the Taliban want to be an international player now and that does make them different.

The BBC might now find they are prohibited from filming certain things and are censored but they will be allowed to do at least something.

Journalism is one of the most dangerous professions in the world. Many are killed. Theres a group called reporters without borders who keep tabs on how dangerous various countries are for journalists. South America is surprising bad - much more than you would think for 'civilised' nations

PicsInRed · 31/08/2021 10:08

[quote Empressofthemundane]@PicsInRed

Is she worth more as a bribe? Who would pay it?

The UK government has a no payment for hostages policy. I am not sure the BBC would be allowed to pay either as a state organisation.[/quote]
Oh no, they won't hostage her for money, they'll hostage her for profile and terror and propaganda purposes.

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Cantlie

lljkk · 31/08/2021 09:49

I follow her on Twitter. She's doing a lot to 'engage' with the PR side of Taliban, to say "Prove we can trust you on things you say you plan to do".

Journalists are very concerned to keep reporting going about the real experiences of people still in the country. LD is not ready to give up yet.

Frank Gardner talks a lot in his memoirs about how important personal assurances of safety are in these traditional cultures. How much they oblige both sides, especially the persons who promise a level of personal safety to you. It's how journalists get to a risk-safety balance they can tolerate.

Smashedavacado · 31/08/2021 09:47

I was surprised to see her reporting last night as the final USA troops left. What a brave lady. Whilst the Taliban may not be such a risk ISIS K seems to be a huge danger now.

sashagabadon · 31/08/2021 09:38

She is amazing - what a woman.
There's a younger male journalist that pops up in news items too, also very brave. I shamefully don't know his name. I think he might have left now as haven't seen a report from him in a while.

ssd · 31/08/2021 09:35

I was going to start a thread about this. I agree @everythingthelighttouches