Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this is a well known scam?

265 replies

EvaRoad · 30/08/2021 20:15

....or have I just been unlucky? (Name changed as too outing)

At the end of July my girlfriend dropped her phone and it broke "beyond repair". She was distraught, did not know what she was going to do and needed a new phone. I suggested she asked her friends or asked her family but ultimately she made it clear that if I didn't get her a phone then she would not be able to contact me anymore. I was in a difficult position, her birthday was coming up, so I eventually relented and purchased her a new phone on a contract. Anyway, I never got to see the phone, as she kept on making excuses not to see me, and then last week she said she had "got back with her ex", didn't want to see me again, and blocked me. Obviously she's still got the phone and I've now got to pay for the rest of the contract.

What really gets me is that this is the second time this has happened to me, my previous girlfriend did something similar, breaking up with me within a few weeks of getting her a new phone a couple of years back.

So is this a well known scam, or have I just been unlucky? Do girls really drop their phones as often as they say?

OP posts:
BadNomad · 30/08/2021 22:06

I don't think you can demand the phone back. You can't buy commitment in a relationship. You said yourself it was a gift. Learn from this. If someone tries to emotionally manipulate you you should walk away. Not give in to it.

SeaShoreGalore · 30/08/2021 22:03

She’s not going to give it back. Just tell her you are cancelling the SiM and reporting it stolen.

EspressoDoubleShot · 30/08/2021 22:02

You have the IMEI ask provider to disable the phone
That way she cannot use it

Aposterhasnoname · 30/08/2021 22:01

@EvaRoad

For those saying I was gullible, how else would you respond to the line "You would do it if you really loved me?"
By saying “and if you really loved me you wouldn’t ask”
apalledandshocked · 30/08/2021 22:01

@EvaRoad

For those saying I was gullible, how else would you respond to the line "You would do it if you really loved me?"
I don't think guillible is the right word exactly... But as a general rule - that line is (in most cases) an absolute red flag that someone is trying to emotionally blackmail you. I would say exactly the same thing to a woman who had been told that (regardless of what the "it" is.) I am sure if someone posted on here "AIBU to get someone to buy me a new phone and then dump them" they would be ripped to shreds - but no-one has posted this. So I think it is reasonable people respond to your situation. No, it isn't a common scam, but at the same time it is possible to have a "arsehole filter" - basically a way of accidentally ensuring that all the arseholes/users etc etc are the ones that get through to you. What you need to be doing is the opposite - filtering those people out when they show red flags. And "buy me material possessions to show you love me" is a huge red flag
EvaRoad · 30/08/2021 21:57

Well I've have a reply: "Well it's my phone now" plus some stuff about it was all my fault. I've replied that I paid for the phone on the basis that we were having a long term relationship and that you needed to contact me, and if you are now back with your ex, I must now ask for my phone back.

OP posts:
phishy · 30/08/2021 21:52

@EvaRoad

For those saying I was gullible, how else would you respond to the line "You would do it if you really loved me?"
I’m now thinking no one could be this naive, surely?
Sparklfairy · 30/08/2021 21:52

@EvaRoad

For those saying I was gullible, how else would you respond to the line "You would do it if you really loved me?"
"Stop being a manipulative grabby cow and buy it yourself."
NumberTheory · 30/08/2021 21:52

@EvaRoad

For those saying I was gullible, how else would you respond to the line "You would do it if you really loved me?"
You could try something like:

"I'm not interested in puppy love."

Or, more likely at only a few months in,

"It's a bit early to be talking about love."

But as previous poster said, that's the sort of manipulation that's worth dumping someone over. Why would you even want to be with someone like that?

GCrebel · 30/08/2021 21:52

For those saying I was gullible, how else would you respond to the line "You would do it if you really loved me

I'd point out that someone who truly loved me wouldn't ask any such thing.

Then I'd dump them, because I deserve better.

OP you deserve better. Whatever happens, please learn from this.

EspressoDoubleShot · 30/08/2021 21:52

Get your card out and get yourself a new phone, Tesco have some for £30
That’s my reply
As an aside you can get a new phone cheaply a Nokia brick why didn’t she just buy a new cheappo phone

NotJuryDutyAgain · 30/08/2021 21:51

Yeah, at some point you do have to stand up for yourself. Someone who's really interested in you as a person won't use emotional blackmail to get you to buy them expensive things. Early in a romantic relationship, you should both still be on best behaviour, not manipulating one another into shelling out for new phones.

You have to put a little more value on yourself than that, or else you'll end up with chancers and losers who only want to use you.

SweetToothsAntlers · 30/08/2021 21:50

@EvaRoad

For those saying I was gullible, how else would you respond to the line "You would do it if you really loved me?"
I'd laugh honestly. Relationships that contain statements like this aren't love. They're people testing each other, treating emotions as transactions, and generally bullying another person into doing things they aren't comfortable with or don't want to freely give. It's toxic.

But I haven't had a partner who would say that to me with a straight face, let alone in reference to buying them gifts. Once you enter the realm of asking people to prove their affection with gifts/boundaries being pushed, you both know it isn't there. They're just playing on your fear of the relationship being revealed for what it is.

SeaShoreGalore · 30/08/2021 21:49

For those saying I was gullible, how else would you respond to the line "You would do it if you really loved me

I don’t love you. I couldn’t possibly love someone who would try to manipulate me like this.

EspressoDoubleShot · 30/08/2021 21:49

It’s not a well known scam as such, it is a really shitty thing to do
You really have had misfortune to date some shady women
Next time don’t buy anyone other than yourself a phone

stevalnamechanger · 30/08/2021 21:48

Get it blocked as stolen 😂

fuzzymoomin · 30/08/2021 21:47

@EvaRoad

For those saying I was gullible, how else would you respond to the line "You would do it if you really loved me?"
"If you really loved me you wouldn't ask"
TartanJumper · 30/08/2021 21:47

@MadeOfStarStuff

Why on earth were you gullible enough to fall for this twice?!

Adults can pay for their own mobile phones. If they can’t afford a contract then they can get a cheap PAYG. If you wanted to be really nice and they were struggling financially you could give them a cheap PAYG. No one with any sense would sign up for a phone contract for something they’d not been dating long.

I've been in similar positions to the OP with family. It's not easy to say no, and it's not the OPs fault that the people took advantage of their good nature.
Hugoslavia · 30/08/2021 21:47

Be sure that when you text her you do not state in writing or agree that it was a gift! Rather than you agreed to purchase a phone which she could use/borrow for the purpose of keeping in touch with you whilst in a relationship.

MadeOfStarStuff · 30/08/2021 21:46

I would respond by telling them to pay for their own bloody mobile phone!

I wouldn’t want to be with someone who would dump me for not signing up to spend hundreds of pounds on something for them that they should pay for themselves as an independent adult.

JulesCobb · 30/08/2021 21:46

@EvaRoad

For those saying I was gullible, how else would you respond to the line "You would do it if you really loved me?"
‘And you wouldn't ask for such an expensive item if you really loved me.’
Daisylg · 30/08/2021 21:46

“For those saying I was gullible, how else would you respond to the line "You would do it if you really loved me?"…

Erm try, “ if you loved me you wouldn’t emotionally blackmail me?”

Get the phone blocked. Learn from it this time

SweetToothsAntlers · 30/08/2021 21:45

As she's blocked you, you can't have a conversation about transferring the contract to her or asking her to purchase the contract. You've got no options really apart from paying for this woman's phone for 11 months or reporting it stolen. You can just say you were loaning it to her while you were in a relationship, but that she's taken it and blocked you. Once it's reported stolen, you can blacklist it with the IMEI via the carrier and it won't work any more.

If you know where she is, you could contact her and ask for it to be returned to prevent needing to do this. It seems extreme, but she didn't suddenly realise you weren't compatible. She strung you along to get the phone, so only you can decide whether you're going to let her profit from it or not.

EyesAsGreenAsAFreshPickledToad · 30/08/2021 21:45

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Anon778833 · 30/08/2021 21:45

People do things like this when they care about someone. Cut the OP some slack.