Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you offer to split costs?

113 replies

LevantineK · 30/08/2021 20:15

I invited a friend and her DC to join us on a trip to Scotland. It’s quite a long way from where we live. We have a seven-seater so the two families fit perfectly in the car. I never said we should share the costs of petrol or parking and I initially thought this would be fine. DH said we should ask, but I insisted we shouldn’t. These were costs we would have anyway, I said, so no need to ask her to contribute. But I’m now left with an uncomfortable feeling that she should offer to pay her share and then it should be down to us to decide. Actually she kind of did that. In the car, she said she would contribute with the petrol. But after a few hours driving, we had to fill up the tank and no additional word from her. In her place, I would undoubtedly have offered to split costs and insisted if needed. We visited quite a few places so we also spent a lot on parking (around 40 pounds in total). I organised the whole trip so I ended paying some of the costs in advance. She paid me back but slightly less than it was due (77 became 75). I know I’m sounding very petty, but maybe I am! About a year ago, they came along on two day trips and she never offered to contribute. In one of them, she offered to split in two the cost of lunch when we always pay more as we have one additional adult. In the other, she bought the kids ice cream. So it’s not like she’s unaware we are partially subsidising her trips. Especially considering this latest, more expensive one. She has more disposable income than we have by the way. It’s been a week since we’ve been back and today she cheerfully asked me where I would I take them next.

OP posts:
LevantineK · 31/08/2021 01:05

Thanks everyone for all the replies. I’m sure my irritation will pass and I’ll try to be clearer if there’s a next time.

OP posts:
WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 31/08/2021 00:53

There’s no way I’d charge someone petrol money just to make my own family trip cheaper than planned.

That seems to be inferring deliberate, cynical motives to make some cash by doing the car equivalent of taking in lodgers, rather than a genuinely kind thought that you have spare seats and some friends who would probably enjoy the trip as well.

Why would OP be wrong to indirectly end up paying a bit less for her family but the friend is apparently not wrong to score a freebie for her family (other than a few token ice creams)?

Even the £77: somebody upthread (correctly) said that it might seem petty to be counting out exact pounds if you were repaying in cash, but in such a scenario, when somebody has already subbed you significantly, surely you would round it up to £80 and not round it down to £75 - by just assuming and not even asking if they minded you short-paying them by a couple of quid ?

LevantineK · 31/08/2021 00:43

@Summerfun54321, this was how I felt initially. But unfortunately it changed. I assume if you put yourself in her place you would have done the same, right? I wouldn’t. And I think that’s why I’m disappointed.

OP posts:
Mothership4two · 31/08/2021 00:34

DH said we should ask, but I insisted we shouldn’t

There is nothing wrong about being clear about a situation like this where money is involved beforehand . Everybody knows where they stand. OP you are obviously thinking she should offer as that is what you would do and she may be thinking, well she's not asking so she doesn't expect it and it didn't happen last time.

Somewhere upthread the OP said that the friend looks down on talking about money. Often CFs use this excuse to their advantage.

Viviennemary · 31/08/2021 00:33

I think she should have paid half the parking and petrol costs or at least offered. Shd did offer. But if you made out you didn't want the money you can't blame her for not paying,

Suetully · 31/08/2021 00:27

maybe missing something but if she is a good friend you should be able to talk freely with her

I don't agree, money can be one of the most difficult subjects to bring up even for the closest of people. Look at the amount of mn threads over secret resentment and other issues people have towards family/friends/partners over money.

LevantineK · 31/08/2021 00:27

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll, that’s interesting. And I agree with you. If I benefit, I’ll want to pay. I hadn’t thought about the full picture of bringing a family along on a proper trip.. but it definitely contributed to me feeling a bit overwhelmed and even at times burdened especially by how she dealt with her younger DS’ behaviour. Nothing new to me but having that affect our plans a few times was hard.

OP posts:
LavendarMoon · 31/08/2021 00:26

Don’t think she sounds particularly cheeky at all. You’ve invited her on a trip you were already going on. She has paid more than her share in the past for things like lunch so doesn’t sound like she is tight. You just haven’t been very good at communicating your expectations with her. In future, make yourself clear when organising an activity. Certainly don’t text looking for money now unless you value that money more than your friendship.

Suetully · 31/08/2021 00:25

There’s no way I’d charge someone petrol money just to make my own family trip cheaper than planned. I’d enjoy the extra company and accept a small gesture if it came my way

Totally depends though. So I don't mind giving lifts if I am going there as I enjoy company too but I say that as a single person with no kids.

If I had a partner and kids, like the op, I am pretty certain I would just want it to be family time so the whole dynamic changes. If I was going on holiday with anybody and they were doing the driving in their car I'd throw money their way whether they wanted it or not.

What I find worse in the story is that her friend saw them paying for parking etc but never once offered to pay. And again what I'd likely do is, at the end of the holiday, throw them a sum of money in cash as I was getting out of the car which would cover petrol and parking and even a bit more for the fact that they did the driving.

Maskedrevenger · 31/08/2021 00:18

I maybe missing something but if she is a good friend you should be able to talk freely with her. If not why are you going on holiday with her? There must be more to this story, on a longer trip, does she pay an agreed spilt of the accommodation costs a fair share of groceries and / or eating out her share of activity costs? Surely you must have had a discussion about those costs so why not a discussion about a small contribution towards the travel costs, it doesn’t make sense to me.

Summerfun54321 · 31/08/2021 00:15

How much money are you actually expecting OP to take someone on a trip that’s costing you nothing extra at all for them to be there? There’s no way I’d charge someone petrol money just to make my own family trip cheaper than planned. I’d enjoy the extra company and accept a small gesture if it came my way (like your friend offered to you by small contributions towards your meals and ice creams etc).

HadEnoughofOtherThreads · 31/08/2021 00:12

She sounds like a CF, although you still invited her even though she has not contributed to previous trips.
You should have discussed all trip related finances up front and been clear from the beginning if you wanted her to contribute.
You changed your mind about her contributing after speaking to your Husband, after you invited her and after realising that the trip was costing more than expected. You did not discuss the possibility of shared costs with her or the likely total cost of the costs before or whilst planning the trip.
She did offer but you pushed back and haven’t reminded her since.
Send her the figure along with your bank a/c details.
Don’t invite her again if you do not want to experience a similar scenario.
Work on being more assertive.

LevantineK · 31/08/2021 00:06

@phishy, it’s great that you managed to change things! My friend is definitely not that bad. But I won’t send the message about the petrol because it would come across as abnormally aggressive considering how I normally talk to her. I would expect her to follow up in the car or in the messages we exchanged after. I’lol concentrate on possible future trips, if they actually happen.

OP posts:
WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 31/08/2021 00:06

I think there are two starkly distinct ways of looking at this kind of scenario. Many will ask why they should pay a share when you were going already; others (like me) will insist why I should pay, because I am also benefiting.

Going on that (former) attitude, nobody 'should' ever expect to pay on a bus or train, as it's going that way anyway - or at least not once enough people have paid to cover the costs. Nonsense: if you benefit, you pay your fair share.

It isn't even just the cost, but you and/or your DH took responsibility for 5 hours of driving (plus the wear and tear on your car) and you also passed up the opportunity of having exclusive time for your own family to chat/share in-jokes/listen to your own favourite music etc.

On a minor note, you would also have had to limit how much stuff you took with you or chose to buy when there, as 7-seater cars are made for either 7 people with very little luggage space or up to 5 people and loads of room to play with.

phishy · 31/08/2021 00:05

*helping

Urgh stupid iPhone keyboard you suck

phishy · 31/08/2021 00:05

@MissM2912

No even if we did go on a road trip somewhere we still wouldn’t hand over cash for petrol. It just would seem odd. If we stopped for lunch we might chip together to pay for the driver or something like that.
Abs that’s nice for you. But you’re not belong OP.
phishy · 31/08/2021 00:04

*paying for petrol and parking

phishy · 31/08/2021 00:03

@MissM2912

We just have been friends for years and years and haven’t shared petrol costs since we were at uni. We just take it in turns or contribute other things- like someone might bring snacks/ bottle of wine/ some sort of other token gesture. Seems quite bizarre to be taking money off a good friend for petrol if you are an adult, would be going anyway, and are comfortably off.
But there are no turns here MissM, it’s the OP/her DH droning abs paying for person and the friend doesn’t offer to pay for any of it, or contribute in other ways by buying food etc.

You’re comparing apples with oranges.

MissM2912 · 31/08/2021 00:02

No even if we did go on a road trip somewhere we still wouldn’t hand over cash for petrol. It just would seem odd. If we stopped for lunch we might chip together to pay for the driver or something like that.

DeathOnTheNile · 31/08/2021 00:01

With these situations, it's often more about the backstory than the situation itself. I have friends who have driven me places and who I've driven places, and it's never occurred to either of us to ask for petrol money. I've offered petrol money and had the offer rejected based on the fact that the person was going there anyway.

Since you invited your friend rather than it being a joint idea, she may have thought that you were okay with not splitting petrol money. But you obviously aren't, and that's okay too - next time make sure to discuss it upfront. It doesn't have to be a production, just a breezy 'so petrol is going to cost X, are you fine to split it?' Her response will tell you if she really is a CF or not.

Suetully · 31/08/2021 00:00

And you are right. It seems impossible to ignore it now.. but I’ll try

And it's not even about the money sometimes, it's more the entitlement and taking advantage. It gives the relationship an uneven/unequal feel. So in my example of Thailand the fags cost nothing, fraction of UK costs, so them asking for them off me annoyed me as it was sheer the cfery of it, the taking advantage. I totally see where you are coming from x

LevantineK · 31/08/2021 00:00

@MissM2912, I think it’s clear what you describe has nothing to do with my particular case. You are describing people taking turns at driving and offering each other lovely tokens like wine.

OP posts:
Suetully · 30/08/2021 23:56

This thread reminds of a holiday I did with 4 others to Thailand years ago. One of the group never bought drinks and constantly asked us for cigarettes. He met his uncle, who lived there, and the uncle started joining us and like nephew like uncle.

Both would sit waiting for a round to be bought and never once returned the favour, it was cringy especially as the drink and fags cost nothing. But cfs will do this.

phishy · 30/08/2021 23:55

In the car, she said she would contribute with the petrol. But after a few hours driving, we had to fill up the tank and no additional word from her.

Given she did offer and you didn’t say no it’s ok, why not text her and say ‘thank you for
offering petrol costs on the drive up, we are actually short of cash this month, if you could transfer £xx , which was the half of the petrol and parking costs, that would really help a lot.’

It will also help you suss out what kind of friend she is.

Palavah · 30/08/2021 23:55

@thisplaceisweird

She offered to split, and since you didn't outright ask to begin with she probably thinks you're not that bothered.

I always reject things like that from my friends because I don't need the contribution and I can't be bothered with sharing bank details etc. She's probably not even thinking about it.

Just ask, 'thanks for offering to split costs, that would be great actually. Petrol will be X and the lunch/activity was x'

This!

You wanted her to offer and she has offered.

Swipe left for the next trending thread