Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you offer to split costs?

113 replies

LevantineK · 30/08/2021 20:15

I invited a friend and her DC to join us on a trip to Scotland. It’s quite a long way from where we live. We have a seven-seater so the two families fit perfectly in the car. I never said we should share the costs of petrol or parking and I initially thought this would be fine. DH said we should ask, but I insisted we shouldn’t. These were costs we would have anyway, I said, so no need to ask her to contribute. But I’m now left with an uncomfortable feeling that she should offer to pay her share and then it should be down to us to decide. Actually she kind of did that. In the car, she said she would contribute with the petrol. But after a few hours driving, we had to fill up the tank and no additional word from her. In her place, I would undoubtedly have offered to split costs and insisted if needed. We visited quite a few places so we also spent a lot on parking (around 40 pounds in total). I organised the whole trip so I ended paying some of the costs in advance. She paid me back but slightly less than it was due (77 became 75). I know I’m sounding very petty, but maybe I am! About a year ago, they came along on two day trips and she never offered to contribute. In one of them, she offered to split in two the cost of lunch when we always pay more as we have one additional adult. In the other, she bought the kids ice cream. So it’s not like she’s unaware we are partially subsidising her trips. Especially considering this latest, more expensive one. She has more disposable income than we have by the way. It’s been a week since we’ve been back and today she cheerfully asked me where I would I take them next.

OP posts:
LevantineK · 31/08/2021 12:19

@Goldbar, yes, I recognise I'm at fault, but I never refused her offer to contribute. When she said she would contribute towards petrol, I nodded, smiled and said thanks. With hindsight, this would have been the perfect opportunity to say that I would send her a message with all the costs at the end of the trip. But I didn't do that and who can say how people interpret nods, discrete smiles and faint thanks! Maybe she read: "They don't really want it, it's all taken care of!". She's definitely not malicious. I think it's more about my lack of clarity and her being self-centred and slightly selfish. 3/7 would be the fair split in my view and I would probably accept less than that exact proportion. After being furious yesterday with her text about "where are you taking us next?", I'm more at peace today with mine and her shortcomings! It was good to vent my frustrations here!

OP posts:
BungleandGeorge · 31/08/2021 12:11

Why get stressed about it? Personally I think now you can text people it makes uncomfortable situations much easier! Next invitation- do you fancy going halves on a day trip out? Where do you fancy going? Then send her how much she owes.

Most people would just contribute voluntarily but not everyone is the same.

LevantineK · 31/08/2021 12:01

@billy1966, I think that's probably what I'll do. Even asking her to contribute to costs for future trips would make me really stressed because it would feel like a dig about the past ones. I know many would think I'm not behaving like an adult, that I lack assertiveness etc. I wish I could be different without developing an ulcer. In short, unless she comes to the conclusion that she should offer to contribute to the costs (doesn't even need to be half), I will stop inviting them. But I'm definitely not ending the friendship. By doing that, I'd be actually preserving it. We get on extremely well in my family unit, have great conversations in the car, so I'm not inviting them to compensate for anything we lack. It was just to have a different type of fun and experience and also because I felt a bit sorry for them, as she's the type who never organises this sort of thing for her family. She is a lovely person but can be self-absorbed. And I also like her children very much.

OP posts:
Goldbar · 31/08/2021 12:00

My reading of this is that you are both at fault.

On your part, there is a communication issue and it is mostly your fault. You refused her offer to contribute and then decided that actually you'd like her to contribute after all. But you're too embarrassed to front up to her about it.

On her part, if I'd gone away with another family for a trip and they'd paid for the petrol and done all the driving, I'd be looking for ways to say thank you and show my appreciation, like treating everyone to a meal out. Not just a round of ice creams and paying a little more than my share for a meal.

The first question to ask is do you like having her and her DC on your trips? If not, don't invite them.

The second question is what it is fair for your friend to contribute. I'd estimate petrol and parking costs and ask her to pay 3/7 in advance into a holiday kitty. Anything left over could be used for a meal out on the last day.

billy1966 · 31/08/2021 11:21

I think that your husband and yourself are very kind to invite her and her children.

Because you state clearly money isn't an issue for her, I do think she is being tight and a CF.

I wouldn't say anything, I just wouldn't include her next time.

It offers no benefit to you and your family and actually is a little stressful.

I just would holiday alone from now on.

She is obviously tight.

Simple manners would dictate you would do something for people doing what you are doing.

IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves · 31/08/2021 11:20

You should laugh back and say I think it's your turn to treat us to a break.

Shodan · 31/08/2021 11:18

One adult jumping in for a short trip in the car is one thing, petrol-wise.

Three extra people in a car doing a long trip such as the OP describes is quite another.

I would definitely have asked for a contribution to the petrol costs, but not the parking.

In all honesty, OP, I'd feel like you, but I think at this stage it would feel far too uncomfortable for me to ask for petrol costs for this trip. But you should (and I would) do it in advance if you ever consider taking her on another trip.

Aprilx · 31/08/2021 11:10

If I invited a friend to join me somewhere I was going anyway, no I would not expect or want a contribution towards petrol. As you do feel put out by it, the answer is to stop inviting her to join you!

PadManic · 31/08/2021 11:04

"you are her guest" should have been "she is your guest". Sorry.

PadManic · 31/08/2021 11:02

Whenever I read these threads about money, it makes me worried that perhaps friends of mine are quietly seething too, without me knowing about it Confused.

None of my friends offer each other petrol money for trips we were already going to make - we just jump in each other's cars without a second thought. If you didn't talk about money beforehand and simply invited her to join you, she'll assume you are her guest effectively.

If you want her to pay, then you need to talk about it before you go.

Context is everything: "I've arranged a family trip on 10 August to Scotland in our seven-seater. It'd be lovely to see you, would you like to join us?" will subconsciously give the message that this is a freebie.

Whereas "It would be nice to do a trip together over the holidays. Where shall we go? What dates suit you? Can we split the travelling costs between us?" obviously isn't.

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 31/08/2021 11:00

@LevantineK what did the 75£ she payed cover? I organised the whole trip so I ended paying some of the costs in advance. She paid me back but slightly less than it was due (77 became 75). And did you respond to her offer to share petrol costs or just brush it up making her think you didn't want her to contribute?

I understand why you feel hurt, I would just contribute too if I was the friend, but I don't think it's fair to expect her to act as you would.
And it sounds like it was only after the fact that you decided it was unfair she didn't contribute. If you're taking her on family outings I'd expect she's a good and valued friend. I wouldn't throw that away over something that can easily be avoided by either not inviting her again or making expectations clear upfront, something less like, "would you like to go to .... with us? It ended up a lot more cost than w expected last time, so if you'd like to come with us to ..... or any other outing in future we'll need to split petrol and parking 50/50."

starrynight87 · 31/08/2021 10:31

You need to be a lot clearer about what contributions you expect.

BungleandGeorge · 31/08/2021 09:52

You do seem to have done an about turn from you not wanting to ask but your husband wanting to. Now it’s you that thinks it cheeky? Just ask her for some money.
Why did you invite her? Was it company for the children? If you’re going to ask for half I think next time you should give her some input on where you go and what day trips you do. Or just go as a family?

burnoutbabe · 31/08/2021 09:08

If I'd offered to pay towards petrol etc I would not expect to have to get out my purse at every petrol station and contribute each time. I'd expect to just be given one amount at the end to pay. Which you haven't done.

Datsandcogs · 31/08/2021 08:56

You would have to have paid petrol and parking anyway. I would expect her to cover the additional costs for her family such as paying entrance fees. But then, if she has any appreciation of your generousity, there should also be a lovely thank you of some kind.

hahahayoumustbejoking · 31/08/2021 08:47

@MissM2912

What age are you?? It honestly would never occur to me or my friends to share petrol costs. We aren’t 18 🙈
Maybe you're the freeloader?
Lotsalotsagiggles · 31/08/2021 08:15

Yep say something like 'we won't be going away for a while as needed to save up etc, although very lovely driving around Scotland cost a lot more than I thought

Ans then change the subject

KarmaStar · 31/08/2021 08:10

We can't afford to take you anywhere but if you'd like to treat us we would be happy to join you.

She's a tight wad and a c.f..

LevantineK · 31/08/2021 06:47

@AndytheUnicorn, she didn’t pay for one adult, but for the equivalent of half of one adult in that particular trip.

OP posts:
LevantineK · 31/08/2021 06:39

@BunnytheFriendlyDragon, I simply nodded, smiled and said thanks.

OP posts:
Doomscrolling · 31/08/2021 04:55

You invited her to join you, you didn’t ask for money at all, it would have cost you the same had she not come. Why have you reversed your position now it’s over?

Like a PP, we’ve not split petrol costs since our skint youth. If it would have cost us anyway, why expect others to subsidise our trip when we can invite them along?

AndytheUnicorn · 31/08/2021 04:44

^^ In one of them, she offered to split in two the cost of lunch when we always pay more as we have one additional adult.

Sorry why should she pay for the additional adult? I don’t get that? She doesn’t have an additional adult. You have one more person, so yes you pay more. Unless I’m missing something.

She paid £2 less for your trip and paid for ice creams. It actually sounds as if she offers to pay, you weren’t bothered as it wouldn’t cost you more. Your husband said something, now you are. Just take her up on her offer or next time saying, would you might paying half before you go. A lot of overthinking here.

1forAll74 · 31/08/2021 04:29

Everything moneywise should be sorted out before you even go on these outings. and then people can decide if they can afford all that has to be paid for. Most people should know about car expenses,and costs when visiting places, and eating out etc, it's always quite costly, so people should always pay their way. Plus you are doing all the driving !!

BunnytheFriendlyDragon · 31/08/2021 03:40

In the car, she said she would contribute with the petrol. But after a few hours driving, we had to fill up the tank and no additional word from her. In her place, I would undoubtedly have offered to split costs and insisted if needed.

What did you say when she said she would contribute?

Diverseopinions · 31/08/2021 01:35

I think your position has swung around quite radically from 'insisting' she shouldn't pay for petrol, being sure you don't want to do it, to thinking she should contribute. The tone of your initial invitation probably reflected your attitude in the first place. She probably picked up on this.

In a way, I think that it's a shame for people who don't drive ( does she?) to be in the sack of potatoes role of being ferried around; helpless; doing a trip they probably wouldn't have done on their own: being beholden. I feel, as a non-driver, that I probably wouldn't, from now on, allow people to drive me on long trips: I think I would rather get the train and meet there. That way, there would be the option to be a bit separate, if we became too much in each others' hair. I don't know if it's good for a friendship for one side to be dependent.

Swipe left for the next trending thread