Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Brother living with me- AIBU?

32 replies

leylaa · 30/08/2021 19:23

My brother in law has been living for over three years. My DH wanted to help him out as he was in constant arguments with his alcoholic parents. He moved from Germany to Edinburgh and DH supported him in finding a job - we really didn’t know he would be with us for this long. We now have a DD who is 4 months and will soon need her own room which is occupied by him, i thought he would get the hint of moving out when he found out I was pregnant but no! He has never paid for rent/ bills etc and I have never ever asked for anything however I heard recently that he had given DH approx £4-5 k when finances were tight and I lost my job due to COVID-19 (my DH asked for help) . I told DH to speak to him when his second visa had come through- should DH pay him back? AIBU to ask him to leave ?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WeBuiltThisCityOnSausageRolls · 06/09/2021 20:06

At 27 and he was earning, I meant to say.. in the second sentence
He was eating too... Grin

WeBuiltThisCityOnSausageRolls · 06/09/2021 20:05

He paid no rent and ought have been contributing . At 27 he was eating and would have paid in excess of £500 per month for a room and his food. I don't think you owe him a penny for his paltry £136 per month (well done to that PP who calculated it!) very late donation towards even part of his expenses. Wouldn't even cover bills or food let alone rent.

Use it towards the baby expenses

It's time BIL leave snd stands on his own two feet as a grown man. 27!!!! Not 19 but 27!!!!! Shock who has been working all along....

I really cannot get my head around how much he has mooched off of his brother and wife, and now isn't bothered that your baby has no bedroom or her own as he's mooching!!!

It - is- time- he- leaves ....

Kite22 · 31/08/2021 23:48
  1. Of course you need to tell him he needs to move out in the next two months as your dd will need her own room. Just as a simple matter of fact. No apologising or 'asking', just stating
  2. Re paying him back - I guess that depends if your dh asked for a loan or asked for a contribution. Morally I don't understand how he has been living with you for over 3 years without giving you some sort of housekeeping at the very least to cover expenses anyway. I don't understand why you didn't sort all that out as soon as he got a job. If the £4.5K he has given you was freely given as a gift, then he has still only paid about £125 per month for all the time he has been there. That probably wouldn't cover the rent per week in a shared house, before food and other consumables, so I sincerely hope it was a 'donation to funds' and not a loan your dh asked for.

*NB, by 'you' I mean 'you as a couple'

RedHelenB · 31/08/2021 23:35

I would talk to your husband, agree when bil needs to leave by and together inform him of this. Aged 27 with a job he should be able to rent somewhere.

leylaa · 31/08/2021 20:51

I had lost my job due to Covid and financially we were tight. He assumed that it was within his right to ask brother to support as he is living with us and hasn’t contributed to the household at all

OP posts:
DelphiniumBlue · 31/08/2021 19:05

@leylaa

He had not told me because I was in an awful state when losing my job, he didn’t want to stress me out further
He didn't want to stress you out by telling you BiL had paid him thousands of pounds?? How would that stress you? Surely it would help you to know that? It doesn't make sense ..there's more going on here, I suspect.
leylaa · 31/08/2021 19:00

He’s 27

OP posts:
TiredButDancing · 31/08/2021 09:20

@DifficultBloodyWoman

You said that he moved from Germany but I am wondering if there could be other cultural expectations at play here given that is very long time to live with a married couple, even if they are family, by European standards. Especially without rent.

Although, perhaps he is just a monumental cheeky fucker, as they exist in all countries.

I be planning to move and ask him about his plans at this stage.

I don't think it's a specifically cultural thing. I have seen similar situations play out too many times. The world appears to be split into people who move in with friends and family for a very short time, are pathetically grateful, do all they can to help out and move out as soon as they can and other people who move in, do nothing and never leave.

Unfortunately, for some reason, the second group often benefit from a weird reluctance from friends and family to tell them to leave. I would love to say I am stronger than this but actually, I had to learn the lesson the hard way when my flatmate's family friend moved in for "2 weeks" and stayed nearly 2 months... and I said nothing just quietly seethed! After that I've been much better about establishing boundaries at the outset.

OP - tell him he has to go. Give him a timeline and mov him out. do not mention the money. If BIL asks, DH should say, "we assumed that was you helping out financially for the 3 years you've lived here completely rent and cost-free".

RedHelenB · 31/08/2021 09:11

How old is he?

TempName01 · 31/08/2021 08:51

It’s important whether the money he gave to DH was a gift or a loan. You can’t ask for rent after the fact. In any case he needs to leave as soon as possible.

ANameChangeAgain · 31/08/2021 08:12

Lots of thoughts an assumptions here from both sides, but not very many frank and honest conversations. You need to start to stand up for your home, your DH clearly isn't going to so it falls on your shoulders.
If your DH asked for the money with a promise to pay it back you might be on a sticky wicket. If there were no discussions about board then your DH possibly isn't legally entitled to keep the money however unfair it feels.
I think he needs to be presented with an invoice of sorts showing what he owes for a third of house hold expenses. Perhaps saying that the loan covers x%. Tell him in writing he needs to move out by x date as the baby will need the room by the time they are 6 months old.

DifficultBloodyWoman · 31/08/2021 05:30

You said that he moved from Germany but I am wondering if there could be other cultural expectations at play here given that is very long time to live with a married couple, even if they are family, by European standards. Especially without rent.

Although, perhaps he is just a monumental cheeky fucker, as they exist in all countries.

I be planning to move and ask him about his plans at this stage.

PennyWus · 31/08/2021 02:34

Just say to him you need the room for the baby and give him a month's notice. Easy to get a flat share if he's got a job and steady income.

Bogeyes · 31/08/2021 02:30

Can I come and live with you too?
He will never move out!

SlipSlop · 31/08/2021 00:42

Oh dear oh dear!

Your BIL has been living with you for 3 years and during most of that time has been working. Neither of you thought it would be a good idea for him to regularly pay you board. And I suppose he didn't volunteer to pay you anything either.

Then when you are both in dire straits, BIL kindly lends his brother a few thousand.

And that makes you and DH beholden to BIL?

What utter nonsense.

As others have pointed out, with the amount BIL 'lent' to your DH, he could not have lived on, never mind rented elsewhere.

So you should both take your blinkers off and give you BIL a couple of month's notice to leave. Six month's notice is far too long.

You have both been taken for a ride by a leech. Stop it now and grow a spine! If he dares to ask about the loan, give him a bill for his board over the last 3 years.

Cherrysoup · 31/08/2021 00:16

Giving your dh £5K over 3 years is pathetic, given he’s working. Have you told your dh you want him to move out? Where will the baby go otherwise?

leylaa · 30/08/2021 23:37

He had not told me because I was in an awful state when losing my job, he didn’t want to stress me out further

OP posts:
SeaShoreGalore · 30/08/2021 20:31

Oh god yes, just give him notice!

PlanDeRaccordement · 30/08/2021 20:27

I’d be DH speak to him now (assuming he is DHs brother and your brother in law). Obviously, a move out date needs to be agreed on and it takes time to find a flat to rent...allow a minimum of two months for that. The visa thing doesn’t matter, he can update Home Office with his new address and if anything comes to you by mistake, you can arrange to give it to him. Home Office won’t care where he is living, him having to move won’t affect his visa approval.

Tiana4 · 30/08/2021 20:19

He's effectively paid £138 per month in a recent lump sum which includes rent and bills and has been working
Bargain for BIL

Regardiess, it was supposed to be a temporary arrangement and your baby needs the bedroom as do you.

"BIL it's time you move out to a house share or rent your own place now. We need our bedroom back for baby. It was only temporary. Hopefully we'll still see you for Sunday lunch some weeks?"

HestersSamplerofCarrots · 30/08/2021 19:59

Oh, and if it’s brother-in-law as per body text of the OP, then I’d be telling your husband that it’s well past time for him to be gone.

Either way, he’s been in your home for years: you’re within your rights to have this conversation with him yourself. IMO.

Therealjudgejudy · 30/08/2021 19:57

If he is working, why hasn't he been paying his way?

HestersSamplerofCarrots · 30/08/2021 19:57

Your brother or your brother-in-law?

Because the title says brother but then everything reads as if it’s your brother-in-law because you won’t have any kind of conversation with him at all, and seem to be relying on your husband to do it all.

If it’s your brother, then why is it your husband who has to have any conversation of meaning with him?

If he’s outstayed his welcome (and for me that would have been several years ago FWIW), then just bloody tell him!

BigPyjamas · 30/08/2021 19:40

It's not really about being kind, although you clearly have been.

Simple facts are:

  • your child needs their own room soon
  • that room is occupied by your BIL
  • your child needs the room, he needs to move out.

It doesn't matter what he has a has not paid (mostly not paid by the sounds of things)

I would present it as facts. Keep emotion out.

When does he find out about visas? I can see that if it's a few weeks it makes sense to wait but otherwise you can't keep waiting.

leylaa · 30/08/2021 19:37

Yes he’s working

OP posts: