Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To teach DS a life lesson or just let it go…

115 replies

Whosthebestbabainalltheworld · 30/08/2021 14:52

DS14 is a capable all-round student, but a bit lazy. He dislikes a particular subject, has decided he doesn’t want to study it and not surprisingly, performed poorly in his summer exam.

Teacher suggests he still aims for higher level in his state exams in 2 years (he could drop to lower level, which is an easier course, but cannot drop the subject entirely). In fact, in our schooling system it’s something he must study until he finishes secondary school (won’t be hard for some to guess the country, but not UK obviously). So once he drops to lower level that’s where he’ll stay for the next 5 years.

My dilemma is this….

Do I agree he can drop levels (despite being capable) or seek to teach him a life lesson - insist he sticks with higher level and pay for extra tuition which he will both hate and resent me for.

I’m torn, please help!

OP posts:
itsgettingwierd · 30/08/2021 16:05

@Tiana4

Also it's worth considering if it is the teacher of subject he hates?

My DD went from loving Maths (for eg) to hating it bc it turned out she was being bullied by the maths teacher who didn't explain but mocked her . She went from predicted 8 to predicted 4-5 by this teacher- who was down marking her. She got a 7 but I considered getting a maths tutor , but once she told me- instead we found online lessons (ask head of maths in school what they recommend) and I taught her some (except matrices as nobody need to learn that!! Shock)

Great post!

My ds always loved science and was good at it. Predicted 7 at gcse. Then hated it. Didn't say why just hated the subject and hated any homework etc. Had a teacher who was just vile to him and allowed students who were bullying him to bully him in class. Told me he'd fail the subject because his writing is poor and his communication is weak (he has a physical disability and autism!).

After an incident where she was caught red handed being an arse they moved him teachers.

He went back up to predicted a 6 in a term and the following year had an even better teacher and ended up with 9/9 in science!

Is there anyway he can stick at higher level for now and if he doesn't get on with it over the next year drop down at a later date?

MaryTalbot · 30/08/2021 16:04

It partly depends on the subject.

In my opinion if it is compulsory I’d try financial incentives and a fab tutor if I could afford it.

My youngest hates writing with a passion and struggles with English. He’s young enough that I can tutor him - yet I have resorting to stickers and money to finish the flipping work books with a ‘determined positive attitude’ when he is older I will get the best English tutor I can afford and stick him with tutoring for the entire time at secondary.

misskatamari · 30/08/2021 16:03

I think it entirely depends on the subject. If it was something like maths or science, I wouldn't want to limit him at this stage, if he can still drop down in the future if needs be. If it's something he just doesn't enjoy AND has no actual bearing on future opportunities then I'd consider letting him drop

Apeirogon · 30/08/2021 16:02

Forgot to say that my bright capable child is also rather lazy.

Apeirogon · 30/08/2021 16:01

I have a bright capable 15yo who really dislikes one particular subject. I would let him drop to the lower level.

ohbygolly · 30/08/2021 15:59

Assuming it's Irish, I'd say there's a huge difference between inability and laziness on this one. I think you put your child in a class that matches their ability, not their level of interest.

I think it would be good to keep him at higher level Irish for the Junior Cert. Even if it all goes horribly wrong, the results will have no impact on him progressing to Leaving Cert, at whatever level he chooses.

The biggest issue I see with dropping to lower level Irish at Leaving Cert level is the impact on attaining the necessary points in his Leaving Cert for high-point courses in college. The UK system is different to the Irish one, and he's going to be relying on points from any subject, irrespective of their relevance to the chosen course.

Most students do 7 subjects for the Leaving. He's going to need 6 of them for points. If he finds himself wanting to do a high-point course (medicine, actuary, veterinary, pharmacy, economics, and who knows what else in years to come), even though Irish won't be relevant, if he does lower level Irish for the LC, then he's putting all his eggs in one basket, and needs the other 6 subjects to go absolutely to plan. That leaves him no fall back, or 'oh shit that exam was awful'. I think better he stick with the higher level in all subjects that phase repeating an entire year because it didn't go to plan in another exam.

Truth is, even if this isn't Irish, the same is true of any subject. I really believe students should sit exams at the level of their ability, not their interest. There's a huge difference between a 14 year old thinking about Summer exams, and an 18 year old thinking about future careers. If at all possible, I wouldn't let his 14 year old self limit his future prospects for a short-term gain of an easier life.

SanFranBear · 30/08/2021 15:58

I was placed in the top set for maths in secondary and I hated it. With tutoring and pressure from my parents, I could probably have taken the exams and passed but I was so miserable and unmotivated. The school offered to drop me down to the intermediary level and it made all the difference. I could only hit a C but I did, comfortably, and will always be grateful my parents allowed it. If he's doing well in his subjects other than this one, I'd accept its not his thing and let him do the lower level.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 30/08/2021 15:58

@CrackerGal

Wondering if it's Irish too? That's not the impression I was given by my kids both in exam years ... they say they were told if you do ordinary at junior cert it doesn't stop you from doing higher at leaving cert in the same subject. Might depend on the school?
Theoretically it doesn't but realistically it does, as they really won't have a good enough grasp of the subject, particularly if it's a language.
PinkPineapples9 · 30/08/2021 15:58

If its a core subject maths/english/science/history, push push push. If it's something he hates and will never look at again once he leaves school then maybe do the lower level but make sure you don't let standards drop anywhere else - don't want to set a precedent!

HOWEVER, totally contradicting myself, there was so many things I thought were crap at school and didn't try hard at and later in life thought hmmmm reallllyy wish I'd listened in that French/Spanish class or whatever.

TempName01 · 30/08/2021 15:58

If it is Irish or similar let him drop down (he will have more time to focus on the other subjects). if it’s Maths get a tutor

OchonAgusOchonOh · 30/08/2021 15:54

@TooBigForMyBoots

Drop it. My DS's school dropped the language requirement for him and a few other boys. Some children just don't get languages. I would much prefer he put his energies into subjects he loves and enjoy school, than make him do a subject that he has no affinity with.
Unless he has an exemption that will really restrict his choices at third level.

It's not as bad as it used to be as some courses don't require the language and not all institutions require both Irish and a foreign language but I would be very, very wary of letting a child drop a language without an exemption.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 30/08/2021 15:50

If he's capable, doing it at higher level for junior cert is the sensible option as it will stand to him in leaving cert, even if he does lower level for LC.

Boys tend to cop on a bit later than girls so he might cop on yet. I certainly wouldn't let him drop down at the end of first year. If needs be, he can drop down in the JC year.

Ds1 is not linguistically gifted (to say the least) but I managed to convince him to continue with higher level french until the end of 5th year even though it was never going to be a points subject for him. He dropped to ordinary level at the beginning of leaving cert and had very little work to do as he had, despite himself, got the basics. Similar with english for ds2.

M0rT · 30/08/2021 15:49

I'd let him decide but explain the implications for his Leaving Cert, so if he goes to ordinary level in Irish he is going to need to do Honours in all his other subjects and aim for honours in them. Will he be willing to that much work or does he want to try keeping honours Irish in case there is something he's even worse at?
Don't feed the ego with bright but lazy either, I'm bright but lazy... potential doesn't pay the bills!

TooBigForMyBoots · 30/08/2021 15:47

Drop it. My DS's school dropped the language requirement for him and a few other boys. Some children just don't get languages. I would much prefer he put his energies into subjects he loves and enjoy school, than make him do a subject that he has no affinity with.

PallasStrand · 30/08/2021 15:41

[quote Anoisagusaris]@PallasStrand you can’t say it’s not difficult. Some people find it difficult - I did, and I had no problem with higher level in all my other subjects. The OP needs to decide if he is just lazy or if he genuinely struggles. Even if it’s the latter, I think many kids could get through JC but not LC[/quote]
Admittedly it still isn’t well taught in general, but the OP herself says he’s clever but lazy.

godmum56 · 30/08/2021 15:33

What use will the subject be to him in later life? ....and also what use will the higher level be to him in later life? I am really not sure what even good tutoring will do if his heart isn't in it? Does he have any lind of career or leaning in mind and how will the lower grade level affect that? I do get the sensitivity if its a national language issue but even then surely his views should be taken into account....I would use the "hill metaphor here but it seems innapropriate...so I will just ask if its worth the disagreement....I mean it may be you who gets the life lesson about what its sensible to spend your money on?

SMabbutt · 30/08/2021 15:32

Why not get him to look at the impact of dropping to the lower level. Say before he makes a decision you want him to list the benefits and problems of staying at the higher level and the same for dropping down. So staying positives may be to do with future education or employment and being with his mates for support in study. Negatives could include restrictions on opportunities, stress or too much work impacting his chosen subjects. Dropping a level may be that it frees time for subjects he needs for future education, it has no impact on his employability etc. At least that way any decision is made with full understanding of the consequences. Also link it to an undertaking to use the reduced expectations in one subject to allow them to focus on at least one other subject with a realistic target of what actions he will be taking and aims to achieve.

Belleager · 30/08/2021 15:31

Also if going into year 2, are they just starting streaming? And will there be a new teacher? I'd give it a go if so - well I would anyway. But these things may help.

If you talk to him about doing honours level now so that he can relax and ace his other subjects at leaving cert (all assuming Ireland) he may see the logic of that and may end up sticking with it. Shifting friendship groups, different teaching, maybe a summer in the Gaeltacht could make a big change. It's early days and if he's not struggling generally, bit of a waste to drop it.

It's true there's nothing stopping you from doing ordinary at junior cert and higher at leaving cert in theory, but he'd have to be very motivated and fill in some gaps himself, I'd expect - schools aren't set up for traffic in that direction. So if he'll need higher level later, no way he should drop it now.

Anoisagusaris · 30/08/2021 15:28

@PallasStrand you can’t say it’s not difficult. Some people find it difficult - I did, and I had no problem with higher level in all my other subjects. The OP needs to decide if he is just lazy or if he genuinely struggles. Even if it’s the latter, I think many kids could get through JC but not LC

PallasStrand · 30/08/2021 15:23

He keeps Irish on at honours level. It’s not difficult, he’s just being lazy.

CrackerGal · 30/08/2021 15:23

It wasn't Irish specifically that I was discussing with my kids though!

CrackerGal · 30/08/2021 15:21

Wondering if it's Irish too?
That's not the impression I was given by my kids both in exam years ... they say they were told if you do ordinary at junior cert it doesn't stop you from doing higher at leaving cert in the same subject. Might depend on the school?

douliket · 30/08/2021 15:20

Ahhh just let him drop to ordinary level in the Irish.
If it this much hassle already and he hates the subject, let him do the ordinary rather than waste his time. Let him focus on the subjects he likes.
There is no life lesson here at all.
He never chose to do Irish, it was forced upon him, what do you think you are possibly teaching him by forcing him to waste time doing the higher lever

achara · 30/08/2021 15:15

Just presuming it's Irish. Better to get points in Higher level subjects he likes. Also be careful for some colleges it is a requirement so better to pass lower level and have it so that he has more options.

AChickenCalledDaal · 30/08/2021 15:14

In similar circumstances we pushed for DD2 to sit higher tier GCSE Maths, because in terms of innate ability, she ought to be able to access the higher level grades. But as it turns out, year 11 was pants and maths was even more pants then anything else. If she'd dropped to Foundation, she'd probably have scored one grade higher than she actually did. And since she's heading for solid Arts subjects at A Level, I do wonder if we made the right choice.

If he's going to have a decent range of other subjects, and this one subject isn't going to hold him back, I'd probably let it go.

Swipe left for the next trending thread