Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To teach DS a life lesson or just let it go…

115 replies

Whosthebestbabainalltheworld · 30/08/2021 14:52

DS14 is a capable all-round student, but a bit lazy. He dislikes a particular subject, has decided he doesn’t want to study it and not surprisingly, performed poorly in his summer exam.

Teacher suggests he still aims for higher level in his state exams in 2 years (he could drop to lower level, which is an easier course, but cannot drop the subject entirely). In fact, in our schooling system it’s something he must study until he finishes secondary school (won’t be hard for some to guess the country, but not UK obviously). So once he drops to lower level that’s where he’ll stay for the next 5 years.

My dilemma is this….

Do I agree he can drop levels (despite being capable) or seek to teach him a life lesson - insist he sticks with higher level and pay for extra tuition which he will both hate and resent me for.

I’m torn, please help!

OP posts:
Belleager · 30/08/2021 19:23

The Irish curriculum is quite broad and more strongly based on verbal skills than UK. Assuming this is Irish, OP's son will be studying at least one modern foreign language as well. So it is a good point @AvocadoPlant but probably not the case here.

AvocadoPlant · 30/08/2021 19:11

If it is a MFL then it might not be laziness in his part. At 14 my DD was in top group for Spanish, but dropped down to foundation for GCSE as she just couldn’t “get” it.
At 17 she was diagnosed with slow processing and dyslexia, it made learning foreign language incredibly difficult.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 30/08/2021 19:11

@Anoisagusaris

You only need lower level Irish for the vast majority of university courses so the discussion about it affecting his course choices is not really relevant.
Yes that is true. But doing higher level at JC means ordinary level at LC will be much much easier as much of the basics will have covered at JC. Same for maths.
Anoisagusaris · 30/08/2021 19:02

You only need lower level Irish for the vast majority of university courses so the discussion about it affecting his course choices is not really relevant.

CatsArePeople · 30/08/2021 18:57

He's 14. He can't possibly know what he will need or not later in whatever career pursuits. If he's capable but lazy, maybe he'd be motivated with an offer of some sort of valuable reward for a good grade?

PallasStrand · 30/08/2021 18:29

[quote OchonAgusOchonOh]**@elizabethdraper* - It's a dead, pointless language*

Learning a language is never pointless. The cognitive benefits are well established.

Irish is also very much alive in parts of the country. The increase in popularity in gaelscoileanna and Gael coláistí would also suggest many disagree with you.[/quote]
Absolutely this. My son could have opted out of Irish when he entered the school system in Ireland, but I think Irish is important.

PallasStrand · 30/08/2021 18:28

@ElizaDarcysDeeds

But the OP hasn't said it's Irish or that she's in Ireland. She posted in AIBU not craicnet so it's a bit odd to tell her to ignore posters. It's also odd that you're assuming all other posters are English and in England. Maybe roll back some of your stereotyping Confused
I’m not assuming anything, but after living in England with a child in school there and teaching in English universities for 25 years, I can assure you I got a close-up, warts and all view of attitudes to languages and post-GCSE education.
OchonAgusOchonOh · 30/08/2021 18:18

@elizabethdraper - It's a dead, pointless language

Learning a language is never pointless. The cognitive benefits are well established.

Irish is also very much alive in parts of the country. The increase in popularity in gaelscoileanna and Gael coláistí would also suggest many disagree with you.

Concernedaboutgranny · 30/08/2021 18:18

Also if he needs paid tuition to keep up with the higher level then he's going to be more comfortable at the lower level.

Concernedaboutgranny · 30/08/2021 18:17

I wouldn't pay for tuition for a child who wasnt going to try. The life lesson is that if he doesn't do his best he won't achieve everything he's capable of.

RuggerHug · 30/08/2021 18:16

Echoing what pp said(sorry app acting up) if it's the teacher than you drop them, not the subject. If it's only for 1 or 2 years then a better one I'd pay for grinds in the mean time.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 30/08/2021 18:15

@Getawaywithit - If he wants to do something popular like medicine, psychology. English, veterinary science, he will need a full house of 7/8/9. If he wants to go to college and be a car mechanic, not so much.

No idea what a "full house of 7/8/9" is but he definitely won't be getting them in his LC. Depending on whether it is maths, Irish, English or foreign language, he will either definitely or probably need it to gain entry to any college.

elizabethdraper · 30/08/2021 18:15

It's clearly irish.

It's a dead, pointless language

Let him drop to a lower lower paper. Life is too short to argue over it.

I never passed an Irish test in my life, the stress and fighting it caused in my house wasn't worth it.

My children have a natural grà for the language which is brilliant but I have a total hatred for it

ElizaDarcysDeeds · 30/08/2021 18:11

But the OP hasn't said it's Irish or that she's in Ireland. She posted in AIBU not craicnet so it's a bit odd to tell her to ignore posters. It's also odd that you're assuming all other posters are English and in England. Maybe roll back some of your stereotyping Confused

OchonAgusOchonOh · 30/08/2021 18:11

@gildalily - Life's too short to be stuck studying something you don't enjoy. Let him study at the level he's comfortable at. The only life lesson you'd be teaching him is that you don't value his judgement on what he likes and dislikes. Let him concentrate on what he enjoys doing.

He's a 14 year old boy. It's perfectly possible to value his judgement on what he likes and what he doesn't, while still recognising that he doesn't have the experience or maturity to fully understand the impact on his options in 5 years time.

PallasStrand · 30/08/2021 18:06

OP, I would ignore quite a few of the posts on here from people outside of Ireland. Some seem to encapsulate some of the worst aspects of English education, early specialisation and the idea that studying languages is fundamentally irrelevant and arcane.

godmum56 · 30/08/2021 18:03

[quote Moiraroseswigs]@godmum56 "only in Ireland" is a bit of a sweeping statement, so he shouldn't bother working a bit harder at 14 as he can always emigrate if he wants a career that he ends up not being eligible for? That's a very limiting decision for a 14 year old...[/quote]
no but the world is a big place. Quite a few of the young people I know are doing college or uni level outside of their home country....they aren't rich, have done it with scholarships and so on....If he can't drop the subject in the system he is in then he can't, but I wonder how much effort and money its worth putting in on the chance of achieving it at a highter level?

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 30/08/2021 17:57

I'm a bit torn.

If he's capable of achieving the higher grade, I'd be tempted to push him to take it. But if it's the teacher that's bothering him, then not so much.

I had a decision a little like this in my O levels (back in the dim and distant 80s in the UK) - one subject I should have taken because it fitted with my general pattern and aims, but I loathed the teacher, he was the pits and I had gone from being near the top of the class to almost failing my Y3 exams. So I didn't take it. I was then offered the option to take it in one year in my Lower 6 year - didn't want to, so didn't (the subject had been REALLY tainted for me). Me not taking this one course really affected my ability to comprehend another course, and I had to take a remedial course in it when I started university, doing a course that luckily didn't require it (although it would have been preferable). It also ruled out several degree options by me not having it.

In hindsight it would have been better if I'd dropped a stream level and got a different teacher and carried on with the subject - but at the time I was Done with it.

So if it's the teacher, I'd probably let him downgrade (especially as he isn't allowed to drop it at all) - but if he's just being slack over it, then get him to review what it would mean for his career options moving forward as to whether or not it would be wise to downgrade. IN fact, he should do that reviewing anyway - 2 years of pain as opposed to several years of "FFS, I should have just done it" is probably preferable, even though it doesn't feel like it at the time.

Getawaywithit · 30/08/2021 17:53

So maths or MFL? Much depends on what he wants to do in the future. If he wants to do something popular like medicine, psychology. English, veterinary science, he will need a full house of 7/8/9. If he wants to go to college and be a car mechanic, not so much.

My parents told me that all they wanted for me was to be happy in life and if sweeping the streets was enough for me then that was fine. But they also added that I owed it to myself to be the best qualified street sweeper I could possibly be.

YouMeandtheSpew · 30/08/2021 17:52

I’m not familiar with the Irish education system (assuming you are in Ireland) but in your shoes I’d be very reluctant to allow him to drop to the junior level if he’s fundamentally capable and it could impact on his options and prospects for tertiary education and jobs.

gildalily · 30/08/2021 17:49

Life's too short to be stuck studying something you don't enjoy. Let him study at the level he's comfortable at. The only life lesson you'd be teaching him is that you don't value his judgement on what he likes and dislikes. Let him concentrate on what he enjoys doing.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 30/08/2021 17:45

@LH1987

Is the subject Irish? If so let him drop to ordinary level, it will impact almost no future opportunity for him and if he hates it, it will take focus from other subjects.
I think that's a reasonable argument at leaving cert but the benefit of doing higher level at JC is that it will put you in a very good position for lower level at leaving cert as the standard at lower level LC is not a massive jump from higher level JC. That will allow them to focus more on the subjects they are using for points than if they had done lower level at JC.
RuggerHug · 30/08/2021 17:43

@godmum56

OchonAgusOchonOh "t's irrelevant whether it's valued outside Ireland. It's a requirement for most university courses so he has to do it. Higher level is only required for certain courses (primary teaching). Don't know if the Ceard Teastas is still a thing, but if it is, a decent standard is required for secondary teaching too."

yes but only in Ireland?

So he's to rule out teaching, government jobs, possibly higher points if he does the exams in Irish/just does it in higher level so rules out high point course because 'only in Ireland' ? It's the Irish education system he's in.
OchonAgusOchonOh · 30/08/2021 17:42

@godmum56

OchonAgusOchonOh "t's irrelevant whether it's valued outside Ireland. It's a requirement for most university courses so he has to do it. Higher level is only required for certain courses (primary teaching). Don't know if the Ceard Teastas is still a thing, but if it is, a decent standard is required for secondary teaching too."

yes but only in Ireland?

Given most Irish kids who go on to third level do so in Ireland, the entry requirements for Irish universities, ITs etc are relevant for the leaving cert.
TheWholeJingbang · 30/08/2021 17:42

Is it Irish?

Swipe left for the next trending thread