Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To teach DS a life lesson or just let it go…

115 replies

Whosthebestbabainalltheworld · 30/08/2021 14:52

DS14 is a capable all-round student, but a bit lazy. He dislikes a particular subject, has decided he doesn’t want to study it and not surprisingly, performed poorly in his summer exam.

Teacher suggests he still aims for higher level in his state exams in 2 years (he could drop to lower level, which is an easier course, but cannot drop the subject entirely). In fact, in our schooling system it’s something he must study until he finishes secondary school (won’t be hard for some to guess the country, but not UK obviously). So once he drops to lower level that’s where he’ll stay for the next 5 years.

My dilemma is this….

Do I agree he can drop levels (despite being capable) or seek to teach him a life lesson - insist he sticks with higher level and pay for extra tuition which he will both hate and resent me for.

I’m torn, please help!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SionnachRua · 31/08/2021 20:22

Yerra sure I reckon we understood what you were getting at anyway - was a solid point! Flowers

justmaybenot · 31/08/2021 20:17

@SionnachRua

I agree with you *@justmaybenot* but think you quoted the wrong person Grin
Ha I couldn't figure out how to do it properly - am too hungry! Brónach
SionnachRua · 31/08/2021 20:01

I agree with you @justmaybenot but think you quoted the wrong person Grin

justmaybenot · 31/08/2021 19:55

@Whosthebestbabainalltheworld

I think higher level JC and lower LC is what we’ll aim for.

Will put the grinds money saved into some gin instead. Thanks all.

Yes - I'd aim for HL JC and sure he might enjoy it and go for higher level LC. If Irish colleges are up and running next year he could go and might learn to appreciate the language once he sees it in a more live context.
justmaybenot · 31/08/2021 19:54

@SionnachRua

My whole school experience is mark by my inability to drop irish. I left school 25 years ago and i still have nightmares about leaving cert irish.

While I sympathise with you, you do know that you were taught under a completely different curriculum to modern Irish teaching, right? It's night and day from what it was, certainly primary - can't speak to secondary. There's a real problem in this country with adults projecting their (totally valid) negative experiences with Irish onto their children and predisposing kids to hate Irish. Not saying you're doing that btw, clearly you aren't if your kids like it. But a general observation.

It sounds like you were almost traumatised, but hitting out at the language rather than the way you were taught isn't helpful. It's sort of amazing Irish has survived and I think it's good to learn it if you can - it helps understand hiberno-english, Irish culture and history and it's a beautiful language once you get into it. It might be nice for you to do a beginner's course even just to prove to yourself that you can and so that you can understand more of what your kids are learning - face the fear and put that particular bogeyman to bed!
SionnachRua · 31/08/2021 19:48

My whole school experience is mark by my inability to drop irish. I left school 25 years ago and i still have nightmares about leaving cert irish.

While I sympathise with you, you do know that you were taught under a completely different curriculum to modern Irish teaching, right? It's night and day from what it was, certainly primary - can't speak to secondary. There's a real problem in this country with adults projecting their (totally valid) negative experiences with Irish onto their children and predisposing kids to hate Irish. Not saying you're doing that btw, clearly you aren't if your kids like it. But a general observation.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 31/08/2021 12:00

@elizabethdraper - sounds more like a reflection of the quality of teaching you had. Abuse is not an acceptable teaching approach.

Certainly, some people are not wired for languages. I'm not and struggled similarly with french Interestingly, I am good at Irish, probably because I did the first 4 years of primary in a gaelscoil so got a proper grounding.

A bad experience by some people is not a reason to remove Irish but is instead a reason to look at how it is taught. Early immersion is the best approach.

Whosthebestbabainalltheworld · 31/08/2021 11:47

I think higher level JC and lower LC is what we’ll aim for.

Will put the grinds money saved into some gin instead. Thanks all.

OP posts:
theleafandnotthetree · 31/08/2021 11:14

@Whosthebestbabainalltheworld

It is Irish. Unlikely to ever be necessary for any university course but he’s more than well capable of doing well if only he turned his mind to it. He’s just being bloody minded (he gets that from DH Grin) and bloody lazy.

It really just irks me that he could do well but couldn’t be arsed.

Thanks for the responses though, I guess getting grinds would be like leading a horse to water, but I’ll never make him drink!

I have a 14 year old son and I literally could have written your post. He is currently in an honours class, has done dismally in Irish tests to date but has passed. If there is a normal Junior Cert this year, I hope he'll stick with it for all the reasons given here. But no way will he be doing honours for LC, that would be flogging a dead horse (again with the horse metaphors).
Aprilx · 31/08/2021 11:03

A life lesson would be allowing him to fail and deal with the consequences, not nagging him to try harder and paying for extra tuition. Confused

I can’t see any point in the insisting and tuition for a subject he doesn’t like and won’t need.

Whosthebestbabainalltheworld · 31/08/2021 10:52

It is Irish. Unlikely to ever be necessary for any university course but he’s more than well capable of doing well if only he turned his mind to it. He’s just being bloody minded (he gets that from DH Grin) and bloody lazy.

It really just irks me that he could do well but couldn’t be arsed.

Thanks for the responses though, I guess getting grinds would be like leading a horse to water, but I’ll never make him drink!

OP posts:
elizabethdraper · 31/08/2021 09:42

[quote OchonAgusOchonOh]**@elizabethdraper* - It's a dead, pointless language*

Learning a language is never pointless. The cognitive benefits are well established.

Irish is also very much alive in parts of the country. The increase in popularity in gaelscoileanna and Gael coláistí would also suggest many disagree with you.[/quote]
The cognitive benefits were no beneficial in my case.

They cause years of crying, unable believable stress, being told I stupid at home and school.

Singled in in class for not saying words correctly.

There was mental, emotional abuse.

Not everyone's brain is wired for languages, my children love irish as does their father. As soon as the irish homework comes out i feel the panic, dread and fear.

My 5 year old has more irish than me, he laughs at me because I cant pronounce words correctly.

My whole school experience is mark by my inability to drop irish. I left school 25 years ago and i still have nightmares about leaving cert irish.

RuggerHug · 30/08/2021 22:43

If it is Irish(and OP hasn't confirmed this) you might be able to nudge him into doing honours for JC by saying it's similar standard to ordinary LC. That's what I was told and in grinds for JC when I was really low on confidence I was given a comprehension paper to do, got it and was then told that's a LC paper question. Really gave me the boost that I wasn't shite. If he decides by LC subject choice time that he doesn't need HL he can still have the confidence that he's able to, rather than try to work up a level when it's harder and there's more pressure.

SionnachRua · 30/08/2021 22:08

And look OP, if he gets a low grade at JC level we all know it doesn't matter. If he's genuinely putting in no work it might actually be a wake up call for him - so many kids coast through school and then get a shock when they hit exams. Better to learn that at JC level than LC or later on in college.

justmaybenot · 30/08/2021 21:42

@elizabethdraper

It's clearly irish.

It's a dead, pointless language

Let him drop to a lower lower paper. Life is too short to argue over it.

I never passed an Irish test in my life, the stress and fighting it caused in my house wasn't worth it.

My children have a natural grà for the language which is brilliant but I have a total hatred for it

What an awful thing to say. It's not a dead nor a pointless language, plenty of people use it in daily life and Irish-medium schools are more and more popular and new ones open every year. There are so many young people breathing new life into the language - including young people of colour like Ola Majekodunmi and Zainab Boladale.
fourminutestosavetheworld · 30/08/2021 21:31

Might he get a better grade if he feels confident working at the lower level, than if he languishes at the bottom of the class studying the higher level, not to mention the knock-on affect of his impaired confidence. If he can get a 'good enough' grade at the lower level, for the next stage of his learning, I'd let him drop down and focus his energies on the other subjects.

justmaybenot · 30/08/2021 21:25

@SionnachRua

Kids who dick about and get low grades at the end of 1st year and into 2nd aren't uncommon. I'd keep him at the higher level working hard, you can always reassess it post JC and even after 4th year. Send him to an Irish summer college if it's Irish, will do him the world of good.
I agree with this and would add that at 14 kids aren't mature enough to make decisions like this.

If it's Irish, I think once they're adults most people wish they were stronger in the language. I recently did a refresher Irish course and they are in huge demand for the over-30s.

I started watching TG4 (Irish language TV) with my kids and it helped them get more into it. I'd say be sympathetic rather than harsh, tell him you'll support him to improve to higher level and then reassess after the JC. We went through something similar with a dc and after being annoyed that they weren't putting in the effort we then took a gentler tack and sort of did it together - my dc may still do OL for the Leaving but at least their Irish is far better than it was. So yeah - tell him to do HL for now and that post-JC you'll reassess.

SionnachRua · 30/08/2021 20:33

Kids who dick about and get low grades at the end of 1st year and into 2nd aren't uncommon. I'd keep him at the higher level working hard, you can always reassess it post JC and even after 4th year. Send him to an Irish summer college if it's Irish, will do him the world of good.

Aimee1987 · 30/08/2021 20:24

If it is Ireland were talking about then as far as I recall ( at least this was the case when I did my leaving cert 15 years ago) you only need to pass English, Irish, maths and a foreign language unless you were studying something specifically related to a subject for example maths being needed at higher level for engineering or higher Irish for primary teaching.

Everyone sat at least 7 subjects and had a dud subject that they ignore for the points. If that's still the case let him drop down.

On a side not I hated how language central Irish education is. I was very bright at school (I tutored 2 of my mates through most of junior cert maths) but constantly called a dosser or lay about. My teachers hated me but now matter how much I tried I didnt understand how it was possible to get an A.

I was diagnosed with dyslexia during my PhD. My sister and me were tiered top for maths and bottom for languages. No one thought to question it and that still irritates me to this day.

RuggerHug · 30/08/2021 20:10

@elizabethdraper

It's clearly irish.

It's a dead, pointless language

Let him drop to a lower lower paper. Life is too short to argue over it.

I never passed an Irish test in my life, the stress and fighting it caused in my house wasn't worth it.

My children have a natural grà for the language which is brilliant but I have a total hatred for it

I've never passed an exam in Japanese, Navajo or Urdu. I sure as shit wouldn't call them dead or useless just because I couldn't manage them. Do you honestly tell your DCs you think it's useless they speak their national language ?
HTH1 · 30/08/2021 19:59

Pick your battles. If it will make a difference to his future prospects, make him do it but, if not, let it go.

justmaybenot · 30/08/2021 19:55

Depends on your own attitude to the subject - if it's something you really value or would like him to value then I'd put the extra effort into persuading him and using the subject in daily life a bit more and maybe the extra tuition as a last resort. If you can, sit with him while he does HL homework in it and chat about it. 14 is a bit young to just give up I think and it's really really difficult to go from OL to HL later on.

PallasStrand · 30/08/2021 19:44

@WhatsMyNameGonnaBeNow

Assuming it is the Irish education system, surely he can only be starting 2nd year now if he’s doing state exams in two years. In which case I wouldn’t be too impressed with him trying to set the bar so low at this early stage! It’s one thing if he’s not capable but the feedback from school is that he is and you yourself seem to suggest he just didn’t apply himself for his summer exams. I think I’d want him to try higher level for this year.

I don’t know why you’d consider getting a tutor as a life lesson though. If the point is to punish him it seems a sure fire way to make him even less inclined to work at the subject. Expensive and counterproductive I’d say.

Oh, I thought the OP was going to make him pay for his own grinds, but maybe you’re right, and I’m misinterpreting. I thought the life lesson was going to involve Junior trotting around mowing lawns and doing paper rounds to pay for his Irish tuition. Grin
WhatsMyNameGonnaBeNow · 30/08/2021 19:41

Assuming it is the Irish education system, surely he can only be starting 2nd year now if he’s doing state exams in two years. In which case I wouldn’t be too impressed with him trying to set the bar so low at this early stage! It’s one thing if he’s not capable but the feedback from school is that he is and you yourself seem to suggest he just didn’t apply himself for his summer exams. I think I’d want him to try higher level for this year.

I don’t know why you’d consider getting a tutor as a life lesson though. If the point is to punish him it seems a sure fire way to make him even less inclined to work at the subject. Expensive and counterproductive I’d say.

LH1987 · 30/08/2021 19:35

I detested studying Irish, I saw no point in it and therefore did not excel in it at all. I found every class painful. I managed to attain very high points in leaving certificate, having dropped to ordinary level in Irish after JC. Mind you, also dropped to ordinary level French as well, so probably have a low level of linguistically ability!

I managed a full university education, including masters degree. Life is too short to be spent doing something you find painful!