Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband wouldn't pay the bill for his brothers birthday aibu ?

286 replies

louisargg · 30/08/2021 13:46

Me and my husband plus his brother /wife and their parents went out on Saturday night for brother in laws 40 th birthday.
6 of us altogether.
Bill came to £300 and that was food /drinks.
My husbands parents wanted to pay but brother in law insisted (even tho it was his birthday)
I said to husband give him £150 towards this bill as it's his birthday.
He refused so I said give him something at least.
He said no it was paid for and to leave it.

End of the night I gave £40 to sister in law and told her to give £20 each to the two kids.
Husband went mental saying I went behind his back.

Aibu ?
Should I not have done this ?

OP posts:
Suetully · 30/08/2021 18:50

Why are people so angry that she treated get nephews to £20 each? That was a nice thing to do

because the bil wanted to treat them, it wasn't about the money-it was the gesture. Op undermined it by giving the money although husband going mental is a bit ott but I can see why he was pissed of, it does seem sneaky.

BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand · 30/08/2021 18:48

@tootiredtospeak

I would keep out unless it was my family or I knew they couldn't afford to do that financially.
I disagree. My dad is hard up, but sensible with the money he has so only spends within his means. DH and I are better off than he is by a large margin.

If my dad said to us, "Let me take you out for dinner/pub lunch/whatever, it's my treat", I'd be appalled if my DH said "No, we can afford it more easily than you, let us pay"

Paying or offering money is not always nice or kind. In some circumstances, it's shitting all over someone's pride and generosity, and making them feel small. We pay for most things we do with my dad, it would be awful for him not to be able to feel he could reciprocate occasionally.

RicherThanYew · 30/08/2021 18:46

@BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand Wow, are you always an enormous dick or does it take practice?

UnsuitableHat · 30/08/2021 18:44

Personally I find it irritating when people won’t accept being treated, as in this case - BIL insisted on paying so he obviously wanted to. Your H perhaps felt you were labouring the point somewhat. I think your £40 gift to nephews was quite a nice gesture though. So can see bits of both sides.

Whinginadeville · 30/08/2021 18:39

I can see why OP disabled voting given most responses say she was tone deaf and was actually just trying to make her husband look bad I am guessing 90% Yabu 10% Yanbu 100 % denial from OP

icedcoffees · 30/08/2021 18:39

It wasn't your place to get involved - your DH knows his family dynamics better than you do. I totally understand why he's pissed off.

Notthemessiah · 30/08/2021 18:36

I’d be very annoyed too if DP interfered in the same way in what was purely a matter between my parents, my brother and I. If you had a problem you should have raised it with your husband and not gone behind his back.

In the end, it doesn’t matter what you think OP - it wasn’t your family, so not your business.

BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand · 30/08/2021 18:29

@Blossomtoes

I can't believe people still think they're hosting when they expect others to pay...?

Quite. And priding themselves on throwing other people’s hospitality back in their faces. So rude.

MN makes me realise how many weird people there are out there!
tootiredtospeak · 30/08/2021 18:27

I would keep out unless it was my family or I knew they couldn't afford to do that financially.

cushioncovers · 30/08/2021 18:25

Yabu op you stuck you nose in when it was wasn't needed. Your Bil was happy to pay on this occasion. Next time you and your dh could pay. No need to make a fuss and start giving money out to nephews to make yourself feel better.

BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand · 30/08/2021 18:25

DH and I took everyone to a restaurant on our wedding day (it was a small affair, so not at a venue or anything). We were hosting so we paid in full, and would have been really unhappy if anyone else had tried to. We even got the restaurant to print menus without prices as we didn't want people feeling like they had to choose cheaply.

When we hold a party for people, we know it's going to be expensive, but we want to treat people. It's not a pissing contest, and we accept the same hospitality graciously when our friends or family do similar.

Blossomtoes · 30/08/2021 18:22

I can't believe people still think they're hosting when they expect others to pay...?

Quite. And priding themselves on throwing other people’s hospitality back in their faces. So rude.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 30/08/2021 18:20

*NOT how we do things.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 30/08/2021 18:19

@smallgoon

Where I come from, the person whose birthday it was would never pay, regardless of whether they organised the dinner or not. Can't believe people would think it's ok to go to dinner for somebody's 40th/50th and then not contribute.
Well that's now how we do things. If we want to just go out to dinner then we just say 'shall we meet here if everyone likes it, menu isn't too pricey' - and everyone pays their own. Nobody is hosting, they are just meeting.

If somebody is actually HOSTING (as OP's BIL clearly was) then they pay the bill. It's their choice, he wanted to do that. I pay the bill if I invite people for a meal, I don't pretend to host, I do it.

I can't believe people still think they're hosting when they expect others to pay...?

BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand · 30/08/2021 18:14

It’s absolutely fine, we give money to nieces and nephew all the time.

You don't do it as a passive-aggressive move to make a point and prove that you are "paying your way" though, do you? I treat my nephews and nieces, sure, but not like this.

It's fine to send your nephews some money. It's not fine to tie it to the paying of the bill.

This.

smallgoon · 30/08/2021 18:12

Where I come from, the person whose birthday it was would never pay, regardless of whether they organised the dinner or not. Can't believe people would think it's ok to go to dinner for somebody's 40th/50th and then not contribute.

phishy · 30/08/2021 18:05

@louisargg

So my feelings don't matter? It didn't feel right He didn't want to accept money for the meal so I gave his 2 kids £20 each We don't see each other often so I don't see any issue They were happy and grateful His brother and wife were happy It's just my husband who wasn't And yes he is tight for those asking
It’s absolutely fine, we give money to nieces and nephew all the time.

Your dh is being a twat.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 30/08/2021 18:02

You gave 'the kids' some money to make yourself feel better, justified, a good person, to be seen as a giver not a taker, etc. That is not ready a nice thing, it is wholly selfish.

And your DH reacted to that.

As others have said, it wasn't about you.

saraclara · 30/08/2021 18:02

It's fine to send your nephews some money. It's not fine to tie it to the paying of the bill.

BIL wanted to pay. He meant it, it was his gesture. So no, your feelings don't count, OP. You undermined BIL's gesture by not believing him when he said he wanted to pay.

LalalalalalaLand123 · 30/08/2021 17:50

I don't understand giving SIL £40 for the children......

SergeantCatFlap · 30/08/2021 17:49

Yeah agree with others - YABU and you've made this all about you. But I don't think you're ever going to agree with the thread consensus.

CyclingIsNotOuting · 30/08/2021 17:39

Agree with others, I leave my DH to deal with his side. By offering up cash you undermined his position and made him look tight.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 30/08/2021 17:38

@louisargg

So my feelings don't matter? It didn't feel right He didn't want to accept money for the meal so I gave his 2 kids £20 each We don't see each other often so I don't see any issue They were happy and grateful His brother and wife were happy It's just my husband who wasn't And yes he is tight for those asking
How is this about you? It's nothing whatsoever to do with you. You were just an invited guest at the meal.

You've now decreed that your husband is 'stingy' and you did exactly what you wanted, played 'Lady Bountiful' with a donation to your BIL's children that had nothing to do with the birthday meal. You could have given them that money at any time without making a 'thing' of it.

What you've done is inserted yourself in a family dynamic that you clearly don't understand - have clumsily trampled all of your BIL's nice gesture - and are now all wide-eyed that your husband is angry with you for being so tone deaf.

You think your your husband's brother and wife were grateful; I very much doubt it. They would be thinking WTF? That £40 wasn't in any way a contribution it was just you wanting to show your generosity and put your husband in his place. Really badly done.

Sorry but I'd be really reluctant for you to attend family events in future if that's what you do - and keep banging on that you're in the right. You weren't and you're not.

JustJustWhy · 30/08/2021 17:38

That was a lovely thing for you to do OP. We're big on treating the kids in our family too and if BIL wouldn't take money for the meal that was a really nice gesture.

toomuchlaundry · 30/08/2021 17:38

Seems wrong he had to pay the whole bill for something he hadn't organised