Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband wouldn't pay the bill for his brothers birthday aibu ?

286 replies

louisargg · 30/08/2021 13:46

Me and my husband plus his brother /wife and their parents went out on Saturday night for brother in laws 40 th birthday.
6 of us altogether.
Bill came to £300 and that was food /drinks.
My husbands parents wanted to pay but brother in law insisted (even tho it was his birthday)
I said to husband give him £150 towards this bill as it's his birthday.
He refused so I said give him something at least.
He said no it was paid for and to leave it.

End of the night I gave £40 to sister in law and told her to give £20 each to the two kids.
Husband went mental saying I went behind his back.

Aibu ?
Should I not have done this ?

OP posts:
BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand · 30/08/2021 20:00

The parents will have been polite, whether they were happy or not.

Her husband, who is far more familiar with the dynamics of his family than the OP, was not happy.

phishy · 30/08/2021 19:58

@BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand

It’s absolutely fine, we give money to nieces and nephew all the time.

You don't do it as a passive-aggressive move to make a point and prove that you are "paying your way" though, do you? I treat my nephews and nieces, sure, but not like this.

It's fine to send your nephews some money. It's not fine to tie it to the paying of the bill.

This.

It’s not passive aggressive, giving money to kids is standard in many families, and OP says the kids and parents were both happy. Just believe her!
Blossomtoes · 30/08/2021 19:56

@TeloMere, one of my friends and I have a running joke about this. We have a race to see who can get her purse out fastest. It’s not in the least controlling. It makes us laugh. It’s been an integral part of our friendship for over 40 years now. You’d hate us !

Aprilx · 30/08/2021 19:50

@louisargg

My brother in law wasn't the host. It was my mother in law that organised it. It didn't feel right going out for his birthday and him paying for 6 people.
Maybe it isn’t something you would do, but it really is perfectly normal. Nobody forced BiL to pay the bill, he wanted to, if you had ever done it you would know that it is an enjoyable thing to do.

The bill was sorted, your behaviours was undermining your husband and was weird and embarrassing to boot.

BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand · 30/08/2021 19:41

Tbf, I don't think the OP has clarified whether her DH offered or not? And even if he didn't offer at the table, it may be that a conversation took place separately that she wasn't party to.

Suetully · 30/08/2021 19:40

Oh give over, passive aggressive to pass money on to children! OP was just being generous.
I'm surprised at how many people think its unreasonable to give money to your nieces and nephews, either mumsnet is a very odd place or this is the difference between English and Irish customs, I'm Irish and it's it's a very normal part of our culture to give younger family members money. And offering to pay for half of the meal is just common decency

I am Irish too and no it's not about giving the kids money, it's the fact that it was done to offload their part of the bill which effectively was supposed to be a gift. It undermined the gift/gesture that was from the bil. And yes offering to contribute for the meal is manners, this wasn't really disputed, it was the fact that the host/birthday boy wanted to pay as it was his night but the op undermined it with the gift.

BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand · 30/08/2021 19:40

I'm not worked up at all. Somewhat amused by how riled people have got at my suggestion that thrusting notes at your relatives is not necessarily the pinnacle of polite behaviour! Grin

Plenty of people on this thread get it though - context is everything.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 30/08/2021 19:38

That is a good point, Suetully, I missed that the husband hadn't offered to pay. That said, he might have had a discussion with his brother separately - or they'd made arrangements. Nobody knows, do they?

Either way, this was a faux pas by the OP.

TeloMere · 30/08/2021 19:37

I think some people just can't accept that it's often kinder to allow someone to be generous, and to accept with thanks rather than insist on "paying your way".

My mother has always insisted on being the one who pays, my grandmother was the same. I think it's a control issue.
I can remember dreading the arguments that would ensue when I was a child and we all went out together. They were both determined to be the one to pay everyone's entry fee/restaurant bill etc.
Would really put a damper on what was supposed to be a happy occasion.

WIS76 · 30/08/2021 19:36

@BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand

BIL insisted on paying. He obviously wanted to treat everyone - his choice. But you decided that your DH should undermine BIL on his birthday by overruling him re: paying on his birthday. YABU about that.

What was the reason for giving SIL £20 for each for the kids? Do they have a birthday coming up? Tbh, it's a bit weird. If I wanted to treat my nephews and nieces I'd either give them a nice gift or treat them to a cake/ice cream while we're out. Not shove cash at their parents.

Do you normally feel that you have to throw cash at people in order to be liked? Giving money when it's socially inappropriate to do so isn't being 'nice', it can actually be very manipulative and weird, and it's not clear at all from your post as to what category this falls into.

Good grief calm down hon, do you usually get this worked up about how people you don't know split their dinner bill. Have a nice glass of wine and take a few breaths!
Suetully · 30/08/2021 19:34

*She said the BIL didn’t want the parents to pay but doesn’t say BIL wouldn’t have appreciated his brothers contribution. If her husband is anything like my dad, he lets everyone else pay and doesn’t offer because he’s so tight and it’s really embarassing. My mum has to force him to put his hand in his pocket.

Maybe OP felt embarrassed and only had £40 cash on her and wanted to contribute*

That's a good point but I suppose the problem is we don't know enough. The op I think came back and said her husband was tight but this could have being because she wasn't getting much support in the responses or her 'definition' of tight is out of touch with reality.

I have seen several threads where the op has claimed her husband was 'tight' and 'financially abusive' although it transpired he was just sensible with their money whereby she wasn't. Attitudes towards money are so different sometimes.

Seeingadistance · 30/08/2021 19:32

@snowgecko

YABU. BIL wants to treat you all for his birthday. While you might offer to pay, surely the polite thing to do is then accept gratefully?
This.
BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand · 30/08/2021 19:32

Hosting a party (whether a wedding or a dinner party), or taking your friends/family to a nice restaurant for a celebratory meal, is equivalent to giving your loved ones a gift. The gift is the party/meal, and you want to enjoy it in their company, with no one worrying about the cost.

If someone gave you an expensive physical gift, you wouldn't open it, tot up the cost and offer to give them equivalent cash, would you? Or slip them a backhander as you're leaving? Of course not! Although you would probably plan to get them a lovely gift for their next birthday in return.

So why behave any differently in a restaurant when someone has made it clear they are treating you to celebrate an occasion?

Saoirse82 · 30/08/2021 19:31

@BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand

Maybe we're not all as stingey as you!

I treat people to stuff all the time.

I just don't go out of my way to embarrass people when they want to treat me. Being polite about someone wanting to pay =/= stingy.

The gift for the nephews/nieces in this case was a passive aggressive move, not a kind gesture.

Oh give over, passive aggressive to pass money on to children! OP was just being generous. I'm surprised at how many people think its unreasonable to give money to your nieces and nephews, either mumsnet is a very odd place or this is the difference between English and Irish customs, I'm Irish and it's it's a very normal part of our culture to give younger family members money. And offering to pay for half of the meal is just common decency!
LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 30/08/2021 19:28

Eliatan - Yes - parents offered to pay and OP's husband offered to pay - both were declined by BIL who elected to pay the bill. Parents understood as did the DH. They offered to pay.

He should have been allowed to do that without fuss or fanfare; grateful thanks would have been enough. Not this awkwardness by trying to encroach on BIL's generosity with this manic gifting of random notes.

I expect OP will return to say that she's been told by everybody in her family that she did the right thing but, it wasn't right.

Eilatan2018 · 30/08/2021 19:27

@TeloMere

YABU. Some people get a lot of pleasure spending money on people they love. Your brother in law wanted to treat everyone and you undermined him. And made a fool of yourself.
She said the BIL didn’t want the parents to pay but doesn’t say BIL wouldn’t have appreciated his brothers contribution. If her husband is anything like my dad, he lets everyone else pay and doesn’t offer because he’s so tight and it’s really embarassing. My mum has to force him to put his hand in his pocket.

Maybe OP felt embarrassed and only had £40 cash on her and wanted to contribute!

Annoyedanddissapointed · 30/08/2021 19:26

Mumsnetters need to amend their motto

"No is a complete sentence unless I don't like it then I still do whatever the fuck I want "

Suetully · 30/08/2021 19:26

Context is everything here

oh and can I add social etiquette and norms which the op has broken.

Blossomtoes · 30/08/2021 19:24

@Straighttalking1

You're not being unreasonable but I would have paid the 130. Not going behind DH back (in full view, in front of him). This is a bug bear of mine. I can't stand ppl who expect and accept others paying for their meals.
That would be so rude. If anyone did that to me I’d never forgive them. If it was cash I’d make sure they saw me tip the waiting staff with it.
Suetully · 30/08/2021 19:23

This is a bug bear of mine. I can't stand ppl who expect and accept others paying for their meals

so would you go up to the bride and groom at a wedding and hand them money for the food and drink you consumed at the meal?

Would you go to a dinner party or a friend's for a birthday dinner and give her the money for the meal? Context is everything here.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 30/08/2021 19:23

Soiarse82, why so rude? You don't understand the convention, that's fine but no need to display your ignorance so gratuitously.

You're talking about a completely different thing - giving money to your younger relatives. What has led you to think that others on the thread don't do that also? The only difference is that some of us wouldn't conflate imposing on somebody else's generosity in hosting buy flinging out a bit of money to make a point.

It was badly done. The money wasn't given to the nephews as a generous gift, it was given awkwardly in visible embarrassment and not even by the relative (ie. the uncle), but in a fit of pique by his wife. Awkward and crass and not well intentioned. I would have been highly embarrassed if I'd been the BIL/SIL because that's not how it's done.

BIL should have been thanked and allowed to pay - his birthday, his decision. I think some posters are getting a bit giddy about a scenario of 'paying for the birthday girl'. This is not the same thing at all.

BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand · 30/08/2021 19:22

@Straighttalking1

You're not being unreasonable but I would have paid the 130. Not going behind DH back (in full view, in front of him). This is a bug bear of mine. I can't stand ppl who expect and accept others paying for their meals.
So you've never let anyone treat you to something?

You've never let a friend or family member host at a party, and provide the food and drink?

Really?!

Eilatan2018 · 30/08/2021 19:22

@BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand

BIL insisted on paying. He obviously wanted to treat everyone - his choice. But you decided that your DH should undermine BIL on his birthday by overruling him re: paying on his birthday. YABU about that.

What was the reason for giving SIL £20 for each for the kids? Do they have a birthday coming up? Tbh, it's a bit weird. If I wanted to treat my nephews and nieces I'd either give them a nice gift or treat them to a cake/ice cream while we're out. Not shove cash at their parents.

Do you normally feel that you have to throw cash at people in order to be liked? Giving money when it's socially inappropriate to do so isn't being 'nice', it can actually be very manipulative and weird, and it's not clear at all from your post as to what category this falls into.

How was what OP did weird?! She clearly felt really awkward about BIL paying and wanted to contribute and that was a nice gesture. Yes BIL paid but to be offered half is just polite.
Annoyedanddissapointed · 30/08/2021 19:22

@Straighttalking1

You're not being unreasonable but I would have paid the 130. Not going behind DH back (in full view, in front of him). This is a bug bear of mine. I can't stand ppl who expect and accept others paying for their meals.
How exactly would you pay that to the BIl? Just curious on how can one force money on someone who doesn't want them and not look lile a twat
toomuchlaundry · 30/08/2021 19:21

If we invited my BIL out for a meal to celebrate his birthday, I wouldn't expect him to pick up the tab