Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband wouldn't pay the bill for his brothers birthday aibu ?

286 replies

louisargg · 30/08/2021 13:46

Me and my husband plus his brother /wife and their parents went out on Saturday night for brother in laws 40 th birthday.
6 of us altogether.
Bill came to £300 and that was food /drinks.
My husbands parents wanted to pay but brother in law insisted (even tho it was his birthday)
I said to husband give him £150 towards this bill as it's his birthday.
He refused so I said give him something at least.
He said no it was paid for and to leave it.

End of the night I gave £40 to sister in law and told her to give £20 each to the two kids.
Husband went mental saying I went behind his back.

Aibu ?
Should I not have done this ?

OP posts:
Dnaltocs · 31/08/2021 18:45

Perhaps your husband had already given his brother the money.
Or.
He knows something you don’t.

Next time send flowers the following day to his wife.

Angie1403 · 31/08/2021 18:43

@Miliao

I think this is really odd. If it was my birthday and was treating people to a meal, I’d be mortified if someone tried to slip my partner cash for my children, especially if they’re not my family. Why are you giving his children cash when it’s not their birthday? It’s really strange, especially when your husband, who will know his brother better than you, said not to. If my husband did that I’d be really angry that he went behind my back, it would prove he didn’t listen to me or care about my family.
She IS family though, I do find it irritating that being married to someone, often for many years and being around their siblings and parents enough to know them well still somehow doesn’t qualify you as family (in the eyes of some). I find that quite dismissive. My MiL and all of my DH family bar one person, have always treated myself and my son like blood and we have never considered ourselves to be anything less than that. We know we are loved.
Toomuchtrouble4me · 31/08/2021 18:35

@BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand

BIL insisted on paying. He obviously wanted to treat everyone - his choice. But you decided that your DH should undermine BIL on his birthday by overruling him re: paying on his birthday. YABU about that.

What was the reason for giving SIL £20 for each for the kids? Do they have a birthday coming up? Tbh, it's a bit weird. If I wanted to treat my nephews and nieces I'd either give them a nice gift or treat them to a cake/ice cream while we're out. Not shove cash at their parents.

Do you normally feel that you have to throw cash at people in order to be liked? Giving money when it's socially inappropriate to do so isn't being 'nice', it can actually be very manipulative and weird, and it's not clear at all from your post as to what category this falls into.

Wow! My brother often give my children £££ when he sees them, as fo various aunts and great aunts. I remember jungles giving me cash too. It’s normal, just as it’s normal to offer to split a bill. No manipulation, just a treat for the children of siblings now and then. I find this reaction unnecessarily angry and rather odd.
DespairingHomeowner · 31/08/2021 18:14

@louisargg: I don't think wanted to show some of the kindness your BIL has shown in treating you & your DH by giving a treat your nephews is weird at all!

I come from a culture where it is v normal to always 'treat' younger family members (younger sibs, nephews, young cousins etc) - is there an age difference between your DH & BIL?

Anyway, its done now, its a 1-off and I'd let the brothers sort these sort of things out between themselves. I am sure your nephews will be happy with the end of school hols spending money Smile

smallgoon · 31/08/2021 18:11

@Viviennemary

I think the £40 was a worse insult than giving nothing.
Good for you.
Viviennemary · 31/08/2021 17:59

I think the £40 was a worse insult than giving nothing.

threatmatrix · 31/08/2021 17:58

I find your answer very rude. I always give kids money. It’s traditional in my circles.

Localocal · 31/08/2021 17:54

As it was BILs birthday and he wanted to pay you should have let him pay with a simple thank you.

Blossomtoes · 31/08/2021 17:47

@Margerine78

Your husband is being tight and controlling OP. Sorry to be blunt but can't see it any other way!
Try reading the thread. You might see the light.
Margerine78 · 31/08/2021 17:39

Your husband is being tight and controlling OP. Sorry to be blunt but can't see it any other way!

CostaBlancaChica · 31/08/2021 17:33

You really overstepped. I'd never get involved with DP and his family dynamic in that situation. If anyone saw you discussing it, you are embarrassing your husband in front of his family
and making it clear you think he's tight. They're HIS family at the end of the day. If my DP did this with my family, I'd be angry too. You should have stayed out of it. Not your place, at all.

littlefireseverywhere · 31/08/2021 17:26

I agree, slightly odd re payments. However I don't get involved with payments for meals or presents or arrangments for visits with his family and similarly I sort out mine. Makes it much easier all round.

shinynewapple21 · 30/08/2021 22:16

@ActonSquirrel

What?!

I often take family out for my birthday, I can afford it.

If my husbands wife gave me £40 when the bill was £300 I'd think it weirder and ruder than being given nothing especially if I had insisted on paying.

Since when is it weird to pay for your own birthday. Do you ask guests to pay for your kids party food and activities or do you pay them as the host.

I agree. Such a weird thing for the OP to do .

Confusedandshaken · 30/08/2021 22:16

@MrsSkylerWhite

Oh I do, phishy.

I just put it badly.

I mean the original question is pointless unless we all know each party’s financial circumstances.

It's irrelevant in this situation. The BIL said he wanted to pay for everyone and did. We don't know of that was a shed load of money to him or a drop in the ocean. It's none of our business either. He is a grown man and can spend his money how he chooses.
Plumtree391 · 30/08/2021 20:35

Your brother in law insisted on paying for his birthday meal which is why your husband didn't feel he should chip in. He knows his brother, understands the dynamics.

When it's your husband's turn, he can pay for everyone.

It was very nice of you to give your sister in law some money for the children. They will appreciate that.

phishy · 30/08/2021 20:32

If you try an ‘us’ versus ‘you’ defence, then expect to get that reaction Lime. It’s like you want a clique.

MrsSkylerWhite · 30/08/2021 20:32

Oh I do, phishy.

I just put it badly.

I mean the original question is pointless unless we all know each party’s financial circumstances.

BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand · 30/08/2021 20:31

It is unikely that the others didn't pick up on the fact that the OP had been telling her DH to pay £150 after the BIL had already paid. Even if it was done in hushed words and pointed glances. The BIL and his wife will have been perfectly polite about it, but they'll have sussed out the motivation for the gift.

The OP has now made clear that BIL paid the bill before anyone else even had a chance to offer. If someone does that, it's because they really wanted to. So accept the gesture, say thank you, and make sure you treat them next time.

LimeRedBanana · 30/08/2021 20:30

I’m perfectly calm, you’re the one throwing ‘pathetic’ and ‘don’t even attempt it’ around on a MN thread about paying for a birthday dinner.

phishy · 30/08/2021 20:29

@MrsSkylerWhite

phishy

MrsSkylerWhite
Those saying YANBU have no idea of each family unit’s financial circumstances.
But those saying YABU do?

No.
Silly question, really, unless everyone does : whatever their point of view

I have no idea what you’re on about, and I don’t you do either.
phishy · 30/08/2021 20:28

@LimeRedBanana

But you’re doing the same thing - I’m not ‘missing anything’ any more than you are. We simply disagree.

No need to worked up - it’s just a thread on Mumsnet. Confused

Actually you were the one who told me I was missing something. You just don’t want to be told the same thing.

And the confused emoji is a sure sign you’re getting worked up, so go have a Wine and calm down.

MrsSkylerWhite · 30/08/2021 20:28

phishy

MrsSkylerWhite
Those saying YANBU have no idea of each family unit’s financial circumstances.
But those saying YABU do?

No.
Silly question, really, unless everyone does : whatever their point of view

ActonSquirrel · 30/08/2021 20:28

Husbands wife?! Jeez husbands sister I meant

ActonSquirrel · 30/08/2021 20:27

What?!

I often take family out for my birthday, I can afford it.

If my husbands wife gave me £40 when the bill was £300 I'd think it weirder and ruder than being given nothing especially if I had insisted on paying.

Since when is it weird to pay for your own birthday. Do you ask guests to pay for your kids party food and activities or do you pay them as the host.

LimeRedBanana · 30/08/2021 20:27

But you’re doing the same thing - I’m not ‘missing anything’ any more than you are. We simply disagree.

No need to worked up - it’s just a thread on Mumsnet. Confused