Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU about clearing the table before everyone has finished?

145 replies

StayOrGoOrWhat · 30/08/2021 13:26

My youngest DD, aged 3, tends to eat more slowly than the rest of us and if she realises that we’ve all finished, she stops eating. So once we are done, we remain seated with our plates there and just chat until she has finished.

When we are at my DMs or she is at ours, as soon as anyone has finished she starts collecting plates up and taking them into the kitchen. It drives me mad! She’s even been known to bring dessert in whilst DD is still eating and is then surprised when she abandons her food in favour of cake.

I’ve asked her not to and she has improved but it seems like some kind of compulsion to start piling plates before we are all done and it is driving me mad! Made me remember how when I was younger, DF would still be eating and have had the entire table cleared around him. So, AIBU to think that’s it’s just not great manners to clear up before everyone is finished?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
aSofaNearYou · 31/08/2021 23:04

@HintofVintagePink

It’s awful manners and I disagree with PP who said people don’t follow etiquette in their own homes.

If children cannot practice good manners at home then where are they meant to learn them?

I’d ask her to please stop clearing the table until everyone has finished eating.

If someone did this to me after I had cooked for them and was about to do the washing up while they sat back and relaxed, I would tell them to bloody do it themselves. Ok in your own home when you are the one doing the drudge work, but incredibly rude otherwise.
Hydrate · 31/08/2021 22:35

Yanbu, she is being rude. Sounds like she was not taught table manners, but never too late to learn.

TwoLeftElbows · 31/08/2021 21:54

When it's your own home, keep doing as your husband has done. I think you can also say something like "we're teaching DD to wait for others at the table so we like to wait for her too." However I'd let it go completely when you're in her home.

HintofVintagePink · 31/08/2021 21:34

It’s awful manners and I disagree with PP who said people don’t follow etiquette in their own homes.

If children cannot practice good manners at home then where are they meant to learn them?

I’d ask her to please stop clearing the table until everyone has finished eating.

KingdomScrolls · 31/08/2021 21:30

I hate this, some people wolf their food down and admittedly I'm a slower eater (maybe because I won't talk with my mouth full, don't shovel food in with one hand and like to engage in conversation over dinner...) , my brother takes his plate out and then doesn't even come back to the table, it's so rude and not how we were raised at all

MargosKaftan · 31/08/2021 21:17

I think if your mum is an ex nurse, you can appeal to that.

So say to her you really need dd to eat a balanced diet without making a big fuss. That she eats slowly, but if she stops too soon and moves onto pudding, she'll fill up on that or be asking for treats later.

That your mum needs to help you not signal to dd that the meal is over by clearing plates at all, not just not moving them to the kitchen, no stacking up. If dd thinks meal time is over, even if she's still hungry she will stop eating then want cake /junk, as a nurse, your mum must think you are doing the right thing to encourage eating meat and veg, not cake. Please can she help you. It might be boring for the adults, but hopefully dd will speed up as she gets older.

StayOrGoOrWhat · 31/08/2021 20:56

@SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius you’re right, it doesn’t matter as a one off at all if she doesn’t finish. I’m also not one for holding back pudding if the main course hasn’t been eaten but we don’t always have a pudding at all. It’s more just that she’s out off easily if the rest of us wander off so makes sense in my mind to just hang fire to give her a chance to eat. I’m sure she will grow out of it as she gets older.

OP posts:
Chicchicchicchiclana · 31/08/2021 19:28

@liveforsummer - I know. I was just making an additional observation, hence "can I add".

liveforsummer · 31/08/2021 18:46

@Chicchicchicchiclana

Can I add to this hosts at a dinner party loading/unloading dishwasher and cleaning up while guests are still there having coffee etc.
This is a toddler eating at her grannies though. Not a dinner party. Full etiquette needn't be followed and as an occasional treat cake before main is finished isn't the end of the world!
Chicchicchicchiclana · 31/08/2021 18:31

Can I add to this hosts at a dinner party loading/unloading dishwasher and cleaning up while guests are still there having coffee etc.

lottiegarbanzo · 31/08/2021 17:57

Stacking plates at the table is pretty unpleasant too, especially if any scraping is involved.

As for people sitting silently staring at you while you eat @aSofaNearYou Where are their conversational skills? Their manners?

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 31/08/2021 17:54

[quote StayOrGoOrWhat]@SukonthaM yes, from looking at the responses, people really do this. Sorry to hear you think I’m miserable and controlling for wanting my 3 year old to not shove her plate to one side because everyone else has finished. Hopefully she will grow out of it and be happy to continue even when she realises we have finished and then I can be less ‘miserable’ at the table.

I personally think it’s more miserable that people want to hurry their family members along when they need a few extra minutes.[/quote]
Just a thought, but if she pushes her plate aside and doesn’t finish her main course, before she gets her dessert sometimes, would that be the end of the world? If she had had enough when she stopped, she’ll eat her pudding and be fine. If she hasn’t eaten enough main course, maybe she will feel hungry later - and that is a natural consequence for her not finishing her mains - and you can tell her “If you had finished your dinner, you wouldn't be hungry now. Next time, eat up your dinner before you have pudding”.

She won’t starve to death if she doesn’t eat enough of her dinner occasionally - if she is really hungry later on, she could have an apple or a drink of milk.

Zombiemum1946 · 31/08/2021 17:51

It's bad manners. If its at her house I would probably just let it go, but not at your own house. I think all you can do is keep reminding her to wait till dd has finished. It's better for her stomach to eat at her pace, it helps to give her stomach time to realise the foods there. We don't usually bother with pudding . My mother didn't bother much with puddings till she had grandkids, constantly told us we had to be careful of our teeth and to not get fat. Caught her buying chocolate fudge breakfast cereal for my son when he was 5yr.

lottiegarbanzo · 31/08/2021 17:50

As a rule, it is bad manners to clear plates before everyone has finished. You're supposed to be eating together, as a social experience. Clearing plates rushes people, which is rude and inhospitable - and why are the clearers not taking part in the conversation, the social experience, themselves? Absenting themselves from the table mid-course is as rude as taking the plates away (unless they have some complex prep to do for the next course). It's a statement that they're bored of the company and conversation and cannot wait to get away.

There are those children who can take an hour to eat half a sandwich though... But in that case you're not so much clearing around them as giving them their own special meal extension.

Cam22 · 31/08/2021 17:38

@whatbigfeet

My mum and stepdad clear plates whilst others are still eating. They even take away dishes of veg etc that are left in the table for sharing, despite people not having finished. Then immediately you get a dessert, before your main course has gone down.

I really really hate it. It seems so rude but I think it's an old fashioned thing?

No it’s not. It simply shows a complete ignorance of dining etiquette.
Cam22 · 31/08/2021 17:37

It is good manners to wait for everyone to be served before starting to eat and also waiting for everyone to have finished before clearing the plates.

Plates should be carried away at the end of a meal. They should never be “scraped” at the table.

aSofaNearYou · 31/08/2021 17:28

I honestly find it strange that so many of the slow eaters on here actively prefer the idea of everyone sitting around watching them eat once they've finished. I'd much rather they just got up and drifted off rather than watch me. I understand how it could be annoying if people were taking the communal food dishes away, trying to take your plate from you, or doing it with an attitude that made it clear they were impatient and annoyed you were still eating. But I've never known anyone do that. Just casually starting to clean up would be by far preferable to me over a group of people watching me eat, waiting...

starrynight87 · 31/08/2021 16:47

It's rude, I eat slowly and I hate people fussing about.

liveforsummer · 31/08/2021 16:44

Well it's not correct etiquette but who follows all of that in their own home anyway? It's her house and she's kindly cooked you a meal. Not the end of the world if dd doesn't finish every meal there (how often are you eating there anyway). Like you say it's like a compulsion so a habit hard for her to break.

whatbigfeet · 31/08/2021 14:51

My mum and stepdad clear plates whilst others are still eating. They even take away dishes of veg etc that are left in the table for sharing, despite people not having finished. Then immediately you get a dessert, before your main course has gone down.

I really really hate it. It seems so rude but I think it's an old fashioned thing?

5foot5 · 31/08/2021 12:52

I would be very annoyed if anyone tried to talk to me while I was eating. I can talk to someone, or concentrate on tasting my food. If my brain is forced to focus on conversation, my food will pass through my mouth without being tasted.

It's not a solution to switch between the two every 30 seconds, a break in concentration in either activity means my brain is not in the same state when I return to it.

@RandomLondoner sorry but I think it is you who is a bit unusual in this case. For most people I think mealtimes are seen as social gatherings where conversation while eating is enjoyable and to be expected.

Feelingmardy · 31/08/2021 11:03

@TwinsandTrifle

If it's a few extra minutes OP, then of course MIL is being unreasonable.

We're not talking big social occasions though, or even the big family sit down dinner of the day. Which is what a lot of posters are acting as if it is.

We all know the rules for an adult dinner. Wait for everyone to be served. Eat. Clear away only when everyone finished. But then adults know that if they're the only person still nursing their starter at a table ten minutes after everyone has finished, then they are equally rude in holding the whole table up from their next course. So it doesn't tend to happen. Maybe uniquely at Christmas, but we're not talking about that.

DH eats quickly. He's always finished a couple of minutes earlier. Elder DS bangs on and on and on, and would take an hour to clear his plate if we didn't literally tell him, stop talking and eat your food (he has ADHD). DTwin boy eats about the same rate as me. DTwin girl will eat one pea at a time. She is careful, considered, examines her food, chews at an excruciatingly slow pace. Our family does not have time to sit and wait for her to behave like this.

We will sometimes get up and leave her to eat. Funnily enough she then does speed up, because she needs to understand (and not learn) that she can't control 4 other people doing nothing for an hour because she's mousing her way through a cheese sandwich and we can't move in the name of manners. She also learns that finishing food in a timely manner means being allowed to get down from the table and back to colouring. Hence we allow her brother to do this, to try and speed her up with incentive.

Again though, OP, if this is four or five minutes, your MIL can wait.

Absolutely agree . We had friend's kids round and they didn't actually really eat when everyone else did. One mouthful then put down fork for 5 minutes. Usually you should wait but in this instance the slow water was being rude. They were kids so I don't hold it against them but they do need to learn to actually eat at dinner.
TwinsandTrifle · 31/08/2021 10:57

It also depends why the girl is slow. Girl twin picks tiny mouthfuls. Sits and holds the next mouthful, looking at it for an eternity until the 200 times she's chewed the previous one is over. It's the pace she goes at when we're all sat there. It's almost like she's people watching, she likes watching us eat, and is far more engaged by being at the table, as opposed to eating at the the table. I continually prompt her. However, the moment we get boy twin down (because he's 1.5yrs and can't sit there indefinitely watching her eat, without getting upset that he's got no food left) suddenly the girl twin has the miraculous power to eat properly, in order to finish her food and be let down to play as well.

This isn't acceptable. If I allowed her to eat how she pleased, we'd all be sitting there for an hour every lunch as she picked over an omelette that boy twin would have finished 50 minutes prior.

It's so unbelievably irritating, and I find far worse manners to hold people up ( unless an occasion meal where it's expected to be an extended affair, Christmas, Easter) because "that's the speed I like to eat, so you can all sit and watch me take as long as I like"

All this suggesting that the only alternative to eating so slowly it's rude and inconsiderate, is ramming food in at such a rate that it's just pig like gobbling, in silence, frankly sounds a bit stupid. That's obviously not what people mean.

If you're always the last to finish, by some time, and (yes someone has to be first and last, clearly again that's not the point) everyone else finished around the same time, then you need to accept you are holding everyone up, and look at how you can address that. Because they're eating at a normal speed, they're not gannets, they're normal. It's like being stuck behind a slow walker with no way to get round them.

randomsabreuse · 31/08/2021 09:35

The "rules" are different when you have young children around. They have to learn how to eat "nicely". Once they can and can understand different rules for different contexts then the rules get relaxed again.

We had a big issue with DD (who is very active and quite thin) tending to flit away from the table and still have issues with remaining sitting properly on her seat rather than hassling her brother or messing around so much she falls off. So we tend to be strict about sitting and remaining sat down until we have fewer risks of concussion... We did consider the "leave table, no more food" option but given weight concerns and that she actually likes plain bread more than most dinners🙈 we decided this was counter productive.

Other families might have other mealtime concerns - all children are different.

We also expect DC to not spend the entire mealtime chatting (and therefore not eating) because we don't want ridiculously slow eating either.

Yep, we are middle class and take the view that knowing "fancy" table manners is a useful life skill, as is eating standing up or at a picnic without wearing most of the food!

aSofaNearYou · 31/08/2021 09:15

@Pallisers

yes people do act like this in their own homes. They wait till everyone is finished before clearing the table. It is a thing. most people consider it good manners.

As for your drama of "a verbal warning " like it was a police warning and " "complaining about her on a public forum" as if it was naming and shaming on twitter. get a grip. Do you realise you did the same when you were talking shit about the OP just now?

I think you're wrong that "most people" do this tbh. Maybe once, but MN is filled with a certain type of demographic. Out in the real world I've never known anyone below middle age (and non middle class) have any kind of strong belief in these rules.