Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to get married to a 37 year old man when I just turned 22?

437 replies

ConeyIsland23 · 30/08/2021 12:28

I am 22 and my boyfriend is 37. He proposed. We are deeply in love. But I am unsure about the long term complications of our age gap after speaking to my parents. Could someone with a similar age gap tell me about the pros and cons? Are we doomed? Do you regret the age gap? Also we will be trying for kids once we are married.

OP posts:
OnlyFantastic · 30/08/2021 19:00

As others have said, the age difference will probably seem more as time passes.

I'm 35. I can't even imagine going out with a 50 year old now. 50 year old men are almost a different generation and totally not attractive to me.

However - I don't think at 22 I'd have dated a 37 year old either so maybe it just won't be an issue for you, where it would for others.

Mulletsaremisunderstood · 30/08/2021 18:53

MakingmeaCake

It is possible that men or women of 37 are not weird because they have not met Miss Right and are not married, divorced or anything in between.

I agree, I'm 37 and never married, so obviously I don't see it as a red flag. However, I'm not pursuing a relationship with someone 15 years younger.

Of course it's not automatically a bad thing, but what people are pointing out (some through bitter experience) that he may well be doing that because women his own age won't put up with his bullshit.

Feelingoktoday · 30/08/2021 18:52

At 22, a 37 year old is fine;
At 37, he will be 52.
At 52, he will be 67.

I’m 55, 67 year old men (and women) are physically a lot older than the 15 year gap at 22. I would not date a 67 year old man.

whatcangowrong · 30/08/2021 18:49

You will miss out on all the fun and freedom of your youth

MakingmeaCake · 30/08/2021 18:44

Never been married - has he had a long term relationship? Doesn't sound like he's got much relationship experience which he should have at his age that in itself is a potential red flag

MN is laughable at times.

So you ask if he's been married @Graphista and without knowing the answer, you say he can't have had much relationship experience.
How do you get to that theory?

On the one hand, if he was divorced with 4 kids at 37, there would be a red flag.

Being single at the terribly old age of 37 after pursuing a very demanding career (doctor) is also a red flag.

WTF?

It is possible that men or women of 37 are not weird because they have not met Miss Right and are not married, divorced or anything in between.

All this doom and gloom about being someone's carer...
you don't know how things will pan out.

If people are meant to be, as a couple, why not have 40 good years together or more, and take whatever happens when they reach older age?

People become carers at all kinds of ages, it's not exclusive to older age. And some elderly people never need a carer- they just die.

supersop60 · 30/08/2021 18:14

If you both want kids, that's one potential complication out of the way. That could go either way - a) the older partner desperate for kids and the younger one wanting to wait, OR b) the older one not wanting kids and the younger one is eager. Time is not on your side in those cases.
Mostly I'd agree with pp - if you are in love and ready to make a commitment, then fine, and I hope your love and the 'sickness and health' bit carries you through when you're 55 and he's 70.

Graphista · 30/08/2021 18:09

How long have you been together?

The age gap is less of an issue now, it'll become more of an issue when you're older so you need to consider that.

He won't just be older, he'll likely be less fit and well as you too.

In ANY relationship you need to have shared values, goals and things like sense of humour

In terms of your age now you're only 2 years older than my dd and she changes her views on major issues weekly! I look back at how I was in my 20's and I changed Soooo much in that decade.

I married around the same age to someone only a year older and very much regret it. Obviously the age gap wasn't an issue but with hindsight it was a mistake, I didn't know myself well enough let alone him!

IF you are meant to be together waiting 5-10 years will make no difference whatsoever and there's no rush to have dc unless there are fertility issues

Never been married - has he had a long term relationship? Doesn't sound like he's got much relationship experience which he should have at his age that in itself is a potential red flag

I know couples in successful age gap relationships BUT they met when the younger was in their mid 30's or older and had some life experience and knew what they were looking for in a relationship and had the confidence to not put up with crappy treatment and to spot red flags

At 22 most people are still pretty clueless tbh

MrsLargeEmbodied · 30/08/2021 18:08

no rush op.

give it another 3 years

Mulletsaremisunderstood · 30/08/2021 18:08

What if you got engaged, but said you didn't want to get married until you were 25? That would be a pretty reasonable request given your age.

It would allow you to establish your own career, mature a bit and get to know him more. You'd still have plenty of time to build a life together.

Most people on here aren't saying dump him, just why the rush into marriage?

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 30/08/2021 18:05

I don't think age gap is really the issue.
If he's a lovely bloke who just hadn't met the right person until you came along, then fab.
If he's very settled in his life pattern and is expecting you to just fit into it, then maybe think quite a lot harder about it too.
If he still lives with his parents... only half joking, it depends on whether he's a functional adult in the home or not!

Does he own his own place? Does he look after it properly?

My parents had a 10y age gap. I know that's not as much as 15, but my mum was the same age as you when they got married. They were married 42 years before she sadly died, but I wouldn't say it was the happiest of relationships - they had some differing attitudes and rubbed each other up the wrong way quite a lot! - but they did stay together and Dad was pretty devastated when she died.

Thing is, I don't think it really matters about other people's experiences, because they're all different people. If you believe that he is a good man, who can pull his weight in the house as well as at work, and who will support you in both career and motherhood then go for it. If you have doubts about his abilities in the home - well, maybe think harder, as I said before.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 30/08/2021 18:05

At 37 and in medicine he is probably at a very busy stage of his career. He probably can't do much exploring and experimenting and travelling and adventuring. You're not going to be off together doing volunteering in Africa or anything like that? And he knows that if you do that without him you will probably outgrow him.

I'm getting a bit of a sense that maybe he wants to marry you now and start a family now as a way of pinning you down. Sure, at his age a family would be something he wants and also something to keep you busy and emotionally engaged at home. But is that really best for you?

You would be missing out, because you have plenty of time to do that adventuring now before you settle down with a family. And if having a family young is really what you want to do for your own sake, then it might still be better to be with a man of a similar age who might also want to go adventuring when the children are older. Your DH-to-be- might be all done with that already.

Forgothowmuchlhatehomeschoolin · 30/08/2021 18:05

My friend and her dh have got a 15 year age gap and it works well - only thing is by the time they met he had already had 3 kids and didn't want any more but if that side of things isn't an issue then go for it!

MakingmeaCake · 30/08/2021 17:54

@Cirin

It's fine for now.

The issues come in a few years. When you're 32 and he's 47, and he sighs and rolls his eyes at everything you do being 'immature'. When you're 35 but he's 50, and all he wants to talk about is retirement. Can't go on holiday, think of retirement. Can't take a day trip. Can't go to dinner. Got to save. Be responsible. Stop being so short sighted and immature.

It's a problem because he'll have done things, travelled, lived life. He has stories and memories of a life well lived before he settled down. You don't. You've done nothing yet. And don't think for a minute you'll get to do them. He won't go with you again - he'll just tell you none of it's really worth it. You should stay at home, be quiet, put aside silly dreams of travel or adventure or moving home or anything.

It's fine now. It's just not in ten years.

Is this your experience @Cirin?

You have known some dull men if that's how you think.

Your post is amazing in the way it's so unlike any 50, 60 or even 70 year olds I know! They are living life to the full.

Many men at 50 are at the peak of their careers and love work.

You also seem incredibly ageist in your opinions of men .

lottiegarbanzo · 30/08/2021 17:54

Mostly, I would not advise anyone to get married at 22. People mature so much and gain so much confidence through their 20s. The 'straight out of university' relationships often crumble 5-15 years later, when both parties realise they have become quite different people to the ones they were at 22.

In your case, that will be you. You could find you outgrow him, or grow in a different direction.

He might easily change from dynamic, energetic youngish man, to grumpy, insular middle aged man, within that same 5-15 years. Many do.

1WayOrAnother2 · 30/08/2021 17:53

The age gap is unlikely to work in your favour - but you might be able to overcome it if you are both the right people to adapt to the divisions it creates. (It won't be easy to overcome if only one of you is doing the adapting.

I agree with the post above. There are many possible divisions between any couple and talking through the list is a good idea. Again, if one of you is quietly compromising through the discussion - then probably things will fall apart in the future.

Before you get married discuss many things about your future not just about your love for each other. Include:
Bucket lists
Dream home
Careers
Education
Political views
Bills
Parenting styles
Credit
Debt
Religion
How to deal with family
What beliefs will be instilled in your children
Childhood trauma
Sexual expectations
Mental health history
Family health history
etc.

Once you have started talking - keep going.

MakingmeaCake · 30/08/2021 17:52

I find it quite shallow and also negative when posters suggest that this age gap can mean the OP will become his carer, or they may be retiring at different ages.

Who's to say she won't get ill and need care?

Who's to say if he retired at 60 or 65, they wouldn't be able to retire together? Very few couples retire in unison in my experience. Often by the time the man is his 60s they have built up enough savings and pension to both retire.

No one knows what the future holds. I've seen friends and people I know of, widowed (either way- wife or husband dies young ish) in ways no one could have expected. I have known women widowed at 35 when their DH's the same age died.

I have a friend who, at around 50, married for the first time to a widower who was 70. I think their attitude was, grab what you can when you can.

It's more about how emotionally mature the OP is and what they each want out of life.

She's not come back so there are lots of unanswered questions about the length of their relationship etc. I'd be worried a 37 yr old wanted to rush a 22 year old into marriage because he ought to recognise she might have some maturing to do before making such a big decision, but who knows?

Cirin · 30/08/2021 17:52

Oh yeah, and at 22 chances are you're going to be financially dependent on him, which is a long way of saying 'utterly fucked' if he pulls the plug.

Cirin · 30/08/2021 17:50

It's fine for now.

The issues come in a few years. When you're 32 and he's 47, and he sighs and rolls his eyes at everything you do being 'immature'. When you're 35 but he's 50, and all he wants to talk about is retirement. Can't go on holiday, think of retirement. Can't take a day trip. Can't go to dinner. Got to save. Be responsible. Stop being so short sighted and immature.

It's a problem because he'll have done things, travelled, lived life. He has stories and memories of a life well lived before he settled down. You don't. You've done nothing yet. And don't think for a minute you'll get to do them. He won't go with you again - he'll just tell you none of it's really worth it. You should stay at home, be quiet, put aside silly dreams of travel or adventure or moving home or anything.

It's fine now. It's just not in ten years.

Zaane · 30/08/2021 17:50

I am going against the grain and saying, go for it! Chances are you will have a good few decades together. I like your plan to have kids early and when they are in school you can go back or start a new career, it will be continuous with no breaks for having kids. I don't agree with people suggesting you take time to build a career if you want to be a stay at home mum for a good few years. I'd take a mature man with an established career anyday.

lottiegarbanzo · 30/08/2021 17:50

If you don't establish a decent career before having children, it will be much harder during or afterwards.

You could end up with a difficult dynamic and financial situation, whereby you're a SAHM or earning little until your mid-40s, at which point he starts thinking about retirement.

If you don't have a solid career established first, which you can carry on working in PT if you wish / go back to post DC, you'll either end up slogging through low paid work for 20 years to top up his one-person pension, while he enjoys a life of leisured retirement, or you'll both be eaking out that inadequate pension together for the rest of your lives, or you'll break up, he'll have his pension and you'll be living off your low-paid earnings. Not fun.

There is nothing romantic about making yourself financially dependent on other person for the rest of your life.

Franklyfrost · 30/08/2021 17:49

Also, I got married young. Have a long engagement, at least 3 years.

Franklyfrost · 30/08/2021 17:48

My parents have a 14 year age gap. The older one is now very unwell but was always the fitter of the two. The younger one seems to have aged faster living with someone older than them although they could theoretically be fitter/ more active. They love each other so that’s good. Younger one is a bit useless- older one does all the practical stuff.

Regularsizedrudy · 30/08/2021 17:48

I wouldn’t marry anyone when I was 22. It’s so young. Why can’t you just date for a while? Surely you can’t have been together that long?

Brainwave89 · 30/08/2021 17:46

In my case, my DH is ten years younger than me. Let me be honest, this is a complication. I would expect to die earlier, I will be returned earlier, and he may spend some time looking after me. All these however are ifs buts and maybes. We are fine, have been together more than 20 years, have two great DC and I would not swop him for the world. IMO, all relationships have pluses and minuses. The age gap will be a minus, but if he makes you happy (and think carefully if he does), then that shoudl be it

lottiegarbanzo · 30/08/2021 17:42

It's not so much the gap, it's that you're very young and will have little to no independent means of support (probably, unless a prodigy or an heiress) to fall back upon, if things go wrong.

Give it five years. Establish yourself in a career and in life. If you still want to marry him and have kids at that point, do it.

If you find you don't, you'd both still be of an age to find other partners (given the different biological clocks of men and women), to marry and have kids with. 27 would still be really young and give you a good five years in hand, to find the right man at leisure, not in a rush and get to the starting a family stage. He could do this at any time in his 40s.