Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to get married to a 37 year old man when I just turned 22?

437 replies

ConeyIsland23 · 30/08/2021 12:28

I am 22 and my boyfriend is 37. He proposed. We are deeply in love. But I am unsure about the long term complications of our age gap after speaking to my parents. Could someone with a similar age gap tell me about the pros and cons? Are we doomed? Do you regret the age gap? Also we will be trying for kids once we are married.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Oblomov21 · 05/09/2021 08:48

I think if I was a 37 year old man, the age difference between me and a 22 young woman would be too much.

I can appreciate the concern.

EmeraldRaine · 05/09/2021 08:43

I can see what he gets out of dating a 22 year old but he's so old compared to you!

MrsIsobelCrawley · 05/09/2021 08:41

One reason a 37 year-old men would choose a 22 year-old partner is because the younger woman is more easily controlled.

Why do you need to marry? Is it because he wants to exert control?

fridgepants · 05/09/2021 08:27

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the user's request.

Pippa12 · 04/09/2021 09:15

Is this a doctor/nurse relationship by any chance? Boy have I seen a few of those crash and blow in my time…

I think you should definitely be together if that’s what you want. Plenty of good examples between couples with big age gaps and if you don’t try you’ll truly never know. Set a date for your wedding in a couple of years time, and enjoy time getting to know one another properly.

My very wise mother always says never comment on to be weds… they can always get divorced Shock

WhatAShilohPitt · 04/09/2021 00:22

*60 or 70!

WhatAShilohPitt · 04/09/2021 00:21

22 is young to get married, no matter how old / young he is. What’s the big rush? How long have you been together? I’d take a little longer to make sure that you’re doing the right thing. I’m nothing like the person I was at 22. Even at 30, my ideas about what I wanted in a partner were radically different. That’s not to say it won’t work but you have absolutely nothing to risk by waiting a couple of years given that you could be married for 70 or 80 years! if he’s right for you, he’ll still want to marry you and waiting two years won’t be a feeble enough reason not to.

honeybuns007 · 03/09/2021 22:32

@fridgepants your situation was nothing to do with an age gap. 19-22 is not an age gap relationship. He was just an idiot.

TurquoiseDragon · 02/09/2021 17:50

@CatsArePeople

She said she is planning to have a baby soon and then give up her job, thereby making herself and her child totally financially dependent on a man she probably met when she was a teenager.

unless he's abusive, criminal, or an addict, nothing specifically wrong with that. Babies don't stay babies for long.

No, but in 20 years time, when they're off your hands, she'll be 42, while he'll be 57. There's no guarantee that he'll be fit and willing to go off and do stuff.

My cousin is 54, married to someone who will be 70 this year. He had a major stroke 10 years ago, and she's been a full time carer since. She loves him, but is just so exhausted. She said that she once wished he'd died from the stroke and not survived.

OP needs to be practical now. Love is not enough, time to draw up the pros and cons list, after having had the talk on all those topics, and more, mentioned by another poster. Going with your gut is not enough.

Even if you do decide to marry, wait a few years, there's no rush. And try saying no a few times to things he wants. This can often lead people to show who they really are, a very useful tool.

fridgepants · 02/09/2021 16:54

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the user's request.

fridgepants · 02/09/2021 16:47

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the user's request.

MrsClatterbuck · 02/09/2021 13:58

I know someone where she is approx 18 years younger and it is working very well. Though I think they met when she would have been late twenties or early thirties. Also another couple who had a 22 year difference and had a great marriage. Though she was widowed early in her fifties but has no regrets.

lottiegarbanzo · 02/09/2021 13:45

On the life is about grabbing happiness where you can, and not thinking too far ahead theme, by all means grab joyful but ultimately unsuitable relationships. All part of the fun of youth. Even go so far as to marry young, if you must. Marriages can be ended. Being young, you probably stand to lose very little from an unsuitable first marriage.

Children though. Children cannot be sent back. They are the biggest commitment you can make, with another adult. You will be committed to co-parenting with their father for 18+ years, whatever else happens in either of your lives. Children do not fit the 'grabbing happiness when you can' narrative. They're great, they do bring happiness (for many / most people, not all) but it's intermittent, in amongst a lot of drudge work. They also bring a lifelong commitment and priority, that means you cannot put yourself entirely first again, for the foreseeable future.

Workwise, 1-2 years experience isn't much, if you're trying to re-establish a career after a 5-10 year absence. Get yourself into the 3-5 years bracket, with some progression and you'll be a much more re-employable prospect.

Finally (this thread has been playing on my mind a bit) your DP sounds like a very focused, successful man, who knows what he wants and when he wants it. (I've met the type. Establish career, tick. Have youthful fun and travel, tick. Gain senior / permanent contract, tick. Settle down and have family, tick). People who have achieved continuous success, worked hard to move from one step to another throughout their lives and achieved what they set out to do, commonly find it very, very hard to deal with bad luck, failure or things going wrong for them. They haven't built up the resilience on the way up that others who've struggled more, or experienced set-backs, have. If things go wrong, they panic at the unfamiliar feeling, experience and display horrible symptoms of stress and sometimes crash and burn in many ways.

I wonder if you have any idea how your DP responds to stress - that is the stress of the unexpected, the disappointing, of things not going his way? I don't mean the everyday, expected, managed stress that is part and parcel of his career.

What happens if one you is infertile, or you struggle to conceive? If you have a child with additional needs, who necessarily becomes the central focus of both your lives, for example? What is he willing to give up, to compromise on, to make family life work? To make life with you, if a family isn't forthcoming, work?

Have you ever seen him in a situation that is truly outside his control, when things haven't gone his way and he hasn't got what he wanted? How did he respond to that?

I would want to get to know him (any potential marriage partner) much better than you possibly can in a year or so, while things were going well for you both, before committing my and future children's lives to him. I'd want to know how things will work during the bad times, the difficult times, the times when compromise is necessary. When you really need to look after each other and it isn't fun. Is he the one who will do that for you? Your future children? Have you seen that quality, rather than just being told it's there?

EspressoDoubleShot · 02/09/2021 13:22

Yes And did they meet when she was student in his work setting?
It’s reasonably common that medics and hcp date at work,after all we spend huge amount of time there with people who are similarly minded. I have not encountered the 37yo dating the 22yo new grad in the workplace

HermioneKipper · 02/09/2021 13:12

How long have you been together OP? Presumably at least 2 years so you were 20 when a 35 year old man pursued you? This makes me a bit uncomfortable. Why is he not going out with someone his own age? Does he want someone much younger he can control?

TheFormidableMrsC · 02/09/2021 12:12

I've had a relationship with a similar gap, it was fine until he got to his mid-40's and he then didn't want to go too much, became a bit "pipe and slippers", thought my 30 year old friends were "immature" etc. We also had a child. He is now in his 60's and while we have co-parented well over two decades, he is very much older than me in every way and we couldn't be more different. Further, after the death of my Mum, my Dad married my (lovely) step-mum. 20 year age gap that didn't seen so awful at the time, they were a good match. However, she is now a full time carer to my elderly Dad with Alzheimers. She's not that much older than me and is a "young" woman in every way, I still have a primary aged child! I don't think they truly anticipated this. Lots to think about. That's not to say it won't work, but do look at things without rose tinted glasses Thanks

Firenight · 02/09/2021 11:52

My husband is 11 years older than me. And definitely never noticed the difference until now. In his 50s he's aged loads and just wants to stay home in his slippers. That's not what I want! He was in his 30s when we got together and much more outgoing.

CecilyP · 02/09/2021 11:48

I'm not suggesting you break up. Ride that peak relationship wave, enjoy it! Get engaged if it feels romantic. Just give things time to settle down and yourself a chance to grow - in the context of the wider world, not just the dream in your head - before you commit yourself to 20+ years of child-rearing.

Great advice, OP!

EspressoDoubleShot · 02/09/2021 11:30

If your relationship involves one person giving things up eg work that introduces a disparity and potential resentment. He gets to keep career, salary,progression and op becomes financially dependent upon him,with no career. That’s unbalanced and disproportionately disadvantages the female

lottiegarbanzo · 02/09/2021 10:48

I find I both agree and profoundly disagree with the comment above that life is about grabbing happiness where you can, and not thinking too far ahead.

Revelling in moments of happiness, enjoying life in that moment, recognising that this might be as good as it gets, yes.

Making long-term, life-changing commitments impulsively, without basic risk-assessment, self-knowledge and reflection, no.

I've lived long enough to see people live to regret those hasty decisions, at leisure. Slow motion car crashes are not a pleasant watch. Neither are the fast kind that take years, lifetimes, to recover from, if recovery is possible at all.

The issue isn't the age gap. It's the OP's age. The impossibility of well-developed adult self-knowledge at that age. The lack of practical life knowledge and experience that would inform any basic risk-assessment.

I felt I was on top of my game at 22-23 too. Peak me. Peak relationship. Peak career possibility. Potential doesn't last. It needs to be replaced by evidence and that is hard won, takes work and doesn't always take you in the direction you expected. I would go so far as to say very rarely does.

I'm not suggesting you break up. Ride that peak relationship wave, enjoy it! Get engaged if it feels romantic. Just give things time to settle down and yourself a chance to grow - in the context of the wider world, not just the dream in your head - before you commit yourself to 20+ years of child-rearing.

EspressoDoubleShot · 02/09/2021 10:21

I haven’t created imaginary anything my post is factual based upon op account
She’s a 22yo new grad he’s a 37yo doctor. I asked did they meet in work whilst she was a student or meet when she was a new grad?
You have introduced teacher as a falsehood. They’re both HCP

lottiegarbanzo · 02/09/2021 10:02

We are both doing well and at the peak of our relationship. So why delay things?

You need that peak to plateau. So you both know what you can rely upon, fall back upon in the hard times, long term.

Just wait until you're 25. You'll still be a young mum with many fertile years ahead. Him too, not young but not old for a new dad.

Rabblesthecat · 01/09/2021 21:47

DH is 16 years older than me

I don’t want kids and he had them with his ex wife and they are grown up so suits me .

Any Imbalance due to age is fixed by me earning twice what he does and he is not poorly paid! I will however benefit from his final salary pension which will be payable at 2/3 to me after he dies and for the rest of my life

honeybuns007 · 01/09/2021 21:16

[quote MakingmeaCake]@LizzieW1969 One thing that stands out from so many posts is the idea that everyone can find someone who is absolutely perfect in every way including what some perceive as an ideal age or age gap.

Real life isn't like that. I know friends who married with a 20 year age gap. I know women who were widowed in their 30s and 40s as their young H's died suddenly.

If you fall in love with someone and feel they are the right person for you, would you give them up just because there was a 10-15 year age difference?

And if, a woman is widowed in her 50s or 60s, she may have 30 years of life left and find another partner.

My great aunt found a new partner in her 70s and they had 20 years before they both died.

Another of my aunts remarried in her 50s after her first husband died at 51.

There is no 'perfect' life. Many people would rather have 20 or 30 happy years with the right person than 50 years with the wrong one.

When you are my age (I'm an older Mnetter) you see so many tragedies where one partner dies young, or half your friends divorce, or live with ill health for years, you realise that life is about grabbing happiness where you can, and not thinking too far ahead.[/quote]
Yes yes yes. Brilliant comment

honeybuns007 · 01/09/2021 21:14

@EspressoDoubleShot

The timeline and dynamics interest me You’re 22, 1 year qualified. So 18-21yo at uni. 22yo and Newly qualified How long have you been dating him? Did you meet when you were a student?was he working in a setting you had a student placement? Or did you meet when you were training but not directly working together

The power dynamics of him dating the much younger student or NQ grad are skewed in his favour.
You’re already taking about giving up work. I note he is not giving up or going PT. But already it’s decided you’ll give up work to stay home. That will significantly affect your career progression

You've created an imaginary scenario where he was the OPs teacher and then condemning him....