Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think 1200 is a quite a lot in a bank account for someone on benefits

213 replies

Happiestyearofmylife · 30/08/2021 11:50

Not a benefits bashing thread. Dd is currently unable to work. She gives me £400 a month. She currently has 1200 in her account and feels like she isn’t saving enough. I’m trying to re assure her that when you have limited money that’s quite a bit.

OP posts:
Plumtree391 · 30/08/2021 13:03

I think your daughter is doing well to have saved so much. Is she anxious to save for something in particular?

Happiestyearofmylife · 30/08/2021 13:02

I work part time as I care for her so our income is lower.

OP posts:
Happiestyearofmylife · 30/08/2021 13:02

No of course I don’t want her money. As I said I was trying to re assure that she’s doing well. Our council tax is over 2000 a year plus bills and rent

OP posts:
MobyDicksTinyCanoe · 30/08/2021 13:02

PollyCat and if your housing benefit stopped how would you propose to pay for the roof over your head and your council tax that's being paid for you right now?

Back in the real world if people have more coming out than they have coming in then they can't survive. And it isnt ok to have one adult in the household struggling whilst the other adults dont have to worry about bills and have an excessive disposable income.

I'm also a carer. I take £300 off my ds towards food and bills. The reality is of ds wasnt at home still id be able to work and bring in a decent income. Of course he should contribute. Anyone who thinks over £200 a week disposable income after all bills and food is too low for one adult are living on cloud cuckoo land.

DumplingsAndStew · 30/08/2021 13:01

@HoldingTheDoor

I think we need to know more about the circumstances- is this the same OP posting various things about their child in quick succession?

Yes it is. They've been posting strange threads on MN for many months, usually regarding being sectioned and psychiatrists. They have a very distinctive posting style and it's pretty clear that it isn't actually the DD but them who is having issues. It's concerning that they're so reliant on MN when they clearly need help from professionals and that the responses to most of their posts are feeding something unhealthy.

Yes, this one name changes and pops up very regularly. She'll disappear again once she's through this manic phase, then reappear in a few weeks.
DifficultBloodyWoman · 30/08/2021 13:01

This thread is crazy!

OP, think of the costs that you incur a) specifically because your daughter and b) you would incur anyway but are higher because of an additional adult.

For example, are you including your daughter in the grocery shopping and cooking or does she have to buy and cook her own food? The first is more likely so think how much you spend on food and divide it by the number of people in the house. Your daughter should be paying you a portion of that.

I assume that you have internet access that your daughter uses because that is considered a modern day utility bill. Your daughter should pay a portion of that.

Water rates or water meter? Most people are on a meter now so think about what proportion of that bill you use versus what she uses and what everyone else in the house uses. The number of times she runs the washing machine compared to everyone else and long, hot baths in comparison to short, sharp showers.

Electricity. Slightly trickier. You would be baying a fair but just to keep the house going with standing charges etc. But more people also mean more usage. So perhaps this bill should reflect that rather than a % based on household size. But still something to consider especially if she has as many devices charging as most young people today.

Council tax - does she pay this? Do you pay this? She should be contributing towards this.

Finally, the rent. A small contribution would be appropriate from an adult whether they are employed or not. It doesn’t matter whether or not you would downsize if she wasn’t living with you.

I’ve got to say that, if you are including food and everything else I mentioned, I think £450pcm actually sound pretty reasonable.

However, if you want to know whether or not it is reasonable,e, do your own calculations and see how much profit or loss you are making way charging your daughter. Then decide whether it is appropriate or not.

SonicStars · 30/08/2021 13:00

Have reread the initial post and it's clearly not about the rent, sorry got derailed by other posters.

Examples of unexpected costs that she would be able to cover from those savings.

£1200 Bond equivalent to six weeks rent plus first month's rent on a £480pm room
£100 contents insurance
£500 replacing an old laptop
£150 multiple birthday presents needed for one month
£200 a weekend away in UK with friends (family wedding or hen do you can't avoid)
£1200 three months rent Inc bills if something goes wrong with the benefits (I would probably like to have another £300 in the pot to cover food too)

Any money helps when you have an unexpected expense.

Is she paying off debts alongside saving or is she debt free? Remind her of her situation there so she realises how well she's really doing.

IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves · 30/08/2021 12:57

If she's on ESA and PIP then she's disabled and it is quite reasonable that disabled people are given extra help. If she doesn't have a lot of outgoings then yes, she's going to save. And that is FINE! It means that when she's able to do more, she'll have the money to pay for it. She might be able to move out at some point.

Are you saying this because you have your eye on it? You want her to hand over her very small savings pot to you?

HeckyPeck · 30/08/2021 12:56

@x2boys

Well good for you *@pollythecat15* im also a carer for my severely disabled child, his DLA goes towards our general living g expenses otherwise we wouldnt be able to afford rent food etc
Yes exactly.

So many people talking from a position of financial privilege here.

If OP can't afford the rent for an extra room for her daughter, then she has to take the money.

HoldingTheDoor · 30/08/2021 12:55

I think we need to know more about the circumstances- is this the same OP posting various things about their child in quick succession?

Yes it is. They've been posting strange threads on MN for many months, usually regarding being sectioned and psychiatrists. They have a very distinctive posting style and it's pretty clear that it isn't actually the DD but them who is having issues. It's concerning that they're so reliant on MN when they clearly need help from professionals and that the responses to most of their posts are feeding something unhealthy.

Babyroobs · 30/08/2021 12:54

@MiddlesexGirl

If it would help your calculations then as a non-dependent the universal credit they would assume she is making a contribution of £75.53 per month (different and rather more complex rules for housing benefit). That may put some perspective on how much rent you are asking from her. Which begs the question of why your rent is so high relative to your ability to pay. Could you be claiming more in benefits yourself?
I don't think this non dependent deduction applies if the non dependent is on PIP ?
x2boys · 30/08/2021 12:54

Well good for you @pollythecat15 im also a carer for my severely disabled child, his DLA goes towards our general living g expenses otherwise we wouldnt be able to afford rent food etc

LakieLady · 30/08/2021 12:54

I think it depends on how much she is getting. If she's in the support group and getting enhanced rate PIP, she could be getting quite a lot.

I'd say around a third of her total income would be reasonable.

And I think that it's great that she's saving.

MiddlesexGirl · 30/08/2021 12:53

If it would help your calculations then as a non-dependent the universal credit they would assume she is making a contribution of £75.53 per month (different and rather more complex rules for housing benefit).
That may put some perspective on how much rent you are asking from her.
Which begs the question of why your rent is so high relative to your ability to pay. Could you be claiming more in benefits yourself?

Booknooks · 30/08/2021 12:52

Despite my struggle, I still wouldn't dream of taking that amount from my daughter.

Why not? I don't see why you'd struggle on, rather than take some money towards living expenses which will still be cheaper than if living elsewhere, and leave leave them money for extras Confused

WorraLiberty · 30/08/2021 12:51

It sounds like a catch 22 situation OP.

If she manages to save enough to move out, you're not going to be able to afford your own rent are you?

I know you said you wouldn't need such a big place if there weren't adults living there, but downsizing takes time and can't just be done overnight.

How many other adults are living there and what are their contributions?

MyDcAreMarvel · 30/08/2021 12:51

@Holweighthelp Are people forgetting the point of benefits?! She is being given the money to pay rent and bills and survive. absolutely not the op’s dd is unable to work she is entitled to the same quality and standard of life as a healthy working adult.

THisbackwithavengeance · 30/08/2021 12:51

I sometimes think there is an alternative universe on MN.

Noone is entitled to save anything.

I was a single FT working parent for many years. I saved literally nothing. Every penny of my wages and tax credits and child benefit was spent and accounted for.

The money that this girl receives in benefits is for her living expenses which includes her share of the OP's household expenses. If she doesnt like it, she can always move out.

Why should she use her PIP/benefits to amass savings and live cost free at the OP's expense?

Babyroobs · 30/08/2021 12:50

@DogFoodPie

It all depends if the dd is better off living at home. Is OP giving her a lot of help and support and does living in the family home give her company that is beneficial? Living alone might not be the best option for her.
Exactly. I don't understand why people are saying she should move out and rent ? How beneficial is that going to be for someone who has severe mental health issues?
ManifestDestinee · 30/08/2021 12:49

If the OP can’t afford her rent, that’s not her daughters problem

Of course it is!! If OP can't pay her rent, she gets evicted. Her daughter also gets evicted. How is that not her problem? If OP could rent something smaller without her daughter, why should the daughter not pay?

These answers are insane. Op should lose her home while the adult who lives with her piles up savings in her account? You're all mad.

Pollythecat15 · 30/08/2021 12:49

@ManifestDestinee

This is why I am the complete opposite with my own daughter

Lucky you can afford that. Many people cannot support adult children, they don';t have the money. Yours, and other posters, privilege is showing.

Neither do I. Every month is a struggle particularly when extras are needed like school uniform.

I'm a single parent. I can't work due to caring full time for my youngest child who is very severely disabled.

Despite my struggle, I still wouldn't dream of taking that amount from my daughter.

Babyroobs · 30/08/2021 12:49

If op's daughter didn't pay £400 a month, she would quickly be over the savings limit for means tested benefits. I see this quite a bit in my line of work - disabled adults getting well over £1000 a month in benefits and disability benefits and they barely spend any if parents don't use/ take some of it, then it accumulates and they no longer qualify for means tested benefits. People on highest rates of PIP are getting over £600 a month just in disability benefits.

DogFoodPie · 30/08/2021 12:49

It all depends if the dd is better off living at home. Is OP giving her a lot of help and support and does living in the family home give her company that is beneficial? Living alone might not be the best option for her.

MakeMeCleanTheHouse · 30/08/2021 12:49

I think it's really important for young people to experience budgeting and if they earn benefits or wages without any e pension they will miss that life skill because its a lot of money with no rent or bills to pay.

If the OP's daughter is on enhanced benefits she might have more available income than the OP? Has anyone considered this? Lots of cash for someone with mental health issues isn't a great thing. Poverty isn't either but some huge assumptions have been made.

DishingOutDone · 30/08/2021 12:48

I think we need to know more about the circumstances- is this the same OP posting various things about their child in quick succession?