Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think 1200 is a quite a lot in a bank account for someone on benefits

213 replies

Happiestyearofmylife · 30/08/2021 11:50

Not a benefits bashing thread. Dd is currently unable to work. She gives me £400 a month. She currently has 1200 in her account and feels like she isn’t saving enough. I’m trying to re assure her that when you have limited money that’s quite a bit.

OP posts:
DumplingsAndStew · 30/08/2021 18:21

@RussianSpy101

I don’t claim carers allowance as I don’t see myself as his carer, I’m his mum. Of course I care for him and I don’t need paying for that.

Well good for you Hmm I do claim Carers Allowance, and that doesn't make me any less of a mum than you.

IndiaMay · 30/08/2021 18:07

I paid rent to my parents when I would come home from uni in the holidays because I had a job and student loan and they no longer got child benefit. I also paid rent when I came home after uni and was saving for a deposit (which I did by the age of 25 and live in the south east so clearly paying parents rent did me no harm).

Dont see how people on here thing that adults can live somewhere rent free just because they're ill or related to the home owner. I couldn't afford to have a fully grown adult move in with me tomorrow! Another 2 showers a day, another bedroom light on all evening, another 3 meals a day plus snacks. If the OP cant afford it what do you suppose she does? Gets into debt just so her ill child can have more money on the bank?

Booknooks · 30/08/2021 17:56

[quote RussianSpy101]@helentomelon like I said previously, I don’t get a single benefit. Not even entitled to child benefit. I don’t claim carers allowance as I don’t see myself as his carer, I’m his mum. Of course I care for him and I don’t need paying for that.
I never said I was a single mum.
My son will never have to contribute to living in his home, nor will either of my other 2 children.
What is £330 a month?[/quote]
Your comment about carers allowance is grim, and your privilege is showing. I don't know how its out of the realm of some peoples imagination that they require money off of their adult children to pay the bills.

helentomelon · 30/08/2021 16:59

Ah okay so you have a partner who pays for you to have the attitude that you have about not asking your disabled son, or any of your children for keep.

That's lovely. But also totally irrelevant when the OP has said she needs the contribution and many of us do.

You're in a very privileged position to be able to do that. I'll admit I'm envious. I wish I could do that for mine but for people on benefits, once your child leaves education you only receive £330 a month (and are expected to look for work) and so need to ask any adult in the house to contribute.

pinkyredrose · 30/08/2021 16:56

How did you end up in the accommodation you're in, were you both in work when you found the house?

RussianSpy101 · 30/08/2021 16:52

@helentomelon like I said previously, I don’t get a single benefit. Not even entitled to child benefit. I don’t claim carers allowance as I don’t see myself as his carer, I’m his mum. Of course I care for him and I don’t need paying for that.
I never said I was a single mum.
My son will never have to contribute to living in his home, nor will either of my other 2 children.
What is £330 a month?

helentomelon · 30/08/2021 16:50

@RussianSpy101

I don’t work, I’m a SAHM due to his care needs. He is only 3 so not yet at school and goes to nursery twice a week.
You'll need money off him when he's out of education and you lose your benefits then. Unless you're working by that point.

Unless you can support both of you on £330 a month Confused

NeverDropYourMooncup · 30/08/2021 16:37

@Happiestyearofmylife

Because our rent is expensive and wouldn’t need that size house. If I didn’t have adults living with me.
Just how much is the full rent, then?
RussianSpy101 · 30/08/2021 16:35

I don’t work, I’m a SAHM due to his care needs. He is only 3 so not yet at school and goes to nursery twice a week.

Babyroobs · 30/08/2021 16:29

@RussianSpy101

I have a disabled son and don’t get any benefits. I’ve never heard of being entitled to tax credits just because your child has a disability? My son gets DLA which I put in a savings account for him, for if he is able to living independently in the future. We pay for independent speech therapy for him as the NHS SALT only sees him once a term. I can’t imagine ever taking money from my son, who will probably never be able to work. It isn’t his fault he is disabled and that will limit his choices in life with regards employment and independent living. He is my son and I will continue to provide everything he needs for as long as he needs it.
Are you aware that building up savings for him will potentially rule him out of claiming any means tested benefits when he is older ? So when he leaves education, if he has more than 16k ( easily built up from DLA if on higher rates) in his name he would not be able to claim means tested benefits like Universal credit ?
itsgettingwierd · 30/08/2021 16:20

@RussianSpy101

I have a disabled son and don’t get any benefits. I’ve never heard of being entitled to tax credits just because your child has a disability? My son gets DLA which I put in a savings account for him, for if he is able to living independently in the future. We pay for independent speech therapy for him as the NHS SALT only sees him once a term. I can’t imagine ever taking money from my son, who will probably never be able to work. It isn’t his fault he is disabled and that will limit his choices in life with regards employment and independent living. He is my son and I will continue to provide everything he needs for as long as he needs it.
Are you a LP who is limited to the hours they can work - if they can work at all?

It's lovely to be able to judge others using their child's DLA to raise them when you are in a position to fund private therapy from a wage.

A disproportionate number of families living in poverty in the uk have disabled members.

thesunwillout · 30/08/2021 16:17

Are you claiming carers allowance on top of this as you say you only have a part time job?

Seesawmummadaw · 30/08/2021 16:14

She’s doing well.

SeaDreaming · 30/08/2021 16:10

I don't necessarily agree that the daughter would have to pay out a lot more if she moved out - the rent/council tax/energy/water bills for my 1 bed flat (before taking any benefits/support into account) come to just under £450 pcm all in. I'm on long term PIP and ESA, so my council tax is covered by council tax support, and my rent (which is within the LHA limit) gets paid directly to my landlord; I also get a disability premium with my ESA as a single person living alone.

helentomelon · 30/08/2021 16:09

@RussianSpy101

I have a disabled son and don’t get any benefits. I’ve never heard of being entitled to tax credits just because your child has a disability? My son gets DLA which I put in a savings account for him, for if he is able to living independently in the future. We pay for independent speech therapy for him as the NHS SALT only sees him once a term. I can’t imagine ever taking money from my son, who will probably never be able to work. It isn’t his fault he is disabled and that will limit his choices in life with regards employment and independent living. He is my son and I will continue to provide everything he needs for as long as he needs it.
But if you dont get benefits and can afford to save the DLA you must be earning a decent wage and be able to afford to do this for your son?

My dd receives DLA and I'm not working due to my own ill health - that money needs to be spent to look after her.

When she leaves education I'll lose child benefit, child element UC, council tax reduction, child maintenance... I simply couldn't afford to not take some of her benefits off her sadly. As much as I'd love to take your approach.

It sounds like OP needs the contribution so I don't think people should be bashing her for how much she takes from her dd.

RussianSpy101 · 30/08/2021 16:01

I have a disabled son and don’t get any benefits. I’ve never heard of being entitled to tax credits just because your child has a disability?
My son gets DLA which I put in a savings account for him, for if he is able to living independently in the future.
We pay for independent speech therapy for him as the NHS SALT only sees him once a term.
I can’t imagine ever taking money from my son, who will probably never be able to work. It isn’t his fault he is disabled and that will limit his choices in life with regards employment and independent living. He is my son and I will continue to provide everything he needs for as long as he needs it.

helentomelon · 30/08/2021 15:57

Very tricky as although £400 is cheaper than she'd been paying elsewhere, she won't be getting housing benefit as living with mum it's assumed she's not paying rent. Even though in reality a lot of mum's would need a contribution.

OP - if she wants to save/have more money id get her to look in to moving on to UC. If she can't work she should be getting LCWRA on top.

Another thing to consider if you're renting is to get her on the tenancy then she can claim housing benefit for her half of the rent. Obviously if you own the house you can't do that.

£1200 is a decent amount of savings for someone without an income but whether or not it feels like a lot depends on what she is saving for?

itsgettingwierd · 30/08/2021 15:54

@Grapewrath

Some people live in dreamland. DD is an adult, not a dependant and £400 pcm for all rent and bills plus food is more than reasonable. She’d pay far more elsewhere and OP shouldn’t have to subsidise her adult child if she can’t afford to!
Agree.

My ds gets pip. It comes to me through this choice because he cannot manage budgeting.

I pay for his swimming, phone, clothes, nice toiletries and days out etc

I also work less hours because I need to be there to care for him and if you work you cannot get carers allowance.

When he starts work this year and gets a job we've discussed what will happen as he'll have to contribute to rent, food and bills.

So he either gets his pip and wages and pays for everything himself and contributes towards the bills at £400/500 a month or I continue to get his pip, pay for those things and he contributes £300ish a month.

People just seem to get that raising a disabled child is easier because of tax credits. When they become an adult you lose that. He can claim wtc but not me on a low wage who will remain limited because of caring for him.

And comparing living at home to elsewhere doesn't really work because he couldn't live independently. But if he was to go down that route it would be same rent as I pay here on HA 2 bed for a studio/1 bed. Another set of bills and council tax plus paying for people to come and help him/ company to deliver meals/ cleaner etc.

I'm a much cheaper option WinkGrin

Grapewrath · 30/08/2021 15:12

Some people live in dreamland. DD is an adult, not a dependant and £400 pcm for all rent and bills plus food is more than reasonable. She’d pay far more elsewhere and OP shouldn’t have to subsidise her adult child if she can’t afford to!

Babyroobs · 30/08/2021 14:47

@Hont1986

If she's on benefits then £400/m is probably over half her income (assuming she's getting UC and has been found not fit for work).

I know MN is generally pro adult kids paying rent but I think that's appalling.

She has PIP on top also. I do think £400 is quite steep also though but does depend what else exactly she is needing to pay out for ?? I also imagine if the daughter has been in hospital for any length of time, the ESA will still have been being paid yet she won't have needed to spend much whilst in hospital.
jimmyhill · 30/08/2021 14:41

So anyone on benefits must also be on the brink of destitution?

YABVU, OP!

ellyeth · 30/08/2021 14:38

If she hasn't always been on benefits then perhaps the savings are from when she had more money, or perhaps she is just very careful with the money she gets. I don't think £1200 is a lot. It is difficult to say whether the £400 a month she is giving you is a lot because I don't know what that covers. However, it sounds quite a lot to me.

Pollythecat15 · 30/08/2021 14:35

Maybe you're right and I should be charging my daughter something.
It is a struggle every month just to get by.
I am in no way judging anyone else. It's just the experience I had when I was working with my own Mum, but that was different.
I am in a really tough financial position myself and fully sympathise.

Pollythecat15 · 30/08/2021 14:28

@x2boys

Well good for you *@pollythecat15* im also a carer for my severely disabled child, his DLA goes towards our general living g expenses otherwise we wouldnt be able to afford rent food etc
My son's DLA goes towards bills. Once I have paid rent, food and any other essentials for the children I literally have about £30 left in my bank account. We don't have days out as I can't afford it.
Pollythecat15 · 30/08/2021 14:21

@x2boys

Well good for you *@pollythecat15* im also a carer for my severely disabled child, his DLA goes towards our general living g expenses otherwise we wouldnt be able to afford rent food etc
Yes my son's goes towards bills too. I wouldn't manage otherwise. I make myself ill worrying about how I'm going to juggle things.