Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that to stay in the healthy weight range I'm going to be hungry 70% of the time for the rest of my life.

183 replies

AliceAbsolum · 30/08/2021 10:17

I've tried eating when I feel hungry, I put on about half a stone a month. Bmi is about 22.

I eat a balanced, protein rich diet based on lean fish, loads of veg, etc. But about an hour after eating each meal I'm generally hungry. Don't drink alcohol, try to avoid processed foods. Don't feel overly stressed, don't smoke etc etc.
Drives me mad.
I run 5 miles most days just to be able to eat an extra 400kcal!
Urgh.
Anyone else?

OP posts:
CampaignToo · 30/08/2021 11:44

That's very old fashioned. I run fasted every morning and don't feel hungry until the afternoon. I force pasta down the night before a marathon but otherwise eat very few carbs. Hydration however, is very important.

Well yes, that is actually what I said.

That works for you. It's not working for OP and it doesn't work for me. I also don't know any serious runner who doesn't eat until afternoon. I won my race this weekend BTW, so I can't be getting it all wrong Grin

JinglingHellsBells · 30/08/2021 11:43

I'm always hungry unless I've had potatoes/rice/pasta with my meal.

This sounds like an emotional/ habitual response. Craving carbs is a bit of an addiction, really, as it's all broken down into sugar.

If you ate a 12 oz steak for example (not saying you should) with a salad, you would be no hungrier than if you'd had less steak and a pile of spuds with it.

LBirch02 · 30/08/2021 11:43

Chicken and broccoli are excellent weight loss foods! Low calorie and filling

JinglingHellsBells · 30/08/2021 11:41

with only a few refined carbs
I meant unrefined!

Carbs like white rice, white pasta, potatoes etc are just turned into glucose and have no nutritional value other than calories.

Not sure what you eat OP, but you might find it helps to swap white rice and pasta for brown rice, wholewheat pasta, white bread for wholemeal, swap potatoes for sweet potatoes, and a portion is your fist size.

samthebordercollie · 30/08/2021 11:39

@CampaignToo

I know it's an unfashionable view but I think you need more carbs, especially if you're running.

I'm always hungry unless I've had potatoes/rice/pasta with my meal.

I'm in my 50s and maintain my weight within healthy guidelines. I don't snack but I'm not hungry. I eat a proper meal until I'm satisfied, then wait until the next meal.

Obviously you are supposed to be hungry as the next mealtime approaches!

That's very old fashioned. I run fasted every morning and don't feel hungry until the afternoon. I force pasta down the night before a marathon but otherwise eat very few carbs. Hydration however, is very important.
PlanDeRaccordement · 30/08/2021 11:38

@OlympicProcrastinator

Yup. I have found I need to live strictly on 1200 calories to stay a healthy weight. I’m starving but if I eat when hungry I just get fat.

Discovered the other day that in the olden days, women generally died shortly after menopause so I figured once we hit 40 plus we are destined to ‘not work’ properly Grin

That’s not accurate. The life expectancy in U.K. in the 1800s was around 40 for women but that is measured as life expectancy at birth and so it is skewed by the high infant mortality, high child mortality, and high childbirth mortality. If you survived infancy, childhood, and child bearing to reach age 40, your life expectancy at age 40 was at a minimum another 25yrs, or 65 yrs old during the 1800s. www.jbending.org.uk/stats3.htm
JinglingHellsBells · 30/08/2021 11:37

From an evolutionary perspective, I think we are meant to feel hunger as it used to spur us into catching animals for food and foraging. We'd also go for long stretches with little food.
Now, everyone is used to feeling full and eating every 4 hours or more, by snacking.

You can learn to ignore hunger pangs. Once the worst bit is over- the hour or so after which you'd normally eat a meal- it gets easier.

It's a habit our bodies get into - eating at specific times.

If you eat 3 meals a day with no snacking, and makes those meals mainly protein and veg/ fruit, with only a few refined carbs, you ought to be able to maintain a healthy weight.

PrinnyPree · 30/08/2021 11:34

Yeah I felt like I really had to "try" to maintain my weight when I had a BMI of 22 but not so much with a BMI of 24 (just make sure I don't have too much junk) its only about 11 or 12 pounds difference but at the moment I have butter on my toast and hearty portions of healthy food and maintain fairly easily. X

CampaignToo · 30/08/2021 11:34

I know it's an unfashionable view but I think you need more carbs, especially if you're running.

I'm always hungry unless I've had potatoes/rice/pasta with my meal.

I'm in my 50s and maintain my weight within healthy guidelines. I don't snack but I'm not hungry. I eat a proper meal until I'm satisfied, then wait until the next meal.

Obviously you are supposed to be hungry as the next mealtime approaches!

thenightsky · 30/08/2021 11:33

If I go over about 1,200 calories a day for more than 2 or 3 days in a row, I put weight on. If I eat breakfast, I put weight on. So, I chose to eat one meal a day, plus a smaller snack sized meal. If I eat a normal sized lunch, I just have a bowl of yoghurt and some fruit for dinner and visa-versa. If the hunger pangs get too bad, I have a cup of tea.

I once fell for that old thing of 'throw away the scales'. I went up 2 dress sizes in a two months!

Phobiaphobic · 30/08/2021 11:32

Well past menopause and can pretty much eat what I want and stay a size 10/12. BUT, I have never fucked up my metabolism through dieting and I try to minimise carbs and eat reasonably healthily and zero processed food. I eat lots of fat as well as fruit and veg.

Eddielzzard · 30/08/2021 11:32

I also do intermittent fasting, skipping breakfast. I naturally don't feel hungry in the morning anyway so it wasn't much of a change.

I also stop eating when I feel satisfied. I find my portion sizes now are really quite small.

I'm not skinny, but not fat. Fatter than I'd like, and I have made peace with never being slim because I love food too much.

Exercise has never helped me lose weight. I walk the dog every day and my work has me on my feet.

Chasing dreams of being model skinny just isn't realistic and sets you up for failure. I don't ban any particular foods. I eat what I like but follow the general principle of not over eating.

workwoes123 · 30/08/2021 11:32

I hear you about the lizard brain. I used to get quite panicky at the thought of being hungry. I've done 16:8 and it is good training in learning to sit comfortably with hunger. It's fine. It's not something to panic about and just means I will appreciate my meal when it comes. But that panicky feeling is hard to ignore.

My mum was always slim and always on a diet throughout my childhood. She said she was always hungry, but that's what it took to stay slim.

Having said that, it's not working now that I am in peri-menopause. I haven't changed the way I eat, I'm probably drinking less and I'm exercising more - yet I am slowly and surely gaining a spare tyre / weight round my middle. I never used to put weight on round my tummy, it always went on my back and boobs before. Thanks, biology of the 49 year old woman.

AliceAbsolum · 30/08/2021 11:31

OK. Good suggestions. I'll try to drink more, I'll wee more but that's OK.

Will try eating more fat and continue the strength training.

OP posts:
iloveeverykindofcat · 30/08/2021 11:29

I just wish women could enjoy their healthy, strong bodies without so much sacrifice to hit a specific number. Its too late for me but I wish I did when I was younger, at the top of the healthy BMI range. Maybe that's where OP's natural weight is.

LindaEllen · 30/08/2021 11:28

@OlympicProcrastinator

Yup. I have found I need to live strictly on 1200 calories to stay a healthy weight. I’m starving but if I eat when hungry I just get fat.

Discovered the other day that in the olden days, women generally died shortly after menopause so I figured once we hit 40 plus we are destined to ‘not work’ properly Grin

Nobody needs to be on a 1200 cal diet to stay a healthy weight for goodness sake. That's absolutely rubbish.
PearlyRising · 30/08/2021 11:26

This thread inspired me to have two eggs just now. Instead of toast. I wanted toast.

PearlyRising · 30/08/2021 11:26

@OneAugustNight

I’ve always been slim but I’m permanently starving. A friend pointed out to me recently that I’m always saying I’m hungry which made me realise I am.
This was me for DECADES I'd eat enough to keep me full for 90 minutes but then the amount Id eaten when I was so hungry when I ate it, kept me ok not satiated for at best 2 hours and then I'd have to wait another 90 minutes before I'd allow myself to eat.

I will say that keto was the exception to this but I don't like meat much.
I think my favourite foods are carbs!

LBirch02 · 30/08/2021 11:24

When I was on a huge weight loss mission last year I used not bother with weights at first thinking it was all about the cardio - but weights makes a huge difference in weight loss - it really does

MushMonster · 30/08/2021 11:23

No, you will not.
When you feel hungry one hour after a meal, you are not really hungry. It is likely that you are thirsty. Drink some wpater. For me a hot tea, like ginger and lemon, is better.
Drink plenty of water.
Stick to a meal plan.
You will only really be hungry for a week max. Then you will be ok with your new portion sizes.
Drink when you feel hinger or want a snack between meals. But not sugary drinks, as those have quite a few calories! Snack on fruit.
You do already have a healthy diet, so it will only need to reduce portions. And up your activity levels. An extra walk, some gym, swimming...

NotSonicTheHedgehog · 30/08/2021 11:22

I’m going to second the weightlifting. I weight lift four times a week; talking serious, heavy lifting (bench, deadlift etc) I’m 5ft 1 and eat about 2500-2700 calories per day and don’t really gain much in the way of fat (muscle yes). I do two 15 mins sessions of cardio each week and that’s it. I don’t eat meat, and don’t smoke or drink.

iloveeverykindofcat · 30/08/2021 11:20

Be careful what you wish for though. Decades of anorexia have made digestion and absorbtion of nutrients a never-ending problem for me. I am constantly taking digestive enzymes, which help a bit, but I have premature fullness, stomach pains, and constant IBS symptoms. I am currently trying really hard to get to a BMI of 18 and stay there its very very difficult. Maybe some people want to look like me (I don't) but I am permanently tired, anxious and cold. I really, genuinely wish I had a better appetite and enjoyed food more. Eating is not a pleasure.

OneAugustNight · 30/08/2021 11:19

I’ve always been slim but I’m permanently starving. A friend pointed out to me recently that I’m always saying I’m hungry which made me realise I am.

OneTC · 30/08/2021 11:18

I am hungry about 70% of the time but have come to enjoy it. Plus anticipation of the next meal 😍

bamboocat · 30/08/2021 11:18

@AliceAbsolum

Bmi is 22 so I reckon that is healthy.

Maybe I'm just not very tolerant of the hunger.

Drink a glass of water.