Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that to stay in the healthy weight range I'm going to be hungry 70% of the time for the rest of my life.

183 replies

AliceAbsolum · 30/08/2021 10:17

I've tried eating when I feel hungry, I put on about half a stone a month. Bmi is about 22.

I eat a balanced, protein rich diet based on lean fish, loads of veg, etc. But about an hour after eating each meal I'm generally hungry. Don't drink alcohol, try to avoid processed foods. Don't feel overly stressed, don't smoke etc etc.
Drives me mad.
I run 5 miles most days just to be able to eat an extra 400kcal!
Urgh.
Anyone else?

OP posts:
PearlyRising · 30/08/2021 15:08

@MareofBeasttown yeh I'm hungry right now too.
Going to have some cheese before I go to the supermarket.........

NettleMania · 30/08/2021 15:08

I do a 36 hour fast once a week and that works for me. It surprises me still, because I'm naturally greedy, but find this easier than any other method; and I've tried a lot over the years!
Everyone's different - you just have to work out what suits you.
Natural hunger comes in waves and only lasts a few minutes. Just keep busy/drink water and ride the storm...

PearlyRising · 30/08/2021 15:07

Wow, good for you! Was it hard to get agreement to that operation. I know 5 stone is not no big deal but i thought surgery was only done for much more overweight people.

One thing that works for me psychologically is to diet only every second day.

I know there'll be the usual chorus of people saying ''it's not a diet'' but when I want to eat MORE yes it is a diet.

So if I restrict to 1,000 only every second day, I will still lose weight and it's kind of bearable. It's a really slow process though.

I need to get back on board with my own advice though.

We all know what works for US but it's doing it. Would love to be going to the shops now to get a baguette, mayonnaise and a roast chicken in a bag but............ off I go to buy courgettes and leeks.

MareofBeasttown · 30/08/2021 15:04

I am hungry right now. So far today, have eaten a bowl of oatmeal ( sugar free, no honey), 2 boiled eggs and some avocado and tomatoes for lunch, and some pistachios as an afternoon snack. Still hungry.

Honestly I would follow the example of the poster who says she doesn't care about her BMI any more-its not vanity- but I have diabetes in the family and was pre-diabetic a couple of years ago, so I have to keep an eye on that.

GreeboIsMySpiritAnimal · 30/08/2021 15:04

@Excelthetube

If you add more fat isn’t that more calories!? I can eat a steak trimmed or not trimmed and the difference is huge

Fat is satiating, so you don't need to eat it large amounts to feel full. I eat three fairly small but high fat meals per day, and rarely need to snack or eat between meals. Admittedly, I don't calorie count, so couldn't tell you how many I eat per day.

Plus, our bodies burn the easiest form of energy first, which is carbs. Reduce the carbs, and it gets to work on burning the fat instead.

LaurieFairyCake · 30/08/2021 14:59

I was very hungry for years and still felt like that on 1400 calories - ALWAYS hungry

This was 100-200 more calories than I burnt off so I put on 5-6 stone over 20 years

I literally couldn't eat any less (again, I was fucking starving all the time!) - I tried EVERYTHING- low carb/exercise of every type/intermittent fasting

Nothing worked so I had surgery to remove 80% of my stomach last year

Now eat 1000 calories a day and I'm NEVER hungry

I could not have coped going into old age starving and 5 stone overweight

PearlyRising · 30/08/2021 14:57

@readytosell yeh, I think we're sold this notion that if we didn't overeat we'd all be so lean, but in a world where food is available and it has to be a conscious choice to fast, then eating when we want to (when we're hungry!) is going to lead to a lot of us looking like we're carrying ten extra pounds. I'm being kind to myself because right now, I'm carrying 15 extra pounds. I've successfully lost weight many times before and always preferred how I looked.

Right, it's my day off and I'm going to the shops to buy courgettes and eggs and leeks and butter. Going to try and do a low carb can't face keto diet.

I kept my carbs under 20 grams per day when I lost a lot of weight but I'm hoping that low carb will help me lose a few pounds.
I start today.

Excelthetube · 30/08/2021 14:57

If you add more fat isn’t that more calories!?
I can eat a steak trimmed or not trimmed and the difference is huge

GreeboIsMySpiritAnimal · 30/08/2021 14:54

@EatYourVegetables

Add more fat to your meals, and reduce the carbs.
This worked for me, I lost three stone two years ago and have kept it off - and I'm don't hungry, aside from a normal hunger for my meals.

I'm 43, size 10, with a BMI of 21.

Excelthetube · 30/08/2021 14:48

Only because I have a bbq today! I am not procrastinating I promise!

Excelthetube · 30/08/2021 14:48

@AliceAbsolum
All of the above probably! I also obviously have deeper issues. I’m going to start the fast 800 tomorrow

Mancity100 · 30/08/2021 14:45

@Whiskyinajar

Quite frankly this is why I have stopped bothering about my weight.

I exercise, I eat when I am hungry.

I gained a stone and its stayed.

I've accepted thar this is the weight my body wants to be.

I've dumped all interest in BMI and weighing scales. The only thing I weigh now is ingredients when cooking specific meals.

Can't do with being hungry. If you are hungry then your body is telling you to eat. If you ignore that then you are potentially starving your body of nutrients it needs.

This is the perfect response
AliceAbsolum · 30/08/2021 14:23

@Excelthetube

Sorry why I eat when I am NOT hungry
Bored? Lonely? Tired?
OP posts:
readytosell · 30/08/2021 14:18

Gosh nice to find a tribe I can join! I lost a lot of weight about 5 years ago and took up exercise (running, weights, yoga).

I've put a little bit back on but yeah the constant hunger thing is real and such a pain. I thought it was just me being a greedy guts but it's so common when I talked with my fellow diet buddies - male and female, older and younger.

I've tried all the eating more protein, drinking more water, giving up alcohol, but none of those have worked to the extent of a noticeable change. I'm happy to be a little bit heavier but less hungry than I was when I hit a target weight that was clearly too low for me.

user78976 · 30/08/2021 14:16

I was doing 16:8 fasting (apparently more suited to men and I would have been better off doing 12:12?). I am not an expert, just relaying my experience and what I have been told by someone who has more expertise than me, in case it helps anyone else...

user78976 · 30/08/2021 14:15

@phoenixrosehere

Re. fasting: Yes, I did this for several month and lost quite a lot of weight, but I also suspect it nearly pushed me into (slightly) early menopause due to the missed periods etc so had to stop.

Fasting shouldn’t be making you miss periods..

I believe this is not uncommon in women and one reason why some people think that prolonged fasting is not appropriate in women who would probably achieve adequate results with just a 12-hour fasting window.
Excelthetube · 30/08/2021 14:11

Sorry why I eat when I am NOT hungry

Excelthetube · 30/08/2021 14:11

It’s interesting. Becuase I actually am very overweight but I don’t eat much, and I get full very quickly. But then I drink a lot and I also eat even if I feel full.
So if I could get rid of my eat when full/booze. Then I think I would find it fine to not eat as much.

If I diet and give up carbs and booze then I am even less hungry! I just can’t stick to it.

Why I eat when I am hungry is a mystery to me

AliceAbsolum · 30/08/2021 13:59

@grasstreeleaf

Oh and incidentally building up slow twitch muscles can improve insulin sensitivity. Slow twitch muscles are fuelled by burning fat through aerobic respiration. Fast twitch muscles are fuelled by glucose through anaerobic respiration. Sprinters tend to have more developed fast twitch muscles, marathon runners more developed slow twitch muscles.
Honestly training for my first marathon 4 years ago, I put on half a stone that I've never managed to lose. Eating the day after an 18 mile long run is like throwing a giant curry down a corridor - doesn't even touch the sides.
OP posts:
phoenixrosehere · 30/08/2021 13:57

Re. fasting: Yes, I did this for several month and lost quite a lot of weight, but I also suspect it nearly pushed me into (slightly) early menopause due to the missed periods etc so had to stop.

Fasting shouldn’t be making you miss periods..

halftermbreak · 30/08/2021 13:55

The ability to tolerate hunger is surely part of the puzzle of weight maintenance. If you haven't read about some of the hormones that drive hunger and satiety, Giles Yeo and one of the Van Tulleken brothers are very good on it.

Like most things, how well your hunger/satiety triggers operate is a mix of genetics and environment. On the environment side, it's possible that over the last 60+ we've lost the habit of being hungry. My impression is that pre 1960s, people didn't eat frequently outside meal-times so they must have been hungry, at least to some extent, between them and perhaps just used to and relatively unbothered by the sensation.

I'm 57 and have had a BMI of 21 since my early '20s. Am I always hungry? No. Am I frequently hungry, I guess so, although it's more 'definitely not full' rather than 'painfully hungry'.

user78976 · 30/08/2021 13:47

Re. fasting: Yes, I did this for several month and lost quite a lot of weight, but I also suspect it nearly pushed me into (slightly) early menopause due to the missed periods etc so had to stop.

CovidCorvid · 30/08/2021 13:47

I lost weight a couple of years ago and yes I was hungry but you get used to it. My PT says when exercising you have to love the burn. And I told myself I had to get used to/love the hunger. Obviously not taking it to extreme... But just accepting its OK. I'm currently waiting to meet a late dd for lunch. I'm hungry and have been since 11am... But I'm no more hungry than I was nearly 3 hours ago.

Jasmine11 · 30/08/2021 13:46

@PegasusReturns

It's a very modern concept to eat at regular intervals

Grin Grin Grin

I find if I haven’t eaten I lack concentration, get irritable, can be prone to headaches and light headedness. None of which are conducive to my ability to perform or general feelings of wellness.

So I’ll take my new fangled modern day at of eating at regular intervals thanks!

Sounds like you are describing out of control blood sugars - none of those things should be happening just because you are hungry, that's not a natural or healthy state of being.
grasstreeleaf · 30/08/2021 13:39

Oh and incidentally building up slow twitch muscles can improve insulin sensitivity. Slow twitch muscles are fuelled by burning fat through aerobic respiration. Fast twitch muscles are fuelled by glucose through anaerobic respiration. Sprinters tend to have more developed fast twitch muscles, marathon runners more developed slow twitch muscles.