Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not invite my sister to my wedding

91 replies

namechanged1090 · 30/08/2021 08:29

In my immediate family only my dad and I have a relationship with my sister. She literally cannot be in the same room as my mum and my 4 brothers intensely dislike her. Two of the 4 boys are so incredibly laid back I don’t think I have ever known them have a falling out with anyone. One is normal and the final one is absolutely precious, so anyone can fall out with him!

I am getting married and I don’t feel like I can invite her to my wedding. She will upset everyone by being there. My cousin had a christening just before covid and she mocked my 7 year old niece with a lazy eye, really horrible behaviour and not a one off. I just don’t think I can tolerate this on my big day. I would be on egg shells. Would I be terrible to not invite her? I don’t know how I will broach this with her, I was bridesmaid at her wedding she is going to be devastated.

OP posts:
ExtraOnions · 30/08/2021 10:16

[quote namechanged1090]@LEMtheoriginal

I know she will be devastated. That is why I am sad but she has done a lot of bad things and has upset people. She does need to take ownership and apologise/ build bridges. She needs professional help to do this from a qualified mediator and this is not a quick fix. The trust needs to be totally rebuilt. That is assuming they accept her outreach (which actually I am not sure they will). I think if she tried.... the siblings would be nice enough but it wouldn't be comfortable for me. I would feel on tenderhooks.... I don't want my wedding to be remembered as the one that an 8 year old got bullied by a fully grown woman/ mother....
[/quote]
When did an 8 year old get bullied ? We’ve still not been told what was said, and why you have chosen once persons version over another.

All this stuff she said was years ago - why are you all unable to move on?

A mediator ? Seriously ?

My bother was a heroin addict … he stole from me, burgled my other sister house, sold my other brothers instruments. He was aggressive, rude and demanding. He went through rehab and has been clean 20 years. Never once have I sat and demanded and apology. He was young, stupid and fighting his own demons. He’s family, and I love him … and he needed compassion.

HeyDugeesCakeBadge · 30/08/2021 10:14

OP how much of her bad behaviour has been in recent times (other than the lazy eye incident?). Are you sure she would have mocked a child and this was not the perception of others due to their relationship with her? I think you'll severely damage your relationship with her by just not inviting her - why don't you sit down and discuss your concerns before making a decision? See what her thoughts are?

DoItAfraid · 30/08/2021 10:13

Sorry I just saw you had already answered about alcohol.

DoItAfraid · 30/08/2021 10:11

Is alcohol ever involved in her “bad behaviour” incidents?

namechanged1090 · 30/08/2021 10:09

@LEMtheoriginal

I know she will be devastated. That is why I am sad but she has done a lot of bad things and has upset people. She does need to take ownership and apologise/ build bridges. She needs professional help to do this from a qualified mediator and this is not a quick fix. The trust needs to be totally rebuilt. That is assuming they accept her outreach (which actually I am not sure they will). I think if she tried.... the siblings would be nice enough but it wouldn't be comfortable for me. I would feel on tenderhooks.... I don't want my wedding to be remembered as the one that an 8 year old got bullied by a fully grown woman/ mother....

OP posts:
godmum56 · 30/08/2021 10:06

OP, how much of what your Sis did is known by you to be actual fact from your own knowledge and how much is reported and/or hearsay?

ExtraOnions · 30/08/2021 10:03

[quote namechanged1090]@ExtraOnions

I gave some examples of things that happened with the other siblings in my response just above. Sorry I maybe should of put it straight out there but I thought it would get long.

I have decided I am not inviting her and I just want to position it with her in the right way. I don't actually think she is a bad person, she has had a hard life and she has done bad things. It is like she has a real problem with impulse control and knowing where to draw the line. When we were in school she had a lot of physical altercations got suspended a lot, expelled etc. She broke up with a boyfriend and kind of ruined his life. She just gets too determined and doesn't think about other people. Does that make sense? With her kids she appears lovely and soft... she was adorable to me as a child..... but there is a very definitely another side to her.

[/quote]
So … sometime ago she crashed a car and didn’t take responsibility.. which is a shitty thing to do.

She said some unspecified things years ago, but hasn’t said anything horrible for ages as she has matured - yep, sounds normal … haven’t we all said stupid things when younger ?

She broke up with a boyfriend, and you took his side

Then there was this recent incident, which you have decided to not believe her about.

So we have a woman, who has made mistakes in the past, who has learned and matured.. who is now ignored by most of her siblings, harshly judged, and excluded. If I was her I would be telling you all to fuck yourselves.

LEMtheoriginal · 30/08/2021 10:03

You were a bridesmaid at her wedding, she will be devastated. Can your family not be civil for a few hours? Youve called her out on the nasty comments re the child. That is done.

namechanged1090 · 30/08/2021 09:56

@Ozanj

The only thing that was surprising is that this hasn't happened in 10 years, so it a behaviour out of the blue. This sort of thing used to happen a lot before she met her DH ( who is lovely and calm).

The reason I don't see this sort of thing is because there isn't conflict when I see her just with her family. It is conflict that brings out the worst in her. She can't handle it at all and it definitely needs help understanding where to stop and count to 10

OP posts:
namechanged1090 · 30/08/2021 09:51

@mnahmnah

She isn't a big drinker. I think one or 2 glasses could make her drunk.

I suspect she was stressed because all of my brothers ignore her and drank more than normal. She wanted to provoke my brother to have a reaction and was horrible about his child. He gave her no reaction, he is over her and nothing she can do will surprise him anymore. She doesn't know where to draw the line or stop... she will just keep on going...

OP posts:
namechanged1090 · 30/08/2021 09:47

@ExtraOnions

I gave some examples of things that happened with the other siblings in my response just above. Sorry I maybe should of put it straight out there but I thought it would get long.

I have decided I am not inviting her and I just want to position it with her in the right way. I don't actually think she is a bad person, she has had a hard life and she has done bad things. It is like she has a real problem with impulse control and knowing where to draw the line. When we were in school she had a lot of physical altercations got suspended a lot, expelled etc. She broke up with a boyfriend and kind of ruined his life. She just gets too determined and doesn't think about other people. Does that make sense? With her kids she appears lovely and soft... she was adorable to me as a child..... but there is a very definitely another side to her.

OP posts:
namechanged1090 · 30/08/2021 09:38

@Ozanj

They were very good to her growing up. Sympathetic even.. they used to take the blame for stuff she did because they would get in less trouble.

They only distanced themselves as adults. They all have their own individual reasons that surprisingly are separate. She crashed one of their cars and refused to take ownership of the event leaving him in a pickle. Things like the comment about my niece happened before, just not for a long long time. She matured a lot when she had her kids but the other siblings were already over having a relationship with her. I gave her a second chance.

I am thinking of telling her that she needs to try and engage them in mediation to build a relationship with them, which will take time. If she does that and the tension lessens I would love to have her at events. That at be in time for my wedding.

OP posts:
Mazblue86 · 30/08/2021 09:37

If you want her there and want a continued relationship with her, you should invite her. Her relationship with everyone else is their business and not your responsibly to manage.

ExtraOnions · 30/08/2021 09:34

Where does the dislike come from … prior to the Christening ? What are the incidents that have caused it ?

With the Christening incident, what was actually said that was “mocking” ? She says she said something out of “concern”.. what was said ?

Reading the thread, seems like you have already made the decision not to invite, and are now gathering the reasons to justify it.

One of my sisters is a huge PITA.. still invited her to my big birthday later this year, she’s decided not to come - which is fine

waltzingparrot · 30/08/2021 09:34

You don't need any drama. You want to be able to relax and enjoy your wedding day. Don't invite her.

mnahmnah · 30/08/2021 09:33

*been drinking

mnahmnah · 30/08/2021 09:33

If she was drunk and loud at the christening, then is it a drink thing? Does she only upset people and misbehave when she’s even drinking?

AtrociousCircumstance · 30/08/2021 09:29

I would love to hear your sisters version of events.

Ozanj · 30/08/2021 09:28

[quote namechanged1090]@Marni83

No sorry I have probably 18 cousins who were at that christening. The one who invited my sister to the christening actually knows my sister the best. They work indirectly together, meet a lot in their spare time etc. That cousin is all about openness and would never get involved in family disagreements. She says schedule stuff invite everyone, don't take sides and let the sort it out themselves.

The cousin who told me about the bullying event is a totally separate person. She said my sister was drunk and loud. She said the comment was said directly to her and she was really uncomfortable.
[/quote]
I would never believe a cousin over a sibling who has proven good behaviour to me, so I would immediately be suspicious.

Ozanj · 30/08/2021 09:26

@namechanged1090

The odd thing about my sister is that when I meet her and her family, she is actually lovely. Her husband is a nice guy, her kids are well behaved and genuinely nice to be around. I can tell she is an excellent mother, it makes me so proud of her. My DH cannot understand why everyone so intensely dislikes her, especially as my brothers are so incredibly easy going.

We had some really tough family dynamics growing up because her and my mum had a pretty toxic relationship. It is something that makes me make allowances for her.....

My Mum and one of my brothers are toxic mother fuckers and used to tell family made up stories about me to paint me in a really bad light. Everyone believed them right up until very recently when the truth unravelled. If your Mum is toxic it’s possible something similar is happening in your family - don’t believe that your brothers are entirely without fault. You may not know what happened - toxicbfamilies usually try to scapegoat people who call bad behaviour out. So I wouldn’t be surprised if your Mum or one of your brothers is engineering the rumours around your sister.

I think as it’s your wedding you should do what you want. Seems like you and your Oh have always known your sister to be lovely and she has proven this to you - so you should invite her. Maybe put her on a different table to your Mum and brothers.

namechanged1090 · 30/08/2021 09:26

@Marni83

No sorry I have probably 18 cousins who were at that christening. The one who invited my sister to the christening actually knows my sister the best. They work indirectly together, meet a lot in their spare time etc. That cousin is all about openness and would never get involved in family disagreements. She says schedule stuff invite everyone, don't take sides and let the sort it out themselves.

The cousin who told me about the bullying event is a totally separate person. She said my sister was drunk and loud. She said the comment was said directly to her and she was really uncomfortable.

OP posts:
DrinkFeckArseBrick · 30/08/2021 09:21

It's a tough one OP

On the one hand you're describing her as a nasty piece of work. On the other you seem to want to continue a relationship with her, and are worried about her feelings.

In the context of the wedding, unfortunately its going to be difficult to have it both ways. She is going to be upset and it might damage your relationship.

So I think you have to decide what's more important to you, to continue a relationship with your sister who you think can be a nasty person, or to have a wedding without being completely stressed. If you want her in your life then it's not an easy decision to make, and it's easy for people here to say not to invite her.

I'm not sure if there is any other way around it. Only thing I can think of is if there is anyone that talks to her there (your dad?) getting him to watch her, give her a clear set of rules to follow and assign him to watch her and try and steer her away from any awful behaviour, and chuck her out if she breaks any rules. Or give her a role at your wedding, something that means she has minimal contact with people

AlrightThereSkippy · 30/08/2021 09:17

I would talk to the sister about it. She may realise she shouldn't be there and might prefer to celebrate with you separately with just you and her family since she is lovely when it's just you? If she's lovely and reasonable with you then keep it to just you.

I know someone like this who is lovely one on one, but awful in bigger groups. It may be a form of social anxiety or something and she lashes out and behaves like a tit. Not that I'm excusing bad behaviour, like making fun of a child, but it's one explanation.

Marni83 · 30/08/2021 09:12

So the cousin who says she heard your sister mooch your niece
Is also encouraging you to invite your sister

How peculiar
She doesn’t sound particularly appealing either

namechanged1090 · 30/08/2021 09:08

The odd thing about my sister is that when I meet her and her family, she is actually lovely. Her husband is a nice guy, her kids are well behaved and genuinely nice to be around. I can tell she is an excellent mother, it makes me so proud of her. My DH cannot understand why everyone so intensely dislikes her, especially as my brothers are so incredibly easy going.

We had some really tough family dynamics growing up because her and my mum had a pretty toxic relationship. It is something that makes me make allowances for her.....

OP posts: