Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell DSis we don't want another joint holiday with her family?

114 replies

bravefox · 29/08/2021 20:43

Just returned from a holiday which was my family, my parents, and DSis's family all together for the first time. DSis and I both have two young kids and ages are similar so we hoped they would hit it off but it was just extremely hard work from start to finish.

While I knew it wasn't going to be the most relaxing of times, the biggest issue was that DSis and I have completely contrasting parenting styles with her kids staying up most of the night, grazing on junk all day and one of her kids in particular pretty much bullied my DD all week. My kids were miserable whenever both families hung out together as DSis and her H just turn a blind eye to what their kids are up to and it was left to the rest of us to supervise most of the time. DH and I have pretty much vowed not to holiday with them again for a very long time, if ever.

I'm very happy with this, but now they are suggesting we repeat again at Christmas! We have no other family so it will be hard to make an excuse but we'd rather just be on our own than repeat all of that again!

AIBU to say we don't want to holiday together again, and if so how do I do it diplomatically?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
saraclara · 30/08/2021 22:51

[quote Meraas]@saraclara you’re exaggerating, this isn’t about destroying families, this is about asserting boundaries. Much better to be politely clear with sister as suggested by Billy1966 rather than making excuses abs then getting brow beaten into it.

No one has suggested a fight. The SIL is a CF, you are suggesting tip toeing around her which is bizarre.[/quote]
I'm not suggesting tiptoeing around her at all. In simply suggesting that OP says no in a very brief, simple yet honest way. There is absolutely no reason to berate SIL for anything, or to lie or to tiptoe around.

Saying "no thanks, we've decided to have Christmas just us this year" does the job.

Risking a family fall out is unnecessary, and would only serve to distress the grandparents, who really don't deserve to be caught up in the middle.

Meraas · 30/08/2021 22:29

@saraclara you’re exaggerating, this isn’t about destroying families, this is about asserting boundaries. Much better to be politely clear with sister as suggested by Billy1966 rather than making excuses abs then getting brow beaten into it.

No one has suggested a fight. The SIL is a CF, you are suggesting tip toeing around her which is bizarre.

JacquelineCarlyle · 30/08/2021 22:24

I agree @saraclara

saraclara · 30/08/2021 21:39

I really dislike the way that many posters encourage people to take action that could destroy families for the rest of their lives. It's so easy to sit in the peanut gallery and tell someone to throw a grenade into a whole extended family, when there are absolutely no repercussions for you.

There are nearly always ways to achieve what OPs need without causing massive collateral damage to other family members.

It's way worse than telling someone to LTB.

Meraas · 30/08/2021 21:24

Exactly Billy!

billy1966 · 30/08/2021 20:45

Why should the OP spare the feelings of a family that ruined their holiday.

If my children's cousins were little bullies and ruining my children's holiday because their parents couldn't be arsed to mind them and imposed on the rest of the family, their feelings would not be my priority.

My children would be.

It's a common theme that I have heard over the years.
The laziest parents ALWAYS pushing for large family holidays.

I remember a friend of mine having to put her younger sister straight.

They had gone on a large family holidays but each had their own individual family accommodation.
Her sister had never once been available to babysit her nieces and nephews in her 20's.

Now they were on holiday she was expecting them to entertain her young children, take them for walks, babysit in the morning to give them a lie in and babysit at night.

My friends teenage children had enough and got pissed off with it after only 24 hours.
It was their family holiday.
My friend had to pull her sister aside and tell her straight that her children had zero interest in looking after a 1 and 2 year old on their holiday.
She was very pissy but the teens weren't budging on it.
It was their holiday and she killed any goodwill within 24 hours.

Taking them for a walk is one thing, expecting them to sit an babysit at night is another thing completely when the family have gone out for a meal.

When you have very young children you pay a babysitter or eat in.
Lots of people do it on holidays and we certainly did.
It's life with small children.

2Rebecca · 30/08/2021 20:43

My kids were never bullies though. I was just thoughtless about being happy for others to parent them. I maybe would have said something to a sib if their kids bullied mine

Skysblue · 30/08/2021 20:17

I had this exact thing!

Parents of bullies always seem to want other families to come on holiday and provide their kids with victims/entertainment while the parents chill out and look the other way 🤔

Tell her that you’d rather catch up with her separately, as your children said it wasn’t a good fit for a holiday. If pushed with ‘but why’ say your children do not want to go on holiday with her children, and that it’s their holiday too, you won’t force them.

They will moan and say that children always squabble etc etc and that ‘but we’re family’ - parents of bullies often pile on the pressure…

Just say no and if they get offended (which they will), they’ll get over it.

2Rebecca · 30/08/2021 20:12

I'd be definite I wasn't doing it but not unpleasant. I think I was a bit thoughtless sometimes when the kids were younger.

Meraas · 30/08/2021 20:08

@billy1966

Why would you do anything other than tell the truth.

Your family did NOT enjoy the holiday and ye want to holiday alone.

Or "thanks but no thanks"
"Why not?"

"We didn't enjoy it".
" Why?"
"Because we didn't and won't be doing it again, thanks".

She's a lazy user, married to a lazy user.

Your poor family holiday ruined.
I'd be so pissed.

She knows bloody well what she's doing, but doesn't give a damn about you, your kids, your holiday.

You need to adopt a similar attitude.

Flowers

Spot on! Sis and BIL are lazy twats and deserve to be called up on it.
bravefox · 30/08/2021 19:34

Crikey this had blown up since I last checked!!!

Thank you for the responses- I will read them all and post again later!

OP posts:
saraclara · 30/08/2021 16:08

@billy1966

Why would you do anything other than tell the truth.

Your family did NOT enjoy the holiday and ye want to holiday alone.

Or "thanks but no thanks"
"Why not?"

"We didn't enjoy it".
" Why?"
"Because we didn't and won't be doing it again, thanks".

She's a lazy user, married to a lazy user.

Your poor family holiday ruined.
I'd be so pissed.

She knows bloody well what she's doing, but doesn't give a damn about you, your kids, your holiday.

You need to adopt a similar attitude.

Flowers

Please don't do the above, OP. There is absolutely no need to light a bomb under your family relationships. As I said in an earlier post, kids go through phases and parents go through phases. Had I said something like that to my SIL and BIL when our kids were young and time together was hard work, the brilliant and supportive relationship we all have now (the cousins are now young adults and really close, too) wouldn't exist, and my late parents in law would have been drawn into bad feeling too.

Simply say "we've decided we'd like a really quiet Christmas, just the four of us" and leave it at that. And if another summer holiday is mooted "we had a big family holiday last year, so this time we plan to be just us"

Seriously, keep it really simple and there's no need for anyone to feel hurt or upset.

Cherrysoup · 30/08/2021 14:56

Be truthful but not brutal. It took me a while to tell family members no, I like to keep people happy but I got fed up pleasing everyone but myself. There’s no way I’d tolerate looking after anyone else’s kids and pandering to them, which is what I had been doing. One family member will happily ‘allow’ everyone else to occupy her dc, to the point of leaving one at an attraction one day, panic ensued, another family member reminded her it was HER dc, not anyone else’s!

billy1966 · 30/08/2021 14:53

Why would you do anything other than tell the truth.

Your family did NOT enjoy the holiday and ye want to holiday alone.

Or "thanks but no thanks"
"Why not?"

"We didn't enjoy it".
" Why?"
"Because we didn't and won't be doing it again, thanks".

She's a lazy user, married to a lazy user.

Your poor family holiday ruined.
I'd be so pissed.

She knows bloody well what she's doing, but doesn't give a damn about you, your kids, your holiday.

You need to adopt a similar attitude.

Flowers
MzHz · 30/08/2021 14:43

@IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves

Bugger diplomatically. Tell her you found it all quite hectic and stressful and have realised you prefer to go away just by yourselves.
Tbh, this is factual, shuts down the possibility of her pestering and is honest. Quiet Christmas is what you’ve got your sights set on
2bazookas · 30/08/2021 13:33

@IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves

Bugger diplomatically. Tell her you found it all quite hectic and stressful and have realised you prefer to go away just by yourselves.
I'm sure OP's parents will be heaving a sigh of relief to be spared having to think up their own excuse :-)
LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 30/08/2021 13:06

@gigi556

It's your sister.... just tell her how you feel! 🤷🏻‍♀️
This. Also during the holiday when they left their children with you/your parents to have a lie in why didn’t you send the children to wake their parents up when they were misbehaving? Same when they were ignoring bad behaviour, you could just have said something «DSis would you mind preventing Tom from hitting Bella please?»
starfishmummy · 30/08/2021 12:35

A "Sorry our plans are made and not changeable. Have a great time and looking forward to hearing about it" would be my answer.

Hellodarknessmyoldpal · 30/08/2021 11:06

Even without the tricky family dynamic i personally wouldn't want to go away over Christmas. Can't you just say that? Kids are worried Santa won't know where to find us kind of thing. Or just a simple we aren't up for that but let's plan a day/meal/party/however you usually celebrate when you are back.

gurglebelly · 30/08/2021 10:54

@Gilly12345

I would just have to be honest and tell tactfully that this was not a relaxing, enjoyable holiday and you would rather not repeat again for a long time and if she pushes the point with you explain how the children were not happy and it is not a holiday for you if you have to look after her children when she disappears and does their own thing.
This, it does my head in that people seem to think the only way to say no is to lie. A simple 'to be honest it didn't really work for us as it was a lot of work and not really a relaxing or enjoyable holiday so we'd rather shelve the idea of group holidays until all the kids are older and a bit more self sufficient' would suffice (and means that you don't have to lie/find another excuse next year, and the year after)
saraclara · 30/08/2021 09:57

Just say thanks for the offer but we just want a quiet Christmas on our own just the four of us this year.

That. No need to embroider it or go into long justifications. And certainly no need to bring up anything negative about the other holiday. Why upset people unnecessarily? My niece and nephew were horrendous to be with for a couple of years, and their parents' hands off style was really frustrating. But the kids turned out great and I have a great relationship with my SIL and BIL now. That wouldn't be the case if I'd given any indication that I didn't want to spend time with them because of their kids/parenting back then.

Keep it simple. There's absolutely nothing to argue with or pick apart in that simple sentence.

PlumpCushion · 30/08/2021 09:56

To avoid a rift, like many PPs have said I’d advise against telling harsh hometruths and just blame it on the hectic ness of having lots of children together.

Alternatively…I don’t know if this would apply to your personality OP but I’m quite introverted (as in need alone time to recharge) so I have in the past said that the dynamic of group holidays don’t really work as I need a proper rest, especially after a difficult time managing XY or Z situation. I emphasise how I love to catch up with everyone and that maybe a weekend would work.

MyPatronusIsACat · 30/08/2021 09:49

@IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves

Bugger diplomatically. Tell her you found it all quite hectic and stressful and have realised you prefer to go away just by yourselves.
Absolutely this! ^

@bravefox

Tell her 'sorry sis but it was such a struggle for me with all the kids together, and it made me quite exhausted to be honest. I couldn't cope with it again. Big family holidays are not my cup of tea.'

You don't have to mention what utter horrors her kids are! Grin

Sorry if it's been said already, (I haven't RTFT,) but it sounds to me like she knows her kids are a pain in the arse, and is finding someone to dump them on.

I know a few people with badly behaved, unruly, disruptive kids like this, and they do seem to love dumping/pushing them onto others, in the guise of 'Conor/Jade would LOVE to play at YOUR house.' Hmm

Many of them seem oblivious to how badly their children behave, and the fact it's affecting others. I don't understand why. I don't get it at all. (Although, as I said, I am convinced some people know their children are hard work, and farm them out to suckers who will look after them/tolerate them!!!)

It's like the parents of the school bully(s.) No matter what, they insisted THEIR child could never - and WOULD never be a bully. Totally in denial. And really bad parenting.

Lightisnotwhite · 30/08/2021 09:43

@AlrightThereSkippy

For me, if I'd said "well SIL, you're quite insensitive and you and bil drink too much. You refuse to parent your own children and offload them at ever opportunity. Add to that, you're all quite rude and inhospitable people with bad manners" it would go down like a lead balloon. So I would tell "THE TRUTH", which is that I'd rather spend Christmas Eve in my own house so kids can open presents. That is also "THE TRUTH", just ommitting the nastier ones. But you do you Sami.
Exactly this. Tell her you found the summer holiday hard work and Christmas won’t be happening. Just make sure the reasons you give are only about you and your feelings. Don’t mention anything about her or her families behaviours because that’s not something you can control and they’ll tell you why you’re “ wrong”. It’s also too late to point these things now. Bullying behaviour, getting dumped with kids etc should have been mentioned at the time they happened.
ivykaty44 · 30/08/2021 09:35

dear sis

It was a different type of holiday for us and its not worked the way we thought,Im sure you'll agree it was a great holiday but stressful. probably best we don't repeat as I think we could all end up falling out and that would be such a shame. A weekend break or an overnight stay is fine but a holiday is a different matter. love you lots