Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to charge my 18yr old a quarter of his wage?

139 replies

ILoveMyCaravan · 29/08/2021 19:36

My son is taking a year off before going to uni next year. He got excellent grades in his GCSEs and A levels. He's got a part time job and seems to work hard. AIBU to ask him for around 1/4 of his take home pay whilst he's living at home for the next year?

We've left it for the first few months of him working as thought he deserved to treat himself when he finished college, but he spends every penny on his girlfriend, clothes, eating out, gym, phone etc he has nothing left at the end of the month. And I'm finding it hard to stand back and watch him be so care free with money.

Tax credits and child benefit stop this month and we will miss that extra money.

I'm only struggling with this decision because I worked p/t from the age of 14 because I wasn't provided for by my parents apart from the basics of having a roof over my head. I had to buy literally everything else that I needed. I don't want him to feel like I did.

OP posts:
wantmorenow · 29/08/2021 22:19

Costs a lot to house a family. Kids eat constantly, use the dryer when I wouldn't, lights on everywhere lol plus if I wasn't housing them I could sell and downsize so mortgage much less.

£300pcm is only & 70 a week. Full board and lodgings for this is not really huge. If it includes lifts a lot, it's a bargain. Perhaps reduce it slightly but he also needs to chip in to household chores now too if he doesn't already. Adulting isn't as much as they think 😂

Wriggleon · 29/08/2021 22:17

£300 for an 18 year old working 25 hours seems quite steep. Does he really cost you that much? I would have thought the extra food and bills wouldn't come to that. He should be paying for bus pass, phone contract, gym membership, own clothes, fancy toiletries etc. If ferrying him around is expensive, stop it, he's an adult he can make his own way about

Bloballbovish · 29/08/2021 22:15

My stepchildren always paid around the amount you're proposing, from leaving college/6th form. They're expensive to feed! There's usually only been two of them at home at a time and my food bills used to be £700 a month. Now they've all gone, my food bill was £250 last month, and that's with school summer holidays for my eldest child and a newly weaned baby added in. No chance was I finding an extra £500 a month to feed adults who swan in with constant new clothes and go out on expensive nights out drinking expensive cocktails and shots all night.

One of them complained but I listed what their share of all the bills was, so they could see that I wasn't trying to fleece them. If your son is not happy show him what things you pay out for cost. I wouldn't focus on the loss of tax credits etc, though its a valid reason, show him what expenses he incurs so he knows why he's contributing. The DSC who complained to me thought it would be cheaper to move out than pay me £250 a month. Took a while for me to stop laughing so I could clear up that one!

PalmsandCharms · 29/08/2021 22:14

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 29/08/2021 22:11

What’s the plan when he leaves?

I can’t imagine it costs £300 a month to feed him and he may be very resentful of having to now pay when that wasn’t agreed prior to the gap year. It’s not his fault the government are no longer paying his costs.

PalmsandCharms · 29/08/2021 22:08

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

VeganVeg · 29/08/2021 22:07

Does it cost you £300 per month to have him living with you? If it does and you have lost that much in benefits, and you can’t live without it, fair enough. If not then no, as you will have to survive when he moves out.

wantmorenow · 29/08/2021 22:05

As a single parent with 3 kids still living at home I think talking money with him is treating him as an adult and a good thing. My oldest DC contributed soon after starting work. We sat down with my bank statements and I showed her my income and expenditure. She was amazed to see that her disposable income was more than mine even on her minimum wage.

Since then she has contributed a little more as her wages increased. She now out earns me by a long way. Still contributing £250 pcm but great at getting in extra shopping etc.
It's not rent. It's contributing to the house she lives in. Works great and she's still here at the age of 26 so she's happy with it. So am I.

Middle child off to university will live away. Still 1 dependent DC left. I have a good job but not well paid, after mortgage, bills and food not much is left.

Please don't frame it as rent as this suggests it's an income for you. It's just an adult helping the other adults meet the costs of living in a home. It's part of growing up and healthy.

Kids need sound financial education and it's part of our job as parents to teach the value of money and how to use it wisely.

Quinoadogvlue · 29/08/2021 22:03

In 1984 I was 17,just out of college and in my first job, my parents asked for 1/4 of my take home pay. They told me this was the ‘going rate’. I had my first month free to allow me to buy some clothes to go to work in. If losing child benefit etc makes you short I don’t think it’s unreasonable to ask for him to contribute and will give him experience of living in the real world and paying for himself.

caringcarer · 29/08/2021 22:02

I charged my boys house contribution but not until they finished full time education. We sat down and worked out 1/4 of council tax as 4 adults living here. 1/4 of water rates, 1/4 of fuel etc. He paid about £200 pcm. Why not suggest he buys some food and learns to prepare. At 18 he should be doing own laundry. Suggest he buys washing powder. Tell him you would like to see he can care for himself before he leaves home.

Tomorrowisanewday · 29/08/2021 21:50

I had a part time job in a supermarket from when i was 14 (i'm old, we were allowed to work when we were at school) and gave my parents a third of my wages. I was never asked, but we didn't have much, and i thought it was right. Unbeknown to me, they saved it all, and gave me it when i needed to buy a car to get to college

allyouneedisconnection · 29/08/2021 21:46

I don't think I could keep the money from my child working. It's a temporary situation. I would however encourage him to save a percentage of the money. I realise I may get hammered for my approach though.

abbs1 · 29/08/2021 21:42

@Ilovemycaravan I dont think its a bad idea. I got a job at 18 as my child benefit my mum got stopped and the top up housing benefit they got for me stopped as well due to me working so I paid towards the money that they lost from that income to go towards food and bills. I was earning after tax etc around £1000 a month so gave them £300 a month and then saved some and bought my own clothes etc as my parents couldn't really afford it and struggled so I did my best to help them and support myself.

PlanDeRaccordement · 29/08/2021 21:39

How have you got by these few months if not having this money is so critical?

You have to admit not discussing this before he made the decision to defer uni for a year and get a p/t job that you’re putting him in an awkward position. It’s the kind of thing that can breed resentment. He might have decided not to defer if he knew he’d be working just to top up your income by £300/mo.

Tee20x · 29/08/2021 21:37

I get it's a bit awkward but like others have said if you truly need the money then you need the money and nothing will change that.

All you can do is have a conversation with him about it & he can either chip in and help out or find somewhere to live himself and cover 100% of the costs.

An alternative could be to get him to spend his own money on things for himself eg food - you say he eats a lot so maybe doing this will put things into perspective for him when he has to budget for himself?

Does he pay all his own bills like phone, phone insurance etc?

My parents never charged me rent to live at home, whether that be while home for the summer from uni, or after uni when I started working full time & if I am in the position to, I wouldn't charge either when DD is of age.

ILoveMyCaravan · 29/08/2021 21:31

With covid it was really hard to have a proper conversation about what would happen. He was undecided about whether to go to uni. No we didn't discuss finances at all. All that was said was if he wanted to defer for a year then he would have to get a job. Maybe it's misleading to say "gap year" he's not travelling, he's just taking a year off and getting some work experience.

Please don't make me sound like a bad parent for asking for money from him. We have to be able to live!

OP posts:
user1487194234 · 29/08/2021 21:31

Our eldest 2are away at Uni,we support them fully and don't want them working in term time
We won't be charging any of them until they have finished their education ( by which time hopefully they will have moved out!)

Carboncheque · 29/08/2021 21:28

I think you’ll be doing him a favour by having the conversation with him. If he spends his year working and spending his money as it comes in he’s going to get used to living that way and have very little saved for University. Knowing that you need him to pay some keep to keep putting food on the table and cover his share of the bills should get him thinking more about his spending choices.

NinDS · 29/08/2021 21:28

Both me and my sibling never paid board while we worked and lived at home but we were expected to buy our own clothes/shoes/toiletries etc unless it was something large and then they would chip in. It worked brilliantly and I will do the same with my children. I would hate to think they have to pay to live in their home. Buying what they want is a different matter.

ILoveMyCaravan · 29/08/2021 21:26

We would expect him to get a p/t job whilst at uni. He'd get the full grant like his brother. We would set him up with everything he needs though, like we did with his sibling.

We're hoping that the work experience he has gained now will help him get a p/t job at uni. He's more than capable of doing both.

OP posts:
DrWhoNowww · 29/08/2021 21:25

I guess it depends on the conversation you had when you agreed to the gap year.

Him turning 18 and you losing child benefit/credits isn’t a surprise - so should have been factored into the conversation surely?

I’d also consider how much loan he will be entitled to at university - if he’s getting anything less than maximum maintenance loan then parents are expected to top up - it’s worth having a conversation with him now if this isn’t going to be possible, so he can start saving the difference for himself (this is why the student loan system is so shit, it should be a flat rate regardless of family income)

If you need the money you need the money and if he was just an adult working it would be a no brainer - but I can’t imagine taking money off a child during a gap year unless I planned to give it back for their first year at uni, everything you take off him now is less money than he will have next year and you’ll be expected to make up the shortfall.

vodkaredbullgirl · 29/08/2021 21:24

My dd came back home from uni 3 yrs ago, she gives me £500 a month out of her wages. Goes towards food, electric, gas and petrol money.

Before anyone says, it is what she said she would give me. She has more money in the bank than I do Smile

ILoveMyCaravan · 29/08/2021 21:22

Yes it would be a fixed amount not a percentage. If he works extra hours then that's to his benefit not mine. Although I really would like to see him save some as well whilst he's got the chance and not studying as well.

OP posts:
Carboncheque · 29/08/2021 21:20

There are some seriously tone deaf posts on here.

Jangle33 · 29/08/2021 21:18

Will you be supporting him through uni? Have you spoken to him about this and how much he will need?

If there’s not been much money spare then he’s probably enjoying having a little cash for the first time, unless times are v tight then I wouldn’t be asking him for money but assuming he needs to support himself through uni then I would focus on that.