Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to charge my 18yr old a quarter of his wage?

139 replies

ILoveMyCaravan · 29/08/2021 19:36

My son is taking a year off before going to uni next year. He got excellent grades in his GCSEs and A levels. He's got a part time job and seems to work hard. AIBU to ask him for around 1/4 of his take home pay whilst he's living at home for the next year?

We've left it for the first few months of him working as thought he deserved to treat himself when he finished college, but he spends every penny on his girlfriend, clothes, eating out, gym, phone etc he has nothing left at the end of the month. And I'm finding it hard to stand back and watch him be so care free with money.

Tax credits and child benefit stop this month and we will miss that extra money.

I'm only struggling with this decision because I worked p/t from the age of 14 because I wasn't provided for by my parents apart from the basics of having a roof over my head. I had to buy literally everything else that I needed. I don't want him to feel like I did.

OP posts:
bumblingbovine49 · 30/08/2021 07:46

I'm in my 50s ( for context) and had a year off before university where I worked full time. I still remember I got paid around £800 a month and voluntarily paid my parents £200 if that. My parents didn't ask for it but I wanted to .

I still managed to save loads ( as well as paying for all my clothes and personal stuff and going out ) and had a healthy chunk of savings to use as living expenses at university and to go on a long holiday to the US. in the summer just before my first year at university. So I'd say YADNBU

Jangle33 · 30/08/2021 07:31

OP I think the lesson here is you really should have already told your child the expectation. He might not have deferred if he knew this was what you were planning. You needed to have planned ahead.

ILoveMyCaravan · 30/08/2021 06:54

Maybe calling it a percentage doesn't give the full picture. He earns around £1k per month on his basic 25 hours. I'm thinking of asking him to contribute £250 to household expenses. And also asking him to put some away for uni, which so far he hasn't saved anything.

OP posts:
Alpenguin · 30/08/2021 01:40

Yanbu - as soon as I left school (went straight to college) I had to pay my mum a quarter of my student grant & loan every term to her for digs.

I was aggrieved as most of my peers were getting their parental contributions and then some enabling them to live in halls & shared flats but I was paying my mum to live at home. She was absolutely right in charging me as soon as I turned 18. We don’t do adult kids any favours by not introducing them to the realities of budgeting and household expenses. My 40something partner who cannot budget for the life of him because mummy financed everything and took nothing in return is the reason why I totally agree with what my mum did. She did me a huge favour and I learned some great life lessons

Babyroobs · 30/08/2021 01:37

I currently have two adult ds's living at home who have just started work. We don't have a mortgage to pay so it feels odd charging them for living here. One barely eats any meals at home either. So other than gas and electricity, I'm not sure what I would be charging them for. Obviously if you need the money then you should ask him to make a contribution.

Babyroobs · 30/08/2021 01:33

It depends how much a quarter of his wage equates to really?

Mintjulia · 30/08/2021 01:24

I'd request 25% of his wage, and keep it in a separate pot.

If you need some of it for an emergency - washing machine or cooker dies etc - then you have it, but if not, use it to kit him out for uni...pots, pans, plates, mugs, student rail card, initial food parcel etc. and keep any left for when he needs car insurance or a flat deposit etc.

Canyrdogdothepussy · 30/08/2021 01:23

Absolutely . We called it "Dig Money" and it's all about learning to pay your way . My mum would end up saving some of it for me and giving it to ke sometimes when I was going somewhere special or for Christmas spending,but it was very much the done thing . I did the same with my oldest (he's got his own flat ) and will do so with my youngest.

Driftingblue · 30/08/2021 01:22

I believe firmly that offspring not in full-time education need to pay rent. There are of course going to be some exceptions, but I think it’s an important life lesson. It’s not about the money. It’s about learning the importance of having and keeping a job and sticking to a budget. Living at home rent free gives a distorted view of discretionary spending. Real life is expensive, much more expensive than a quarter of his wages towards what I’m guessing is covering housing, utilities, laundry, and most of his food and toiletries.

MissTrip82 · 30/08/2021 01:20

If you need the money you need it.

There are many many families in which everyone needs to contribute financially.

He also needs to be saving so he can work fewer hours if at all possible while he’s studying. But that’s his lookout.

Justlovedogs · 30/08/2021 01:14

OP - YANBU at all. At 16, I intended to do A levels, but left school after half a term of 6th form to start work. There was never any question of not paying mum 'housekeeping', or whatever anyone wants to call it. I was an adult, earning a wage (all be it quite a small one, especially by today's standards) and I knew mum would appreciate the extra. Started paying from my first month's pay day until the day I left home, 5 years later.

Thedogscollar · 30/08/2021 00:46

OP I think you are most definitely doing the right thing.

You are giving your child a life lesson that in the future he will not have his whole wage to fritter away as he pleases whilst his rent, food, water, gas, electricity, community tax and transport costs are paid for by Mum n Dad.

On MN this is always a divisive one and you have some come on here braying oh I would never do that to my dear child, almost like you're stealing all their wages.

Anyway stick to your guns have the convo explain how now that the benefits have stopped and he is an adult drawing an adult wage he has to contribute to the household in which he lives.

This does not make you an awful Mum it makes you a good Mum.

simitra · 30/08/2021 00:33

Sometimes when I read these threads I think that young people living at home and being supported by parents dont know they are born.

When I was 18 (mid 1960s) I wanted to go onto a full time course to complete my professional qualifications. My parents made this impossible by insisting I had to tip up (out of my maintenance grant) the same money as if I was working. Obviously that was not possible. At a later stage I did manage a part time course where my grandmother helped me financially. It took a lot longer But I never forgave my parents for their penny pinching attitude and for seeking to hold me back. Unfortunately my parents never saw the value in education and regarded being a student as "faffing about".

The result was that I resented every penny I ever gave them towards my "keep" and left home as soon as I was financially able to afford my own place.

Hairbrush123 · 30/08/2021 00:31

Personally I would never charge my children rent however if I were in your circumstances — I would.

ILoveMyCaravan · 30/08/2021 00:20

@PlanDeRaccordement oh dear are you really that out of touch with reality that you don't know in which month tax credits/child benefits stop after a child turns 18?

OP posts:
Boredhimtodeath · 30/08/2021 00:17

It’s not unreasonable. He is earning money so it’s only fair he pays a contribution, I would consider taking slightly more and saving the extra towards uni for him.

Lennybenny · 30/08/2021 00:03

You really aren't being unreasonable to ask your adult child live in the house that you all share

Lennybenny · 30/08/2021 00:00

Ooof....there are a few people on here who had parents with no financial issues growing up.

Absolutely you should expect him to contribute to his home. Whether you choose to save some of it for him or use it to pay for all that goes with having a dc at home is up to you.
Financially as of next year I will have a ds at uni and will lose the cb/uc for him. It will be hard to lose that and pay the extra ct. I still have to feed him though. He has a pt job as of a month ago and I will take a % off him on his pay day as I did last month.....part of it will go towards the £66 a week I pay for his driving lessons. It won't touch it but I expect him to contribute (exh doesn't so things have always been tight) he absolutely understands this and is happy to. What he doesn't know is I will pay into his savings account and make sure he has £1000 for the day he goes off to uni. Not much by a lot of people's standards but massive by ours. I will work extra hours and by the time he leaves 6th form I will be ready for the drop in income.....but he will either pay towards his keep or have certain bills transferred to him so he can understand his budget (phone, insurance etc)
Your ds needs to know the value of money and a budget. Take it now so uni is not a shock when he realises he's spent his money on food but not books. Explain why you want it and explain how he has none of big bills to pay but also explain in detail how rent, ct, electric, gas, TV licence etc work. You aren't asking him to pay for your things but contribute to the things he needs as well...iykwim. L

Sleepinghyena · 30/08/2021 00:00

@PlanDeRaccordement Tax credits and child benefit stop at the end of August after your child has left school or college. The op. has stated the payments stop THIS MONTH. She hasn't managed without the money for months at all. Your post is nasty. Telling her she doesn't need the money- how the hell do you know her financial situation?

Carboncheque · 29/08/2021 23:50

Read the first post again

’Tax credits and child benefit stop this month and we will miss that extra money’

THIS MONTH.

At least read the post properly before you condemn the OP.

PlanDeRaccordement · 29/08/2021 23:40

Come on OP, you have the choice. Otherwise you would not have been able to get through these first few months without the money from your DC. Your OP was the most honest post you wrote on here: You don’t need the money, you miss the “extra” money and you can’t stand to watch him spend his money because you think he’s wasting it. That’s what is behind this. Not financial struggles. Not teaching him a life lesson.

CityCommuter · 29/08/2021 23:39

@ILoveMyCaravan if you decide to charge your DS a quarter of his wage will you be keeping / saving that money separately to give to him for Uni? He'll probably think you're going to spend it on bills but putting it aside is a good idea and prevents him from spending all of his wages as soon as gets paid! Some of my family members do this and I probably will follow their example as it works really well...

ILoveMyCaravan · 29/08/2021 23:17

Oh dear! Yes I chose to have children. They are now adults. This isn't about replacing 'handouts' I'm approaching 60 and have worked since I was 14! Think I've more than paid my way in life!

Good for you, all those who have the choice whether to take rent from their adult offspring or not. Many people don't have that choice. But I'd rather be in my position than be so oblivious to the struggles of others.

Thank you to all those who have taken the time to reply with kindness.

OP posts:
CoffeeRunner · 29/08/2021 22:24

Is he your eldest/first to go to Uni?

DS2 cost us way more at Uni than he ever did at home!

Both DS1 & DS2 are now back living at home & working full time. Both earn roughly £25k per year (before tax obviously) and pay me £250 each per month.

MyMabel · 29/08/2021 22:20

I paid £180 a month to my mum - don’t get me wrong I’m still care free about money but at the same time I have friends that have never been charged a penny by their parents and they’re always shocked by how much living costs are now they’ve moved out. We sat down and talked about living costs when I started working; initially I was shocked that you even had to pay for water 😂 food costs are shocking too. It’s a great learning curve because no one like paying bills, it still has to be done.